Is Homeopathy truly debunked?

In the sense that there is absolutely no agreement among homeopaths as to HOW a remedy should be prescribed. Different homeopaths, different methodologies.
and yet
Individualised homeopathy was provided by three nonmedically trained classical homeopaths, each of whom had been in practice for at least 10 years and met membership criteria for the Society for Homeopaths, UK. Patients could attend up to six homeopathic consultations over the course of a year, plus extra telephone consultations as necessary according to normal practice. Other advice such as dietary recommendations could be given in the usual way. Children were encouraged not to alter their conventional medication without advice from their asthma nurse or doctor. There was no maximum number of prescriptions allowed for each subject. In order to ensure a reasonable degree of uniformity of practice, the three homeopaths held case conferences at approximately monthly intervals. Each child’s case was presented and discussed on at least one occasion. The homeopaths reported that their approaches were substantially the same and that any differences would be unlikely to affect the outcome.
 
I am not, as you may have guessed, a member of the 'skeptic movement.' I am often skeptical (in the ordinary dictionary sense) of the consistency of its skepticism. In other words, I often find it selective.

OK: I agree that skepticism has blind spots. Medicine and homeopathy is not one of them.




And if she/he is not interested in the fact that some ideas are backed by vested interests and seek to dominate the culture for reasons other than the purest search for truth, then he/she is simply burying his/her head in the sand --in the name of intellectual integrity, sadly.

Two problems: I don't know if anybody is 'not interested' in identifying vested interest. Skeptics' core value is consumer protection.

Secondly, every viewpoint has a vested interest. If nothing more, once somebody has made a claim, they're biased to defend it. This is why bias is irrelevant to the investigation of whether a finding is true or not. It only informs you about why somebody would cling to a view that is demonstrably false.




It would have been braver to debunk homeopathy in the 19th century than now, and more satisfying from the standpoint of 'doing good.' Yes, the Robin Hood factor does matter.

I don't care about brave. I care about 'crooked'. Homeopathy doesn't work, and they're charging money for it. They've become masters of defending their income by changing the subject, avoiding the responsibility of proving that their product does what they claim it does.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom