Climate change scepticism - its sources and origins

Status
Not open for further replies.
So yes, I'm skeptical of people claiming we should do something we don't have any clue what effect it will have, when there are other things we could be doing with measurable effects. It seems a little self serving to me. Oh yah let's worry about future generations when we can take care of this one? WTF?

What is it that has been proposed that we don't have any clue of what effect it will have? What things have measurable effects that haven't been proposed?

3body obviously doesn't like being asked questions about his rather odd reasoning in this thread, but if more people start doing it, eventually he'll either stop his strange reasoning, or he'll start answering.
 
First, please feel free to link them so I can defend myself. I'm getting pretty sick of this tactic. I post something and then the adhoms start flying immediately from various sources. I respond in kind, eventually, and someone comes along, ingnores the numerous attacks I've taken and starts making their own on me again. This only flies on the internet because you know what response this would draw on the street. Normally people restrain from making these stupid attacks to people they don't know.

You don't really have any say in how I respond to anyone else, first because you're not a moderator and second you don't have enough info to do so. But if you want to link them so I can show you how things transpired that's fine. I'm very pleasant and respectful of people until provoked.

"The stakes are too high", indeed they are. So why would you not want to know exactly what effect you are having? What if you pour $1 trillion dollars into CO2 trading and the 25 coal plants being built in Indonesia totally negate that investment? What if Gen IV reactors can be comissioned 20 years earlier with a $1 trillion R&D budget? What if carbon sequestering technology is just $8 billion short of being viable?

We don't have answers to these questions be we're not at a point of being able to know what effects we can have. Short of stopping output alltogether what do we know a 4% reduction in some are of industry will have? What if it's better for Asia to go green than the US and Brazil because of geography? It's because the stakes are high we should approach this issue calmly.

And yes, it's possible we have other pressing issues that would be better served by throwing money at them rather than AGW. We could have 10 extra hurricanes and the loss of 100 miles of beaches over the next few years but we know X amount of people will die because of this issues and Y amount of people will die because of that issue. Both X and Y have known fixes at known costs, but we don't have any clue what a 10% reduction in CO2 will have on those hurricanes and lost beaches.

So yes, I'm skeptical of people claiming we should do something we don't have any clue what effect it will have, when there are other things we could be doing with measurable effects. It seems a little self serving to me. Oh yah let's worry about future generations when we can take care of this one? WTF?
3d, so you are saying that you want the approach to be more directed. I dont know that it isnt to be honest, other than you saying it isn't. And Im afraid that wont do. From where Im sitting all your doing is making rash statements with no substance and then arguing about it. Strawman.

We could have 10 extra hurricanes and the loss of 100 miles of beaches over the next few years but we know X amount of people will die because of this issues and Y amount of people will die because of that issue. Both X and Y have known fixes at known costs, but we don't have any clue what a 10% reduction in CO2 will have on those hurricanes and lost beaches.

I mean its impossible to make an argument for or against what you are saying because you are not providing any specific examples of where alarmism has had an unrestrained unrequired overreaction. Personally I dont know how they are going to manage this issue across the globe effectively and economically. Its going to be a complicated political and management task that could be even more complicated than AGW science is itself.

I notice you are making several aruments at once here, one of them being that people are being alarmist on this thread. Theres been quite a few posts requesting that you back up that claim.
 
3d, so you are saying that you want the approach to be more directed. I dont know that it isnt to be honest, other than you saying it isn't. And Im afraid that wont do. From where Im sitting all your doing is making rash statements with no substance and then arguing about it. Strawman.

I mean its impossible to make an argument for or against what you are saying because you are not providing any specific examples of where alarmism has had an unrestrained unrequired overreaction. Personally I dont know how they are going to manage this issue across the globe effectively and economically. Its going to be a complicated political and management task that could be even more complicated than AGW science is itself.

I notice you are making several aruments at once here, one of them being that people are being alarmist on this thread. Theres been quite a few posts requesting that you back up that claim.

Anyone that can't see how I'm being skeptical and calling me a denier is probably an alarmist. The ones who misrepresent my words, attribute positions to me that I don't hold are alarmists. It's obvious they don't want to have a discussio, they want to force their agenda on people.

The agenda tends to be labelling skeptics as "deniers" and trying to discredit them, or call into question their education. They want other to believe you have to be a genius to understand AGW, and and position other than full accepting of AGW in all it's forms is an artifact of their poor mental faculties.

They want to bully people into accepting AGW.

And I know why, because when you take a rational look at it we are essentially doing what we can to curb emissions. Beyond what we are doing it's going to require going on blind faith believeing what the politicians come up with will result in a noticeable positive effect on the climate., because the science just isn't there yet to actually measure its success.

So we are going to end up with a bunch of politicians making money, no actual measured effect on the climate and the scientists saying "yah well we told you we weren't there yet" when people demand some accountability.

I say It's a bunch of crap until we can get some accountability, and we need the science to do that.

YOU can do your own part to make change. You can get an EV and insolate your home and get better windows and recycle and all that fun stuff that saves you money and helps the environment until the science is better and we can start to know what effect we will have. And there need to be more serious talks with the world nations about what they can do to reduce emissions.

So maybe I'm more skeptical of the people than anything. They don't appear to be rational. Take a look at the numer of posts and threads moderated or in AAH. Is that the work of rational minds? I don't think so.
 
We saw this with the question of cloud cover, and again it became evident on the discussion of evaporation. If they can't connect the dots for themselves they rely on someone else to do so, short of that they begin misrepresenting the question entirely.

The only thing that was evident in the discussion about evaporation that you never manage to backup anything you claim.

What you write above also seems to be a adhom attack.

edit:

The whole "this is a result of poor critical thinking skills and reliance on others to do so for them. If the question falls outside a topic someone can't specifically Google and get an answer to they are at a complete loss to formulate one of their own. We saw this with the question of cloud cover, and again it became evident on the discussion of evaporation. If they can't connect the dots for themselves they rely on someone else to do so, short of that they begin misrepresenting the question entirely. "

Seems like an adhom/personal attack. Why do you attack your opponents instead of at least once in a while back up what you write.
 
Last edited:
Anyone that can't see how I'm being skeptical and calling me a denier is probably an alarmist. The ones who misrepresent my words, attribute positions to me that I don't hold are alarmists. It's obvious they don't want to have a discussio, they want to force their agenda on people.

The agenda tends to be labelling skeptics as "deniers" and trying to discredit them, or call into question their education. They want other to believe you have to be a genius to understand AGW, and and position other than full accepting of AGW in all it's forms is an artifact of their poor mental faculties.

They want to bully people into accepting AGW.

Endless links to science were given. They were ignored. More unsubstantiated claims were made, posters demanded substantiation.

It is not "bullying" to demand that claims be supported.

And I know why, because when you take a rational look at it we are essentially doing what we can to curb emissions. Beyond what we are doing it's going to require going on blind faith believeing what the politicians come up with will result in a noticeable positive effect on the climate., because the science just isn't there yet to actually measure its success.

Who is "we?"

As an American I can tell you that we aren't remotely close to doing everything we can. In the first place, we could stop the direct subsidies of oil companies that cut the cost of gasoline at the pump in half. We could tax emission, do a cap-and-trade system, invest the money we spend supporting oil companies on alternative energy sources, invest in better energy delivery systems (about 60% of energy is just lost in the transmission process), develop building codes that require more efficient structures...etc.

There are a million things we could be doing that we aren't. The first step is ending the massive flow of tax-payer dollars to activities destructive to the environment.

So we are going to end up with a bunch of politicians making money, no actual measured effect on the climate and the scientists saying "yah well we told you we weren't there yet" when people demand some accountability.

I say It's a bunch of crap until we can get some accountability, and we need the science to do that.

Is this what happened after the 1989 Montreal Protocols banned the use of ozone depleting aerosols?

YOU can do your own part to make change. You can get an EV and insolate your home and get better windows and recycle and all that fun stuff that saves you money and helps the environment until the science is better and we can start to know what effect we will have. And there need to be more serious talks with the world nations about what they can do to reduce emissions.

Sure, and you know what would make that easier? Instead of paying oil companies to make the cost of gas look cheaper than it is, we could use subsidies to help people make their houses more energy efficient.

Think of all the people that would be able to find employment helping that switch-over. It should be done now.

So maybe I'm more skeptical of the people than anything. They don't appear to be rational. Take a look at the numer of posts and threads moderated or in AAH. Is that the work of rational minds? I don't think so.

Again, no examples. Find a single instance of bad science.
 
Last edited:
Endless links to science were given. They were ignored. More unsubstantiated claims were made, posters demanded substantiation.

It is not "bullying" to demand that claims be supported.
Who is "we?"

As an American I can tell you that we aren't remotely close to doing everything we can. In the first place, we could stop the direct subsidies of oil companies that cut the cost of gasoline at the pump in half. We could tax emission, do a cap-and-trade system, invest the money we spend supporting oil companies on alternative energy sources, invest in better energy delivery systems (about 60% of energy is just lost in the transmission process), develop building codes that require more efficient structures...etc.

There are a million things we could be doing that we aren't. The first step is ending the massive flow of tax-payer dollars to activities destructive to the environment.

Is this what happened after the 1989 Montreal Protocols banned the use of ozone depleting aerosols?

Sure, and you know what would make that easier? Instead of paying oil companies to make the cost of gas look cheaper than it is, we could use subsidies to help people make their houses more energy efficient.

Think of all the people that would be able to find employment helping that switch-over. It should be done now.

Again, no examples. Find a single instance of bad science.

So you think the NA economy could sustain a doubling at the pump? I don't. I've seen people saying this economic crisis was a result of the increase in the price of gas. The increase always seems to lead the slowing of the economy. I'm not sure I'm buying that as a reasonable method of reducing CO2, although EV's should offset that to some degree. I think as they hit the market "gasoline" prices should start to soar. It's not so much "gas" prices as it is "fuel" prices. If you could seperate the two in your argument I could follow it easier.

As for the rest of your post TW, I'm not getting drawn into a bunch of bickering over who said what to who and why. Let's just stick to exchanges like your last post and mine above, they are so much more constructive. I got warned to be "civil and polite" and I intend to do that. :)
 
Anyone that can't see how I'm being skeptical and calling me a denier is probably an alarmist. The ones who misrepresent my words, attribute positions to me that I don't hold are alarmists.
I thought an alarmist was someone who made predictions of catastrophe they couldn't back up with credible evidence. Hence the request for you to quote examples of the people you consider alarmists doing just that.

If the definition of alarmist is "someone who misrepresents my position" then it would be a different set of people for each poster. My own list of alarmists would consist entirely of deniers.

ETA: http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/alarmist

–noun
1.a person who tends to raise alarms, esp. without sufficient reason, as by exaggerating dangers or prophesying calamities

n. A person who needlessly alarms or attempts to alarm others, as by inventing or spreading false or exaggerated rumors of impending danger or catastrophe.
 
Last edited:
Anyone that can't see how I'm being skeptical and calling me a denier is probably an alarmist. The ones who misrepresent my words, attribute positions to me that I don't hold are alarmists. It's obvious they don't want to have a discussio, they want to force their agenda on people.

The agenda tends to be labelling skeptics as "deniers" and trying to discredit them, or call into question their education. They want other to believe you have to be a genius to understand AGW, and and position other than full accepting of AGW in all it's forms is an artifact of their poor mental faculties.

They want to bully people into accepting AGW.

And I know why, because when you take a rational look at it we are essentially doing what we can to curb emissions. Beyond what we are doing it's going to require going on blind faith believeing what the politicians come up with will result in a noticeable positive effect on the climate., because the science just isn't there yet to actually measure its success.

So we are going to end up with a bunch of politicians making money, no actual measured effect on the climate and the scientists saying "yah well we told you we weren't there yet" when people demand some accountability.

I say It's a bunch of crap until we can get some accountability, and we need the science to do that.

YOU can do your own part to make change. You can get an EV and insolate your home and get better windows and recycle and all that fun stuff that saves you money and helps the environment until the science is better and we can start to know what effect we will have. And there need to be more serious talks with the world nations about what they can do to reduce emissions.

So maybe I'm more skeptical of the people than anything. They don't appear to be rational. Take a look at the numer of posts and threads moderated or in AAH. Is that the work of rational minds? I don't think so.

Why can't you ever answer a question or provide a source for any of your many wild claims? If you can't answer my questions, at least try to answer someone else's. Right now, your argument doesn't make any sense, and you seem to be skipping from one talking point to another without any coherence whatsoever.
 
As for the rest of your post TW, I'm not getting drawn into a bunch of bickering over who said what to who and why. Let's just stick to exchanges like your last post and mine above, they are so much more constructive. I got warned to be "civil and polite" and I intend to do that. :)

If the only way you are able to stay civil and polite is to ignore all questions posed to you and never cite any sources to back up your claims, you should probably rethink your argument and the way you're arguing. Right now you're not contributing to the discussion, and your posts can be argued to be proselytizing.
 
As you've called several of us alarmists, could you list which ones of us fall into this category?

TBH the only alarmism I've seen in this thread is when 3bp says the world will fall apart if we reduce our carbon emissions
 
So you think the NA economy could sustain a doubling at the pump? I don't. I've seen people saying this economic crisis was a result of the increase in the price of gas. The increase always seems to lead the slowing of the economy. I'm not sure I'm buying that as a reasonable method of reducing CO2, although EV's should offset that to some degree. I think as they hit the market "gasoline" prices should start to soar. It's not so much "gas" prices as it is "fuel" prices. If you could seperate the two in your argument I could follow it easier.

You're missing the point. We already pay for that doubling (actually, it was 15-1 in 1998: www.icta.org/doc/Real Price of Gasoline.pdf). It's just hidden from the consumer.

Yes, we could take that money away from subsidizing the price of gasoline and apply it to cleaner sources of energy. This would create a market incentive to innovate through non-carbon based energy.

The argument is not complicated: insteaded of investing tax dollars to hide the real price of gas from consumers, invest tax dollrs to make altenative energy sources (be it nuclear, wind or solar) more competitive on the market. We're already spending the money, so the argument that the economy can't handle it is specious.

As for the rest of your post TW, I'm not getting drawn into a bunch of bickering over who said what to who and why. Let's just stick to exchanges like your last post and mine above, they are so much more constructive. I got warned to be "civil and polite" and I intend to do that. :)

Displaying examples of bad scientific reasoning is not a personal attack. You're welcome, for example, to cite any point at which I linked to or described a scientific principle or argument that was wrong. I will not be offended. Hell, you can call me an ******* and I won't be offended, but the moderators don't like that sort of thing.
 
Last edited:
So you think the NA economy could sustain a doubling at the pump?


I think it could. some places would do better then others, but hey that's the free market for you. Should the places that build their towns/countries around unsustainable use of fossil fuels fail, well that's the discipline of the market.
 
I think it could. some places would do better then others, but hey that's the free market for you. Should the places that build their towns/countries around unsustainable use of fossil fuels fail, well that's the discipline of the market.

Well I typed up a whole scenario for TW and it got deleted on accident but here goes.

Say the US government outlawed cars over 5 years old and less than 30 mpg. Then gave every one a US Auto "Patriot" edition EV. What effect would it have on CO2? Surprisingly little I'm afraid.

The trains, planes, locos and big rigs use something like75% of the fossil fuel. So at best we could chip away at the 25% personal and recreational vehicles. Of that a good portion is the car, say 20%.

Now that 20% is gone, but now replaced by electric, the electricity is still going to have some carbon content, because the immediate need for electricity would hopefully be met by combined cycle cogen. There's no way the NIMBY's and Greenpeace are going to allow you to build nukes.

So of that 20% reduction you're looking at say a 10% maybe 15% reduction on CO2 at best. That's jut a drop in the bucket. I don't have any idea what effect it would have on the climate, but it certainly could make gas cheaper for China and India. They bump up their appetite for cars and gasoline just a bit, and all that you got rid of in the US just gets put into the sky over New Delhi and Hong Kong.

So maybe keeping gas usage high is actually keeping less of it being used? Because we know there are potential customers for the gasoline and the only thing I see stopping then from acquiring it is making it a luxury item. Something to consider.

Bill Clinton missed the boat when he had an opportunity a decade ago to increase the taxes on gasoline, where was Al Gore then?
 
Well I typed up a whole scenario for TW and it got deleted on accident but here goes.

Say the US government outlawed cars over 5 years old and less than 30 mpg. Then gave every one a US Auto "Patriot" edition EV. What effect would it have on CO2? Surprisingly little I'm afraid.

The trains, planes, locos and big rigs use something like75% of the fossil fuel. So at best we could chip away at the 25% personal and recreational vehicles. Of that a good portion is the car, say 20%.

Now that 20% is gone, but now replaced by electric, the electricity is still going to have some carbon content, because the immediate need for electricity would hopefully be met by combined cycle cogen. There's no way the NIMBY's and Greenpeace are going to allow you to build nukes.

So of that 20% reduction you're looking at say a 10% maybe 15% reduction on CO2 at best. That's jut a drop in the bucket. I don't have any idea what effect it would have on the climate, but it certainly could make gas cheaper for China and India. They bump up their appetite for cars and gasoline just a bit, and all that you got rid of in the US just gets put into the sky over New Delhi and Hong Kong.

So maybe keeping gas usage high is actually keeping less of it being used? Because we know there are potential customers for the gasoline and the only thing I see stopping then from acquiring it is making it a luxury item. Something to consider.

Bill Clinton missed the boat when he had an opportunity a decade ago to increase the taxes on gasoline, where was Al Gore then?

Well, why did Sweden and Norway manage to limit their CO2 emissions and put a plan in place for complete carbon neutrality by 2050? I mean, if we're discussing percentages, there's no reason why a large nation should have bigger trouble than a small one? What's the difference?
 
It appears that many of you are unable to keep this civil. If you wish to discuss this topic further, please do so in the Moderated Thread. Do not start another topic on this subject in order to get around moderated status.

Thread closed.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Tricky
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom