Evidence against God's existence

Naturally, my three little statements can be expanded to as fine a point as would no doubt satisfy even Valis; I do tend towards brevity....

Even Dawkins has stated (in The God Delusion) that we can't categorically deny the possibility of some sort of god. As noted above, such a being could hide from us if it wished to.
Why it would wish to, and why it would create anything at all, brings up the realm of probability, which is where Dawkins claims the question can be posed scientifically.

As I've said before, whether you are atheist or deist, you must at some point confront the notions of infinity and eternity. We humans are ill-equipped for such speculations, though many try.
To my way of thinking, it's simpler to posit an eternal and infinite void which has as a property the tendency to spawn universes occasionally (or even frequently) than it is to posit a complex, super-intelligent and potent being which is also eternal.
 
I'll start off with a really old one.

The Problem of Evil

Is God willing to prevent evil, but not able?
Then he is not omnipotent.
Is he able, but not willing?
Then he is malevolent.
Is he both able and willing?
Then whence cometh evil?
Is he neither able nor willing?
Then why call him God?

Epicurus – Greek philosopher, BC 341-270

Many years ago, Epicurus realized that there was a conflict between the existence of evil, and a powerful being that has a goal of stopping evil. After all, one would expect a competent firefighter to do everything in his power to save a person from a burning building. If he failed to do so, we would infer that he was either unwilling or incapable of accomplishing this task. So why not apply this same reasoning to the concept of a god?

The syllogistic form goes something like this:

1. If a god exists, it is omnipotent, omniscient, and omnibonevolent.
2. It naturally follows, that if a god exists, it is aware of all suffering, is capable of ending it, and has a desire to do so. (from 1)
3. If a god exists, there would be no suffering. (from 2)
4. Suffering exists.
C: Therefore, a god does not exist. (from 3 and 4)

Denial of the first premise does leave open the possibility of other god definitions, but very few modern Christians will be willing to go this route.

A common rebuttal is the "free will" argument, but this fails in many ways. Does the alleviation of a starving child's hunger pains necessitate an interference with the free will of anyone? Is God capable of ending suffering without inhibiting free will? If so, the problem stands. If not, he is not omnipotent. And besides, just what is free will and how does it refute this argument? For any theists willing to go this route, I would ask you to first define "free will" before you make your point.

There is also the appeal to a supposed "plan" that this god must enact. Apparently, suffering is a necessary factor of it. If this is so, is God incapable of carrying out this plan without the agony of the masses? If he cannot, then not only does this imply his impotence, it further appeals to some force greater than him, and he is a slave to it. He wouldn't be much of a god, then.

The concept of heaven causes huge problems for the theist in this argument. It establishes that there is a perfect paradise in which none shall undergo hardship, but God, for whatever reason, has placed his subjects in a realm in which they will suffer, even though he doesn't want them to. This contradiction demands an explanation.

In this argument, it is necessary for the theist to appeal to a god that works in mysterious ways that we cannot perceive. I would ask, then, what is the difference between your god, and a god that does not exist?

Bill gates is able to stop suffering.. But isn't revelations the end of suffering, evil ? both here on earth and in the realm you speak of. Sure it hasn't happened yet, but it will. Just my 2 cents.
 
Bill gates is able to stop suffering.. But isn't revelations the end of suffering, evil ? both here on earth and in the realm you speak of. Sure it hasn't happened yet, but it will. Just my 2 cents.

no, bill isnt able to, ever used Windows?
 
I would argue the existence of Atheists isevidence of God's non-existence as the only two possible explanations for their existence are that a) God does not exist or b) God exists but wants a significant portion of the planet not to believe in him.

c) God doesn't care if people believe in Him or not.
d) God doesn't want *anyone* to believe in Him and the religious ones are thinking of the wrong God.

The same being cannot be both omniscient and omnipotent, as these absolutes are contradictory. If a being is omniscient, it can't do other than what it knows it will do, and an omnipotent being could do other than it knows it will do.

I like that logic a lot. Also, I completely disagree. Maybe time works differently wherever God "lives" and so His omniscience in OUR universe isn't complete in His. Maybe your argument would run into trouble if God said "No, I can do anything. I just do what I want, and don't want to do what I don't. Knowing my choice ahead of time because I know myself isn't a limit on my ability in the same way that you have the power to choose a bowl of rancid spinach over a bowl of delicious ice cream but never will." Or maybe we would just have to concede that there are variations on the definitions of those terms that would still count as Omniscient and Omnipotent to the average Joe.

If you are telling me there is a difference, then please, explain to me what that difference is.

In one case there's a God, and in the other there isn't. That's it. That's the difference.

There's no difference to you, here, in this moment if I had fruity pebbles or cocoa puffs for breakfast this morning. You'll never know. Either way I'm riding a sugar high, and I'll have the opposite tomorrow so the overall supply levels will remain the same in either case. This does not impact your life. So is there a difference? Yes.
 
In one case there's a God, and in the other there isn't. That's it. That's the difference.

That's a repetition of the claim. Stating "It just is," is tautological and uninformative.

I can differentiate between Coco Puffs and Fruity Pebbles. One is colorful, the other brown. One tastes like chocolate, the other like candy. I could even get quite reductionist and state that the atoms composing one cereal are separate from the atoms composing another.

Give me a tangible difference between a god who has no interaction with the universe whatsoever, and a non-existent god. If you can't (and this is the third time I've raised this issue), my point stands.
 
If you are telling me there is a difference, then please, explain to me what that difference is.
~ship~
From our perspective this non-interactive god would for all intense and purposes not exist to us.

From this type of god's perpsective, it exists but it chooses not to (or cannot) interact with us or it interacts with us in such a fashion as to be unnoticed by us.

The first statement does not exclude the second statement.


Let's say somewhere in South America there is a member of a stone age tribe named Bobino.
Bobino is completely unaware of your existance and you choose not to interact with him in any fashion. In fact you ignore him completely or may not even be aware of his existance either.

Since he is isolated from modern technology and other resources, he has no method available to him to detect or prove your existance.

For all intents and purposes you do not exist to him.

Astonishingly, this has no effect on the state of your existance.
 
Last edited:
That's a repetition of the claim. Stating "It just is," is tautological and uninformative.
But this still still does not exclued the possibility of a god's existance.

I can differentiate between Coco Puffs and Fruity Pebbles. One is colorful, the other brown. One tastes like chocolate, the other like candy. I could even get quite reductionist and state that the atoms composing one cereal are separate from the atoms composing another.

Give me a tangible difference between a god who has no interaction with the universe whatsoever, and a non-existent god. If you can't (and this is the third time I've raised this issue), my point stands.

Your point only states that a non-interactive god "is the same as" no god from our perspective. Your point does not provide proof or evidence of the non-existance of a god.
 
Perspective is irrelevant. Whether or not I know a given individual is present in a certain location is not the issue. This is a matter of whether or not there is a difference between non-interaction within the universe, and non-existence. By defining Bobino as a living thing in South America, you are stating that he interacts with the universe (he takes up space, at the least), so I don't know how that analogy applies.

Light doesn't cease to exist when I close my eyes.
 
Perspective is irrelevant. Whether or not I know a given individual is present in a certain location is not the issue. This is a matter of whether or not there is a difference between non-interaction within the universe, and non-existence. By defining Bobino as a living thing in South America, you are stating that he interacts with the universe (he takes up space, at the least), so I don't know how that analogy applies.

Light doesn't cease to exist when I close my eyes.

Actually it is Bobino's lack of knowledge of or ability to detect your existance that the analogy is about. We may not be able to detect god's existance because we lack the method or ability in which to do so.

Your OP stated or suggested you had evidence against a god's existance. The idea that there is no difference (to us) between a non-interactive god and no god is not evidence against the existance god.

It is simply a statement of condition based on our perspective. That is what I tried to illustrate with my analogy.
 
That's a repetition of the claim. Stating "It just is," is tautological and uninformative.

It's VERY informative. Here, I'll change a word:

Q: What's the difference between there being a duck, and there not being a duck?
A: In one case, a duck exists.

That's a totally valid answer. If the duck doesn't impact my life and I'm not aware of any other differences, then the main thing is the existence of the duck. Here, I'll add another thing: the other difference is that the guy who said there's a duck is correct in the case that there is one.

I can differentiate between Coco Puffs and Fruity Pebbles.

Oh? Then which one did I eat? My example never suggested you couldn't know which one YOU ate, it said you couldn't know which one I ate but that, even without you knowing or being remotely impacted by it, one or the other is still true and that is a difference.

Give me a tangible difference between a god who has no interaction with the universe whatsoever, and a non-existent god. If you can't (and this is the third time I've raised this issue), my point stands.

Tangible to who? God would be able to feel himself, does that count? If God created the universe (or in a sense IS the universe) there's plenty of touching. See, God counts as an observer if He exists. So a reality with a God and a reality without a God is different due to the presence or absence of that observer. Take it another step, what if in addition to God there is also some sort of afterlife? That would mean there's difference not ony in principle but to you specifically.

Light doesn't cease to exist when I close my eyes.

Nor does God if He exists.

This may just be an issue of semantics. What do you mean by "different"? I'll happily concede (and have already done so) that from your perspective the two cases are indistinguishable. You can't tell the difference. Agreed. Because you can't tell the difference, it does not seem to be currently impacting your life - just like whether I had Fruity Pebbles or Cocoa Puffs, or whether or not there is some guy named Bobino out there. Still, those things are or are not true even if they have absolutely no impact on you.

Let's dip some science into this philosophy fondue.

We can't observe something until information has had time to reach us, right? With the speed of light usually being cited as the limitation, if something happens a light year away we can say it will not have any impact on us for at least a year. Does it exist now, or in a year? Bobino is on a planet, a million light years away. When he is born it is absolutely impossible for you to detect it because the information won't get here until you are long, long dead. Does he still exist? There is, for you, no way within the realms of physics to be at all aware of him. That doesn't rule out the possibility of his existence.
 
Last edited:
Actually it is Bobino's lack of knowledge of or ability to detect your existance that the analogy is about.

Then it's apples and oranges.

If you had posited that a god may exist in a way that cannot be detected by humans, then I'd wholeheartedly agree with you. That is possible. But you didn't lay out a mysterious type of interaction. You were talking about no interaction whatsoever.

Let's look at this another way:

"Darth Vader does not exist."

What is the meaning behind the bold section? By "Darth Vader" I am referring to the character as portrayed by the Star Wars story, not some actor in a costume, and not a name on a script. Can you explain the meaning behind that sentence without using circular language, such as, "He's not real?"

It's VERY informative. Here, I'll change a word:

Q: What's the difference between there being a duck, and there not being a duck?
A: In one case, a duck exists.

That's a totally valid answer. If the duck doesn't impact my life and I'm not aware of any other differences, then the main thing is the existence of the duck. Here, I'll add another thing: the other difference is that the guy who said there's a duck is correct in the case that there is one.

You really don't know what a tautology is, do you?

Let's imagine someone were to ask me, "What's the difference between a British accent and an Australian accent?"

If I were to answer, "Well, one is a British accent, whereas the other is an Australian accent," have I actually given this individual any new information?
 
Last edited:
If you had posited that a god may exist in a way that cannot be detected by humans, then I'd wholeheartedly agree with you. That is possible. But you didn't lay out a mysterious type of interaction. You were talking about no interaction whatsoever.

Um... what's the difference?

You really don't know what a tautology is, do you?

That's seriously the only thing in my post you're going to address, isn't it? Wow.

I feel like the rest of my post provided a lot of clarification and you just snipped it out. That's pretty frustrating. You say there's no difference but unless you're going to specify from whose perspective I'm going to act as if you are referring to Truth, uppercase. There is an inherant difference between something existing and something not existing, in terms of Truth.
 
Last edited:
Then it's apples and oranges.

If you had posited that a god may exist in a way that cannot be detected by humans, then I'd wholeheartedly agree with you. That is possible. But you didn't lay out a mysterious type of interaction. You were talking about no interaction whatsoever.

Let's look at this another way:

"Darth Vader does not exist."

What is the meaning behind the bold section? By "Darth Vader" I am referring to the character as portrayed by the Star Wars story, not some actor in a costume, and not a name on a script. Can you explain the meaning behind that sentence without using circular language, such as, "He's not real?"

You asked me "If you are telling me there is a difference, then please, explain to me what that difference is."

The difference is only between the two conditions in the statementment.

One condition of there being a god, but one which does not interact with the universe and another condition of there being no god.

The outcomes, based on our perspective, are the same. But the conditions are not.

One condition implies the existance of a god the other does not.

But observe that the statement provides no evidence against the existance of a non-interactive god.

It is only a statement of similarity of outcomes between two possible conditions.

You are obviously meant to infer a conclusion from the statement, but no evidence is provided.
 
Last edited:
To: I am the scum

I think the answer to this question depends on whether or not "god" exists within the universe. Logically, he would have to, since the universe means "everything that exists".

Thus, if a god did exist, and he didn't interact with the REST of the universe, he would still exist because he would interact with himself (a part of the universe).

If he is not part of the universe, that would indeed be the same as saying he does not exist.
 
This will be the last post I make in regards to perspective.

When we speak of things existing, we speak of things engaging in activity outside the mind. No, I don't know what kind of cereal you ate for breakfast. Does that mean that you didn't eat any cereal for breakfast? Obviously not. That would open up a huge can of worms.

Take the following statement: God does not exist because I have never perceived him. If you state that this claim is false and illogical (and it is), then you agree that things can exist independent of one's perception of them. Otherwise, everyone has their own separate reality that is different from everyone else's, but this belies the definition of reality.

The problem is this: On one hand, you're talking about existence, and on the other, you're talking about experience. These are two very different things, and any attempt to equate the two will lend credence to the bold statement above. I have explained this as thoroughly as I can, and will chase the red herring no longer.

I will now attempt to explain logical equivalence, to the best of my ability.

Let's take the two following ideas:
A. Abe Lincoln's assassin
B. John Wilkes Booth


We can agree that these are two different phrases that describe the same thing. But what do we mean when we say they are "the same." Basically, we are saying that for any given proposition in which A is invoked, we could just as easily substitute A with B, and the truth value would remain the same. That's logical equivalence.

If someone were to state that A and B were not the same (ignoring for a moment that we know this is false), could we make sense of this statement? Absolutely. One could state, for example, that the assassin shot Abe Lincoln, whereas John Wilkes Booth did not. I can conceptualize this. If one were to state that these two ideas are separate, but was unable to point out the difference, even hypothetically, and was left stating, "Well, they're just different," it would be fair for me to state that the two ideas are identical, as the argument to the contrary has not been justified.

So, when one says to me that there is a difference between a god that exists, yet does not interact with the world in any way, and a god that does not exist at all, I am forced to question what this person means. To me, existence entails interaction with the universe (not a given specific individual). I can easily point out this separation with other ideas. For example, I drank a Dr. Pepper during lunch. The Dr. Pepper exists. When I state it exists, I mean the following: I tasted it. It quenched my thirst. It took up space in my fridge prior to that, and was dispersing heat to the fridge a week prior. Etc. A non-existent Dr. Pepper cannot do any of these things. Here, I have illustrated a difference between A) an existent Dr. Pepper and B) a non-existent Dr. Pepper.

So tell me the difference between A) a god that has no interaction with the universe whatsoever and B) a god that does not exist, in some informative way.
 
Last edited:
So tell me the difference between A) a god that has no interaction with the universe whatsoever and B) a god that does not exist, in some informative way.


If there IS a god:
You might get to meet God when you die.
God might have had some influence on the way the universe came into existance.

If there is NOT a god:
Neither of the above.

Ta-dah! It's true that neither of those are things you can test and they don't change the way you observe the universe, but as you said it's not about your perception.
 
And you have defined God in a way that he interacts with the universe, thus contradicting yourself.
 
And you have defined God in a way that he interacts with the universe, thus contradicting yourself.

Eh. I figured you counted anything pre-creation or post-death to be outside of the standard definition of "the universe", and were focusing more on direct, current interaction with the normal physical world. If there's a plane of reality, another dimension that isn't accessible or testable to anything we're familiar with, and God lives there and does nothing at all to influence our universe does that work for you, or would that still count as part of the universe? What about if it's a planet within our universe but so far away from all other matter that it is completely and fundamentally impossible to detect prior to the eventual heat death of the universe?

Take either of those, if they work for you. Go ahead and remove any chance of you meeting him or him influencing the universe outside of his little pocket dimension or hopelessly distant planet. If He exists, it is STILL different than not existing.

Let's go back to your Dr. Pepper example. Put that can of Dr. Pepper into the pocket dimension, or that far-flung rock. Does the Dr. Pepper still exist? Yes. Can you show proof of it? No. Same principle. You can argue against it as being incredibly unlikely, you can point out that there's no proof FOR it, but that doesn't change whether or not it exists.

ETA: If you just want to reply to Uruk and not this it won't hurt my feelings; that post just below this one set out some of my issues with your logic better than I did.
 
Last edited:
~snip~
I will now attempt to explain logical equivalence, to the best of my ability.

Let's take the two following ideas:
A. Abe Lincoln's assassin
B. John Wilkes Booth


We can agree that these are two different phrases that describe the same thing. But what do we mean when we say they are "the same." Basically, we are saying that for any given proposition in which A is invoked, we could just as easily substitute A with B, and the truth value would remain the same. That's logical equivalence.

If someone were to state that A and B were not the same (ignoring for a moment that we know this is false), could we make sense of this statement? Absolutely. One could state, for example, that the assassin shot Abe Lincoln, whereas John Wilkes Booth did not. I can conceptualize this. If one were to state that these two ideas are separate, but was unable to point out the difference, even hypothetically, and was left stating, "Well, they're just different," it would be fair for me to state that the two ideas are identical, as the argument to the contrary has not been justified.
Your logical equivalence example does not relate to the no god / non-interactive god statement.
Abe Lincoln's Assassin and John Wilkes Booth do not have the same relationship with each other as the no god and non-interactive god relationship.

For one condition there is "no god". This is the opposite of the other condition in which a god exists but it does not interact with the universe.

"No god" is the state of there being no god in existance. "Non-interactive god" is a state where a god exists but it does not interact with the universe.

The outcome of both conditions are similar but the conditions of the statements are different. One condition excludes the other condition.

The two conditions are not the same even though the outcome of each condition is the same.

"Abe Lincoln's assassin" is a description of a person, "John Wilkes Booth" is a person who history has show was Abe Lincoln's assassasin. The description of the person does not exclude the person. The conditions of the two statements are not opposed to each other.

So, when one says to me that there is a difference between a god that exists, yet does not interact with the world in any way, and a god that does not exist at all, I am forced to question what this person means. To me, existence entails interaction with the universe (not a given specific individual). I can easily point out this separation with other ideas. For example, I drank a Dr. Pepper during lunch. The Dr. Pepper exists. When I state it exists, I mean the following: I tasted it. It quenched my thirst. It took up space in my fridge prior to that, and was dispersing heat to the fridge a week prior. Etc. A non-existent Dr. Pepper cannot do any of these things. Here, I have illustrated a difference between A) an existent Dr. Pepper and B) a non-existent Dr. Pepper.
So here you've chosen to define existance as interaction with the universe. Is this a necessary condition? Could there be other states of existance that we are not aware of? We certainly don't have all the answers. We have no mental or mathematical frame work to describe "where" this universe exists, if there was a "before" or "outside".

All our observations so far point to an initiation point (big bang). If a deity initiated this universe but then has no other interaction with it, does it satisfy your criteria?

Think about my Bobino analogy. Bobino has a very limited conceptual framework. All of existance for him is within that limited framework he percieves. He has no concept of the bigger framework that exists outside of his, of which your framework is apart of.

To him a framework in which you exist, but you do not interact with him is the equivilent of a framework where you do not exist. Except that you do exist within a larger framework of which he is not aware of.

He can even use your logical equivilent argument in an attempt to prove to others around him that you do not exist because by his definition of existance you have to interact with his framework in order to be considered to exist.

Of course you can interact with his, but you choose not to. Does this mean you do not exist within the larger framework?

So tell me the difference between A) a god that has no interaction with the universe whatsoever and B) a god that does not exist, in some informative way.


see above
 
Last edited:
Again, I find myself arguing against ones who are attempting to equate existence and experience. Existence is true or false independent of the perspective of any given individual. I cannot stress this enough. There is no such thing as "It exists for me, but not for you," provided we both operate within the same reality (and I may question that, soon enough).

The formation of the universe does constitute interaction with the universe. I can't imagine why that is in question.

I'm trying to word this as clearly as I can. To me, "It exists, but has no tangible impact on the universe whatsoever," is contradictory. I can't make sense of it. It's like telling me, "This bar is made of steel, but contains no iron atoms." How about this? Somebody give me an explanatory definition of "exist," and then we'll work from there. "It is real" or, "It is not fake" are not explanatory.

If this distinction cannot be made (after all the times I have asked), then I will not continue this conversation.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom