You can’t get something from nothing
Matter doesn’t just pop into existence out of nowhere. There has to be something that is eternally present to make everything the way it is today. If you think that the universe began to exist, you are a fool.
If you were to take the above statement with no context whatsoever, you would be somewhat justified in assuming it was yet another creationist making yet another silly and errant criticism of the Big Bang Theory. On the contrary, this is coming from a hardcore atheist. Today, we will see that as often as theists bring up the “you can’t get something from nothing” argument, it causes more problems for themselves than it does for any atheist. In essence, I will be demonstrating how the creationist shoots himself in the foot.
What exactly is nothing? This question is far more complicated than it initially appears. After all, it is nonsensical. By answering the question, you would be describing something, but something is not nothing, and you will have contradicted yourself. Nothing is not a thing. You cannot point at something, and say, in the literal sense, “That is nothing.”
We can also use the word to describe an action taking place, and, counter-intuitively, end up describing no action at all. Let’s imagine that Little Timmy has been accused of throwing a baseball through the neighbor’s window. Little Timmy proclaims, “I threw nothing at the window.” Timmy is not stating that he scooped up a hand full of nothing, gripped it tightly, then swung his arm forward while releasing. No, Timmy is stating, “I did not throw anything at the window.” These two sentences are logically equivalent.
So, to start taking this into a cosmological route, can we state that something ever begins to exist? Truly, we cannot. You may object, stating that, for example, a birdhouse begins to exist at the moment its construction is complete. However, this is a matter of identity. Would the actual stuff composing the birdhouse have begun to exist once it was finished? No, the stuff came from something else. It has transitioned from one form to another, yes, and we do label each state, but this is not something from nothing. Anyone stating that the birdhouse, or anything else, for that matter, has come from nothing, is speaking nonsense. Just like Little Timmy “throwing nothing” equates to no action at all, “transforming nothing” does the same.
This all applies to the universe, as well. If we can define the universe as “the sum total of all physical matter and energy, in whichever form it takes,” then we can say that the universe has always existed. In logic, we analyze time with situations, which basically means a moment in time. Can you point out to me any situation in which the statement, “The universe does not exist,” is true? Of course not. If you could, you would be positing that the universe began to exist, which, as previously established, is a logical contradiction. The birdhouse has existed since the dawn of time, just in a different form.
At a theological level, this presents problems with the concept of god. For the die-hard creationists that attempt to ridicule the big bang cosmologists while insisting that their god created everything from nothing, they are positing that this god has an illogical nature. You might as well define God as “a connoisseurs of squared circles.”
A deist may retreat to the position of, “then what caused the Big Bang?” but this is a matter of speculation (as it has always been), and, via Occam’s Razor, it would be far more prudent to assume as little as possible on the matter. I certainly see no reason for it being the product of intelligence. Even with this looser definition of God, the deity has been relegated to the role of a being that is forced to work with eternally present stuff. He cannot make his own, and is therefore, limited.