Is Homeopathy truly debunked?

#2. Homeopathic methodology –as odd as it is…and it IS odd, but not disproven (or proven for that matter) – prescribes remedies according to each patient’s symptoms. If Mr. X has a throbbing headache on the left side of his head, while Mr. Y has a dull headache on the right side of his head….then one would look up “throbbing” + “left-side” + “Headache” in a homeopathic repertory to find the correct remedy for Mr. X, and one would look up “dull headache” + “right-side” to find the correct remedy for Mr. Y. I just don't see how a double-blind study could be of use, given the personal nature of the prescription.

Tea, if no double-blind test can be designed, I submit that no homeopath could ever learn the trade.

If it works, you can design a test for it.
 


MrTea, you seem that you have a lot to learn, listen to Randi, he will clue you in on the snake-oil of Homeopathy.

Paul

:) :) :)
 
Last edited:
Wahrheit
"It's up to the people making the claims to work on proof and evidence for their claims, not the

other way round".
>>Agreed.
If you agree to my above statement, the rest of your post becomes a little bit obsolete".

Not in this case, since I am criticising the studies that claim to debunk homeopathy.

******************************************************************************************

Blutoski
“Then you don't understand what the term 'double blind' means. This scenario can be perfectly

accomodated into a scientific double-blinded, placebo-controlled, statistically valid

experiment. The athenticated (method to be determined) homeopath is given the patient's

complaint, is allowed to ask questions to clarify, and then prescribes and prepares the nostrum

of his choice. The homeopath hands the nostrum to the coders who either pass it along to the

administrator, or replace it with placebo and hand this to the administrator. The coders record

whether the patient received treatment or placebo. The administrator gives the nostrum to the

patient, per instructions from the homeopath”.

Good point!



"can homeopahts agree on the definition of a 'legitemate' homeopath"

no, they cannot.



"If not, then are you saying that in principle, it is impossible to "debunk" homeopathy short

of testing everybody in the world who claims to be a homeopath"?

until an authentication process can be found, it will be impossible to prove or disprove homeopathy.



"My warning is more about being realistic: this experimental format has been available to homeopaths for 200 years, and they've never shown interest before".

That is a BIG problem, especially since there is NO incentive to do so...bad for business for the quacks.

********************************************************************************************

Blue Wode
"Homeos are licensed in some states here. One in Nevada and one in Arizona have been in the news for killing their customers".

Wouldn't that be proof that homeopathy DOES have an effect on patients (malign in this case)?

********************************************************************************************

Paulhoff
"MrTea, you seem that you have a lot to learn"

Why yes, yes I do!
 
Mr Tea, I didn’t post
"Homeos are licensed in some states here. One in Nevada and one in Arizona have been in the news for killing their customers".

I quoted JJM.

However, I would say that licensing is not proof that homeopathy has an effect on patients. Rather it is proof of how easily legislators - who are unlikely to be well-versed in scientific matters - can be duped. And let’s not forget that there’s political mileage to be had in keeping sCAM fans happy.

ETA: Good grief, Mr Tea. I’ve just realised that you might be inferring that homeopathy works in some way because it can kill. Is that assumption correct?
 
Last edited:
{snip}
JJM said:
"Homeos are licensed in some states here. One in Nevada and one in Arizona have been in the news for killing their customers".

Wouldn't that be proof that homeopathy DOES have an effect on patients (malign in this case)?
Huh?
 
Wahrheit
"It's up to the people making the claims to work on proof and evidence for their claims, not the other way round".

>>Agreed.

If you agree to my above statement, the rest of your post becomes a little bit obsolete".

Not in this case, since I am criticising the studies that claim to debunk homeopathy.

I reread this thread, but couldn't find any reference to the studies "that claim to debunk homeopathy". Maybe I missed it.
What exactly are you talking about?

@JJM: :eusa_clap::thumbsup:
 
Last edited:
Homeopath, Heal Thyself!

No. It has just been diluted to the point where no truth remains.

!
I have an idea: Burn a copy of the Organon, do a 30c dillution of the ashes, and offer homeopaths the chance to sacrifice for their profession and prove it works by curing themselves of their own woo....
 
Last edited:
Warheit
"I reread this thread, but couldn't find any reference to the studies "that claim to debunk homeopathy". Maybe I missed it. What exactly are you talking about"?

I'm referring to studies such as this:
thorax.bmj.com/cgi/content/abstract/58/4/317

There are many studies that claim to debunk homeopathy (ie: that there is no difference between a homeopathic treatment, and a placebo). Such studies are invalid until reliable and qualified homeopaths can participate. At the moment, it is impossible to distinguish between a valid homeopath, and a quack.
 
MrTea said:
There are many studies that claim to debunk homeopathy (ie: that there is no difference between a homeopathic treatment, and a placebo).

Actually, those studies say that there is no statistical difference between the two. That means nothing else than saying that homeopathy is STILL not shown to dowk after all those tests.

You seem to read the conclusion differently than the rest of us.

Such studies are invalid until reliable and qualified homeopaths can participate.

No True Scottsman, again. Plus, double-blind studies, when made properly, speak for themselves, and you haven't shown that most of those studies were poorly conducted.

At the moment, it is impossible to distinguish between a valid homeopath, and a quack.

Meaning you have no idea if there are anything BUT quacks.
 
Warheit
"I reread this thread, but couldn't find any reference to the studies "that claim to debunk homeopathy". Maybe I missed it. What exactly are you talking about"?

I'm referring to studies such as this:
thorax.bmj.com/cgi/content/abstract/58/4/317

There are many studies that claim to debunk homeopathy (ie: that there is no difference between a homeopathic treatment, and a placebo). Such studies are invalid until reliable and qualified homeopaths can participate. At the moment, it is impossible to distinguish between a valid homeopath, and a quack.
Read, mmmmm, there is a video of Randi above that you seemed to not have watched.

Paul

:) :) :)
 
I'm referring to studies such as this:
thorax.bmj.com/cgi/content/abstract/58/4/317

There are many studies that claim to debunk homeopathy
Nowhere on the page you linked to can I find a phrase that even remotely reads like "We hereby claim to debunk homeopathy, and therefore made the following study".

(ie: that there is no difference between a homeopathic treatment, and a placebo).

Exactly. After 200 years of homeopathy, that's exactly what it looks like.

Such studies are invalid until reliable and qualified homeopaths can participate.

What's a "reliable" homeopath?

What's a "qualified" homeopath? The qualification to become a homeopath in most (all?) countries is a joke. In Germany, for example, a hair dresser can take the test to become a homeopath as soon as he is 25 years old.

At the moment, it is impossible to distinguish between a valid homeopath, and a quack.

That's because there is no difference.
 
Warheit
I'm referring to studies such as this:
thorax.bmj.com/cgi/content/abstract/58/4/317

There are many studies that claim to debunk homeopathy (ie: that there is no difference between a homeopathic treatment, and a placebo). Such studies are invalid until reliable and qualified homeopaths can participate. At the moment, it is impossible to distinguish between a valid homeopath, and a quack.

What makes you think that this study didn't test "reliable and qualified homeopaths"? Was this apparent before, or only after, you read the study's conclusions?
 
Presuming most common germs, bacteria, viruses, etc, which people tend to 'pick up' migrate into municipal water systems through the washing of hands, shouldn't most, if not all, diseases start becoming extinct?

Wouldn't all bodies of water start becoming SUPER-HOMEOPATHIC remedies with all of their inherent contaminants and dilution?

Has anyone done studies on individuals who live and swim near lakes and who have accidentally ingested large quantities of lake water? I bet those people are hardly ever sick!
 
Here is the most effective debunking;

Many commercial homeopathic preparations never, ever had any of the material they claim to have been made from. Manufacturers have been caught filling bottles with tap water.

And Homeopaths seemed not to notice AT ALL that they had been buying straight tap water.
 
How often do homoeopathic remedies come as water anyway? Every one I have ever seen has been a bottle (or in once case a brown envelope) of sugar pills.

Many manufacturers use alcohol (95% I believe) as the solvent for making the potencies, not water. Hence the priceless spectacle of Rao et al. (2007) writing a long introduction about the possibility of the memory of water, then presenting experimental results obtained from the analysis of 95% ethanol because that's what the homoeopathic manufacturer they used sent them. Why they didn't use one of the manufacturers (like the notorious King Bio) who do use water, I really don't know. As I understand it, Hahnemann used alcohol to make the dilutions, and the water idea was a modification to pacify the teetotal element among US customers, but I'm open to clarification.

Rolfe.
 
Here is the most effective debunking;

Many commercial homeopathic preparations never, ever had any of the material they claim to have been made from. Manufacturers have been caught filling bottles with tap water.

Do you have a citation for that? It would be very useful.
 
I'm referring to studies such as this:
thorax.bmj.com/cgi/content/abstract/58/4/317

There are many studies that claim to debunk homeopathy (ie: that there is no difference between a homeopathic treatment, and a placebo). Such studies are invalid until reliable and qualified homeopaths can participate. At the moment, it is impossible to distinguish between a valid homeopath, and a quack.

The methods section of that study says:
Individualised homeopathy was provided by three nonmedically trained classical homeopaths, each of whom had been in practice for at least 10 years and met membership criteria for the Society for Homeopaths, UK. Patients could attend up to six homeopathic consultations over the course of a year, plus extra telephone consultations as necessary according to normal practice. Other advice such as dietary recommendations could be given in the usual way. Children were encouraged not to alter their conventional medication without advice from their asthma nurse or doctor. There was no maximum number of prescriptions allowed for each subject. In order to ensure a reasonable degree of uniformity of practice, the three homeopaths held case conferences at approximately monthly intervals. Each child’s case was presented and discussed on at least one occasion. The homeopaths reported that their approaches were substantially the same and that any differences would be unlikely to affect the outcome.
In what sense do you claim that these homeopaths were not "reliable and qualified"?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom