Climate change scepticism - its sources and origins

Status
Not open for further replies.
So in other words, you dont know where this PR is coming from?

Mailman

Should teach me not to peek at posts from people I have on ignore.

Have you really not been paying attention at all, mailman? We have already provided links explaining where the PR comes from, how it started and who is doing it. Please, if you are so determined to post in these threads, try to learn the basics, ok?
 
Not only should you not peek, you shouldn't quote!

Yeah, I know. Curiosity got the better of me, and I just had to reply with a quote. Won't happen again... maybe. ;)

Anyway, here's a good article that has already been posted, but bears repeating.

Living in denial: Why sensible people reject the truth

It's rather scathing in places, including passages like this:

Whatever they are denying, denial movements have much in common with one another, not least the use of similar tactics. All set themselves up as courageous underdogs fighting a corrupt elite engaged in a conspiracy to suppress the truth or foist a malicious lie on ordinary people. This conspiracy is usually claimed to be promoting a sinister agenda: the nanny state, takeover of the world economy, government power over individuals, financial gain, atheism.

This common ground tells us a great deal about the underlying causes of denialism. The first thing to note is that denial finds its most fertile ground in areas where the science must be taken on trust. There is no denial of antibiotics, which visibly work. But there is denial of vaccines, which we are merely told will prevent diseases - diseases, moreover, which most of us have never seen, ironically because the vaccines work.

Similarly, global warming, evolution and the link between tobacco and cancer must be taken on trust, usually on the word of scientists, doctors and other technical experts who many non-scientists see as arrogant and alien.

[Seth Kalichman, a social psychologist at the University of Connecticut at Storrs] believes the instigators of denialist movements have more serious psychological problems than most of their followers. "They display all the features of paranoid personality disorder", he says, including anger, intolerance of criticism, and what psychiatrists call a grandiose sense of their own importance. "Ultimately, their denialism is a mental health problem. That is why these movements all have the same features, especially the underlying conspiracy theory."

The article is well sourced, and links the different denialist movements rather well. It's worth a read.
 
Hmmmm....



and



Ill leave it up to you to use that new fandangled thing called the intraweb to delve deeper in to this slight inconvenience and challenge to your belief.

Then again, I guess there really is nothing to see here for those who want to see nothing! :D

Regards

Mailman

First, in answer to your question, I and most other AGW proponents would wish that the science behind AGW were not true. It would be fine if we could burn all the fossil fuels with no impact to the environment.

As to the quotes in your post,

Have you read the paper in question?

http://www.int-res.com/articles/cr2003/23/c023p089.pdf

from the paper

soon and baliunus said:
However, the
proxies show that the 20th century is not unusually
warm or extreme.

I think that is why some had a problem with that paper.
 
LOL, the ironic thing is that MM was just asking where exactly the PR was coming from. And the video I replied to him with shows a great deal of it came from the Marshall Institute, who were, in fact, paying Willie Soon at the time he published that paper! :D
 
Should teach me not to peek at posts from people I have on ignore.

Have you really not been paying attention at all, mailman? We have already provided links explaining where the PR comes from, how it started and who is doing it. Please, if you are so determined to post in these threads, try to learn the basics, ok?

You have only posted links to other talking heads who agree with your position BUT no actual proof that someone like Al baby is trying to take over the world.

So again, where exactly is this suble PR coming from? I demand names dammit...NAMES! :D
 
LOL, the ironic thing is that MM was just asking where exactly the PR was coming from. And the video I replied to him with shows a great deal of it came from the Marshall Institute, who were, in fact, paying Willie Soon at the time he published that paper! :D

So lets be clear here, its not ok for Soon to accept money from the Marshall Institute or the API because that might be a conflict of interset BUT its ok for Jones, Mann, Schmidt et al to accept Government money because Goverments NEVER have conflicts of interest?

Just so we are clear like! :D

Mailman
 
The best PR is subtle, very subtle. It's little wonder that you are in denial about it's impact as well.

Now you're in conspiracy territory :D

If you could cite some example of this subtle PR? I've never seen any myself, although it almost comes hand in hand where big business is concerned doesn't it.
 
Correct. The fact that the US government payees the scientists that work for it is very normal. Money that comes from special interest group trying to promote a political agenda is suspect is suspect.

Can you please explain to us what you there is something wrong with this?
 
Have you read any of the links? I've read them, and I even provided one (posted before, but needed to be repeated in face of your claims). Not only has there been a rise in denialism, the term "skepticism" is under serious attack by the denialists who keep trying to claim it for themselves.



Yes, it does. It has to do with the same kind of politically motivated misinformation, in several instances being spread by the same people. Climate scientists and scientists in general are aware of the fact that public understanding of climate science and scientific understanding thereof don't match up, and they now have to take the time to fight these forces of anti-science that threaten to undermine public understanding futher - time that could be spent doing science.



I believe I have.



That link has been proven time and time again. The easiest to prove is the link to tobacco-cancer denialism, and that has been done several times on this forum. The links I and others have posted show clear links in behaviour and thinking between AGW denialism and creationism, 9/11 denialism and other forms of woo.



It really does, but you seem to be in denial about it. Fitting, really.

More handwaving without addressing the issue. How many climate skeptics in this forum also subscribe to any of your other "denialisms"?

There's probably more climate scientists that believe in God on a per capita basis. Not that any of this matters because we all know the label is just a cop out for when AGW proponents fail to convert a skeptic. Along the lines of "If you don't believe me you must be a commie!"

The majority of skeptics believe there is current warming, along the lines of 0.2 degrees over the last 2 decades, but that increase is statistically insignificant. Further, the projections based on current models are flawed and exist in a cloud of uncertainty. They also realize the feedbacks, both positive and negative aren't fully understood. They also realize CO2 emissions have to be curtailed.
 
You're not a skeptic - you are just ignorant of climate science - don't hide your ignorance behind skepticism as if it's some boyscout badge. :rolleyes:

You've demonstrated time and again you fail to understand the most basic principles of geo-physical systems yet claim some sort of "special knowledge" that lets you diss the climate science community - even that of the fossil fuel companies own scientists
....how unarguably stupid can that claim be in the face of overwhelming evidence...

sorry but at this point it's

:dl:
 
Correct. The fact that the US government payees the scientists that work for it is very normal. Money that comes from special interest group trying to promote a political agenda is suspect is suspect.

Can you please explain to us what you there is something wrong with this?

Aside from your out of character grammatical structure? :p

I think I see what you're getting at and I agree. Special interest groups are suspect because we know what they seek to promote. Of course they wish to promote science which supports their agenda. At the same time, if the science supports it, it doesn't matter who supports it.

Oddly enough, the tobacco companies, when faced with a complete ban on advertising, embraced ads that put their product in a bad light, knowing full well that bad publicity is still better than none at all.
 
but that increase is statistically insignificant.


That makes them deniers, because when you actually do the statistics the warming is statistically significant.

They also realize the feedbacks, both positive and negative aren't fully understood.


Again this points to them being deniers for two reasons. First they refuse to bring any quantified feedbacks to the table Second, the Paleoclimate evidence suggests an unknown negative feedback is unlikely and would require a similar unknown positive feedback.

Further, the projections based on current models are flawed

Again, denier because they can’t point to actual flaws that just handwave and claim there are flaws without published any detailed description of what these “flaws” are or how much effect fixing them would have on the model.

Deniers seldom look to advancing knowledge their trademark is that they simply claim their “evidence” overturns all the accepted science even though they can’t show it makes any difference at all.
 
More handwaving without addressing the issue.

Excuse me, how did I not address the issue?

How many climate skeptics in this forum also subscribe to any of your other "denialisms"?

I have no idea, nor is it relevant in any way.

There's probably more climate scientists that believe in God on a per capita basis. Not that any of this matters because we all know the label is just a cop out for when AGW proponents fail to convert a skeptic. Along the lines of "If you don't believe me you must be a commie!"

No, there is a clear distinction between a skeptic and a denialist. When you cross that line, there's often no converting you, period. It's quite evident on these boards alone, as tons of science is being presented but the denialists stick to their long debunked grasps of straw, fighting desperately to hang on to their beliefs.

The majority of skeptics believe there is current warming, along the lines of 0.2 degrees over the last 2 decades, but that increase is statistically insignificant.

Then those skeptics aren't skeptics. A skeptic would realize that 2 decades means nothing when talking climate and instead look at the long term trends. He would then seek the counsel of people who are trained for this sort of thing - climatologists - and would then ask them if they feel the warming trend is significant and why. When given an answer, the skeptic would make up his mind, as he now possesses the relevant information. As you obviously got stuck at step 1, you're not a skeptic.

Further, the projections based on current models are flawed and exist in a cloud of uncertainty.

A skeptic would of course realize that no science is certain and instead look at probabilities. What do the probabilities tell us? Well, the climatologists seem to think that it is most probable that their models and predictions are true, and that if anything is wrong, it's because they were too conservative. A denialist would cling on to the statement of normal scientific uncertainty and hold it up as proof that there isn't a scientific consensus about AGW, or that the models are junk. We both know which role you play here.

They also realize the feedbacks, both positive and negative aren't fully understood.

Again, a skeptic would understand that most things in science are never fully understood. "More research needed" is a common phrase used in scientific papers. This normal scientific uncertainty is, as we have already noted, something that the denialist clings on to for dear life.

They also realize CO2 emissions have to be curtailed.

A skeptic would want to know why CO2 emissions have to be curtailed. As you have denied the science of anthropogenic global warming, there's no reason for you to think CO2 emissions should be curtailed.

I think they need to be curtailed because climate science tells us they are one of the major causes of global warming.
 
That makes them deniers, because when you actually do the statistics the warming is statistically significant.

Again this points to them being deniers for two reasons. First they refuse to bring any quantified feedbacks to the table Second, the Paleoclimate evidence suggests an unknown negative feedback is unlikely and would require a similar unknown positive feedback.

Again, denier because they can’t point to actual flaws that just handwave and claim there are flaws without published any detailed description of what these “flaws” are or how much effect fixing them would have on the model.

Deniers seldom look to advancing knowledge their trademark is that they simply claim their “evidence” overturns all the accepted science even though they can’t show it makes any difference at all.

Oh, so there's no need for another IPCC report then, and we can stop funding because the science is settled. Anything from this point forward is just icing on the cake?

lol, fat chance of that! The IPCC, NASA, MIT all admit the models are incomplete and more research is needed. The certainty you express in the above post doesn't exist among scientists. They would never presume that much. The science is new and very complex.

But you keep telling people otherwise and scratch your head as the number of skeptics grow! :dl:
 
The IPCC, NASA, MIT all admit the models are incomplete and more research is needed.

All models are incomplete and need more research.

Research is ongoing to fit the fossil record into the model that is evolution. By your logic this means evolution is suspect and anyone with alternate ideas are engaging in legitimate skepticism.

You are in fact highlighting the most common denier meme. Deniers always claim “science is proof therefore any crackpot idea that goes against mainstream science is legitimate skepticism”.
 
Oh, so there's no need for another IPCC report then, and we can stop funding because the science is settled. Anything from this point forward is just icing on the cake?

lol, fat chance of that! The IPCC, NASA, MIT all admit the models are incomplete and more research is needed. The certainty you express in the above post doesn't exist among scientists. They would never presume that much. The science is new and very complex.

But you keep telling people otherwise and scratch your head as the number of skeptics grow! :dl:

Thank you so much for proving my point about denialists who grasp at normal scientific uncertainty as proof of global warming being in doubt.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom