Climate change scepticism - its sources and origins

Status
Not open for further replies.
From the original link



A perfect example of my thesis of Science as schizophrenic search for an underlying metanarrative.

Notice how the scientist here instinctively shrinks away from embracing complexity and having to reduce everything to a Manichaeism lens of cooling vs warming.

Also an implicit desire of regression to infancy: a belief that the childhood of the scientist represented an unchanging golden age of climate which the hormonal surges of puberty (here beautifully represented by the temptations of consumption and the play on words of (CO2) emissions) threatens to rend asunder.

In fact, there is no zero point of climate, no ideal to return to, all was always flux. The point of flux that is now, is no better or worse than the point of flux that was 1900 AD or 1900 BC. And what from the child's eye was a period of stability and shelter was for the adults living through it a society riven by uncontrollable seismic forces.

Perhaps all Climate Scientists need is a good therapist?

Seriously, as far as internet psychology goes, you suck at it.
 
What is NOT in question is
a) it's getting warmer
b) we're primarily responsible due to use of fossil fuels.


other than in the minds of a few cranks.
Are you counted amongst them? :garfield:

"In the time it took you to read this post, 150 smokers dies of lung cancer, 2500 children died of hunger, 7500 familes became homeless, 1500 women were beaten within an inch of their lives and oh yah, the planet warmed by 0.0000000186 degrees"

Of these predictions, all but one are well documented as fact. 1 is a best guess estimate based on admittedly flawed models.

other than a few cranks, most people are aware of the serious issues facing society. Are you counted amongst them?
 
You should go over the Steve Schneider transcript in the OP. As far as complex systems go climate modelling is about as good as it gets.
 
Last edited:
You should go over the Steve Schneider transcript in the OP. As far as complex systems climate modelling is about as good as it gets.

Thats what concerns me. He flip flops on cooling to warming one day, whats to say he won't do it again?

Clearly his position on whether the earth is cooler or warming or just bouncing around like normally does, is not based on anything as vulgarly mundane as a temperature gauge. Any monkey can read one of those.
 
Thats what concerns me. He flip flops on cooling to warming one day, whats to say he won't do it again?

You do realize that that is proper skepticism, right? A skeptic follows the evidence, and if the evidence show that it's warming, a skeptic acknowledges that it's warming.

A denialist would accuse a skeptic of flip flopping, though.
 
You should go over the Steve Schneider transcript in the OP. As far as complex systems go climate modelling is about as good as it gets.

No doubt, there are some seriously smart people working on these models. They are as good as it gets until they get better.

The actual amount of warming and that predicted by models remains in a statistical cloud of uncertainty. As do the effects of said warming on the globe.

The misrepresentation of this by AGW proponents is the major reason for the upswell of skepticism.

In an attempt to cover this up the AGW proponents have created a smear campaign, trying to lump GW skeptics in with the likes of Holocaust "deniers".

This will undoubtedly lead to more "negative feedback", a term most AGW proponents are completely unfamiliar with :D
 
Wrong- there are thousands of papers detailing the effects of GW on biota , agriculture, silva culture, fishing and migration.

The impacts in the north in particular are not in the least clouded.

Once more you ave no idea what you are talking about, no support for your ill-informed opinion.

Analogue signals of change to a warmer planet are clear and pervasive both in the geo-systems and in the bio-sphere.

Just why do you think YOU are correct and fossil fuel company's own scientists who say AGW is undeniable are wrong? :popcorn
You come into a science forum with grand pronouncements and not an iota of backup for them and flying in the face of thousands of papers tracing a warming world and simple physics known for over a century.

Give us a break. :rolleyes:
 
What I wonder is how much money gets paid to people who seem to troll the Internet 24/7 JAQing and insinuating about AGW and trashing the reputations of scientists. I would be amazed at this point if there was not some actual money changing hands.

Yes, I wonder how much money has flowed in to the coffers of those who support Mann Made Global Warming (tm)?

But really...this is yet another rediculous effort by those who believe man is solely responsible for Mann Made Global Warming (tm) in deligitimising those who are sceptical of mans role in Mann Made Global Warming(tm).

Anyway, seeing as you have all conveniently buried your heads in the sand...Ill ask my question for a third time;

"Do you want the science behind Mann Made Global Warming (tm) to be correct...yes or no?"

Regards

Mailman
 
The misrepresentation of this by AGW proponents is the major reason for the upswell of skepticism.

Interesting theory. Too bad it fails in it's premise, as there has been no misrepresentation.

Further, any upswell hasn't been of skepticism, but of denialism, and the reasons for that upswell is many faceted. One major reason is a organized campaign of sowing doubt orchestrated by a select few with political agendas. This is all well documented of course. You can read further about this upswell of denialism here.


In an attempt to cover this up the AGW proponents have created a smear campaign, trying to lump GW skeptics in with the likes of Holocaust "deniers".

Wrong again, I am afraid. The links to holocaust denialism and is merely superficial, in that the same kind of though processes are involved, and that they are both ideologically based. The links to tobacco industry effort in cancer denialism are a lot more substantiated. Of course, just as holocaust denialism, there are definite links to 9/11 denialism (twooferism), AIDS denialism and other conspiracy theories.

The one thing AGW "skepticism" isn't in any way related to is scientific skepticism.
 
Interesting theory. Too bad it fails in it's premise, as there has been no misrepresentation.

Further, any upswell hasn't been of skepticism, but of denialism, and the reasons for that upswell is many faceted. One major reason is a organized campaign of sowing doubt orchestrated by a select few with political agendas. This is all well documented of course. You can read further about this upswell of denialism here.




Wrong again, I am afraid. The links to holocaust denialism and is merely superficial, in that the same kind of though processes are involved, and that they are both ideologically based. The links to tobacco industry effort in cancer denialism are a lot more substantiated. Of course, just as holocaust denialism, there are definite links to 9/11 denialism (twooferism), AIDS denialism and other conspiracy theories.

The one thing AGW "skepticism" isn't in any way related to is scientific skepticism.

Your alleged rise in denialism as opposed to skepticism is completely unfounded. Have you read any of the links in this thread? It's clear from them you're misapplying the term.

Keep trying to draw lines that clearly don't exist. The fact remains, the number of people in the general public who don't believe in AGW is growing, and that has nothing to do with the holocaust or the creationism.

You could prove me wrong you know. Feel free to conduct a poll that actually establishes some relation between AGW skeptics and creationism or homeopaty or any of the other "woo" you claim exists.

It doesn't and the term "denier" is a spectacular fail. But you already knew that didn't you ;)
 
Keep trying to draw lines that clearly don't exist. The fact remains, the number of people in the general public who don't believe in AGW is growing, and that has nothing to do with the holocaust or the creationism.

That has everything to do with good PR and NOTHING to do with science or the arguments that are held in the scientific community. All it says really is that the lesson from tobacco denialism were well learned by those who seek to deny the reality of climate science. PR works. No ****, Sherlock!
 
IOW Peer reviewed science is one giant conspiricy!

Hmmmm....

“This was the danger of always criticising the skeptics for not publishing in the “peer-reviewed literature”. Obviously, they found a solution to that–take over a journal! So what do we do about this? I think we have to stop considering “Climate Research” as a legitimate peer-reviewed journal. Perhaps we should encourage our colleagues in the climate research community to no longer submit to, or cite papers in, this journal. We would also need to consider what we tell or request of our more reasonable colleagues who currently sit on the editorial board…What do others think?”

and

“I will be emailing the journal to tell them I’m having nothing more to do with it until they rid themselves of this troublesome editor. It results from this journal having a number of editors. The responsible one for this is a well-known skeptic in NZ. He has let a few papers through by Michaels and Gray in the past. I’ve had words with Hans von Storch about this, but got nowhere. Another thing to discuss in Nice !”

Ill leave it up to you to use that new fandangled thing called the intraweb to delve deeper in to this slight inconvenience and challenge to your belief.

Then again, I guess there really is nothing to see here for those who want to see nothing! :D

Regards

Mailman
 
That has everything to do with good PR
Good PR by who? Considering the near complete strangle hold the belief in Mann Made Global Warming (tm) has on the main stream media...just where is this so called "good PR" getting propogated from/through?

and NOTHING to do with science or the arguments that are held in the scientific community.
Ah...yes, keep burying your head in the sand. There is nothing to see here!

Sadly for you the reality is that the growth in scepticism is in direct proportion to discovery of the lack of science that has gone in to the science of Mann Made Global Warming (tm).

I know, you can continue to pretend that the science is settled but again, the reality is that the science on Mann Made Global Warming (tm) is anything BUT settled.

All it says really is that the lesson from tobacco denialism were well learned by those who seek to deny the reality of climate science. PR works. No ****, Sherlock!

Isnt it funny though, once upon a time a denialist would have been considered someone who denied the existence of the midevil warm period! :D

Mailman
 
That has everything to do with good PR and NOTHING to do with science or the arguments that are held in the scientific community. All it says really is that the lesson from tobacco denialism were well learned by those who seek to deny the reality of climate science. PR works. No ****, Sherlock!

Since I don't find myself in that group I can't really comment. Nor do most of the people I encounter that express their concerns about GW being a farce. I'm just not aware of any PR.

I honestly believe it's the fear mongering "forcing" the issue and skepticism is merely a "feedback".
 
The best PR is subtle, very subtle. It's little wonder that you are in denial about it's impact as well.
 
Your alleged rise in denialism as opposed to skepticism is completely unfounded. Have you read any of the links in this thread? It's clear from them you're misapplying the term.

Have you read any of the links? I've read them, and I even provided one (posted before, but needed to be repeated in face of your claims). Not only has there been a rise in denialism, the term "skepticism" is under serious attack by the denialists who keep trying to claim it for themselves.

Keep trying to draw lines that clearly don't exist. The fact remains, the number of people in the general public who don't believe in AGW is growing, and that has nothing to do with the holocaust or the creationism.

Yes, it does. It has to do with the same kind of politically motivated misinformation, in several instances being spread by the same people. Climate scientists and scientists in general are aware of the fact that public understanding of climate science and scientific understanding thereof don't match up, and they now have to take the time to fight these forces of anti-science that threaten to undermine public understanding futher - time that could be spent doing science.

You could prove me wrong you know.

I believe I have.

Feel free to conduct a poll that actually establishes some relation between AGW skeptics and creationism or homeopaty or any of the other "woo" you claim exists.

That link has been proven time and time again. The easiest to prove is the link to tobacco-cancer denialism, and that has been done several times on this forum. The links I and others have posted show clear links in behaviour and thinking between AGW denialism and creationism, 9/11 denialism and other forms of woo.

It doesn't and the term "denier" is a spectacular fail. But you already knew that didn't you ;)

It really does, but you seem to be in denial about it. Fitting, really.
 
And yet Uke, you provide no proof to back your arguments up. Why is that? Because you actually have NO proof? :D

Mailman
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom