Wahrheit
"It's up to the people making the claims to work on proof and evidence for their claims, not the
other way round".
>>Agreed.
If you agree to my above statement, the rest of your post becomes a little bit obsolete".
Not in this case, since I am criticising the studies that claim to debunk homeopathy.
******************************************************************************************
Blutoski
“Then you don't understand what the term 'double blind' means. This scenario can be perfectly
accomodated into a scientific double-blinded, placebo-controlled, statistically valid
experiment. The athenticated (method to be determined) homeopath is given the patient's
complaint, is allowed to ask questions to clarify, and then prescribes and prepares the nostrum
of his choice. The homeopath hands the nostrum to the coders who either pass it along to the
administrator, or replace it with placebo and hand this to the administrator. The coders record
whether the patient received treatment or placebo. The administrator gives the nostrum to the
patient, per instructions from the homeopath”.
Good point!
"can homeopahts agree on the definition of a 'legitemate' homeopath"
no, they cannot.
"If not, then are you saying that in principle, it is impossible to "debunk" homeopathy short
of testing everybody in the world who claims to be a homeopath"?
until an authentication process can be found, it will be impossible to prove or disprove homeopathy.
"My warning is more about being realistic: this experimental format has been available to homeopaths for 200 years, and they've never shown interest before".
That is a BIG problem, especially since there is NO incentive to do so...bad for business for the quacks.
********************************************************************************************
Blue Wode
"Homeos are licensed in some states here. One in Nevada and one in Arizona have been in the news for killing their customers".
Wouldn't that be proof that homeopathy DOES have an effect on patients (malign in this case)?
********************************************************************************************
Paulhoff
"MrTea, you seem that you have a lot to learn"
Why yes, yes I do!