Evidence against God's existence

I Am The Scum

Philosopher
Joined
Mar 5, 2010
Messages
5,952
The purpose of this thread is to share some of the reasons why I believe that there are no gods whatsoever. I intend to explain why this is a challenging task, and why many atheists are apprehensive in going as far as I have.

I will be posting my own arguments over the next couple of weeks in this thread. I do realize that I am "preaching to the choir" here., but this should give the theists on the board a chance to go on the attack. Rather than have their ideas shot down left and right, they will now have something to sink their teeth into. Also, there are some atheist arguments that I find to be really bad, such as the supposed conflict between an omniscient being and free will. I may take an opportunity to address my concerns with those, as well.

----------------------------------

The term "god" has many, many definitions. Some are specific, some are vague. A few are fairly mundane, and many are nonsensical. To say that none of them are accurate portrayals of reality is, by necessity, to paint with a large brush. Not may people are comfortable with making such a sweeping generalization. First, it would be prudent to establish a fair definition of "god," and then, to come to a reasonable conclusion on its status. After all, this thing either does exist, or it does not. Which of those two propositions best fits the world around us? After all the analyzation I have done, I find that the godless universe is a far more accurate explanation.

So what is a god? At the very least, god should be a conscious entity, that has a will, and makes choices. This rules out some of the sillier definitions, such as the pantheist's "God is the universe," or some woo-woo stating "God is gravity." Furthermore, god is defined as the creator of the universe and/or human life. This rules out some ancient ideas of gods, such as the Greek pantheon, but this is a fair portrayal of what the modern theological concept centers around. In addition, god is usually, but not always, defined as a character that has a desire to make its existence known. Finally, god is usually, but not always, defined as a being that holds some authority or sway over the affairs of man. Typically, this entails god being a good, loving entity that takes care of humanity, through intercessory prayer, for example.

Those last two properties are not included in the god of deism, but this is the vaguest definition of god you will probably find, so most arguments will not apply to it.

Gods are often described as having other properties, such as omnipotence, but this varies greatly. Because of this, there is no one single argument that disproves all gods, but that's not the point. If I can successfully demonstrate, for example, that there is no such thing as an all-loving god, then Christianity is false. Deism might still be true, but I would have to tackle that separately.
 
I'll start off with a really old one.

The Problem of Evil

Is God willing to prevent evil, but not able?
Then he is not omnipotent.
Is he able, but not willing?
Then he is malevolent.
Is he both able and willing?
Then whence cometh evil?
Is he neither able nor willing?
Then why call him God?

Epicurus – Greek philosopher, BC 341-270

Many years ago, Epicurus realized that there was a conflict between the existence of evil, and a powerful being that has a goal of stopping evil. After all, one would expect a competent firefighter to do everything in his power to save a person from a burning building. If he failed to do so, we would infer that he was either unwilling or incapable of accomplishing this task. So why not apply this same reasoning to the concept of a god?

The syllogistic form goes something like this:

1. If a god exists, it is omnipotent, omniscient, and omnibonevolent.
2. It naturally follows, that if a god exists, it is aware of all suffering, is capable of ending it, and has a desire to do so. (from 1)
3. If a god exists, there would be no suffering. (from 2)
4. Suffering exists.
C: Therefore, a god does not exist. (from 3 and 4)

Denial of the first premise does leave open the possibility of other god definitions, but very few modern Christians will be willing to go this route.

A common rebuttal is the "free will" argument, but this fails in many ways. Does the alleviation of a starving child's hunger pains necessitate an interference with the free will of anyone? Is God capable of ending suffering without inhibiting free will? If so, the problem stands. If not, he is not omnipotent. And besides, just what is free will and how does it refute this argument? For any theists willing to go this route, I would ask you to first define "free will" before you make your point.

There is also the appeal to a supposed "plan" that this god must enact. Apparently, suffering is a necessary factor of it. If this is so, is God incapable of carrying out this plan without the agony of the masses? If he cannot, then not only does this imply his impotence, it further appeals to some force greater than him, and he is a slave to it. He wouldn't be much of a god, then.

The concept of heaven causes huge problems for the theist in this argument. It establishes that there is a perfect paradise in which none shall undergo hardship, but God, for whatever reason, has placed his subjects in a realm in which they will suffer, even though he doesn't want them to. This contradiction demands an explanation.

In this argument, it is necessary for the theist to appeal to a god that works in mysterious ways that we cannot perceive. I would ask, then, what is the difference between your god, and a god that does not exist?
 
Those last two properties are not included in the god of deism, but this is the vaguest definition of god you will probably find, so most arguments will not apply to it.

[...] Deism might still be true, but I would have to tackle that separately.

Aww, I came here all ready for a debate, too.

Ah well. Carry on.
 
The purpose of this thread is to share some of the reasons why I believe that there are no gods whatsoever. [...]

So what is a god? At the very least, god should be a conscious entity, that has a will, and makes choices. This rules out some of the sillier definitions, such as the pantheist's "God is the universe," or some woo-woo stating "God is gravity."

It's tiresome to have to keep saying it, but I'm not a theist - I'm sure I'm not the most rigorous skeptic either, but even I can see that it's relatively easy to believe 'there are no gods whatsoever' if your first step is to define god in such a way that precludes 'god' existing and to exclude from your definition such gods as you cannot so easily dispose of.
 
Essentially a "God" should be more intelligent than us at a bare minimum and capable of exercising power over us beyond what we would be willing to allow. Is there any evidence to suggest that there is something more "intelligent" than us that also has the ability to control us?

We are basically at the mercy of the Universe and it's laws --- the ultimate defining points of our abilities to manipulate it being that we are not able to create Life or Stop Death. So the woo-woo idea of "everything is God" has a point ... but we are also unable to identify concretely and objectively a form of intelligence to the Universe. So the evidence that there is something more intelligent than us which binds us as well is nill and speculative.

We appear to be the gods.
 
Last edited:
Aww, I came here all ready for a debate, too.

Ah well. Carry on.
Have no worries. I'll be getting to cosmological arguments soon enough.

It's tiresome to have to keep saying it, but I'm not a theist - I'm sure I'm not the most rigorous skeptic either, but even I can see that it's relatively easy to believe 'there are no gods whatsoever' if your first step is to define god in such a way that precludes 'god' existing and to exclude from your definition such gods as you cannot so easily dispose of.
How is this a problem? Pretty much all definitions are, well, by definition, limiting. For example, a vehicle is defined as "A device or structure for transporting persons or things; a conveyance." This definition would exclude skyscrapers. Is this definition, therefore, unfair?

Now, if someone were to demonstrate that gravity, or the universe, or some other large, important, mundane thing did contain consciousness, then I would love to hear about it. Or, if there are any theists here who find my definitions unfair, I'm open to suggestions.
 
Last edited:
Yes, because we are obviously the most powerful force in the Universe :rolleyes:
LOL. We are not the most powerful ... but what is more intelligent? Both aspects are so subjective in context ... that saying the Universe is a non anthropomorphized god isn't that outlandish. I think when you limit it and say, "God is that raccoon that goes through my trash," or "God is a spirit deity in the 17th dimension with a tardis" etc .... there is no evidence.

I think our curiosity or "desire" to know if there is a god or not is basically the quest for extraterrestrial life and something just above our "peer level". Something we can relate to that is more advanced than we are as a species.
 
Now, if someone were to demonstrate that gravity, or the universe, or some other large, important, mundane thing did contain consciousness, then I would love to hear about it. Or, if there are any theists here who find my definitions unfair, I'm open to suggestions.
Oh dear ... getting into what is AI and strong AI and the hard problem of consciousness .... leaves open the possibility that something might be "conscious" but not self-aware or capable of meta-consciousness. This could quickly turn into a consciousness thread.

I think the evidence, however, presents that properties and fundamentals such as gravity, time, etc ... are not conscious. Speculatively they could be but it does not appear to be similar to the type of consciousness we are familiar with. So Occam's Razor helps to assume what we know based on evidence. If there is a god ... it requires faith to believe.

Even a miracle could always have another cause attributed until "god himself" shows up and takes credit on a big cloud descending from the sky. But even then, we might be able to eventually identify God as a "type" of species from another world. The classic notion of a "one and only" god isn't necessary, then, to attribute the title of God to some entity, IMO.
 
LOL. We are not the most powerful ... but what is more intelligent? Both aspects are so subjective in context ... that saying the Universe is a non anthropomorphized god isn't that outlandish. I think when you limit it and say, "God is that raccoon that goes through my trash," or "God is a spirit deity in the 17th dimension with a tardis" etc .... there is no evidence.

I think our curiosity or "desire" to know if there is a god or not is basically the quest for extraterrestrial life and something just above our "peer level". Something we can relate to that is more advanced than we are as a species.

I was just giving you guff, perhaps unnecessarily :o ... am in a strange mood today.

But I think there are a couple of mistakes some atheists and theists make that are curiously similar in their extremes: many theists insist humans - and everything positive in the Universe- is made in God's image. And then some atheists speak of humans as if they are the most powerful force in the Universe. To re-iterate: I said some.
 
Many years ago, Epicurus realized that there was a conflict between the existence of evil, and a powerful being that has a goal of stopping evil. After all, one would expect a competent firefighter to do everything in his power to save a person from a burning building. If he failed to do so, we would infer that he was either unwilling or incapable of accomplishing this task. So why not apply this same reasoning to the concept of a god?
God as a policeman: Responding to your call would rob the intruder of his free will.
God as a fire fighter: You caused the fire by being dumb, you deal with it. Either way, it's not as if you've got lots of neighbours, why aren't they putting out the fire?
God as a paramedic:
There needs to be illness in the city so we can truly appreciate healthiness.
 
The syllogistic form goes something like this:

1. If a god exists, it is omnipotent, omniscient, and omnibonevolent.
2. It naturally follows, that if a god exists, it is aware of all suffering, is capable of ending it, and has a desire to do so. (from 1)
3. If a god exists, there would be no suffering. (from 2)
4. Suffering exists.
C: Therefore, a god does not exist. (from 3 and 4)

Denial of the first premise does leave open the possibility of other god definitions, but very few modern Christians will be willing to go this route.


It's strange that they won't since the Old Testament is part of their belief system. For example, God mentions he intends to visit Sodom to see if the reports he's received about it are accurate, so he's clearly not omniscient. He's powerless against chariots with steel-rimmed wheels, so he's clearly not omnipotent. And there's multitudes of examples of malevolent behavior from him, so he's clearly not omni-benevolent.

So 1 fails on all counts when viewd in the context of the Old Testament.
 
----------------------------------~snip~

The term "god" has many, many definitions. Some are specific, some are vague. A few are fairly mundane, and many are nonsensical. To say that none of them are accurate portrayals of reality is, by necessity, to paint with a large brush. Not may people are comfortable with making such a sweeping generalization. First, it would be prudent to establish a fair definition of "god," and then, to come to a reasonable conclusion on its status. After all, this thing either does exist, or it does not. Which of those two propositions best fits the world around us? After all the analyzation I have done, I find that the godless universe is a far more accurate explanation.
~snip~
Deism might still be true, but I would have to tackle that separately.

Most specific definitions of god are easy to disprove.

I'll wait to see how you deal with a hidden, non-interactive god.

Just remember a god is under no obligation to conform to our definitions
 
Most specific definitions of god are easy to disprove.

I'll wait to see how you deal with a hidden, non-interactive god.

Just remember a god is under no obligation to conform to our definitions

That's easy. This definition of god is synonymous with a non-existent god, just like Carl Sagan's Dragon.
 
That's easy. This definition of god is synonymous with a non-existent god, just like Carl Sagan's Dragon.

It's not so much synonymous in definition as it is indistiguishable in practice. That's a fine line, I'll grant you, but the line is there.
 
Essentially a "God" should be more intelligent than us at a bare minimum and capable of exercising power over us beyond what we would be willing to allow.
...
We appear to be the gods.

Unless you appeal to swarm intelligence and suppose it to be more capable than individual intelligence, we are not more intelligent than us. Therefore, by your definition, we are not gods. ;)
 
Unless you appeal to swarm intelligence and suppose it to be more capable than individual intelligence, we are not more intelligent than us. Therefore, by your definition, we are not gods. ;)
Actually, I think it's much more complicated than I even stated because intelligence is subjective on many levels, and with some cultures it's not even the highest trait or value a person can have.

Considering swarm intelligence ... I've been fascinated by the idea of "human swarming" and the overall "plan" of humanity, evolutionarily speaking.

My own personal opinion is that we are a kind of "failed god" more or less, and what we are god over isn't life or death or the universe ... rather we are god over ethics and morality. And it is this very creation of ours that is our undoing. Individually, I think we have more capability to make wiser decisions outside of the bounds of morality ... but corporately or concerning a swarm intelligence, I think the swarm effect is self-defeated by our very creation. So although a couple of people might realize there are no winners in war, for example .... it only takes a couple who don't realize that and send nukes that blow up and threaten the life of the whole swarm and the goal behind it's forming an intelligent design in the first place (and I'm talking about the intelligent design of the human swarm, not a "god").

If I rambled or didn't make sense, my apologies :)
 
Most specific definitions of god are easy to disprove.

I'll wait to see how you deal with a hidden, non-interactive god.
A hidden, non-interactive what? What do you mean? You used the word "god". What do you mean when you say "god"?
Just remember a god is under no obligation to conform to our definitions
A what is under no obligation to conform to our definitions? There you go with that undefined word again. What do you mean when you use that word? It's your responsibility to define the words you use. Please either do that or stop posting utterly meaningless sentences. :confused:
 
I think our curiosity or "desire" to know if there is a god or not is basically the quest for extraterrestrial life and something just above our "peer level". Something we can relate to that is more advanced than we are as a species.

Or maybe stems from humans survival for this long by being able and willing to seek out new pastures? Having to look past the current horizon, whether that be on Earth or not? Is that what you mean?

I'm not sure about the more advanced, part. :) I sure as heck wouldn't want to travel to some promising-looking land or planet just to find out that I'm going to be dinner. :eye-poppi
 
As for the OP I also think -

The astounding lack of evidence "for" any god.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom