Is Homeopathy truly debunked?

Fine, next time you break something I will shove sugar pills down your throat and let the break heal in its own way.

Linda: Yeah, like CPR with chest compression can lead to rib fractures. I'd rather be dead.

Interesting examples. They are both:

- very old techniques
- very low tech
- very inexpensive
- clearly useful from a common sense perspective
- practiced by nurses and lower-ranked personnel, rarely by MDs

They cover a minute fraction of the spectrum of modern medicine and are both beyond criticism (although the official CPR technique keeps evolving every couple of years, so it's clearly not an exact science). They are not representative of where the resources in money, skill and knowledge go.
 
Interesting examples. They are both:

- very old techniques
- very low tech
- very inexpensive
- clearly useful from a common sense perspective
- practiced by nurses and lower-ranked personnel, rarely by MDs

They cover a minute fraction of the spectrum of modern medicine and are both beyond criticism (although the official CPR technique keeps evolving every couple of years, so it's clearly not an exact science). They are not representative of where the resources in money, skill and knowledge go.

But were they simple enough for you to understand the point?

Linda
 
Linda,

Just between you and me, after I posted the jaw-drop image (and I don't use those things lightly) I said to myself "Self, maybe mslxl was having us on and is going to triumphantly call 'Gotcha'"! (Non-native English speakers, that would mean mslxl fooled us.) Maybe mslxl will still do so.

I have to run, now, to get my liver-flush and colon-detoxification.
 
They cover a minute fraction of the spectrum of modern medicine and are both beyond criticism (although the official CPR technique keeps evolving every couple of years, so it's clearly not an exact science). They are not representative of where the resources in money, skill and knowledge go.

mslxl, it sounds like you're basing your evaulation of medicine on some naturopathy web page. I might hazard a guess that this web page complains that (a) vaccines cause autism, (b) antidepressants cause suicide, and (c) AZT causes AIDS, and (d) people pick up infections at hospitals, and (e) chemotherapy makes your hair fall out.

I'm also going to guess that this web page makes no mention of 99 percent of what modern medicine actually does---the uncontroversial treatments for emphysema, infections, cancers, allergies, diabetes, heart attacks, strokes, parasites, arthritis, seizures, cleft palate, and so on, that contradict your theory.
 
mslxl, it sounds like you're basing your evaulation of medicine on some naturopathy web page. I might hazard a guess that this web page complains that (a) vaccines cause autism, (b) antidepressants cause suicide, and (c) AZT causes AIDS, and (d) people pick up infections at hospitals, and (e) chemotherapy makes your hair fall out.

I'm also going to guess that this web page makes no mention of 99 percent of what modern medicine actually does---the uncontroversial treatments for emphysema, infections, cancers, allergies, diabetes, heart attacks, strokes, parasites, arthritis, seizures, cleft palate, and so on, that contradict your theory.

What's my theory again, since you enjoy guessing?

Seriously, I have an old friend with enphysema and she is convinced she has to die. Where can I find info on treatments that work? You can also PM me about that -- I would appreciate it.
 
Interesting examples. They are both:

- very old techniques
- very low tech
- very inexpensive
- clearly useful from a common sense perspective
- practiced by nurses and lower-ranked personnel, rarely by MDs

Oh, are they? I had the chance to watch the emergency doctors who scrape together what's left after an accident on the Autobahn near the Alps and fly them back to the hospital in a helicopter. It didn't seem old, low tech, nor cheap to me. And there was no nurse on that helicopter, either.
 
No. Please type with bigger fonts, add pictures and ad hominem insults.

:blush:

I'm not very good at that stuff. I might try to learn if you think it would help, but I've got a few other projects in the queue ahead of it.

Linda
 
...the official CPR technique keeps evolving every couple of years, so it's clearly not an exact science.


Actually, that's kind of a hallmark of science: new evidence and knowledge leading to revision of theories and improved techniques.

Homoeopathy, on the other hand, is pretty much unchanged over the last 200 years.

Does this tell you anything?
 
mslxl fails to address my point so I will underscore it;

1810 was the last date at which Homeopathy had any significant changes done to it. The Canon from that date is still in use today by Homeopaths.

Now, in 1810, the average doctor was a quack you were better off not seeing. But since 1905, the average visit to the average doctor has been more beneficial than staying away.

Homeopathy is just a means of avoiding sound medical care, and its practitioners should be tried for capital murder on a regular basis, and its fake nostrums should be banned from sale, and Homeopaths should by law not be allowed to practice medicine or bill insurance.

In short, its not only woo, its MURDEROUS woo.
 
Last edited:
mslxl fails to address my point so I will underscore it;

1810 was the last date at which Homeopathy had any significant changes done to it. The Canon from that date is still in use today by Homeopaths.

Now, in 1810, the average doctor was a quack you were better off not seeing. But since 1905, the average visit to the average doctor has been more beneficial than staying away.

Homeopathy is just a means of avoiding sound medical care, and its practitioners should be tried for capital murder on a regular basis, and its fake nostrums should be banned from sale, and Homeopaths should by law not be allowed to practice medicine or bill insurance.

In short, its not only woo, its MURDEROUS woo.

Estimated iatrogenic deaths in USA for year 2000: 225 000 to 284 000 (Source: Dr. Barbara Starfield, Is US Health Really the Best in the World?, Journal of the American Medical Association, Volume 284, No. 4)

Estimated yearly deaths from homeopathy? You tell me.
 
Estimated iatrogenic deaths in USA for year 2000: 225 000 to 284 000 (Source: Dr. Barbara Starfield, Is US Health Really the Best in the World?, Journal of the American Medical Association, Volume 284, No. 4)

Estimated yearly deaths from homeopathy? You tell me.

100% of all seriously ill patients "treated" by Homeopathy can be expected to die.
 
Estimated iatrogenic deaths in USA for year 2000: 225 000 to 284 000 (Source: Dr. Barbara Starfield, Is US Health Really the Best in the World?, Journal of the American Medical Association, Volume 284, No. 4)

Estimated yearly deaths from homeopathy? You tell me.

I wrote something in another thread that addresses this issue, so I'm just going to copy it here.

"You are assuming that iatrogenic death and disability are something to be avoided, but they are not. I know this seems crazy so I will explain. You need to ask, "how could I have prevented this iatrogenic death and what would the consequences be?" For example, the largest cause, by far, of iatrogenic problems is adverse drug events. And within that category, the use of blood thinners accounts for a large portion. It may be that the only way to prevent a specific death from the use of a blood thinner would be to avoid the use of blood thinners in general. And the consequences of avoiding blood thinners in general would be increased death and disability among those people whose use of the blood thinner prevented death and disability. So it may be that in order to prevent one death from blood thinners, ten people would die who otherwise would not. Most people would find this trade-off unacceptable, so we have to accept that iatrogenic problems cannot and should not be entirely avoided.

Even the death from an iatrogenic cause in an individual may not be preventable in that individual; it would just be from a different cause. An example of this would be the death from chemotherapy in an individual who would have otherwise died from their cancer. Only a small portion of iatrogenic deaths are found to be preventable (i.e. preventable in that particular individual).

A large portion of medical research, and the activities of physicians and hospitals, are directed at finding ways minimize iatrogenic problems. Examples - identifying those people who are more likely to have a complication, identifying those people most likely to benefit from a treatment, investigating errors, implementing programs that significantly impact errors (such as computerized prescribing), standardized monitoring, etc. We have to accept that some consequences of medical care are not preventable, but that to withhold medical care in general would lead to far more devastating consequences. If those 225,000 victims chose placebo instead, then the death toll would be far higher, and would still include most of those 225,000."

So the answer to your question is, the death toll from homeopathy (i.e. if homeopathy was used as a way to avoid iatrogenic death) would be much higher than that. To avoid the death from a bleed, all (since we don't know beforehand who it will be) those on anti-coagulants would have to switch to homeopathy, killing all of those in whom the anti-coagulants were preventing a fatal stroke.

Linda
 
Basically the ONLY things that Homeopathy can "treat" are psychosomatic illnesses, and illnesses that are self-limiting.

Go to a Homeopath with a bad flu and he will give you some useless drops to take and then you go home and either recover or die on your own. An Allopath would listen to your lungs and know when pneumonia was setting in and give you steroids and antibiotics, and possibly Tamiflu, and you pull through. Some small number of Homeopathic cases also live through flu-caused pneumonia, but those are usually the young and otherwise healthy patients. The ones who would have made it without ANY treatment. And even in those patients I would bet that the amount of lung function permanently lost is more than in the allopathic-treated group.
 
Basically the ONLY things that Homeopathy can "treat" are psychosomatic illnesses, and illnesses that are self-limiting.

Go to a Homeopath with a bad flu and he will give you some useless drops to take and then you go home and either recover or die on your own. An Allopath would listen to your lungs and know when pneumonia was setting in and give you steroids and antibiotics, and possibly Tamiflu, and you pull through. Some small number of Homeopathic cases also live through flu-caused pneumonia, but those are usually the young and otherwise healthy patients. The ones who would have made it without ANY treatment. And even in those patients I would bet that the amount of lung function permanently lost is more than in the allopathic-treated group.

Talking about lung function, can I have some help for my friend with emphysema?
 
Talking about lung function, can I have some help for my friend with emphysema?

Absolutely. Go back in time 40 years and tell him not to smoke as allopaths have been saying for years.

Beyond that, lung reduction and lung transplant both have reasonably good outcomes. And of course O2 therapy (an allopathic treatment) extends the life of thousands of emphysema sufferers, as do steroids and antibiotics.

My father AND my mother died this way, and without modern medicine would have died years sooner.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom