Evidence against God's existence

When you find yourself arguing for the existence of leprechauns you might want to reexamine your premises.

Another effort to misrepresent via strawman. You know full well that I'm not arguing one way or the other. What I do eventually with people who insist on heckling and jeckling and cluttering My Screen with nonsense is to place them on my ignore list. Keeps the screen clear of unnecessary distractions and leaves it only with those who really wish to discuss the matter logically.
 
Yes you do. You wouldn't call it an "ID" unless you were assuming characteristics which would distinguish it from something like gravity.

Linda

Since the subject is an ID how could I do otherwise? Your requirement is tantamount simply saying "SHUT UP!" Or, don't think. Or don't dare propose that idea cause it causes me psychological pain. Instead why not explain to me in order to convince me why I should be as absolutely certain as you are about the nonexistence of an ID.
 
There's a difference between "ruling out" and saying "there's no evidence for."

Sure, it may be a vastly more complex universe than we can imagine or observe, and all sorts of things are possible...
Still, we don't have any more evidence for these alternate universes or designers or anything else than we do for God.

"You can't rule out the possibility of some sort of god or designer." True, but that's pretty thin beer; hardly different from saying there's no god or designer at all.

The difference is that in this discussion I'm not proposing the existence or nonexistence of anything at all as you insist that I am. I'm simply asking about the basis for the certainty or at least the strong tendency to dismiss the possibility as silly. Can you please give me a logical reason why I should consider the possibility silly?

BTW
Many people view life sprouting from water all by itself silly.
 
Last edited:
Since the subject is an ID how could I do otherwise?

Simple. You don't bother to posit entities without necessity.

Your requirement is tantamount simply saying "SHUT UP!" Or, don't think. Or don't dare propose that idea cause it causes me psychological pain.

Nah. It's apathy. Why put yourself to the trouble of figuring out whether leprechauns have green eyes if you don't have to?

Instead why not explain to me in order to convince me why I should be as absolutely certain as you are about the nonexistence of an ID.

Who says I'm certain about the non-existence of an ID?

Linda
 
Stating there is no intelligent designer is no more presumptuous than stating there are no leprechauns.

Since you brought the topic up, my next argument will be about the philosophical (not scientific) problems with an intelligent designer. More to come tonight, or maybe tomorrow.


Wrong! There is a big difference since Leprachauns aren't credited with creation of mankind or the universe. So there is definitely a vast philosophical difference.
You know that.
 
Simple. You don't bother to posit entities without necessity.



Nah. It's apathy. Why put yourself to the trouble of figuring out whether leprechauns have green eyes if you don't have to?



Who says I'm certain about the non-existence of an ID?

Linda


So I'm trying to figure out if Lepracauns have green eyes? OK.
 
Wrong! There is a big difference since Leprachauns aren't credited with creation of mankind or the universe. So there is definitely a vast philosophical difference.
You know that.

The analogy was comparing one unevidenced mythological creature with another.
You know that.

Would you prefer to compare an intelligent designer to the Great Green Arkleseizure?
 
Wrong! There is a big difference since Leprachauns aren't credited with creation of mankind or the universe. So there is definitely a vast philosophical difference.
You know that.

In addition to what RoboTimbo stated: Is a belief in an intelligent designer more justified than a belief in leprechauns? If so, please illustrate to me why this is so. If not, I agree wholeheartedly.
 
In addition to what RoboTimbo stated: Is a belief in an intelligent designer more justified than a belief in leprechauns? If so, please illustrate to me why this is so. If not, I agree wholeheartedly.

The belief in leprecahauns doesn't entail intelligent design. Bringing in leprechauns, fairies, trolls, elves, Peter Pan etcetera, constitutes an annoying p[ersistent false analogy in the service of disagreement.


BTW
Why do you assume I'm restricting the designer to one? I'm focusing on the act of design by a mind or minds. I am not focusing on the nature of the designer. Neither am I refering to it as a god, GOd, god. That title and subsequent behavior based on that isn't part of the subject from my standpoint.
 
Last edited:
Simple. You don't bother to posit entities without necessity.



Nah. It's apathy. Why put yourself to the trouble of figuring out whether leprechauns have green eyes if you don't have to?



Who says I'm certain about the non-existence of an ID?

Linda


He's been trying to cram that word ("certainty") into someone's mouth since I stared reading this thread.
 
He's been trying to cram that word ("certainty") into someone's mouth since I stared reading this thread.

Tantamount to certainty then. Many of these responders are responding to their own strawman arguments.
But you haven't noticed that.
 
Last edited:
Another effort to misrepresent via strawman. You know full well that I'm not arguing one way or the other. What I do eventually with people who insist on heckling and jeckling and cluttering My Screen with nonsense is to place them on my ignore list. Keeps the screen clear of unnecessary distractions and leaves it only with those who really wish to discuss the matter logically.

Then soon you'll have a thread full of nothing but your own comments.

It's sad when a person decides to lock their mind away from any unsettling opinions.
 
Wrong! There is a big difference since Leprachauns aren't credited with creation of mankind or the universe. So there is definitely a vast philosophical difference.
You know that.

So if I make up a story about Leprechauns creating the universe you'll start taking them seriously?
 
The belief in leprecahauns doesn't entail intelligent design.

I never said it did. I would highly recommend a lesson in reading comprehension, as you are exhibiting a habit of seeing messages that are not there.

Let's try this one more time: Is a belief in an intelligent designer more justified than a belief in leprechauns? If so, please illustrate to me why this is so. If not, I agree wholeheartedly.
 
I never said it did. I would highly recommend a lesson in reading comprehension, as you are exhibiting a habit of seeing messages that are not there.

Let's try this one more time: Is a belief in an intelligent designer more justified than a belief in leprechauns? If so, please illustrate to me why this is so. If not, I agree wholeheartedly.

I asked about leprechauns and had the ignore button brandished in front of me so you might be in grave danger.:D
 
I never said it did. I would highly recommend a lesson in reading comprehension, as you are exhibiting a habit of seeing messages that are not there.

Let's try this one more time: Is a belief in an intelligent designer more justified than a belief in leprechauns? If so, please illustrate to me why this is so. If not, I agree wholeheartedly.

You asked for the reason why? Correct? I gave you the reason why. I never said that you proposed that leprechauns involve intelligent design issues. Obviously you don't find my reason acceptable. So I guess we simply disagree on that point.
 
Tantamount to certainty then. Many of these responders are responding to their own strawman arguments.
But you haven't noticed that.

Whatever you call it. Trying to shoehorn your words into other peoples mouth is the strawman argument.

I don't think you're up on your logical fallacies as you seem to want people to believe.
 
Last edited:
You asked for the reason why? Correct? I gave you the reason why. I never said that you proposed that leprechauns involve intelligent design issues. Obviously you don't find my reason acceptable. So I guess we simply disagree on that point.

Let's try it one more time.

Why Is a belief in an intelligent designer more justified than a belief in leprechauns?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom