Is Homeopathy truly debunked?

There's just simply absolutely NO REASON why it would work. Not one iota of sense at all. It's just water or sugar pills. That's it, that's all. It has no physiological effect, aside from what happens when you eat sugar or drink water. There's no way of telling one remedy from another if you take it out of the bottle.

It's just plain stupid.

Damned right, and it needs to be said more often. Homeopathy has had 200 years to provide scientific evidence, and has failed to do so, and is based on near-total ignorance and blatant idiocy.

After two centuries, I think it is fair to dismiss homeopathy outright. Why do we pretend that there is anything worth respecting?

It's just plain stupid.
 
It always strikes me as odd that homeopathy is "prescribed" to treat trivial illnesses that seem to resolve at about the same rate with a homeopathic cure as they would on their own.

I can just see it now...

"TUMOR ON, apply directly to tumor. TUMOR ON, apply directly to tumor. TUMOR ON, apply directly to tumor. TUMOR ON, apply directly to tumor. TUMOR ON, apply directly to tumor."

:D

-Dr. Imago
 
If Mr. X has a headache on the LEFT side of his head, then he would be given remedy A

If Mr. Y has a headache on the right side of his head, he would be given remedy B (according to homeopathic theory).

Why would a headache on the left side require a different remedy from one on the right side?
Or are you saying Mr. X just requires a differet remedy from Mr. Y, because they're different people?
 
Let me begin my reply by stating that I can only speak from teh homeopathic school of thought that I follow.

And there are just as many of those as there are homeopaths...

Evidence for the effectiveness of homeopathy can be rendered less anecdotal by using good homeopaths.

No True Scottsman fallacy.

The criteria to find such people? The %age of patients (that a homeopath has seen over a period of time) that report positive long-term results.

Laughable. All that could indicate is how good a peoples' person the homeopath is. Remember, patients tend to feel better when they have a positive interaction with someone.

-yet other studies yield different results (unfortunately I am not allowed to post urls at the moment...an annoying forum rule indeed)...

So post more. It only takes 15 posts.

That would depend on how the remedy was administered, and its dilution.

How it's administered ? You mean, other than ingested ?
 
Last edited:
{snip} How it's administered ? You mean, other than ingested ?
I once came across a book on treating accident victims with homeopathy (from whatever "school" of this cult). Every "treatment" begins with "Dial 911" (the national, emergency telephone-number in the USA). Then, one is advised to select the proper remedy and apply a drop to a convenient spot on the skin while waiting for help.
 
I'm often surprised by the number of friends who have absolutely no idea what homeopathy is based. Most people I ask seem to think a homeopathic ahem remedy is "herbal". When I mention like-cures-like, ultra-dilution and succussing (sp?) the most common reaction is one of stunned disbelief.

@ Dan 0. - :D
 
Most people think I'm exagerating, and don't believe that is all there is to it. My former classmates still think there's something "magical" to it, and I'm just not "open" to how it "really" works :rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes:
 
Most people think I'm exagerating, and don't believe that is all there is to it. My former classmates still think there's something "magical" to it, and I'm just not "open" to how it "really" works :rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes:

Yeah, because you know, there's so many people using it, it can't be entirely rubbish, they have heard so much about it, so many pharmacies sell it, even real doctors prescribe it, there must be something, it must have a kernel of truth, science just don't understand it, yet, blah blah blah. *throws up a little bit*
 
I once came across a book on treating accident victims with homeopathy (from whatever "school" of this cult). Every "treatment" begins with "Dial 911" (the national, emergency telephone-number in the USA). Then, one is advised to select the proper remedy and apply a drop to a convenient spot on the skin while waiting for help.

That sounds remarkably useless.
 
I agree: Homeopathy hasn't given us any reasons to take it seriously in the first place.
 
Homeopathy hasn't given us any reasons to take it seriously in the first place.


Apart from claiming to be an effective system of medicine, of course. Advising patients to, for example, try to avoid malaria using homoeopathy rather than methods that are actually effective is certainly a reason for taking these people seriously.
 
I once came across a book on treating accident victims with homeopathy (from whatever "school" of this cult). Every "treatment" begins with "Dial 911" (the national, emergency telephone-number in the USA). Then, one is advised to select the proper remedy and apply a drop to a convenient spot on the skin while waiting for help.


At least they did say to dial the emergency services!

Once upon a time there was a page on the Internet (on this site, I think, or possibly this one) entitled "Bloat in the dog, and how to treat it homoeopathically".

It began with a perfectly correct description of the clinical signs of what is termed "bloat" in dogs, that is a displacement and torson of the stomach, so that it rapidly fills up with gas. This was headed "symptoms according to [name - can't remember]", which suggested that the writer of the page (a British homoeopath with no medical or veterinary qualifications) had never actually seen a case herself.

Then followed a table cross-referencing these symptoms against the alleged proving symptoms for certain remedies - presumably symptoms reported by human provers, as remedies are never proved in animals. Then the writer chose her preferred remedy, and another which was a good partial match.

Then came the prescribed treatment. Drip a little of the chosen remedy into the dog's mouth and repeat at intervals (either five or 15 minutes, can't remember). If this doesn't seem to be doing the trick, try the other remedy. "Repeat until symptoms ease up or are gone."

Of course, the symptoms of bloat ease up and go when the dog dies! This is a fire-brigade emergency, as the only hope of saving the dog is immediate surgery. I read the page with mounting incredulity, waiting to see when the writer would get to the advice to call the vet. I'd recommend about 10 seconds from realising what's going on, myself - or less if you can get to your phone more quickly. But no. The writer never got there. No suggestion anywhere that the owner might consider calling the vet.

What sort of "prescribed methodology" was that, then?

The only saving grace of this page was that the hit counter at the bottom was in low double figures, and half of that was probably me and some other vets I told about the page. To publish that sort of advice about a condition you've never seen, have no training or experience with, and which is in fact fatal without immediate surgery, is just appalling. I'm glad the page is gone, but it was there for a long time.

(There was a funny sequel to this. I tried to initiate a discussion about the page on a veterinary alternative medicine emal group, and the first reply from a dog owner was to post another url, headed "an even more damgerous page". The page linked to was a mainstream site advising routine vaccination and giving standard dietary advice for pet owners. The poster went into a rant about how vaccines cause cancer and kidney failure - obviously true because she had had dogs which were vaccinated die of these diseases. Pointing out that these are the commonest causes of death in elderly dogs in any case, got nowhere. When she started claiming to have three dogs all aged over 20, which she fed entirely on raw ingredients, so it was obvious pet food was an evil conspiracy, we sort of gave up. But the bloat page never did get property addressed.)

Rolfe.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom