Is Homeopathy truly debunked?

How often do homoeopathic remedies come as water anyway? Every one I have ever seen has been a bottle (or in once case a brown envelope) of sugar pills.

Many manufacturers use alcohol (95% I believe) as the solvent for making the potencies, not water. Hence the priceless spectacle of Rao et al. (2007) writing a long introduction about the possibility of the memory of water, then presenting experimental results obtained from the analysis of 95% ethanol because that's what the homoeopathic manufacturer they used sent them. Why they didn't use one of the manufacturers (like the notorious King Bio) who do use water, I really don't know. As I understand it, Hahnemann used alcohol to make the dilutions, and the water idea was a modification to pacify the teetotal element among US customers, but I'm open to clarification.

Rolfe.

Pfah! That's hilarious, Rolfe. Ethanol.
 
At the moment, it is impossible to distinguish between a valid homeopath, and a quack.

I can not believe that anyone capable of thought and reason can actually type this, consider its value and still claim that there are homeopaths out there that are "valid".
 
Presuming most common germs, bacteria, viruses, etc, which people tend to 'pick up' migrate into municipal water systems through the washing of hands, shouldn't most, if not all, diseases start becoming extinct?

Wouldn't all bodies of water start becoming SUPER-HOMEOPATHIC remedies with all of their inherent contaminants and dilution?

Has anyone done studies on individuals who live and swim near lakes and who have accidentally ingested large quantities of lake water? I bet those people are hardly ever sick!

The homeopaths have an answer to your retort. They believe that the solution becomes "active" only if it is succussed properly. Many homeopaths believe that the proper way to make water remember the initial ingredient is to shake the vial up and down ten times, back and forth ten times, and left and right ten times. That process must be repeated for each dilution. Therefore, the water in rivers and lakes does not have active homeopathic properties.
 
Many commercial homeopathic preparations never, ever had any of the material they claim to have been made from. Manufacturers have been caught filling bottles with tap water.

And Homeopaths seemed not to notice AT ALL that they had been buying straight tap water.


Not quite the same thing, but I'd be interested to know how many homoeopaths noticed this in the 6 months before the recall.
 
The homeopaths have an answer to your retort. They believe that the solution becomes "active" only if it is succussed properly. Many homeopaths believe that the proper way to make water remember the initial ingredient is to shake the vial up and down ten times, back and forth ten times, and left and right ten times. That process must be repeated for each dilution. Therefore, the water in rivers and lakes does not have active homeopathic properties.

Except, of course, the pharmacies vary considerably in what they actually do so the water has to be really really clever. Do you suppose it reads the signs on the walls so it knows it's in Boiron's factory?

They should run a series of trials half with the lights on and half in the dark just to confuse those water molecules. Or ethanol molecules, as appropriate.
 
How often do homoeopathic remedies come as water anyway? Every one I have ever seen has been a bottle (or in once case a brown envelope) of sugar pills.

Many manufacturers use alcohol (95% I believe) as the solvent for making the potencies, not water. Hence the priceless spectacle of Rao et al. (2007) writing a long introduction about the possibility of the memory of water, then presenting experimental results obtained from the analysis of 95% ethanol because that's what the homoeopathic manufacturer they used sent them. Why they didn't use one of the manufacturers (like the notorious King Bio) who do use water, I really don't know. As I understand it, Hahnemann used alcohol to make the dilutions, and the water idea was a modification to pacify the teetotal element among US customers, but I'm open to clarification.

Rolfe.

And the more dilute the "active" ingredients, the better; nothing's better for your health than 100% pure ethanol! (Good thing my liver regenerates spontaneously!)
 
How would you like it if GlaxoSmithKline was allowed to say, "hey, we've got thsi new drug, ther's no evidence oterh than anecdotal that it works or is safe, but we're going to sell it until someone proves otherwise"?
Would that be OK? If not, why not? And why should homoeopathy be any different?

But GSK and others DO put drugs out as 'safe' until someone proves otherwise. Look at all the problems that came about for something like Seroxat (an antidepressant). They said it was perfectly safe and non-addictive. Tell that to all the people who it made worse and killed themselves and the ones who spent months or years trying to get off it but couldn't. So now the doctors don't presribe it anymore, why? because it's not safe.

I don't think you can go around saying Homeopathic remedies are any worse than the Pharm. companies. If anything the Pharm. companies have got far more money and should be getting it right (telling the truth ;)) rather than pushing stuff out with minimal testing just to make more money for themselves.

Blu
 
In this country manufacturers have to demonstrate that new medicines "meet the standards of safety, quality and efficacy" before they can be sold or prescribed.

But homoeopathic medicines are exempt from this requirement.
 
Last edited:
In this country manufacturers have to demonstrate that new medicines "meet the standards of safety, quality and efficacy" before they can be sold or prescribed.

But homoeopathic medicines are exempt from this requirement.


Not forgetting that new medicines are monitored once they hit the market through the yellow card system. Some side effects either won't become apparent until you have a much larger pool of recipients than the clinical trials can provide or may have repercussions that are measured over years.

Just last week Lumiracoxib has had it's license pulled due to "Risk of severe liver reactions", see the letter here
 
Not forgetting that new medicines are monitored once they hit the market through the yellow card system. Some side effects either won't become apparent until you have a much larger pool of recipients than the clinical trials can provide or may have repercussions that are measured over years.

Just last week Lumiracoxib has had it's license pulled due to "Risk of severe liver reactions", see the letter here

A Homeopathic nostrum would have to have an effect to have a side-effect.
 
But GSK and others DO put drugs out as 'safe' until someone proves otherwise. Look at all the problems that came about for something like Seroxat (an antidepressant). {snip}
In fact, nothing can be proven "safe." That is just shorthand for "safe according to standard, clinical tests and specialized knowledge." Water can kill you, even when used as intended if one drinks too much. Unfortunately, after testing a drug for a limited time on a couple thousand people, they cannot always catch the problems that crop up in millions of patients over longer times.

{snip} If anything the Pharm. companies have got far more money and should be getting it right {snip}
See above.

rather than pushing stuff out with minimal testing just to make more money for themselves.
Calling the clinical trials required for a new drug "minimal testing" is astonishing. You clearly have no idea what you are writing about.

On the other hand, homeopaths make enormous amounts of money (too), in part because they do no safety (and efficacy) testing whatsoever. That standard falls below "minimal testing" no matter how you define "minimal."

Homeos don't even have quality control requirements similar to drug companies. Homeo preps can be contaminated with bacteria, or deliberately adulterated with clinically effective drugs that produce the desired effect. This is a serious problem if the drug is not safe for the patient, who thinks s/he is not taking it.


 
Not forgetting that new medicines are monitored once they hit the market through the yellow card system. Some side effects either won't become apparent until you have a much larger pool of recipients than the clinical trials can provide or may have repercussions that are measured over years.

Just last week Lumiracoxib has had it's license pulled due to "Risk of severe liver reactions", see the letter here
A Homeopathic nostrum would have to have an effect to have a side-effect.


Actually, it appears that medicines can be recalled for reasons other than unexpected side effects:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=1890927#post1890927

“Directive 2001/83/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 6 November 2001
on the Community code relating to medicinal products for human use” specifies under what
circumstances a recall may be required in Article 117. It defines the obligations of the
competent authorities of the relevant member states and of the marketing authorisation
holder.
1. If a medicinal product proves to be harmful under normal conditions of use.
2. If a medicinal product is lacking in therapeutic efficacy.

And apparently homoeopathic remedies can be reported as defective under the Yellow Card scheme...
 
Last edited:
Homeopathy doesn't do anything except by virtue of a placebo effect. However it is vastly superior to allopathic medicine, simply because it refrains from its many harmful practices.
 
Homeopathy doesn't do anything except by virtue of a placebo effect. However it is vastly superior to allopathic medicine, simply because it refrains from its many harmful practices.

Yeah, like CPR with chest compression can lead to rib fractures. I'd rather be dead.

Linda
 
Last edited:
Homeopathy doesn't do anything except by virtue of a placebo effect. However it is vastly superior to allopathic medicine, simply because it refrains from its many harmful practices.
:jaw-dropp
 
Who needs homeopathy when we have Dianetics. Same results with no shaking required.
 
Homeopathy doesn't do anything except by virtue of a placebo effect. However it is vastly superior to allopathic medicine, simply because it refrains from its many harmful practices.

Fine, next time you break something I will shove sugar pills down your throat and let the break heal in its own way.
 
Homeopathy doesn't do anything except by virtue of a placebo effect. However it is vastly superior to allopathic medicine, simply because it refrains from its many harmful practices.

And in 1810, that was likely a true statement. The state of Medicine was SO primitive then that doing NOTHING, i.e. Homeopathy, was actually often better for the patient than what an allopath would do to you.

However, it appears to have escaped your notice, but Medical Science is now producing outcomes better than no treatment in every area you might care to study. Allopathy (which merged with Surgery along the way) has advanced greatly as any actuary can prove to you, but Homeopathy hasn't advanced one step since 1810. And the treatment is still NOTHING.
 
Is Homeopathy truly debunked?


My question would be: Has Homeopathy been untruly debunked?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom