I Am The Scum
Philosopher
- Joined
- Mar 5, 2010
- Messages
- 5,952
The purpose of this thread is to share some of the reasons why I believe that there are no gods whatsoever. I intend to explain why this is a challenging task, and why many atheists are apprehensive in going as far as I have.
I will be posting my own arguments over the next couple of weeks in this thread. I do realize that I am "preaching to the choir" here., but this should give the theists on the board a chance to go on the attack. Rather than have their ideas shot down left and right, they will now have something to sink their teeth into. Also, there are some atheist arguments that I find to be really bad, such as the supposed conflict between an omniscient being and free will. I may take an opportunity to address my concerns with those, as well.
----------------------------------
The term "god" has many, many definitions. Some are specific, some are vague. A few are fairly mundane, and many are nonsensical. To say that none of them are accurate portrayals of reality is, by necessity, to paint with a large brush. Not may people are comfortable with making such a sweeping generalization. First, it would be prudent to establish a fair definition of "god," and then, to come to a reasonable conclusion on its status. After all, this thing either does exist, or it does not. Which of those two propositions best fits the world around us? After all the analyzation I have done, I find that the godless universe is a far more accurate explanation.
So what is a god? At the very least, god should be a conscious entity, that has a will, and makes choices. This rules out some of the sillier definitions, such as the pantheist's "God is the universe," or some woo-woo stating "God is gravity." Furthermore, god is defined as the creator of the universe and/or human life. This rules out some ancient ideas of gods, such as the Greek pantheon, but this is a fair portrayal of what the modern theological concept centers around. In addition, god is usually, but not always, defined as a character that has a desire to make its existence known. Finally, god is usually, but not always, defined as a being that holds some authority or sway over the affairs of man. Typically, this entails god being a good, loving entity that takes care of humanity, through intercessory prayer, for example.
Those last two properties are not included in the god of deism, but this is the vaguest definition of god you will probably find, so most arguments will not apply to it.
Gods are often described as having other properties, such as omnipotence, but this varies greatly. Because of this, there is no one single argument that disproves all gods, but that's not the point. If I can successfully demonstrate, for example, that there is no such thing as an all-loving god, then Christianity is false. Deism might still be true, but I would have to tackle that separately.
I will be posting my own arguments over the next couple of weeks in this thread. I do realize that I am "preaching to the choir" here., but this should give the theists on the board a chance to go on the attack. Rather than have their ideas shot down left and right, they will now have something to sink their teeth into. Also, there are some atheist arguments that I find to be really bad, such as the supposed conflict between an omniscient being and free will. I may take an opportunity to address my concerns with those, as well.
----------------------------------
The term "god" has many, many definitions. Some are specific, some are vague. A few are fairly mundane, and many are nonsensical. To say that none of them are accurate portrayals of reality is, by necessity, to paint with a large brush. Not may people are comfortable with making such a sweeping generalization. First, it would be prudent to establish a fair definition of "god," and then, to come to a reasonable conclusion on its status. After all, this thing either does exist, or it does not. Which of those two propositions best fits the world around us? After all the analyzation I have done, I find that the godless universe is a far more accurate explanation.
So what is a god? At the very least, god should be a conscious entity, that has a will, and makes choices. This rules out some of the sillier definitions, such as the pantheist's "God is the universe," or some woo-woo stating "God is gravity." Furthermore, god is defined as the creator of the universe and/or human life. This rules out some ancient ideas of gods, such as the Greek pantheon, but this is a fair portrayal of what the modern theological concept centers around. In addition, god is usually, but not always, defined as a character that has a desire to make its existence known. Finally, god is usually, but not always, defined as a being that holds some authority or sway over the affairs of man. Typically, this entails god being a good, loving entity that takes care of humanity, through intercessory prayer, for example.
Those last two properties are not included in the god of deism, but this is the vaguest definition of god you will probably find, so most arguments will not apply to it.
Gods are often described as having other properties, such as omnipotence, but this varies greatly. Because of this, there is no one single argument that disproves all gods, but that's not the point. If I can successfully demonstrate, for example, that there is no such thing as an all-loving god, then Christianity is false. Deism might still be true, but I would have to tackle that separately.
