Is Homeopathy truly debunked?

Let me begin my reply by stating that I can only speak from the homeopathic school of thought that I follow.

Do you realize that you can win $1,000,000 and gain interantional fame and recognition if you are able to reliably distinguish between your own preparations and stock solution? The JREF Challenge rules allow for homeopaths to use any method they choose in distinguishing the two solutions: give it to patients, give it to yourself, test it with a machine, wave a dowsing rod over it, or use some other personal method. Your choice. One million dollars.
 
Why would a headache on the left side require a different remedy from one on the right side?
Or are you saying Mr. X just requires a differet remedy from Mr. Y, because they're different people?
That is what he should be saying, but he knows so little about homeopathy that he doesn't realise it.
The individulalised remedies for a left sided headache in Mr X would/should usually be different to those for a left sided headache in Mr Y (but equally it is also possible that the individualised remedies for a left sided headache in Mr A could be identical to those for a right sided headache in Mr B).
 
I notice something common between MrTea's belief and myriad other forms of crackpottery: (a) Failure to pass a test is always an individual mistake on the part of the testee, and (b) the real test would be passed by ... someone somewhere I can't quite put my finger on.

Thus Proluna and Aquila have told us all about the other schools of astrology that really are scientific, unlike the charlatans who have been tested. Free-energy enthusiasts always have a broken perpetual-motion machine in there garage, but they've heard of a working model down in Georgia (until that one got lost ... but its inventor based it on a working model in Nevada ...) And here we've got the excuse that homeopathy tests always failed because they used the wrong sort of homeopathy. The correct homeopathy would pass! (What is the correct homeopathy? No one knows. Always, it seems, one that hasn't been tested yet!)
 
If Mr. X has a headache on the LEFT side of his head, then he would be given remedy A

If Mr. Y has a headache on the right side of his head, he would be given remedy B (according to homeopathic theory).

Can you tell us exactly what ingredients are used in your example? Are there really different homepathic remedies for left and right headaches?
 
I notice something common between MrTea's belief and myriad other forms of crackpottery: (a) Failure to pass a test is always an individual mistake on the part of the testee, and (b) the real test would be passed by ... someone somewhere I can't quite put my finger on.

Thus Proluna and Aquila have told us all about the other schools of astrology that really are scientific, unlike the charlatans who have been tested. Free-energy enthusiasts always have a broken perpetual-motion machine in there garage, but they've heard of a working model down in Georgia (until that one got lost ... but its inventor based it on a working model in Nevada ...) And here we've got the excuse that homeopathy tests always failed because they used the wrong sort of homeopathy. The correct homeopathy would pass! (What is the correct homeopathy? No one knows. Always, it seems, one that hasn't been tested yet!)

Couldn't agree more. Though you might add to the reasons for failure (c) Them scientists and/or that grumpy conjuror ruined the test with their bad vibrations, they are to closed-minded.
 
response numero two

Wahrheit
"It's up to the people making the claims to work on proof and evidence for their claims, not the other way round".

Agreed. What say u all about this link (apologies for no url….again)
pediatrics[dot] aappublications[dot]org/cgi/content/abstract/93/5/719

my take is that studies like the one above that seem to “prove” homeopathy are just as dubious as similar studies that disprove homeopathy for a variety of reasons:

#1. There is a lack of licensing regulation. Therefore, it is impossible to tell if a homeopath that was used in a double-blind study is good or not…which paves the way for the No True Scotsman fallacy.

#2. Homeopathic methodology –as odd as it is…and it IS odd, but not disproven (or proven for that matter) – prescribes remedies according to each patient’s symptoms. If Mr. X has a throbbing headache on the left side of his head, while Mr. Y has a dull headache on the right side of his head….then one would look up “throbbing” + “left-side” + “Headache” in a homeopathic repertory to find the correct remedy for Mr. X, and one would look up “dull headache” + “right-side” to find the correct remedy for Mr. Y. I just don't see how a double-blind study could be of use, given the personal nature of the prescription.

The fact that diluted homeopathic remedies can only be distinguished by their labels can mean that there truly is no difference OR….just maybe (and I realize this is a moot point)…our detection abilities, as advanced as they are, are insufficient at this moment in time. Obviously I have no way of proving this, and trying to prove a negative in this situation is absurd.

The real conundrum for me is finding a way to license homeopaths –at least at the state/provincial level– to then incorporate in a well thought–out study. Then we can get underway towards finally seeing some proof –or lack thereof.
 
brodski & blutoski
Evidence for the effectiveness of homeopathy can be rendered less anecdotal by using good homeopaths. The criteria to find such people? The %age of patients (that a homeopath has seen over a period of time) that report positive long-term results.

Based on whose reporting? We just ask the homeopaths? What if they all claim equal success rates?

And if they don't claim equal success rates, but the profession isn't revising the treatment guidelines, what does this say about the profession's claim to be based on science?

And I agree with fls: we're not responsible for debunking - I assert that homeopaths are still at the stage where they have to provide just a scrap or two of credible evidence that their claims are even remotely true.
 
Last edited:
Wahrheit
"It's up to the people making the claims to work on proof and evidence for their claims, not the other way round".

Agreed.

If you agree to my above statement, the rest of your post becomes a little bit obsolete.

What say u all about this link (apologies for no url….again)
http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/cgi/content/abstract/93/5/719

Fixed the link for you. But I am not a medical pro, so other people should give a response to that specific link.

However, a small alarm bell rings in my head when I read that this "study" (I can't determine if it actually is) is from 1992. Where is the follow-up? That's 15 years old. Do you have any link for this?

Also, another small alarm rings when I read it is about diarrhea. Which kind of answers the rest of your post for me, regarding the headache. Those are conditions typical for the homeopathic business. Very common medical conditions which usually disappear after a short period of time anyway, no matter if any treatment was given or not. I want a real disease treated successfully by homeopathy to convince me, not those everyday everybody now-and-then conditions.
 
#1. There is a lack of licensing regulation. Therefore, it is impossible to tell if a homeopath that was used in a double-blind study is good or not…which paves the way for the No True Scotsman fallacy.

Fair enough. Here's a few questions then:
* can homeopahts agree on the definition of a 'legitemate' homeopath?
* Would using your criteria satisfy anybody but you?
* If not, then are you saying that in principle, it is impossible to "debunk" homeopathy short of testing everybody in the world who claims to be a homeopath? (Consider Popper here)
* Are you aware that failure does not dissuade true belivers? (consider that every dowser who has failed Randi's test, simply invents a convoluted excuse for why they had a bad day, and returns to their career of practicing dowsing for money)





#2. Homeopathic methodology –as odd as it is…and it IS odd, but not disproven (or proven for that matter) – prescribes remedies according to each patient’s symptoms. If Mr. X has a throbbing headache on the left side of his head, while Mr. Y has a dull headache on the right side of his head….then one would look up “throbbing” + “left-side” + “Headache” in a homeopathic repertory to find the correct remedy for Mr. X, and one would look up “dull headache” + “right-side” to find the correct remedy for Mr. Y. I just don't see how a double-blind study could be of use, given the personal nature of the prescription.

Then you don't understand what the term 'double blind' means. This scenario can be perfectly accomodated into a scientific double-blinded, placebo-controlled, statistically valid experiment. The athenticated (method to be determined) homeopath is given the patient's complaint, is allowed to ask questions to clarify, and then prescribes and prepares the nostrum of his choice. The homeopath hands the nostrum to the coders who either pass it along to the administrator, or replace it with placebo and hand this to the administrator. The coders record whether the patient received treatment or placebo. The administrator gives the nostrum to the patient, per instructions from the homeopath.





The fact that diluted homeopathic remedies can only be distinguished by their labels can mean that there truly is no difference OR….just maybe (and I realize this is a moot point)…our detection abilities, as advanced as they are, are insufficient at this moment in time.

It's not moot: one of the methods that has been used to test for difference between homeopathic remedy versus placebo is "improvement in the patient's complaint". ie: does it work? I can't think of a more appropriate test.






Obviously I have no way of proving this, and trying to prove a negative in this situation is absurd.

Irony truly is dead, then. What is demanding science to debunk homeopathy, if not asking us to prove a negative?

We are merely asking homeopaths to prove their central claim before charging patients money, which is the law for conventional medicine. They have exempted themselves from this accountability, and hold that we have to prove a negative. Thus, 200 years of free ride.

I appreciate that many are sincere, but I nevertheless regard the profession to be little more than a racket.






The real conundrum for me is finding a way to license homeopaths –at least at the state/provincial level– to then incorporate in a well thought–out study. Then we can get underway towards finally seeing some proof –or lack thereof.

Good luck with that: homepoaths would never allow this. They don't want to be tested - they may be proven to not have anything of value. Bad for business.
 
#2. Homeopathic methodology –as odd as it is…and it IS odd, but not disproven (or proven for that matter) – prescribes remedies according to each patient’s symptoms. If Mr. X has a throbbing headache on the left side of his head, while Mr. Y has a dull headache on the right side of his head….then one would look up “throbbing” + “left-side” + “Headache” in a homeopathic repertory to find the correct remedy for Mr. X, and one would look up “dull headache” + “right-side” to find the correct remedy for Mr. Y. I just don't see how a double-blind study could be of use, given the personal nature of the prescription.
You say "look up "dull headache" + Right-side"". How has the remedy for this particular combination been decided?
 
Those of you interested in a good overview of Homeopathy and a pile of relevant studies showing it's lack of efficacy should take a look at the Wikipedia article on it.
 
What say u all about this link (apologies for no url….again)
pediatrics[dot] aappublications[dot]org/cgi/content/abstract/93/5/719


There aren't that many studies claiming positive results for homoeopathy, so we tend to have already discussed them. In this case most recently here.

A criticism of the study was published in the same journal as the study: http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/cgi/content/abstract/96/5/961

I don't have access to the full text, but apparently it "pointed out that not only were the sickest children excluded, but [while the homeopathic group had one less unformed stool than the control group on day 3 of treatment] there were no significant differences on Days 1, 2, 4, or 5. This suggests that the conclusion was not valid. Further, there was no assurance that the homeopathic remedy was not adulterated (contaminated). Finally, standard remedies which halt diarrhea were not used for comparison purposes."
 
Wahrheit
"It's up to the people making the claims to work on proof and evidence for their claims, not the other way round".

Agreed. What say u all about this link (apologies for no url….again)
pediatrics[dot] aappublications[dot]org/cgi/content/abstract/93/5/719

my take is that studies like the one above that seem to “prove” homeopathy are just as dubious as similar studies that disprove homeopathy for a variety of reasons:

#1. There is a lack of licensing regulation. Therefore, it is impossible to tell if a homeopath that was used in a double-blind study is good or not…which paves the way for the No True Scotsman fallacy.

This isn't a problem. The question is, "where does the idea that homeopathy even works come from?" It doesn't come from people riding the coat-tails of a few truly skilled individuals who have made a careful and objective evaluation. It comes about because we all have cognitive biases. And unless we take specific measures to reduce or eliminate the effects of these biases, we will always find patterns. Because the practice of the True Homeopath makes no effort to eliminate the contributions of chance and bias, there is no reason to think that their patterns are any more real (i.e. based on something other than chance and bias (and fraud)) than those of the False Homeopath.

You seem to be making the claim that a careful, considered, subjective evaluation by someone with expertise, as a tool, is a reasonable way to discover real patterns. We all want to believe this. But it turns out that this claim is horribly wrong. This is how medicine was practiced for thousands of years and no progress was made during that time. It wasn't until we began to seriously consider the possibility that we were wrong, that we began to make progress. Instead of assuming that anything that happened after a treatment was because of the treatment, we actually measured what happened in the absence of treatment instead of just what happened in the presence of treatment. Instead of assuming that we could put aside wishful thinking when making evaluations, we made wishful thinking irrelevant by removing pre-knowledge through blinding. And what happened? We discovered that we had been wrong in a million different ways. But we also discovered that when you shave away all your wrong ideas and start to build on what's left, progress is explosive.

The most important result of the scientific process is not the body of facts that has gradually accumulated. It is that we have a process that accurately tells us when we are wrong. The practice of homeopathy does not use this process which means that the True Homeopath is no different from the False Homeopath when it comes to the possibility that their ideas are wrong.

#2. Homeopathic methodology –as odd as it is…and it IS odd, but not disproven (or proven for that matter) – prescribes remedies according to each patient’s symptoms. If Mr. X has a throbbing headache on the left side of his head, while Mr. Y has a dull headache on the right side of his head….then one would look up “throbbing” + “left-side” + “Headache” in a homeopathic repertory to find the correct remedy for Mr. X, and one would look up “dull headache” + “right-side” to find the correct remedy for Mr. Y. I just don't see how a double-blind study could be of use, given the personal nature of the prescription.

You don't understand the nature of 'double-blind'. 'Blinding' has absolutely nothing to do with the scenario you just described. The process of diagnosis and prescription can be done with full and complete knowledge on the part of both the patient and the practitioner.

The fact that diluted homeopathic remedies can only be distinguished by their labels can mean that there truly is no difference OR….just maybe (and I realize this is a moot point)…our detection abilities, as advanced as they are, are insufficient at this moment in time. Obviously I have no way of proving this, and trying to prove a negative in this situation is absurd.

This is completely irrelevant. Homeopathic remedies are not distinguished by their labels, but by their effects. If our detection abilities (i.e. differences in effects) are insufficient to tell the difference, how could any claims made by homeopaths and their patients (which depends solely upon these effects) be considered valid? You can't have it both ways.

The real conundrum for me is finding a way to license homeopaths –at least at the state/provincial level– to then incorporate in a well thought–out study. Then we can get underway towards finally seeing some proof –or lack thereof.

No. This is a complete waste of resources. Considering that most of our ideas are wrong, the a priori assumption should be that the idea is wrong until carefully tested. And the idea has already been carefully tested and shown to be wrong. The only support for the idea is a method of evaluation which has been shown to be horribly unreliable. All of the other 'support' for the idea has already been proven wrong by any reasonable measure (similars, infinitesimals, etc.). That it continues to occupy our bandwidth is almost a crime.

Linda
 
Evidence for the effectiveness of homeopathy can be rendered less anecdotal by using good homeopaths.


The evidence can only be "rendered less anecdotal" by relying on properly controlled tests. The fact that a patient appears to have improved after being given a remedy tells us nothing about whether they would have improved without the remedy. Anecdotal evidence is anecdotal, no matter how "good" the homoeopath is.
 
I just had a bit of a thought about the individualization problem, and realized that the solution already exists in the way conventional medicine approaches these trials.

Rather than attempting to debunk 'homeopathy' by going through weird hoops about how to define a good homeopath... scrap that and just examine the validity of each treatment/indication combo.

Assuming that there is at least *some* consensus out there about what "homeopathic repertory" is to be used, then focus on patients with one indication. Let's say throbbing left-side. Get enough patients with this condition to establish statistical power, and run them against placebo and perhaps even nontreatment (if ethical).

My warning is more about being realistic: this experimental format has been available to homeopaths for 200 years, and they've never shown interest before. Why do you think even a well-designed and executed experiment will have any effect on the "homeopathy question"?
 
Assuming that there is at least *some* consensus out there about what "homeopathic repertory" is to be used, then focus on patients with one indication. Let's say throbbing left-side.


I suspect that the official line will be that there is no consensus about the appropriate treatment for a particular indication, because the homoeopath looks at all of the patients symptoms, not just the ones they initially report (and these 'symptoms' may well go as far as including things like what sort of food they like) so that there is no specific remedy for any particular indication.

I also suspect, though, that patients going to a homoeopath with a particular condition will, after the consultation process and detailed symptom taking, tend to be prescribed the same remedy or group of remedies (a bit like the Nutrimatic drinks machine, which, having made an instant but highly detailed examination of the subject's taste buds and a spectroscopic analysis of the user's metabolism and then sent tiny experimental signals down the neural pathways to the taste centres of the user's brain to see what is likely to go down well, invariably delivers a cupful of brown liquid that is almost, but not quite, entirely unlike tea). Is there any published research on this?
 
I suspect that the official line will be that there is no consensus about the appropriate treatment for a particular indication, because the homoeopath looks at all of the patients symptoms, not just the ones they initially report (and these 'symptoms' may well go as far as including things like what sort of food they like) so that there is no specific remedy for any particular indication. {snip}
Yes; but this can be solved, after a fashion. However, homeos are full of "outs" that invalidate attempts at research. One is that, when a prep is ineffective it means the homeo made the wrong choice- not that homeo cannot work for the problem. So, they keep trying different stuff till the condition goes away on its own. Then they claim success.

Homeos are licensed in some states here. One in Nevada and one in Arizona have been in the news for killing their customers.
 
Homeos are licensed in some states here. One in Nevada and one in Arizona have been in the news for killing their customers.


…although the negative press coverage doesn’t seem to have interfered with their plans for this:

The American Medical College of Homeopathy in Phoenix is kicking off a $10 million capital campaign to build a medical campus that will include a research institute and medical center.

-snip-

Scheduled to open in 2009, the 5-acre campus also would include an American Museum of Homeopathy, pharmacy, veterinary clinic, public center, open-air theater, cafeteria and lounge, as well as water features throughout the grounds.

So far, about $200,000 has been raised. Although the goal is $10 million, the medical school portion could open with just $1 million, said Dr. Todd Rowe, the founder, president and chief executive of the homeopathic college in Phoenix. He also is both a medical doctor and a homeopathic physician.

More…
http://phoenix.bizjournals.com/phoenix/stories/2007/07/16/story1.html?b=1184558400^1490093#

(2 pages)
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom