Evidence against God's existence

I hope Radrook doesn't think of himself as a Christian. He really doesn't seem to get that whole "love thy neighbour, turn the other cheek" bit.


I don't know.

Until I snitched on him and it was removed, he had a request related to cheeks in his signature. Perhaps his understanding of xian 'principles' is merely a bit skewed...
 
Suffering does at first seem to pose a bad problem, but I believe we must continue a wee bit deeper into the subject of suffering before we can give any conclusions.
The very first question to be considered, since this is an objection to any God, including the God of Christianity, is what does God say about the origin of suffering? I, since I'm a Christian will appeal to the Bible.
The Bible teaches that when God first made the world, it was good, and perfect(Genesis 1:31). And after God made man, he gave him a explicit commandment, "...Of every tree of the garden thou mayest freely eat: but of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil, thou shalt not eat of it: for in the day that thou eatest thereof thou shalt surely die." We all pretty much know what happened later; Eve was deceived, & she ate of it; she gave it to Adam & he ate of it. That very day they both died spiritually, and they began slowly to grow old and then finally died naturally.
Every man since then was born with a sinful nature. I common objection to this is that why should Adam's descendants pay for something they had nothing to do with? The answer is simple; God does not punish anybody for another's sin(Deuteronomy 24:16), but since we inherited a sinful nature, we all have sinned ourselves, thus making us guilty before God.
So the origin of suffering is not from God, but from man!
Second, one must consider the route God decided to take to fix what Adam had done. Romans 1:1-3 states, "Paul, a servant of Jesus Christ, called to be an apostle, separated unto the gospel of God, (Which he had promised afore by his prophets in the holy scriptures,) Concerning his Son Jesus Christ our Lord, which was made of the seed of David according to the flesh:..." This speaks of the prophecies of the Old Testament concerning Jesus Christ. Lets compare to Isaiah 53:4-6, "Surely he hath brone our griefs, and carried our sorrows: yet we did esteem him stricken, smitten of God, and afflicted. But he was wounded for our trangressions, he was bruised for our iniquites: the chastisement of our peace was upon him; and with his stripes we are healed. All we like sheep have gone astray; we have turned every one to his own way; and the LORD hath laid on him the iniquity of us all." On a side note, it is common for people to dismiss the accuracy of Old Testament prophecies by simply saying they were added or changed after the days of the beginning of Christianity. The problem with this is that if they were added after the time of Jesus, they would be rejected by people of the Jewish faith; but since these prophecies are included in the Jewish translations of the Tanach(Old Testament), the only plausible solution is that these prophecies had to be in the orginals, and already accepted by the Jewish communty before the time of Jesus.Also this could not have been talking of the nation of Israel as the suffer because Isaiah stated that God had laid on him the iniquity of "us" all. If the preceeding prophecy teaches about the suffering of Israel, then why does it say that "God" laid on "him(the righteous servant, Isaiah 53:12)" the iniquity of "us(Isaiah and Israel)?"
Okay now, since Jesus is taught in Christianity to be the fulness of the Godhead bodily(Col 2:8-9), and that he suffered for the sins of the world, how can one with a good reason condemn God over suffering?
To make this clearer, MAN sinned and caused suffering, but JESUS CHRIST suffered, bore the sins of the entire world, died, and rose again, for a problem the human race brought on its own self!
Imagine(and only imagine :) ), you were in God's place for a moment. Now would you want to do what Jesus done for us? God went out of his way to help us.
Now why wouldn't he just fix the problem without going to that extreme? The Bible shows in Romans 9:23, "And that he might make known the riches of his glory on the vessels of mercy, which he had afore prepared unto glory,..." God chose this way so that he could show how much he loved us! And on top of this, what does it matter if he decided to take this route to fix OUR problem? the point is that HE fixed OUR problem. Some might ask, "What problem?" Romans 6:23, "For the wages of sin is death; but the gift of God is eternal life through Jesus Christ our Lord."
Now third, you had a question you desired a Christian to answer; you said that there was a contradiction in that God prepared a place called heaven, but yet we had to endure all the suffering in this life before we go on to the next. I would like to ask, "What contradiction???" God nowhere in the scripture said, "If you turn to me, you'll live in this life in complete bliss; you'll trod through a bed of roses on your way to eternal paradise with me in heaven!" The word, "contradiction" separated into its prefix, affix and root, literally means, "The action of speaking against." This was stated by you meaning that there was a place where Christian doctrine spoke against its own self. Since the Bible does not teach that there will be no suffering in this life, but rather that there will be no suffering in the world to come for those who trust and yeild theirselves to Christ, it therefore does not contradict itself in the slightest way in this area. The covenant with God is eternal life in the next world through Jesus Christ. Jesus said in John 14:20, "Remember the word that I said unto you, The servent is not greater than his lord. If they have persecuted me, they will also persecute you; if they have kept my saying, they will keep yours also." Anyone who looks at the suffering in this present life, and attempts to point a finger of God, must point his finger through the cross. The Cross nullifies, in my opinion, any accusation against God in this matter. Hebrews 2:9-10, "But we see Jesus, who was made a little lower than the angels for the suffering of death, crowned with glory and honour; that he by the grace of God should taste death for every man. For it became him, for whom are all things, and by whom are all things, in bringing many sons unto glory, to make the captain of their salvation perfect through sufferings." Again in Hebrews 4:14-15, "Seeing then that we have a great high priest, that is passed into the heavens, Jesus the Son of God, let us hold fast to our profession. For we have not an high priest which cannot be touched with the feeling of our infirmities; but was in all points tempted like as we are, yet without sin."
So in short,
1. The human race caused suffering on its own self.
2. God to show his Glory and Love, chose to wrap himself in flesh, experiencing our sorrows, our griefs, baring our sin on his flesh, all to solve a problem humans caused.
3 We were never promised not to suffer in this world, but we were instructed to remember that the servants(the Christians) are not greater than their Lord(Jesus Christ), who suffered persecution immeasurably. To accuse God on these grounds, one must completely overlook the atoning, torturous death of Jesus Christ.

You earlier quoted Epicurus; one thing of note, Epicurus was from 341- 270 BC, as you noted. BC, could be taken as before Christ. Anything that happened "Before Christ" happened "Before the Cross of Jesus," which is the only time where Epicurus' comments could bring any damaging effect on the belief that there is a true benevolent, loving God.
 
I don't know.

Until I snitched on him and it was removed, he had a request related to cheeks in his signature. Perhaps his understanding of xian 'principles' is merely a bit skewed...

Love thy neighbour's cheeks?
 
Umm... I don't mean to be critical, but thought your username was "Complexity?"


I am perfectly capable of reading what you wrote. I'm even able to make as much sense of what you wrote as is possible.

I won't read what you wrote, however.

You haven't learned how to use whitespace to improve readability. This alone is sufficient to disqualify your text for reading. It is also very discourteous.

Your text contains bibble citations. This alone is sufficient to disqualify your text for reading. It is also very discourteous.

You wrote it. This alone is sufficient to disqualify your text for reading.

I hope that you understand why I will not read what you wrote or anything that you will write.
 
Last edited:
What a dense, unreadable mess!

Same ol' same ol'

God made man, man disobeyed god, god killed himself to redeem man, we should be grateful or we'll go to hell.

Add a few miracles, disasters, prophets and genocides.
 
Cutting to the chase:
1. The human race caused suffering on its own self.
Did the human race cause disease, famine, natural disasters and other such common causes of suffering? The short answer is "no". Those things are either natural phenomena or are created by powers above those of mere humans.

2. God to show his Glory and Love, chose to wrap himself in flesh, experiencing our sorrows, our griefs, baring our sin on his flesh, all to solve a problem humans caused.
Why didn't God show his glory and love by eliminating the causes of suffering? Does God hate and want to torture humans?

3 We were never promised not to suffer in this world, but we were instructed to remember that the servants(the Christians) are not greater than their Lord(Jesus Christ), who suffered persecution immeasurably. To accuse God on these grounds, one must completely overlook the atoning, torturous death of Jesus Christ.
Come on. Jesus didn't suffer immeasurably. He suffered for three days. I had an aunt with bone cancer that suffered worse than Jesus, and for years. Lots of people have suffered worse than Jesus. And what has God done about that? Not a damn thing. Humans, on the other hand, have made great strides in alleviating suffering, sometimes in opposition to the teachings of the church.

So if it comes down to God's "mercy" versus human compassion for each other, I'd pick humans every time. The God of the Bible is a total, egotistical, humorless, mean-spirited self-serving prick.

The only consolation is that the God of the Bible doesn't exist. Thank God.
Yes, that was deliberate. Meant as sarcasm, not as any acknowledgement of God.
 
So the origin of suffering is not from God, but from man!

Your argument is flawed. You could still make your point by other means, but the path you've chosen is doomed to failure for a few reasons.

1. You can't use the bible as proof of anything without first establishing that the bible can be taken as an authority on these things. I would strongly reccommend not even trying to do so, because most people here have already heard all the arguments and have not found them to be at all compelling. If you want to use arguments from the bible they would have to stand by themselves, so rather than "the bible tells us..." you would start with "okay, but hypothetically what if...".

2. Even as a hypothetical scenario yours is pretty weak. Putting the blame on man while also presuming an omnipotent and omnicient creator doesn't work because God would have known the outcome before even starting the experiment and so the blame is still his. He still deliberately set out to do things that way.

Since the original point wasn't trying to prove the bible wrong, though, you still have some ways to argue for the existance of a god despite suffering.

1. Humans are not "special" to God, and He is indifferent to our suffering.
2. The universe was built for some purpose and engineering it so that there is no suffering would make it not suitable for that purpose.
3. God is outright evil, and likes suffering a lot.
4. God doesn't count it as suffering, because our souls (or whatever) provided informed consent prior to being born and will benefit from the experience after the fact.

There's four options open to you that don't rely on the bible and allow for some version of God despite human suffering.
 
First, the reason why I have been quoting the Bible in this discussion is because the first objection placed by the maker of this thread was proposed against God on a moral level, which is God's own domain. My point is not to prove to anyone that the Bible is true at this point, but to prove that Christianity survives the thread maker's objection.

Tricky, since you say that "Jesus didn't suffer immeasurably," I thought a detailed analysis of the crucifixion of Jesus is in order. What I'm about to discuss should be skipped by people with weak stomachs.

First, the victim would be flogged with a whip with several prongs designed to tear the flesh from his body. He would be beat to the point to where the inner organs were exposed. Then after this he would be forced to carry his own cross, which had been hewed into shape with an axe, thus making the surface full of long splenters, to the place of his death. They would then lay him on the cross, and nail one wrist(in the time this was written, the word hand would have included the wrist) to the cross with a pin as big as a railroad stake. This would cause the nail to go through the median nerve, which is the largest nerve going out to the hand, thus crushing it. To show how painful this is, i'll describe something we have all felt before. When a person 'hits his funnybone(actually, his ulna nerve), it produces great pain. The pain Jesus would have endured would have been similar to someone squeezing the ulna nerve with a pair of wire pliers to the point of crushing it. His other arm would have been stretched out and nailed in the same manner, and also his feet. He would then be risen upward. Through this proccess his shoulders would have went out of joint. He would hang downwards, and by his own weight would begin to sufficate himself. The only why to get breath would be to push upwards with his pierced feet. And his death did not transpire in minutes, but in hours. Couple this with the Christian doctrine that Christ bore the sin of the whole world. When a person does something they regret doing, or something they know is immoral, at times depending on the deepness of the circumstance, they feel horrible, they feel dejected, and worthless. Picture Christ baring the burden & judgement of ALL sin, from a simple sinner, to the worsed sinner, from Adam to Hitler, from a wife beater to a child molester. I don't believe it is fair to state that Christ only suffered a little bit, when he really suffered more, if you count the burden of the entire world's sin, than any person on earth.

Jesus has made a way to reach a place of eternal rest. Even if we suffer here, the blessings to be had with Jesus in the next life are far abundant. 2 Corinthians 4:17, "For our light affliction, which is but for a moment, worketh for us a far more exceeding and eternal weight of glory."

Hebrews 12:10-11, "For they for a few days chastened us after their own pleasure; but he[God] for our profit, that we might be partakers of his holiness. Now no chastening for the present seemeth to be joyous, but grievous: nevertheless afterward it yieldeth the peaceable fruit of righteousness unto them which are exercised thereby."
 
bro.mack, you're still not getting the point.

For the sake of this discussion, I will grant you that all suffering, even suffering caused by natural disasters, is man-made in some supernatural fashion. Given that, why doesn't God prevent natural disasters from occurring? You have not addressed this point at all.

In addition, you do not understand my point about heaven. Heaven is defined as a realm with no suffering at all. So, what if an individual in heaven wants to cause the suffering of another, or act in some manner that "introduces sin to the world?"
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom