Climate change scepticism - its sources and origins

Status
Not open for further replies.
The planet has warmed by more then 1 deg C in the last 100 years
Data appears to justify that, with only minor arguments about cherry-picking.


and about 75% of that is due to greenhouse gasses.
Maybe. Climate models imply it, anyway.


This is the most rapid climate change seen since the end of the last ice age. How is this “small”?
Rapid? Seems so. Most rapid? Maybe. That depends on how reliable you deem various proxies.
 
You miss the reality of hysteresis ...what we see now in atmospheric changes as a result of radiative imbalance is only a portion of what's in the pipeline.

Even if we stopped cold now with new CO2 - the imbalance would persist until temps rise another .6 C or so over the next half century.

In addition both cryosphere and hydrosphere are much slower to respond to the additional energy.
This gives a good sense of scale and change

http://climateprogress.org/2009/10/...ooling-is-still-happening-ocean-heat-content/

Given latent heat issues, the scale of the energies in the global net glacial mass loss that is accelerating is astounding.
 
Last edited:
. What's the best model? What's your favourite model?

False dilemma. First of all they all show roughly the same thing. Second, what’s wrong with the IPCC approach of using an ensemble that averages a number of model runs for a number (17 IIRC) of models.
 
The paper you quote say there is no "best model" - yet you expect people to pick one
:dl:
That is just about par for the course with you.

How about answering the question put to you numerous times before you bailed out of the moderated thread.

Is the sun closer to the earth in summer or winter?


•••

In the meantime you can provide us with the relevant material



that supports this bit of nonsense.
:popcorn1

Wow. Unbelievable. Even after I explained it to you, you don't get it. No surprise, really.

I suspect you never did well with multiple choice questions where "None of the above" was a possible answer. :rolleyes:

The "What's the best model?" question was deliberate to ensure the reader had actually read the paper cited. There are several references in the paper showing how 1 single model fares differently depending on criteria and there is no "best model". The subsequent questions I asked tranwreck were an expansion on this notion of a multi-model use. They lead into a personal preference for any one model based on proficiency in certain areas like surface temperature or ocean temperature etc.

Well done macdoc, well done. You've managed to ensnare yourself in a trap set for someone else. Brilliant!

edit: this is better than your last claim that NASA was wrong. You've got quite the running tally with blunders this week.
 
Last edited:
You seem to think this heat lost by evaporation is carried by the air, and not the water vapour.

what exactly is it you think is moving the water vapor?

What you don't seem to realize is that if you take the water vapor away heat still rises by convection.


Let us not forget that your original claim was that convection carried heat all the way into space and that your current argment represents your third of forth goalpost shift.
 
Well, the tendency is for the deniers to direct the course of action because they say absolutely goofy things and everyone rushes to respond. That's probably a bad habit on our part.

I would like to hope that humans don't reach a point of no return with respect to understaning numbers, but I am hardly sanguine about it.

I think there are a great many issues where the incapability of grasping numbers forestalls any hope of understanding. I think a lot of evolution deniers have this problem: 6000 years vs. 4.5 billion.

But a decent command of climate science can be gained almost purely from an appreciation of the scientific process or basic logic. I think it's more like 9-11 trutherism in that regard.

Of course, I can only speak from experience, and a that article implied, innummeracy afects understanding of very basic concepts.
Whew! I'm not invisible :D

So here's my point (well, one of them anyway): to what extent is it possible to divide those who are consistent and persistent in their 'climate change scepticism' into "numerates" and "innumerates"?

And if possible, is it then possible - in principle - to address the numerates by working towards common ground, based on "numeracy"? Perhaps reaching consensus of great swathes of stuff, and well-defined, clearly bounded parts of parameter space where consensus is not possible? Note that this is - by definition - impossible wrt the innumerates.

And if possible (2), is it then possible - in principle - to address the innumerates by using the methods described in the article? By definition, this could not take place here, in the SMMT section of JREF (you cannot do science if you are innumerate, at least not science in the 21st century).

In other words, if may be so bold, is there not a way - potentially - to break the apparent endless cycle that many of the SMMT threads seem to descend to?
 
It certainly doesn't make that "clear." That argument does not appear at all in the executive summary, nor, as far as I can tell, at any point in the paper. Admittedly I skimmed some deal of it given that it is 135 pages long. Is there a section you want to quote or somehow direct us to the relevant point?

Here's the only thing I found that relates in any way to curtailing emissions (pg. 11):



That doesn't say "it would be foolish to go beyond what's already being done to curtail emissions." It says that individual models cannot be relied upon, so their components should be broken down and studied.

Given that there's a whole chapter (7) dedicated to the application of models to climate catastrophes, that study hardly supports the claim you made.

But again, I didn't read every word, so please, direct me to the relevant section.

Did you search the document for "it would be foolish to go beyond what's already being done to curtail emissions". I'm sure it's in there.

Or maybe those were my words. I get confused. :p

Do you see anywhere in what you've read that the current measures are insufficient? Do you see anywhere a recommendation for going beyond what's already being done? Because I don't. I see a pretty fair analysis of what the current models and and cannot do and with what accuracy I also see how flawed future predictions based on these models can be. Do you know how I know this? I suspect you've glossed over an important part of the report.
 
Did you search the document for "it would be foolish to go beyond what's already being done to curtail emissions". I'm sure it's in there.

Or maybe those were my words. I get confused. :p

Do you see anywhere in what you've read that the current measures are insufficient? Do you see anywhere a recommendation for going beyond what's already being done? Because I don't. I see a pretty fair analysis of what the current models and and cannot do and with what accuracy I also see how flawed future predictions based on these models can be. Do you know how I know this? I suspect you've glossed over an important part of the report.

What is this BS about playing coy? Just make your *********** argument. No, I have no idea what little section you're referring to in a 135 page paper. Pick out the parts that support your contention, quote them, and make something resembling a point.

The report is a strong overview of the current state of climate modeling. It doesn't contain any prescription for future action. It does, however, discuss climate change multiple times and has a whole chapter devoted to the effects of climate change.

Saying that models cannot currently predict the future exactly does not lead to the conclusion that we shouldn't curb emissions. You're making a massive, unwarranted leap based on a biased, comical reading of that report.

No to mention your consistent desire to pretend like climate science depends on modelling. If no computer model existed we would still have ample information supporting AGW and, therefore, excellent reason to curb emissions.
 
Did you search the document for "it would be foolish to go beyond what's already being done to curtail emissions". I'm sure it's in there.

Or maybe those were my words. I get confused. :p

Do you see anywhere in what you've read that the current measures are insufficient? Do you see anywhere a recommendation for going beyond what's already being done? Because I don't. I see a pretty fair analysis of what the current models and and cannot do and with what accuracy I also see how flawed future predictions based on these models can be. Do you know how I know this? I suspect you've glossed over an important part of the report.

:jaw-dropp

So, because the article doesn't outright recommend going beyond what's already being done, you read that as a recommendation to not go beyond what's being done?

I don't know what to say... :eye-poppi
 
Whew! I'm not invisible :D

So here's my point (well, one of them anyway): to what extent is it possible to divide those who are consistent and persistent in their 'climate change scepticism' into "numerates" and "innumerates"?

And if possible, is it then possible - in principle - to address the numerates by working towards common ground, based on "numeracy"? Perhaps reaching consensus of great swathes of stuff, and well-defined, clearly bounded parts of parameter space where consensus is not possible? Note that this is - by definition - impossible wrt the innumerates.

And if possible (2), is it then possible - in principle - to address the innumerates by using the methods described in the article? By definition, this could not take place here, in the SMMT section of JREF (you cannot do science if you are innumerate, at least not science in the 21st century).

In other words, if may be so bold, is there not a way - potentially - to break the apparent endless cycle that many of the SMMT threads seem to descend to?

You'd think so, but it doesn't seem to be that way. The hardcore warmers don't like to admit anything is less than 100% other than to say "it will never be perfect".

And it won't be perfect. The system is too complex. The models have come a long way since the 90's even, but they have further to go before we can hope to begin to predict the furture.

I'd be interested in what people think about the accuracy of current models based on the paper I cited.
 
You'd think so, but it doesn't seem to be that way. The hardcore warmers don't like to admit anything is less than 100% other than to say "it will never be perfect".

And it won't be perfect. The system is too complex. The models have come a long way since the 90's even, but they have further to go before we can hope to begin to predict the furture.

I'd be interested in what people think about the accuracy of current models based on the paper I cited.

That's your mantra, is it? "The system is too complex"...

It might be too complex for you, but intelligent people (climate scientists) are figuring it out, and they tell us we have a warming problem. They base this on the science as opposed to hunches.
 
What is this BS about playing coy? Just make your *********** argument. No, I have no idea what little section you're referring to in a 135 page paper. Pick out the parts that support your contention, quote them, and make something resembling a point.

The report is a strong overview of the current state of climate modeling. It doesn't contain any prescription for future action. It does, however, discuss climate change multiple times and has a whole chapter devoted to the effects of climate change.

Saying that models cannot currently predict the future exactly does not lead to the conclusion that we shouldn't curb emissions. You're making a massive, unwarranted leap based on a biased, comical reading of that report.

No to mention your consistent desire to pretend like climate science depends on modelling. If no computer model existed we would still have ample information supporting AGW and, therefore, excellent reason to curb emissions.

In case you haven't heard we are curbing emissions. What we don't know is what effect they will have. The excellent reason to curb emissions lies soley in the fact that we put it there, not flawed models, or climate science or polar bears. We put it there and it needs to go. End of story.

You're determined to dress up this pig and take it to the prom aren't you :D
 
In case you haven't heard we are curbing emissions. What we don't know is what effect they will have. The excellent reason to curb emissions lies soley in the fact that we put it there, not flawed models, or climate science or polar bears. We put it there and it needs to go. End of story.

You're determined to dress up this pig and take it to the prom aren't you :D

:confused:

We put the ISS in orbit. It has to go. We built Chicago. It has to go. We created TV. It has to go.

Seriously stupid argument.

You want CO2 emissions cut because we put it there. Not because it causes the earth to warm as science tells us.

I don't know whether to laugh or cry.
 
Yay! I'm not invisible2 !

To be honest, I don't see any such way. The denialists here are dead set against changing their minds. In fact, for every thread where they get shot down with evidence, their resolve is seemingly strengthened. In the end, it becomes a matter of pride.
In reading this I'm struck by an apparent strong correlation, between "denialists" and "innumerates".

For example, you can't - by definition - "shoot down with [quantitative, scientific] evidence" for someone who simply does not (and, if an adult, cannot?) grasp the quantitative, numerate basis of contemporary science.

And, as you* say, when you engage an innumerate in a manner that works so well with numerates, you (often) get a result that is opposite to that you had hoped for ("their resolve is seemingly strengthened", for example).

I'd say that denialists today are a lost cause. If the poles melted tomorrow they would say it's "natural change" or "alarmism". What's needed is focus on the general public that isn't involved in a war of egos on the internet. Scientists are aware of the fact that the denialists have been very successful in their propaganda campaign. I think the best way to go is to adapt the denialist tactic of media-blitz.
The article you cite suggests this may be one approach, to use with innumerates, but is by no means the only one that may be effective (unlike 'shooting down with evidence').

Not what could be construed as alarmism, though, as that's just going to be twisted by denialists. Instead, a media-campaign should focus on telling the story of denialism, and highlighting the importance of science. Perhaps shows like Dawkins' "Growing up in the Universe", only focused on climate science instead.

The fight is - as always - between science and pseudo-science, and pseudo-science is often more appealing to a non-skeptical mind.
The article you cite suggests the underlying cause of the miscommunication (talking past each other) is, for the most part, not about these two, but more about numerate vs innumerate.

The problem is, scientists can't do all the fighting. People need to be recruited. Journalists need to be informed about the actual science, and about the denialist tactic of "equal time". Science won the war on Big Tobacco, and it will win this war. The problem is that it's taking too long.
Perhaps, but is it possible that a deeper understanding of the "sources and origins" (of denialism) - which is, supposedly, the topic of this thread - may provide insights into how to better address effectiveness and efficiency metrics?

* actually, the article you cited
 
Yay! I'm not invisible2 !


In reading this I'm struck by an apparent strong correlation, between "denialists" and "innumerates".

For example, you can't - by definition - "shoot down with [quantitative, scientific] evidence" for someone who simply does not (and, if an adult, cannot?) grasp the quantitative, numerate basis of contemporary science.

And, as you* say, when you engage an innumerate in a manner that works so well with numerates, you (often) get a result that is opposite to that you had hoped for ("their resolve is seemingly strengthened", for example).


The article you cite suggests this may be one approach, to use with innumerates, but is by no means the only one that may be effective (unlike 'shooting down with evidence').


The article you cite suggests the underlying cause of the miscommunication (talking past each other) is, for the most part, not about these two, but more about numerate vs innumerate.

Yeah, the article does say that. I doubt there's any scientifically evidenced "right" way to deal with denialism, and it's all down to opinion at this time. The article provides what the author feels is good paths to take.

Perhaps, but is it possible that a deeper understanding of the "sources and origins" (of denialism) - which is, supposedly, the topic of this thread - may provide insights into how to better address effectiveness and efficiency metrics?

Might be true. It would take someone trained in psychology I suppose. I don't doubt people of said training are conducting research in denialism as we speak.
 
Originally Posted by 3bodyproblem
In case you haven't heard we are curbing emissions. What we don't know is what effect they will have

What YOU don't know is what effect curbing GHG emissions will have. Don't speak for others, the climate science community in particular.

It's straight forward - the physics has been around for 150 years.
http://www.aip.org/history/climate/summary.htm

it will reduce the future radiative imbalance which we have initiated by adding fossil carbon to the atmosphere and keep the rising temperatures less over time. Buy us time to deal with the issue.

Carbon is forever : article : Nature Reports Climate Change
by M Inman - 2008 - Cited by 1 - Related articles
Carbon is forever. Carbon dioxide emissions and their associated warming could linger for millennia, according to some climate scientists. ...
http://www.nature.com/climate/2008/0812/full/climate.2008.122.html

The uncertainty arises from tipping points for large scale changes in the release of methane both land bound and coastal.
That's the 900 lb gorilla that is stirring.

#
Study Says Undersea Release of Methane Is Under Way - NYTimes.com
5 Mar 2010 ... But a scientist who led the study said it was too soon to say whether the findings suggest the potential for a dangerous release of methane ...
www.nytimes.com/2010/03/05/science/.../05methane.html - Add to iGoogle
#
Arctic permafrost leaking methane at record levels, figures show ...
14 Jan 2010 ... 14 Jan 2010, 9:12PM. So methane is a significantly more powerful .... by increased methane emissions will itself release yet more methane ...

Press Release 10-036
Methane Releases From Arctic Shelf May Be Much Larger and Faster Than Anticipated

Thawing by climate change of subsea layer of permafrost may release stores of underlying, seabed methane

That is a very nasty feedback once underway.

http://www.nsf.gov/news/news_summ.jsp?cntn_id=116532

If you actually read some climate science you would know that. :garfield:
 
Last edited:
You're running out of denier steam. Go watch a YouTube of Joe Rogan claiming the moon landing was faked. You need inspiration.

And there is more of a problem than just "putting it there."

But now I'm curious, just like the 9-11 nuts never explain their theory because two words in it falls apart, you have yet to explain why you think the Earth is warming. What accounts for it, according to you?

Another reason for growing skepticism. AGW proponents tend to make totally irrelevant statements like this. Once you dig through the nonsense and rhetorical questions there's nothing here.

Perhaps he means that climate science took a big step forward during the space race? Perhaps it was unusually warm on 9/11? I don't know. It's just a tactic to divert your attention away from the discussion at hand, the climate models are still incomplete and have much more room to grow before they can be meaningful in substantiating any effects of mitigation. Mitigating the effects of CO2, the cause of the current warming (yes I know it's rhetorical, but they need humoring sometimes)
 
Yeah, the article does say that. I doubt there's any scientifically evidenced "right" way to deal with denialism, and it's all down to opinion at this time. The article provides what the author feels is good paths to take.



Might be true. It would take someone trained in psychology I suppose. I don't doubt people of said training are conducting research in denialism as we speak.
If one isn't prepared to at least try to understand "root causes", one must be prepared to emulate Sisyphus, mustn't one?
 
You don't seem to be able to follow the science here fred. You seem to think this heat lost by evaporation is carried by the air, and not the water vapour. You fail miserably at understanding thermodynamics.

So ironic. Why cant we try to get on expert to determine who of us that know basic thermodynamics?

About your newest "theory". Lets take it sloooooow and I am going to try to explain what is happening clearly and hope I don't mix up any terms.

Air is gas.
Water vapor is a gas.
Air is a gas that consist of oxygen, nitrogen and other most of the time other gases like CO2, water vapor etc.
The "energy" in the water vapor is called latent heat.

Now the complicated part that can be found in every single meteorological book.

We have air close to the ground. This air also most of the time contains water vapor.
The sun heat the ground.
Some of that heat evaporate water which result in more vater vapor in the air close to the ground.
Some of the heat is heating the air close to the ground making it warmer.
The air close to the ground is now still a mix gas which includes water vapor.

The heated air is now less dense due to it beeing warmer compare to the air above it. Buoyancy is now resulting in that air moving up in the atmosphere. This is called convection or thermals.

So the whole chunk of air is moving up, not just the water vapor and the water vapor is not necessary.

What you wrote above is just gibberish because water vapor is a part of the air and it carries together with the air.

edit:
Why did you quote the following sentence from MIT "The heat lost by evaporation is carried deep into the atmosphere by convection" when it is obviously true and nothing I have ever written have contradicted that?

Why do you quote obvious facts that don't have anything to do with our discussion? The only reason I can think of are that you want to prove that you haven't understood anything about our discussion... You just prove over and over again that you are clueless about the issue and that you don't seem to be able to understand what you are reading.
 
Last edited:
What you wrote above is just gibberish because water vapor is a part of the air and it carries together with the air.

lol.

A common misconception

Often the notion of air holding water vapor is presented to describe the concept of relative humidity. However, air simply acts as a transporter of water vapour and is not a holder of it. Therefore, relative humidity is wholly understood in terms of the physical properties of water alone and thus is unrelated to this concept.[2][3] In fact, water vapor can be present in an airless volume and therefore the relative humidity of this volume can be readily determined.

The misconception that air holds water is likely the result of the use of the word saturation which is often misused in descriptions of relative humidity. In the present context the word saturation refers to the state of water vapor,[4] not the solubility of one material in another.

Your other folly:
Some of the heat is heating the air close to the ground making it warmer.

It's heating the water vapour, not the air. I already explained to you the thermal capacity of water is significantly higher than "air". In about grade 6 we teach our children this by boiling water in a paper cup. The paper cup doesn't get hot and burn, the water does and boils.

So for the last time fred, it's the water vapour in air that creates the predominant form of convection on this planet. "Dry" convection can occur, but is almost non-existent due to the fact that almost everywhere on this planet there is water vapour in the air. Your talk of it in relation to cloud formation is utterly nonsensical.

Gaseous water represents a small but environmentally significant constituent of the atmosphere. Approximately 99.13% of it is contained in the troposphere. The condensation of water vapor to the liquid or ice phase is responsible for clouds, rain, snow, and other precipitation, all of which count among the most significant elements of what we experience as weather. Less obviously, the latent heat of vaporization, which is released to the atmosphere whenever condensation occurs, is one of the most important terms in the atmospheric energy budget on both local and global scales. For example, latent heat release in atmospheric convection is directly responsible for powering destructive storms such as tropical cyclones and severe thunderstorms. Water vapor is also the most potent greenhouse gas owing to the presence of the hydroxyl bond which absorbs strongly in the infra-red region of the light spectrum. Because the water vapor content of the atmosphere will increase in response to warmer temperatures, there is a water vapor feedback is expected to amplify the climate warming effect due to increased carbon dioxide alone. It is less clear how cloudiness would respond to a warming climate; depending on the nature of the response, clouds could either further amplify or partly mitigate warming from long-lived greenhouse gases.

Fog and clouds form through condensation around cloud condensation nuclei. In the absence of nuclei, condensation will only occur at much lower temperatures. Under persistent condensation or deposition, cloud droplets or snowflakes form, which precipitate when they reach a critical mass.

bolding mine.

I hope you finally get this fred.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom