No Intelligence, No Design
The idea of intelligent design states that life was created due to the intent of an intelligent being, or designer. ID proponents often cite the complexity and almost mechanical nature of the physiological systems of plants and animals, and the balance of ecology as a whole. It is commonly stated that these complex structures could not arise on their own; they must have come from something more complex. After all, if you were walking in a forest and found a watch on the ground, you would not assume that it had arrived there by natural means. Rather, it was made by something intelligent.
I will freely admit that, at a glance, intelligent design does make some sense. However, on further inspection, it fails miserably.
To start, just what is complexity? It’s certainly not something that can be objectively measured. It is a matter of
perception. At a microscopic level, isn’t a rock complex? Trillions of atoms composed in a very specific way make a rock what it is. Any variation among them, and it would be a different rock. So, are rocks the product of this designer as well? If so, then how are we to infer complexity? After all, isn’t
everything complex now? Appealing to the intricacy of life hinges upon contrasting what is complex and what is not, which now fails, as there is no non-complex thing. If the rock is not complex, then what is? Merely what you state is so? Show me a standard you are using that does not apply to the rock, or other natural systems, such as gravity or the water cycle.
In addition, the necessity of a complex designer would also apply to the designer itself. Who made the designer? This leads into the
homunculus fallacy. (I will not go into detail on it here)
So even looking past that, what do we see in the natural world? Do we see a perfectly working system? No. We see failure. We see error. We see extinction. We see flaw. If life is the product of an intelligent designer, why do we see a flaw in the design? Why do humans have a blind spot in each eye? Why is it that 99% of the species that have ever come to be on this planet have gone extinct? Why are there not enough resources to go around? The
only possible answer an ID proponent can give in response to these questions is, “That’s just the way he did it.” But that’s not much of an answer. That has no explanatory power whatsoever. The necessary conclusion is either that the designer made a mistake in his work, or he purposely made the world with flaws, neither of which any theist will admit.
The fact is, an unguided natural order with no intent or goal is a far superior explanation to the world we see. Why are there flaws? Because random mutations do not guarantee the best solution. Why is there extinction? Because natural selection weeds out the inferior species, and they die off. Why is there scarcity of resources? Because there is no loving entity striving to ensure our survival.
Intelligent design is an idea that died over a hundred years ago. Science has been beating the dead horse ever since.