Is Homeopathy truly debunked?

To me, there is an official story that needs defending, so I tend to be, yes, skeptical and side with the underdog.

That's not skepticism: that's contrarianism. Or iconoclasm. Or Don Quixote. This behavior is usually a sign of being unskeptical.

Remember: homeopathy was *the* way medicine was done in the 19th century. There were government-funded schools of homeopathy, and they were licensed to treat a huge breadth of conditions. They were the establishment.

(Homeopathy was the official medicine of the Third Reich, because they were backward-thinking reactionaries, trying to relive imaginary good old days where this German science dominated the field of medicine... before "Jewish Medicine" swept homeopathy under the carpet.)

Like the flat earth theory, despite being obviously wrong, homeopathy nevertheless still has adherents.

Skeptics are not compelled to defend these guys because they're quaint. Skeptics defend the scientific method, and it has led us farther and farther away from homeopathy.
 
That's not skepticism: that's contrarianism. Or iconoclasm. Or Don Quixote. This behavior is usually a sign of being unskeptical.

I am not, as you may have guessed, a member of the 'skeptic movement.' I am often skeptical (in the ordinary dictionary sense) of the consistency of its skepticism. In other words, I often find it selective.

It is true that the social dominance or underdog status of an idea should not determine the appropriateness of being skeptical of it. But to the extent that a 'skeptic' (a member of the 'skeptic movement') is equipped with a social conscience and a desire to right epistemic wrongs in society, it might be a better use of his/her inquiring powers to look into those ideas that are less often subjected to critical examination.

And if she/he is not interested in the fact that some ideas are backed by vested interests and seek to dominate the culture for reasons other than the purest search for truth, then he/she is simply burying his/her head in the sand --in the name of intellectual integrity, sadly.

It would have been braver to debunk homeopathy in the 19th century than now, and more satisfying from the standpoint of 'doing good.' Yes, the Robin Hood factor does matter.
 
Well, my question to you would be "do you think any of the improvements we have seen can in any way be attributed to unproven advances, or are they all necessarily attributed to proven advances?"

Or in other words, why could common people afford windows? Was it because window-magicians claimed to alchemize glass from truffles, or was it because additional knowledge, from reproducible events, led to cheaper glass?

It could have been new glass technology, or increased income, or changed patterns in the glassmaking industry, or urbanization patterns, or some public campaigns for or against something, or... I really don't know.

And I don't know what you mean by proven and unproven advances.
 
I generally follow the WHO definition of health:

"a state of complete physical, mental and social well-being and not merely the absence of disease or infirmity".

What do you use?

This is cool. Self-rated health (i.e. the answer to the question, "for your age would you say, in general, your health is excellent, good, fair, poor or bad?") is a much better predictor of mortality than objective measures of health by a physician.

Linda

Well, I follow the WOO definition of health:

"I know it when I feel it":p
 
And I don't know what you mean by proven and unproven advances.

I mean that whatever caused the common people to be able to get windows had a proven effect -- people got windows. That is how it is with science. If something works, it works, if not, not. There is always a leading edge of hypothetical science that needs to be tested, but once it is and the results are conclusive ... well there is really nothing more to say.

I wouldn't claim that medical advances alone are responsible for greater longevity and quality of life. I would claim, however, that science in general is.
 
I mean that whatever caused the common people to be able to get windows had a proven effect -- people got windows. That is how it is with science. If something works, it works, if not, not. There is always a leading edge of hypothetical science that needs to be tested, but once it is and the results are conclusive ... well there is really nothing more to say.

I wouldn't claim that medical advances alone are responsible for greater longevity and quality of life. I would claim, however, that science in general is.

Well, if by science you also mean technological improvements, the industrial revolution and the attendant social changes, I agree.

However, there is some evidence that medicine has been claiming a bigger share of the credit than it deserves, and that was the point of my answer to your question.
 
However, there is some evidence that medicine has been claiming a bigger share of the credit than it deserves, and that was the point of my answer to your question.

Who cares? Medicine is not the primary attacker of homeopathy -- evidence based inquiry in general is. And it is easy to see that all of the improvements in history are based solely on rational thought and evidence based inquiry.
 
Well, if by science you also mean technological improvements, the industrial revolution and the attendant social changes, I agree.

However, there is some evidence that medicine has been claiming a bigger share of the credit than it deserves, and that was the point of my answer to your question.

And this is relevant because ... ?
 
Who cares? Medicine is not the primary attacker of homeopathy -- evidence based inquiry in general is. And it is easy to see that all of the improvements in history are based solely on rational thought and evidence based inquiry.

Dude...

You asked:

"Just out of curiosity, what else do you propose might be responsible?"

And then you asked:

"Yes, tell us, what are the main causes?"

And now you say:

"Who cares?"

Please try to pay attention.

Oh, and are you suggesting that I am defending homeopathy?

Please, please, try to pay attention.
 
Let’s see, we can do a test with one group using homeopathic pills, and the other group using nothing, and I bet that the results will be the same.

Paul

:) :) :)

Surprise, surprise, surprise
 
Let’s see, we can do a test with one group using homeopathic pills, and the other group using nothing, and I bet that the results will be the same.

Paul

:) :) :)

Surprise, surprise, surprise

Except that would be an unethical study. But I have no doubt you are correct.

Part of the reason that "placebo effect" is still thought to exist is because to study it as you would have to in a non-trivial disease requires you to have two cohorts, one you deny any treatment to, the other you give a sugar pill to.

And obviously, thats another Tuskegee.

I think we will eventually find, however, that it is not an effect at all except in self-limiting conditions where the effect is one of perception, not outcome.
 
Is homeopathy truly debunked.

"Debunked" is an odd word. Homeopathy is bunk. If we could remove it from serious consideration, our world would have been de-bunked. Or so it seems to me ;)
 
Mr Tea - response #4

Belz
“Meaning you have no idea if there are anything BUT quacks”.

Precisely. The only reason I am defending an irrational concept like homeopathy is due to the numerous observations I have witnessed on myself, when treated by homeopathy. At first I was incredulous, and now I have come to believe that there is something to this craziness!



Thing
In what sense do you claim that these homeopaths were not "reliable and qualified"?

In the sense that there is absolutely no agreement among homeopaths as to HOW a remedy should be prescribed. Different homeopaths, different methodologies.




Ron_Tomkins
“My question would be: Has Homeopathy been untruly debunked”?

My contention is that it hasn’t been proven, or disproven. It is up to homeopaths to prove that it works. It is therefore absurd (but fun) to debate this issue.
 
Precisely. The only reason I am defending an irrational concept like homeopathy is due to the numerous observations I have witnessed on myself, when treated by homeopathy. At first I was incredulous, and now I have come to believe that there is something to this craziness!

Tea, I've told you before, personal experience is unreliable. Otherwise you'd also have believe in UFOs, ghosts, etc., because people have personnal experience of them.

In the sense that there is absolutely no agreement among homeopaths as to HOW a remedy should be prescribed. Different homeopaths, different methodologies.

And you HAPPEN to think that SOME of them MAY have it right ?

My contention is that it hasn’t been proven, or disproven. It is up to homeopaths to prove that it works. It is therefore absurd (but fun) to debate this issue.

No, it isn't.
 
Some people get much better with Homopathic treatment, but those are ALWAYS self-limiting conditions. They would have gotten better without any treatment, and would have more money in their pocket.

If Homeopathy works, where is the HIV cure, or the Hodgkin's Lymphoma cure?

If you could knock those two things out with tap water or Everclear (the two things that might be in the bottle) the would would beat a path to your door no matter how many people think its woo.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom