Here you use the tactic of implying that the science isn't open, without making a direct accusation. This is a line that McIntyre identified early on and has made himself a guru for denialists on the back of it.
Really...so people like Jones and Biffa et al have been completely up front, open and transparent about everything they have done?
That seems odd...even the various white wash enquiries held here in the UK pointed out that Jones HAD not been completely transparent with making his data available for review etc. And lets not forget the scientists themselves "conspiring" to keep data out of the hands of those who would pull their work apart, which only became apparent once the seedy underworld of climate science was exposed in those "stolen"* emails released from CRU.
The truth is, those heavily invested in climate science have been anything but open and transparent about the data they have used to create Mann Made Global Warming (tm).
The institutions of science (such as paid-for journals and proprietary data) were never designed for the onslaught of slander and innuendo that AGW has provoked.
Hmmm...this is interesting really. Especially when you look at the "outrage" my initial comment created in this thread.
But lets be honest here for a second. All of todays problems with the transparency of the science that has gone in to Mann Made Global Warming (tm) could have, and SHOULD have, been avoided with people like Jones being completely transparent in everything they have done.
you release a paper on X,Y,Z...then you release the data you based that paper on. really, its not rocket science here.
If people like McIntyre are going to pull your work apart like a rag doll then isnt that a good thing? If flaws are highlighted in your work and then you come back, review your work and release an improved "paper", then how can that be wrong?
They are better prepared for any repeat performance.
What, are those invested in Mann Made Global Warming (tm) now going to release their data so that their work can be checked and verified and experiments repeated etc?
The accusation that something is being hidden from us can never be refuted because, after all, it's being hidden.
Because that is EXACTLY what has gone on in climate science. Those scientists who are so heavily invested in Mann Made Global Warming have been for years with holding their data back or, as is the case with CRU, purposely ignored FOI requests so that their work could not be truly independently checked and verified.
In fact, it wasnt until one of those lofty scientific journals actually enforced their data archiving policy that McIntyre finally got to see the science...or lack thereof, behind Biffa's work.
Surely we all want the same thing here? For the science behind Mann Made Global Warming (tm) to be correct?
Mailman
*BTW, I use the term "stolen" in tongue and cheek...just in case some of the big brains that inhabit this thread cant work that out
