Evidence against God's existence

Existence is true or false independent of the perspective of any given individual. I cannot stress this enough. There is no such thing as "It exists for me, but not for you," provided we both operate within the same reality (and I may question that, soon enough).

That's what I've been saying this whole time. You are the one who has debated that.

I'm trying to word this as clearly as I can. To me, "It exists, but has no tangible impact on the universe whatsoever," is contradictory. I can't make sense of it. It's like telling me, "This bar is made of steel, but contains no iron atoms." How about this? Somebody give me an explanatory definition of "exist," and then we'll work from there. "It is real" or, "It is not fake" are not explanatory.

No. I think you're focusing on the wrong nitpicky sematics.

The word that is giving us trouble is "universe". You seem to be using it to include absolutely everything in any possible sense of the word "everything", which is a defendable position but not a sensible one in this context.

If God is in some paralell dimension, or even in this one but 9999^9999999999999 billion light years away he isn't in the same universe as us. Maybe God is made out of something like Dark Matter but infinitely moreso - where we can't see dark matter except for gravitational effects maybe God Matter doesn't even show that. Hell, I could build a whole mythology off of that one... hmm.
 
The presence or absence of evil on earth at this time has nothing to do with the existence or non-existence of a creator.
 
To: I am the scum

I think the answer to this question depends on whether or not "god" exists within the universe. Logically, he would have to, since the universe means "everything that exists".

Thus, if a god did exist, and he didn't interact with the REST of the universe, he would still exist because he would interact with himself (a part of the universe).

If he is not part of the universe, that would indeed be the same as saying he does not exist.

From a biblical standpoint there was a time when the universe did not exist and there was only one thing in existence--God. In short, that would make him the creator of all that exists, be it multiple univereses, alternate realities, branes, etcetera.
 
Last edited:
From a biblical standpoint there was a time when the universe did not exist and there was only one thing in existence--God. In short, that would make him the creator of all that exists, be it multiple univereses, alternate realities, branes, etcetera.
It cannot be both be true that God exists and that God is the creator of all that exists (unless God can be the creator of himself).

So that would make God, at most, the creator of all that exists except for himself.

Also it is not clear that the Bible supports the idea that there was a time when the Universe did not exist, and in fact the main theologians of Christianity like St Augustine and Aquinas deny that the Bible says this and that there was a time when the universe did not exist.
 
It cannot be both be true that God exists and that God is the creator of all that exists (unless God can be the creator of himself).

So that would make God, at most, the creator of all that exists except for himself.

Also it is not clear that the Bible supports the idea that there was a time when the Universe did not exist, and in fact the main theologians of Christianity like St Augustine and Aquinas deny that the Bible says this and that there was a time when the universe did not exist.


All things refers to all things apart from himself.

Revelation 4:11
11"You are worthy, our Lord and God to receive glory and honor and power, for you created all things,
and by your will they were created and have their being."


BTW
Prominent theologians are notorious for not only twisting biblical teachings but for joining in with atheists in attacking biblical veracity. But let me remind you that when I refer to an ID I am not approaching the subject religiously but purely frtom a logical standpoint.
 
Last edited:
The presence of evil does not prove the nonexistence of an ID.

You are correct. The designer itself could be evil. Or it could have no opinion at all on the value of good and evil.

The problem for those making more specific claims about this designer is that they themselves have defined evil and claimed that it is displeasing to the designer as they define it. And, of course, this definition of the designer very often includes the properties of omniscience, omnipotence and infallibility. The logical inconsistency derives from the claim that the designer is somehow displeased with its creation.
 
All things refers to all things apart from himself.
Don't you mean "itself"? Male and female gender is a function of sexual reproduction. If anything, it would be more logical to refer to God as "herself" rather than "himself".

Prominent theologians are notorious for not only twisting biblical teachings but for joining in with atheists in attacking biblical veracity.
When you can't dispute the facts and evidence that they present, resort to attacking their motives.
 
From a biblical standpoint there was a time when the universe did not exist and there was only one thing in existence--God. In short, that would make him the creator of all that exists, be it multiple univereses, alternate realities, branes, etcetera.

Ok, you specifically define the universe as "everything that exists aside from god." What does this accomplish? It seems to me (forgive me if I'm wrong) as if this is some attempt to claim that god is an exception to the notion that everything that exists must have a creator. Saying that god isn't part of the universe doesn't in any way explain why he is there in the first place.

The same holds for the idea that he is part of a parallel or alternate universe. Either he exists or he doesn't.
 
~snip~

I'm trying to word this as clearly as I can. To me, "It exists, but has no tangible impact on the universe whatsoever," is contradictory. I can't make sense of it. It's like telling me, "This bar is made of steel, but contains no iron atoms." How about this? Somebody give me an explanatory definition of "exist," and then we'll work from there. "It is real" or, "It is not fake" are not explanatory.

If this distinction cannot be made (after all the times I have asked), then I will not continue this conversation.
Your difficulty in comprehension could could have something to do with your particular definition of existance. Is interaction with this universe a necessary characteristic for existance? I do not necessarily believe that it is. I will explain why.

Theoretical Physists Claim that there may be parallel universes that exist "somewhere/time" in relation to this universe. As far as we know, these things may exist but they do not seem to have any detectable impact on our universe. Dispite this characteristic these thoeretical physist claim there is a possibility of thier existance.
At the very least big bang and parallel universes argue that there is a "boundry" or an "outside" to this universe that may "exist". If this "outside" exists then that leaves a small possibilty for "something" that fits the bill for a "god" to also exist.

If the claim can be made of a parallel universes that exists "outside" or "adjacent to" this universe (dispite it's non-interaction with ours) then why cannot a similar claim be made about some sort of self aware, self determining system with superior understanding and capabilities to our own exist in some continuum outside our own but yet still be aware of our continuum?

Granted it requires that you have to make a great deal of assumptions and the probabiltiy for it existance is exceedingly low, but I do not see anything that would negate it's possibility.

Remember making an absolute statement about the condition of something requires that you to have absolute knowledge of the state of that thing. Who can claim that they have absolute knowledge of anything?
 
Last edited:
Don't you mean "itself"? Male and female gender is a function of sexual reproduction. If anything, it would be more logical to refer to God as "herself" rather than "himself".

Perhaps. But since we refer to objects and animals as "it" I prefer the less logical description. The pronoun "it" though perhaps more logical, comes accross as denigrating to the entity referred to. You know, the ID. Also, from a biblical viewpoint nonhuman asexual beings are referred to as "he'. But if you wish to use the word "it" it's okay by me.


When you can't dispute the facts and evidence that they present, resort to attacking their motives.

Motives are irrelevant. Evidence can be presented for justifying torturing people and burning them at the stake to save their supposed souls?
 
Last edited:
Your difficulty in comprehension could could have something to do with your particular definition of existance. Is interaction with this universe a necessary characteristic for existance? I do not necessarily believe that it is. I will explain why.

Theoretical Physists Claim that there may be parallel universes that exist "somewhere/time" in relation to this universe. As far as we know, these things may exist but they do not seem to have any detectable impact on our universe. Dispite this characteristic these thoeretical physist claim there is a possibility of thier existance.
At the very least big bang and parallel universes argue that there is a "boundry" or an "outside" to this universe that may "exist". If this "outside" exists then that leaves a small possibilty for "something" that fits the bill for a "god" to also exist.

If the claim can be made of a parallel universes that exists "outside" or "adjacent to" this universe (dispite it's non-interaction with ours) then why cannot a similar claim be made about some sort of self aware, self determining system with superior understanding and capabilities to our own exist in some continuum outside our own but yet still be aware of our continuum?

Granted it requires that you have to make a great deal of assumptions and the probabiltiy for it existance is exceedingly low, but I do not see anything that would negate it's possibility.

Remember making an absolute statement about the condition of something requires that you to have absolute knowledge of the state of that thing. Who can claim that they have absolute knowledge of anything?

Good post.

Hey my brother Radrook good to see ya!
 
I wish to put in my 2 cents for the definition in my sig, which seems to cover all the bases:

God - a capricious creative or controlling force said to be the subject of a religion.

And as to the existence of God, one is really only interested in whether events/interactions are different in God's absence compared to its presence.

Linda
 
Your difficulty in comprehension could could have something to do with your particular definition of existance.
Sorry, but this "existance" crap is really starting to get to me. Please learn how to spell the word.
 
Sorry, but this "existance" crap is really starting to get to me. Please learn how to spell the word.

So sorry to offend. I will try to use the correct spelling in the future.
 
I wish to put in my 2 cents for the definition in my sig, which seems to cover all the bases:

God - a capricious creative or controlling force said to be the subject of a religion.

And as to the existence of God, one is really only interested in whether events/interactions are different in God's absence compared to its presence.

Linda

I think that one can say with a certain amount of certainty that events and interactions, and the universe, in general behaive as if a god does not exist.

But then we really don't know how those events or interactions would behaive with a god.
The examples provided by religions are in all probability ficticious.

But I believe that the more we understand this universe the further we can go to closing the book on god.

Or opening up a new page. You never know what you'll find.
 
Ok, you specifically define the universe as "everything that exists aside from god." What does this accomplish? It seems to me (forgive me if I'm wrong) as if this is some attempt to claim that god is an exception to the notion that everything that exists must have a creator. Saying that god isn't part of the universe doesn't in any way explain why he is there in the first place.

The same holds for the idea that he is part of a parallel or alternate universe. Either he exists or he doesn't.

Seems paradoxical doesn't it? Yet that might be due to the limits of human perception and its requirements for cause and effect sequences as Hume pointed out.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom