Climate change scepticism - its sources and origins

Status
Not open for further replies.

bit_pattern

Unregistered
Joined
Apr 22, 2010
Messages
7,406
An illuminating piece from the Science Show on ABC Radio. Read the transcript or listen to the audio:

http://www.abc.net.au/rn/scienceshow/stories/2010/2859986.htm#transcript

This week The Science Show presents excerpts from a symposium at the recent American Association for the Advancement of Science meeting in San Diego which looks at the sources and strategies of scepticism to climate change science. While the science supporting anthropogenic climate change becomes stronger and more consensual, it still remains highly controversial. This symposium addresses the contributors to this anomaly, and the success of contrarian scientists and others in promoting climate change scepticism throughout society.
 
Just finished listening to it and have gotta say, the Steve Schneider presentation is priceless, I can't recommend it enough.
 
Very interesting. It's good to know that the scientists are not only aware of the gap between scientific understanding of climate change and public understanding thereof, but that they are also thinking about how to combat the problem.

Although it feels dirty, I'd say that the best option is to just copy the denialist tactics (well, the legal ones anyway) and start a media campaign. Nifty sound-bytes and pictures, but not of polar bears and crying children, but of what the denialists are lying about. Get the word out there that they are lying. Normal people don't like liars.
 
Huh...and here I would have thought the best tactic for scientists would be to be utterly and completely transparent in everything they do?

Mailman
 
Huh...and here I would have thought the best tactic for scientists would be to be utterly and completely transparent in everything they do?

Mailman
A great idea, but those denying the reality of climate change lie and decieve so much that it would be drowned out in the morass of lies, edited soundbites, half truths and strawmen.
 
MM
Huh...and here I would have thought the best tactic for scientists would be to be utterly and completely transparent in everything they do?

They are and have been for 15 years - just because you're behind the curve does not mean others are.

Even the fossil fuel company scientists knew it and acknowledged it to management in 1995 and this pretty much sums it up....

Here is what Gammon had to say concerning links between humans and climate change.

This is like asking, ‘Is the moon round?’ or ‘Does smoking cause cancer?’ We’re at a point now where there is no responsible position stating that humans are not responsible for climate change. That is just not where the science is.…For a long time, for at least five years and probably 10 years, the international scientific community has been very clear.”

In case there is any doubt, Gammon went on:
This is not the balance-of-evidence argument for a civil lawsuit; this is the criminal standard, beyond a reasonable doubt We’ve been there for a long time and I think the media has really not presented that to the public.”

Dr. Richard H. Gammon
Professor of Chemistry and Oceanography*
Adjunct Professor Atmospheric Sciences, University of Washington

[/QUOTE]

You might as well question evolution at this point in the knowledge curve. But there are cranks on that as well.

All that is left on the denier side is manufactured controversy by many of the same crowd that tried to create doubt on cigarette smoking and cancer.

Denial of human induced climate change verges on pathetic at this point in time and puts you in with anti-evos ( many of the same clowns - funny that ).

There are many extremely difficult choices ahead and things to learn.

How to address the changes.

How to blunt the impacts.

How to shift our society to carbon neutral and how rapidly we need to undertake that.

How fast the impacts will arrive ( those that are not already in play ).

Where the impacts will be felt worst.

What is NOT in question is
a) it's getting warmer
b) we're primarily responsible due to use of fossil fuels.


other than in the minds of a few cranks.
Are you counted amongst them? :garfield:
 
Huh...and here I would have thought the best tactic for scientists would be to be utterly and completely transparent in everything they do?

Mailman

Yeah - and politicians and mailmen, too!! :rolleyes:
 
Huh...and here I would have thought the best tactic for scientists would be to be utterly and completely transparent in everything they do?

Mailman

Here you use the tactic of implying that the science isn't open, without making a direct accusation. This is a line that McIntyre identified early on and has made himself a guru for denialists on the back of it.

The institutions of science (such as paid-for journals and proprietary data) were never designed for the onslaught of slander and innuendo that AGW has provoked. (Not even the tobacco lobby was so monstrous, although they did develop the techniques.) They are better prepared for any repeat performance.

The accusation that something is being hidden from us can never be refuted because, after all, it's being hidden.
 
To be fair, Inhofe is quite openly an idiot. And let's not forget lawyers (Cuccinelli naturally comes to mind).

picture.php
 
Here you use the tactic of implying that the science isn't open, without making a direct accusation. This is a line that McIntyre identified early on and has made himself a guru for denialists on the back of it.

Really...so people like Jones and Biffa et al have been completely up front, open and transparent about everything they have done?

That seems odd...even the various white wash enquiries held here in the UK pointed out that Jones HAD not been completely transparent with making his data available for review etc. And lets not forget the scientists themselves "conspiring" to keep data out of the hands of those who would pull their work apart, which only became apparent once the seedy underworld of climate science was exposed in those "stolen"* emails released from CRU.

The truth is, those heavily invested in climate science have been anything but open and transparent about the data they have used to create Mann Made Global Warming (tm).

The institutions of science (such as paid-for journals and proprietary data) were never designed for the onslaught of slander and innuendo that AGW has provoked.

Hmmm...this is interesting really. Especially when you look at the "outrage" my initial comment created in this thread.

But lets be honest here for a second. All of todays problems with the transparency of the science that has gone in to Mann Made Global Warming (tm) could have, and SHOULD have, been avoided with people like Jones being completely transparent in everything they have done.

you release a paper on X,Y,Z...then you release the data you based that paper on. really, its not rocket science here.

If people like McIntyre are going to pull your work apart like a rag doll then isnt that a good thing? If flaws are highlighted in your work and then you come back, review your work and release an improved "paper", then how can that be wrong?

They are better prepared for any repeat performance.
What, are those invested in Mann Made Global Warming (tm) now going to release their data so that their work can be checked and verified and experiments repeated etc?

The accusation that something is being hidden from us can never be refuted because, after all, it's being hidden.
Because that is EXACTLY what has gone on in climate science. Those scientists who are so heavily invested in Mann Made Global Warming have been for years with holding their data back or, as is the case with CRU, purposely ignored FOI requests so that their work could not be truly independently checked and verified.

In fact, it wasnt until one of those lofty scientific journals actually enforced their data archiving policy that McIntyre finally got to see the science...or lack thereof, behind Biffa's work.

Surely we all want the same thing here? For the science behind Mann Made Global Warming (tm) to be correct?

Mailman

*BTW, I use the term "stolen" in tongue and cheek...just in case some of the big brains that inhabit this thread cant work that out :D
 
Last edited:
Ever heard of the term peer? :rolleyes:

You are trumpeting a failed meme.

The fossil companies themselves know the score, knew it for 15 years.
Where have you been??

Why are you not stamping and complaining about them hiding the findings of their own scientists.....

Gets in the way of your agenda eh?

Industry Ignored Its Scientists on Climate

By ANDREW C. REVKIN
Published: April 23, 2009

snip

“The scientific basis for the Greenhouse Effect and the potential impact of human emissions of greenhouse gases such as CO2 on climate is well established and cannot be denied,” the experts wrote in an internal report compiled for the coalition in 1995.

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/04/24/science/earth/24deny.html

Now how about applying your misplaced skepticism to the schemes about solving the problem instead of beating the dead horse of denial of human induced climate change. :garfield:
 
Ever heard of the term peer? :rolleyes:
Yes, and how did that turn out for the IPCC? :D

Of course...peer review, how silly of me. Oh hang on...thats right, another inconvenience for you with Mann et al conspiring to use the peer review process to keep papers counter to their "religion"...oh sorry, "science" out of IPCC and scientific literature.


The fossil companies themselves know the score, knew it for 15 years.
Irrelevant to this discussion (although I suspect you will now go in to over drive to distract this thread from questioning the science behind Mann Made Global Warming?:D ).

Gets in the way of your agenda eh?
Hands up...you have found me out :D

So, btw, did you purposely ignore my question or what?

Do you want the science behind Mann Made Global Warming (tm) to be correct...yes or no?

Mailman
 
What I wonder is how much money gets paid to people who seem to troll the Internet 24/7 JAQing and insinuating about AGW and trashing the reputations of scientists. I would be amazed at this point if there was not some actual money changing hands.
 
Oh hang on...thats right, another inconvenience for you with Mann et al conspiring to use the peer review process to keep papers counter to their "religion"...oh sorry, "science" out of IPCC and scientific literature.

IOW Peer reviewed science is one giant conspiricy!

:dl:
 
What I wonder is how much money gets paid to people who seem to troll the Internet 24/7 JAQing and insinuating about AGW and trashing the reputations of scientists. I would be amazed at this point if there was not some actual money changing hands.

I think you underestimate some people's devotion to their political agendas combined with the false sense of superiority that being contrarian can bring.
 
From the original link

Stephen Schneider: So we're going to talk about the issue of scepticism. I'm going to start right out now; what's the difference between scepticism and denial? There's no such thing as a good scientist who isn't a sceptic. I changed my opinion in 1970 from cooling to warming, published it first, it's one of my proudest moments in science because we found, as the evidence accumulated, that there were a number of reasons, it's all explained in chapter one of Science as a Contact Sport, and I still have to hear things from those famous climate professors, the ones that publish all the papers in the referee journals, professors Limbaugh and Will, you know, about how... 'Oh Schneider, he's just an environmentalist for all temperatures', it's a great line!

A perfect example of my thesis of Science as schizophrenic search for an underlying metanarrative.

Notice how the scientist here instinctively shrinks away from embracing complexity and having to reduce everything to a Manichaeism lens of cooling vs warming.

Also an implicit desire of regression to infancy: a belief that the childhood of the scientist represented an unchanging golden age of climate which the hormonal surges of puberty (here beautifully represented by the temptations of consumption and the play on words of (CO2) emissions) threatens to rend asunder.

In fact, there is no zero point of climate, no ideal to return to, all was always flux. The point of flux that is now, is no better or worse than the point of flux that was 1900 AD or 1900 BC. And what from the child's eye was a period of stability and shelter was for the adults living through it a society riven by uncontrollable seismic forces.

Perhaps all Climate Scientists need is a good therapist?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom