Is Homeopathy truly debunked?

MrTea

New Blood
Joined
Apr 9, 2007
Messages
10
I would like to make a brash and controversial statement.

The so-called "proof" that homeopathy is ineffective cannot be taken seriously, given that the majority of research papers have NOT used homeopathy's prescribed methodology when carrying out their research.

Double-blind studies do NOT prove that homeopathy is ineffective, given that homeopathy prescribes a remedy based on a patient's symptoms, here is an example:

If Mr. X has a headache on the LEFT side of his head, then he would be given remedy A

If Mr. Y has a headache on the right side of his head, he would be given remedy B (according to homeopathic theory).

Therefore, giving remedy A to both Mr.X AND Mr. Y, is inadmissible evidence, given that no good homeopath would ever do such a thing.
 
Yes, it has. Even if what you are saying is 100% true, there would have been a discernable positive statistical anomoly in some, if not all, of the studies performed.

Also, this is in the wrong subforum.
 
Homeopathy has not been debunked, but it has consistently failed to back up the claims made for it. The only way it could be debunked is if cheating was uncovered, otherwise you're trying to prove a negative.
 
Therefore, giving remedy A to both Mr.X AND Mr. Y, is inadmissible evidence, given that no good homeopath would ever do such a thing.

Oh, bur plenty of homeopaths do do such a thing. I have also yet to see any way of differentiation between a "good" homeopath and any other type of homoeopath, what criteria do you use? What is the evidence that their way works better?


Furthermore not all randomised double blind placebo controlled trials of h'pathy work like you describe. A simple protocol.
A homoeopath sees 10 patients with similar conditions, prescribes individualised remedies to each, at the homeopathic pharmacy patients are randomly assigned either the prescribed remedy, or a placebo. And there you have it.
Of course you still have it backwards, as it's not up to us to prove that h'pathy doesn't work, it's up to homs to prove that it does. How would you like it if GlaxoSmithKline was allowed to say, "hey, we've got thsi new drug, ther's no evidence oterh than anecdotal that it works or is safe, but we're going to sell it until someone proves otherwise"?
Would that be OK? If not, why not? And why should homoeopathy be any different?
 
Therefore, giving remedy A to both Mr.X AND Mr. Y, is inadmissible evidence, given that no good homeopath would ever do such a thing.

Are you saying that there are no 'one size fits all' homeopathic remedies?

If that's the case... this product must be a scam, no?

http://www.healthabounds2.com/pages...products/boiron-homeopathic-first-aid-kit.php

Boiron Homeopathic First Aid Kit

With just a little knowledge, anyone can begin using the remedies for the indicated situations.
 
I would like to make a brash and controversial statement.

The so-called "proof" that homeopathy is ineffective cannot be taken seriously, given that the majority of research papers have NOT used homeopathy's prescribed methodology when carrying out their research.

Double-blind studies do NOT prove that homeopathy is ineffective, given that homeopathy prescribes a remedy based on a patient's symptoms, here is an example:

If Mr. X has a headache on the LEFT side of his head, then he would be given remedy A

If Mr. Y has a headache on the right side of his head, he would be given remedy B (according to homeopathic theory).

Therefore, giving remedy A to both Mr.X AND Mr. Y, is inadmissible evidence, given that no good homeopath would ever do such a thing.

It is posible to design studies that get around that one:

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sites/entrez?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&list_uids=12668794&dopt=AbstractPlus
 
I would like to make a brash and controversial statement.

The so-called "proof" that homeopathy is ineffective cannot be taken seriously, given that the majority of research papers have NOT used homeopathy's prescribed methodology when carrying out their research.

Double-blind studies do NOT prove that homeopathy is ineffective, given that homeopathy prescribes a remedy based on a patient's symptoms, here is an example:

If Mr. X has a headache on the LEFT side of his head, then he would be given remedy A

If Mr. Y has a headache on the right side of his head, he would be given remedy B (according to homeopathic theory).

Therefore, giving remedy A to both Mr.X AND Mr. Y, is inadmissible evidence, given that no good homeopath would ever do such a thing.

You're talking about individualization. It's not unique to homeopathy - many naturopathic treatments are also intended to be individualized.

There are two problems, though:

1. Many experiments have been based on individualization. Homeopaths have volunteered to prepare an appropriate treatment, and then the patient either gets this treatment or placebo. There is no difference between the groups.

2. There is no consensus among homeopaths about how to treat any condition. Any study structured as above in point #1 will automatically be rejected by every other homeopath, because it was another homeopath than himself, and therefore, the experiment used a method certain to have no curative effect.

This in itself is a problem for homeopaths to deal with, before claiming that their treatment methods actually work.

We have been dealing with the same problem with Astrologers. Every time an astrologer fails, the others say: "Well, what do you expect... he was using the Sun-style, right-hand, semi-verbalized, neo-Watsonian, revision of 1832 technique. That's crazy talk."
 
The very theories on which homeopathy is based can be tested, especially the one called "The Theory of Infinitesimals". This is where homeopaths claim that remedies diluted an incredible number of times still have some clearly measurable "potency". The test is simply that, beyond a certain level of dilution (called "ultra-molar" dilutions), they need to be compared to "stock" solutions. Some difference is supposed to be discernible...by homeopaths anyway.

So the basic test being proposed currently is simply to distinguish a genuine ultra-molar homeopathic dilution from stock solution, by any method provided the testing is properly blinded. The homeopath does not even have to do diagnoses nor put patients' health at risk, although testing on patients can be used as a distinguishing test if desired.

The problems found so far on this protocol are that (1) no homeopath is prepared to rely on "store-bought" ultra-molar remedies as being REALLY ultra-molar (and yet the prescribe these by the gallon!); and (2) the vast majority of them seem to find the most torturous excuses for not wanting to do the test (so much for their faith in their medicine!).

So we wait...
 
If Mr. X has a headache on the LEFT side of his head, then he would be given remedy A

If Mr. Y has a headache on the right side of his head, he would be given remedy B (according to homeopathic theory).

It is also important to know this: how does the homeopath decide why remedy A should be given to Mr. X?

The answer I have usually received from homeopaths is that each remedy is tested with "proving" on healthy people. Proving is certainly scientifically testable, since it involves giving the same remedy to a number of healthy people. If remedy A and remedy B each produce specific symptoms when administered to healthy people, it should be possible to distinguish between the two remedies in a double blind test. As yet, nobody has been able to do this.
 
MrTea said:
The so-called "proof" that homeopathy is ineffective cannot be taken seriously, given that the majority of research papers have NOT used homeopathy's prescribed methodology when carrying out their research.
Could you please give us a link to the official description of "homeopathy's prescribed methodology"?

~~ Paul
 
Mr TEa Reply (round 1)

Let me begin my reply by stating that I can only speak from teh homeopathic school of thought that I follow.

brodski & blutoski
Evidence for the effectiveness of homeopathy can be rendered less anecdotal by using good homeopaths. The criteria to find such people? The %age of patients (that a homeopath has seen over a period of time) that report positive long-term results.

geni
-yet other studies yield different results (unfortunately I am not allowed to post urls at the moment...an annoying forum rule indeed)...
pediatrics[dot] aappublications[dot] org/cgi/content/abstract/93/5/719

Zep
Some differences should indeed be discernable, based on the patient results. Again, the problem is finding good homeopaths to include in studies.

Michael C
That would depend on how the remedy was administered, and its dilution.

Paul C. Anagnostopoulos
That I cannot do, however I can enumerate it based on the School that follow, if you think it will benefit our debate.
 
Michael C
That would depend on how the remedy was administered, and its dilution.

I'm not sure what your point is here. I asked: "It is also important to know this: how does the homeopath decide why remedy A should be given to Mr. X?"

So plese tell me: according to your homeopathic shool of thought, how does the homeopath decide which remedy to give to a patient?
 
I guess the question for me is, "what is there to debunk?" given that homeopaths have made no attempt in their practice to remove the effects of chance, bias and wishful thinking. We already know that these effects are indistinguishable from the effects of treatment. So in the absence of any reason to think otherwise, why even consider homeopathy effective in the first place?

Linda
 
MrTea
I would like to make a brash and controversial statement.

The so-called "proof" that homeopathy is ineffective cannot be taken seriously, given that the majority of research papers have NOT used homeopathy's prescribed methodology when carrying out their research.
If I may add to 'fls"- why have homeopaths not used their prescribed methods when carrying out reliable research? Homeopaths make "brash and controversial" and unproven statements all the time; you are adding nothing new. Do you have a purpose?
 
There's just simply absolutely NO REASON why it would work. Not one iota of sense at all. It's just water or sugar pills. That's it, that's all. It has no physiological effect, aside from what happens when you eat sugar or drink water. There's no way of telling one remedy from another if you take it out of the bottle.

It's just plain stupid.
 
There's just simply absolutely NO REASON why it would work. Not one iota of sense at all. It's just water or sugar pills. That's it, that's all. It has no physiological effect, aside from what happens when you eat sugar or drink water. There's no way of telling one remedy from another if you take it out of the bottle.

It's just plain stupid.

Don't be coy, girl.
Say what you think.:)
 
There's just simply absolutely NO REASON why it would work. Not one iota of sense at all. It's just water or sugar pills. That's it, that's all. It has no physiological effect, aside from what happens when you eat sugar or drink water. There's no way of telling one remedy from another if you take it out of the bottle. It's just plain stupid.
Agreed.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom