Belz...
Fiend God
NOTE: let's be patient with MrTea's answers. He only checks this forum once a week.
Let me begin my reply by stating that I can only speak from the homeopathic school of thought that I follow.
That is what he should be saying, but he knows so little about homeopathy that he doesn't realise it.Why would a headache on the left side require a different remedy from one on the right side?
Or are you saying Mr. X just requires a differet remedy from Mr. Y, because they're different people?
If Mr. X has a headache on the LEFT side of his head, then he would be given remedy A
If Mr. Y has a headache on the right side of his head, he would be given remedy B (according to homeopathic theory).
I notice something common between MrTea's belief and myriad other forms of crackpottery: (a) Failure to pass a test is always an individual mistake on the part of the testee, and (b) the real test would be passed by ... someone somewhere I can't quite put my finger on.
Thus Proluna and Aquila have told us all about the other schools of astrology that really are scientific, unlike the charlatans who have been tested. Free-energy enthusiasts always have a broken perpetual-motion machine in there garage, but they've heard of a working model down in Georgia (until that one got lost ... but its inventor based it on a working model in Nevada ...) And here we've got the excuse that homeopathy tests always failed because they used the wrong sort of homeopathy. The correct homeopathy would pass! (What is the correct homeopathy? No one knows. Always, it seems, one that hasn't been tested yet!)
brodski & blutoski
Evidence for the effectiveness of homeopathy can be rendered less anecdotal by using good homeopaths. The criteria to find such people? The %age of patients (that a homeopath has seen over a period of time) that report positive long-term results.
Wahrheit
"It's up to the people making the claims to work on proof and evidence for their claims, not the other way round".
Agreed.
What say u all about this link (apologies for no url….again)
http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/cgi/content/abstract/93/5/719
#1. There is a lack of licensing regulation. Therefore, it is impossible to tell if a homeopath that was used in a double-blind study is good or not…which paves the way for the No True Scotsman fallacy.
#2. Homeopathic methodology –as odd as it is…and it IS odd, but not disproven (or proven for that matter) – prescribes remedies according to each patient’s symptoms. If Mr. X has a throbbing headache on the left side of his head, while Mr. Y has a dull headache on the right side of his head….then one would look up “throbbing” + “left-side” + “Headache” in a homeopathic repertory to find the correct remedy for Mr. X, and one would look up “dull headache” + “right-side” to find the correct remedy for Mr. Y. I just don't see how a double-blind study could be of use, given the personal nature of the prescription.
The fact that diluted homeopathic remedies can only be distinguished by their labels can mean that there truly is no difference OR….just maybe (and I realize this is a moot point)…our detection abilities, as advanced as they are, are insufficient at this moment in time.
Obviously I have no way of proving this, and trying to prove a negative in this situation is absurd.
The real conundrum for me is finding a way to license homeopaths –at least at the state/provincial level– to then incorporate in a well thought–out study. Then we can get underway towards finally seeing some proof –or lack thereof.
#2. Homeopathic methodology –as odd as it is…and it IS odd, but not disproven (or proven for that matter) – prescribes remedies according to each patient’s symptoms. If Mr. X has a throbbing headache on the left side of his head, while Mr. Y has a dull headache on the right side of his head….then one would look up “throbbing” + “left-side” + “Headache” in a homeopathic repertory to find the correct remedy for Mr. X, and one would look up “dull headache” + “right-side” to find the correct remedy for Mr. Y. I just don't see how a double-blind study could be of use, given the personal nature of the prescription.You say "look up "dull headache" + Right-side"". How has the remedy for this particular combination been decided?
What say u all about this link (apologies for no url….again)
pediatrics[dot] aappublications[dot]org/cgi/content/abstract/93/5/719
Wahrheit
"It's up to the people making the claims to work on proof and evidence for their claims, not the other way round".
Agreed. What say u all about this link (apologies for no url….again)
pediatrics[dot] aappublications[dot]org/cgi/content/abstract/93/5/719
my take is that studies like the one above that seem to “prove” homeopathy are just as dubious as similar studies that disprove homeopathy for a variety of reasons:
#1. There is a lack of licensing regulation. Therefore, it is impossible to tell if a homeopath that was used in a double-blind study is good or not…which paves the way for the No True Scotsman fallacy.
#2. Homeopathic methodology –as odd as it is…and it IS odd, but not disproven (or proven for that matter) – prescribes remedies according to each patient’s symptoms. If Mr. X has a throbbing headache on the left side of his head, while Mr. Y has a dull headache on the right side of his head….then one would look up “throbbing” + “left-side” + “Headache” in a homeopathic repertory to find the correct remedy for Mr. X, and one would look up “dull headache” + “right-side” to find the correct remedy for Mr. Y. I just don't see how a double-blind study could be of use, given the personal nature of the prescription.
The fact that diluted homeopathic remedies can only be distinguished by their labels can mean that there truly is no difference OR….just maybe (and I realize this is a moot point)…our detection abilities, as advanced as they are, are insufficient at this moment in time. Obviously I have no way of proving this, and trying to prove a negative in this situation is absurd.
The real conundrum for me is finding a way to license homeopaths –at least at the state/provincial level– to then incorporate in a well thought–out study. Then we can get underway towards finally seeing some proof –or lack thereof.
Evidence for the effectiveness of homeopathy can be rendered less anecdotal by using good homeopaths.
Assuming that there is at least *some* consensus out there about what "homeopathic repertory" is to be used, then focus on patients with one indication. Let's say throbbing left-side.
Yes; but this can be solved, after a fashion. However, homeos are full of "outs" that invalidate attempts at research. One is that, when a prep is ineffective it means the homeo made the wrong choice- not that homeo cannot work for the problem. So, they keep trying different stuff till the condition goes away on its own. Then they claim success.I suspect that the official line will be that there is no consensus about the appropriate treatment for a particular indication, because the homoeopath looks at all of the patients symptoms, not just the ones they initially report (and these 'symptoms' may well go as far as including things like what sort of food they like) so that there is no specific remedy for any particular indication. {snip}
Homeos are licensed in some states here. One in Nevada and one in Arizona have been in the news for killing their customers.
The American Medical College of Homeopathy in Phoenix is kicking off a $10 million capital campaign to build a medical campus that will include a research institute and medical center.
-snip-
Scheduled to open in 2009, the 5-acre campus also would include an American Museum of Homeopathy, pharmacy, veterinary clinic, public center, open-air theater, cafeteria and lounge, as well as water features throughout the grounds.
So far, about $200,000 has been raised. Although the goal is $10 million, the medical school portion could open with just $1 million, said Dr. Todd Rowe, the founder, president and chief executive of the homeopathic college in Phoenix. He also is both a medical doctor and a homeopathic physician.
More…
http://phoenix.bizjournals.com/phoenix/stories/2007/07/16/story1.html?b=1184558400^1490093#
(2 pages)