Evidence against God's existence

I think that one can say with a certain amount of certainty that events and interactions, and the universe, in general behaive as if a god does not exist.

It hasn't yet been necessary to postulate that the events and interactions are capricious, anyway.

But then we really don't know how those events or interactions would behaive with a god.
The examples provided by religions are in all probability ficticious.

Yes, that's the problem. Proposing God-like parallel universes or Deism means that miracles or mystical experiences can't be examples of God.

Linda
 
It hasn't yet been necessary to postulate that the events and interactions are capricious, anyway.



Yes, that's the problem. Proposing God-like parallel universes or Deism means that miracles or mystical experiences can't be examples of God.

Linda

All I'm saying is that when we rule out an ID we are claiming omnicience. We are also commiting the falacy of hasty conclusion based on insufficient evidence since our little corner of the universe might very well be atypical in the vast scheme of things. This I find tantamount to huybris from creatures that are chained to their meager limited senses and who depend on making gadgets to help them out.
 
There's a difference between "ruling out" and saying "there's no evidence for."

Sure, it may be a vastly more complex universe than we can imagine or observe, and all sorts of things are possible...
Still, we don't have any more evidence for these alternate universes or designers or anything else than we do for God.

"You can't rule out the possibility of some sort of god or designer." True, but that's pretty thin beer; hardly different from saying there's no god or designer at all.
 
All I'm saying is that when we rule out an ID we are claiming omnicience. We are also commiting the falacy of hasty conclusion based on insufficient evidence since our little corner of the universe might very well be atypical in the vast scheme of things. This I find tantamount to huybris from creatures that are chained to their meager limited senses and who depend on making gadgets to help them out.

Why is it presumed that we are obliged to say anything at all about ID? ID is an assumption that the nature of a creative or controlling force is capricious. But why make any assumptions in the absence of any indications that capriciousness is necessary?

Linda
 
I rule out ID because it is useless, unevidenced, intellectual lazy, intellectually dishonest, based on stupidity and based on ignorance.

Did I say completely useless? Sorry, I'm mistaken. No, it is actually harmful garbage that stunts scientific development for the sole purpose of mental masturbation of lazy theists who are so faithless,they have to jam their unscientific nonsense into classrooms and whine about how everyone thinks their nonsense gets no respect.
 
Why is it presumed that we are obliged to say anything at all about ID? ID is an assumption that the nature of a creative or controlling force is capricious. But why make any assumptions in the absence of any indications that capriciousness is necessary?

Linda

I don't assume anything at all when I accept the possibility of an ID.
 
I don't assume anything at all when I accept the possibility of an ID.

Yes you do. You wouldn't call it an "ID" unless you were assuming characteristics which would distinguish it from something like gravity.

Linda
 
All I'm saying is that when we rule out an ID we are claiming omnicience. We are also commiting the falacy of hasty conclusion based on insufficient evidence since our little corner of the universe might very well be atypical in the vast scheme of things. This I find tantamount to huybris from creatures that are chained to their meager limited senses and who depend on making gadgets to help them out.

Stating there is no intelligent designer is no more presumptuous than stating there are no leprechauns.

Since you brought the topic up, my next argument will be about the philosophical (not scientific) problems with an intelligent designer. More to come tonight, or maybe tomorrow.
 
So sorry to offend. I will try to use the correct spelling in the future.
Go ahead and snap at me like a dog biting a veterinarian, I was expecting it. I still feel good, knowing that with the way you're trying to impress everyone, deep down inside you're actually grateful to be aware of the mistake so that you can avoid it in the future.
 
Stating there is no intelligent designer is no more presumptuous than stating there are no leprechauns.

Since you brought the topic up, my next argument will be about the philosophical (not scientific) problems with an intelligent designer. More to come tonight, or maybe tomorrow.


So in the whole universe there are absolutely no creatures which would fit the description of a leprechaun? On what do you base your certainty?
 
So in the whole universe there are absolutely no KNOWN creatures which would fit the description of a leprechaun?
Corrected it for you.
On what do you base your certainty?
The fact that leprechauns are a myth and there is no reason to believe something without any evidence.
 
So in the whole universe there are absolutely no creatures which would fit the description of a leprechaun? On what do you base your certainty?

Are you honestly going to go the route of "There are no leprechauns" is an unjustified statement?
 
God as a policeman: Responding to your call would rob the intruder of his free will.
God as a fire fighter: You caused the fire by being dumb, you deal with it. Either way, it's not as if you've got lots of neighbours, why aren't they putting out the fire?
God as a paramedic:
There needs to be illness in the city so we can truly appreciate healthiness.

God as an absentee landlord: I don't care about you or your interpretation of any of this, and I don't have to do a thing that you expect me to do.
 
I'm just curious about your absolute certainty and trying to determine on what it is based.

Can you please point out to me in this thread, where anyone other than you has mentioned certainty in regards to an intelligent designer?
 
Can you please point out to me in this thread, where anyone other than you has mentioned certainty in regards to an intelligent designer?

Accepting a possibility isn't expressing certainty. Certainty is what you claim to know for sure--that the possibility doesn't exist.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom