Climate change scepticism - its sources and origins

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yeah, I know. Curiosity got the better of me, and I just had to reply with a quote. Won't happen again... maybe. ;)

Anyway, here's a good article that has already been posted, but bears repeating.

Living in denial: Why sensible people reject the truth

It's rather scathing in places, including passages like this:







The article is well sourced, and links the different denialist movements rather well. It's worth a read.
It most certainly is worth a read (be sure to read the first few articles it provides a link to too), many thanks! :)

As I read it several of the popular crackpot cults (for want of a better word) that I am familiar with* sprang to mind ... so many similarities!

The one I was most impressed with is the "innumerates"; overwhelmingly the popular woo I encounter* is devoid of math, and even numbers (and some promoters of this woo are even explicitly proud of the fact that they can't 'do the numbers').

* in the fields of astronomy, astrophysics, and cosmology
 
You're not a skeptic - you are just ignorant of climate science - don't hide your ignorance behind skepticism as if it's some boyscout badge. :rolleyes:

Always the name calling! :D

You've demonstrated time and again you fail to understand the most basic principles of geo-physical systems yet claim some sort of "special knowledge" that lets you diss the climate science community - even that of the fossil fuel companies own scientists

I think Ive already asked for this a number of times...but where is all this "subtle PR" coming from? So far no one has offered up any evidence that any evil group is corrupting climate science to counter what those who believe in Mann Made Global Warming (tm)?

you would think that if there was so much evidence out there of this PR that it would be quite easy to provide (Im talking about actual evidence...not screeds of links to talking heads who merely agree with your position lads :D).

....how unarguably stupid can that claim be in the face of overwhelming evidence...

Over whelming evidence? :D

Sorta like how spring is supposedly 11 days earlier now...even though exhibitors at this years Chelsea Flower show have had to move their flowers in to glass houses cause spring hasnt actually arrived early...or that the northern hemisphere being covered in snow is now proof of Mann Made Global Warming (even though no one has pointed out where exactly it was warmer this past winter).

Yes...over whelming science indeed :D

Mailman
 
He has provided nothing more than links to others who agree with him...not actual proof that backs his arguments up.

As an example, Uke wanted proof that CRU had broken the laws in relation to FOI, which I provided him with a link to the BBC which discussed the FOI request and the ruling passed down (stating that I provieded the BBC link because the BBC is squarely on the side of Mann Made Global Warming (tm) so that he COULDNT accuse me of bias) and included a link to the FOI ruling itself.

Whereas had I provided a link from wattsupwiththat or climateaudit he would have dismissed that out of hand.

So the challenge is there, provide the proof or accept your belief in Mann Made Global Warming (tm) is nothing but woo! :D

Mailman
 
All models are incomplete and need more research.

Research is ongoing to fit the fossil record into the model that is evolution. By your logic this means evolution is suspect and anyone with alternate ideas are engaging in legitimate skepticism.

You are in fact highlighting the most common denier meme. Deniers always claim “science is proof therefore any crackpot idea that goes against mainstream science is legitimate skepticism”.

No, I'm reiterating the scientists concerns that the models are incomplete. We also know that the climate has returned from greater extremes than present now due to natural negative feedbacks. We haven't begun to establish what these feedbacks may be.

The increase in CO2 concentration has had a surprisingly small effect to date. Whether or not this is a result of lag in the system remains to be seen.
 
The deniers have an ideological viewpoint that will not let them acknowledge the science
The problem here isnt ideoligucal like it is with the lefts need to believe in Mann Made Global Warming (tm). No, the real problem here is the more we get to look in to the bubble that is climate science...the dodgier that science looks. YET, people want to bankrupt Western economies on the advice of this science?

Lets not forget that it was climate science that claimed 98 was the hottest year evah in the history of the planet in Amerikkka BUT it was a mere statistician that pointed out problems with that claim...which lead to that claim be rescinded.

Yet had it not been for this unqualified statistiacian pointed out a basic error, this myth would still be with us.

And then lets not forget the contribution to climate science made by a mere weather man, who had the tamerity to point out that readings by weather stations around the US cant be trusted because of changes around those same weather stations.

And then there are claims made in the IPCC that the Himalaya's will be a med like tropical paradise and all those reports by NGO's that feed in to the IPCC...because they all cant have politically motived agenda's can they?

Every one of these threads eventually degrades into name calling and then fizzles out. Oh well, I guess we'll chalk it up to the SIWOTI syndrome. It does kinda make for good theatre, in a 'go get the popcorn' sort of way...
I think you will find that 11 times out of 5 that the name calling comes from those who are ideoligically committed to Mann Made Global Warming (tm).

You want to prove your science, then be transparent about how you go about that so called science and release your data instead of trying to hide it from sceptics who have the front to question your beliefs! :D

Mailman
 
Last edited:
What? I don't think you understood what I wrote. Maybe you should go ask your workmates. Maybe they could help you understand.

It is also amusing that you chose to take one part of a long post and respond to only just that, and even then you failed to understand what you were responding to. I'm glad the denialist movement is made up of your kind of people.

Because once I got to your contradictory statement I fell on the floor laughing.

Works over, everyone is back to their respective plants. I'm sure the anecdotes will entertain power plant lunch rooms across the US.
 
Correct. The fact that the US government payees the scientists that work for it is very normal. Money that comes from special interest group trying to promote a political agenda is suspect is suspect.

Can you please explain to us what you there is something wrong with this?

It's also worth pointing out that a great deal of excellent climate science was produced with government funding between January 2001 and January 2009.

I believe we can all remember who was in charge of the government at that time. If that federal funding contorted the conclusions of the research it supported, why did all that work support the thesis of AGW? It's fairly obvious what conclusions the Bush administration would have preferred that they reach...
 
Is it OK, within the bounds of the JREF rules, to apply the test/guidelines/criteria in the link uke2se provided to the posts of selected JREF members? Only those within this SMMT section, of course.

And if not individually, then how about collectively, and anonomously?

I think the results would be very interesting! :)
 
I think we're just doing it "for the lurkers". I think most of us understand that 3body, mailman, mhaze and alfie aren't going to change their minds regardless of the evidence, so we do our best to just point out their lies in order to make sure any newcomers to the debate realize that this isn't a scientific debate, but rather a question of science versus anti-science.

Fair point. In that case, here is an excellent resource that anthropogenic climate change fence sitters should read:

Spencer Weart's The Discovery of Global Warming - A History

It's long, but it is an excellent layperson's guide to how the scientists converged on the AGW problem. I'm sure you folks have already pointed people at this page, but it bears repeating.

It also bears repeating that even the prominent deniers like McIntyre are indirectly funded through right wing think tanks like the George C. Marshall Institute and Heartland Institute. These in turn receive funding from big oil and coal. Follow the money. These mega corporations have hundreds of billions at stake in maintaining the status quo: burning whatever we can dig out of the ground. They don't give a **** what happens to the environment as a result. Pro tip: it ain't the scientists driving around in Ferraris.

Edited by LashL: 
Edited for Rule 10 re: autocensor.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
You should start a poll to discover which way the "lurkers" are being swayed by threads like this one.

As I see it, the pro-AGW posters here couldn't sell dollar bills for 50 cents.

ymmv.

Mmm, substance.

What, exactly, would you like? You can look at the other recent global warming threads and notice that literally hundreds of links to scientific research have been provided.

There has yet to be a single link to substantive science provided by the deniers. Just unhinged babbling based on their misunderstanding of basic principles.

How should this go? Here's a link to a site with endless resources, citations, and explanations:

http://www.realclimate.org/

The deniers will respond with false, debunked complaints about the scientists who run the site and never deal with any of the arguments contained therein. What else can be done to move forward?
 
Yeah, it's ideology again. We see this in opposition to science.

Right vs. Evolution
Right vs. AGW
Right vs. Alternative Energy
Right vs. Distributing condoms in Africa
Left vs. Nuclear Energy
Left vs. Sane regulation of "alternative medicine"

And nothing can shake knuckleheads who have decided something is correct and that all opposition to that opinion is part of some vast conspiracy to suppress them. They think that only they know the Truth and that some day they will be acknowledged as Saviors Of The World.
If you read the link in uke2se's post, you'll see some suggestions for effective methods of addressing this.

Interestingly, many of the responses of "numerates" are ineffective, which is quite counter-intuitive to those numerates (and some of the effective approaches are equally counter-intuitive, to numerates).

There's clearly a psychological component, but equally there's a - possibly unbridgable - gulf ... "numerates" and "innumerates" have such different worldviews (and, perhaps, it is extraordinarily difficult for an adult "innumerate" to become a "numerate", no matter how much they want to).

Just a thought.
 
Each time such sanctimony is expressed it's worth remmbering that 3body's denialism is based on a comical misundestanding of clouds.

Yes, clouds, the deus ex machina of this forum's deniers.

And when endless links were provided from NASA, published papers, and experts, they were ignored.

Deniers use the word "science" like little blue creatures use the word "Smurf." It is interjected whenever they run out of things to say, which is often, and it carries no meaning save for the intentionality of the speaker. In that regard it's almost tautological: "Warmers don't understand "science," ie, the nutty stuff I believe with no factual support."

Here read: http://www.climatescience.gov/Library/sap/sap3-1/final-report/sap3-1-final-all.pdf

When you understand feel free to try and discuss what you've read. What's the best model? What's your favourite model? What limitations are there in your favourite model?
 
So I guess I should write to Randi about the bet? Can you show me the links that is supposed to show that you are correct?



You really are special. You manage to ignore everything that contradicts your theories but jump on two completely irrelevant sources that definitely don't agree with your theories (that convection is caused by evaporation).

Macdoc is correct, you are not a sceptic or denier but just clueless about the subject and it also seems scientific discourse in general.

So why don't you give any relevant sources, take the bet or just shut up?

From MIT:
The heat lost by evaporation is carried deep into the atmosphere by convection

You don't seem to be able to follow the science here fred. You seem to think this heat lost by evaporation is carried by the air, and not the water vapour. You fail miserably at understanding thermodynamics.

fyi-gambling is illegal fred.
 
Here read: http://www.climatescience.gov/Library/sap/sap3-1/final-report/sap3-1-final-all.pdf

When you understand feel free to try and discuss what you've read. What's the best model? What's your favourite model? What limitations are there in your favourite model?

Do you have a point?

I assume we're headed to a "climate models contain uncertainty" argument. No duh. You'll notice that PDF discusses long-term persistence and natural variability. If you want to argue that any factor is sufficient to defeat the climate models, you need to prove the strength of the variable to be great enough to do so. LTP failed because of this, and right now you've offered no evidence to believe that any other factor is more capable.
 
Last edited:
Do you have a point?

I assume we're headed to a "climate models contain uncertainty" argument. No duh. You'll notice that PDF discusses long-term persistence and natural variability. If you want to argue that any factor is sufficient to defeat the climate models, you need to prove the strength of the variable to be great enough to do so. LTP failed because of this, and right now you've offered no evidence to believe that any other factor is more capable.

It won't be much longer before the models approach a certainty and validate long term predictions. Until then it would be foolish to go beyond what's already being done to curtail emissions. They make that clear in this paper.
 
It won't be much longer before the models approach a certainty and validate long term predictions. Until then it would be foolish to go beyond what's already being done to curtail emissions. They make that clear in this paper.

It certainly doesn't make that "clear." That argument does not appear at all in the executive summary, nor, as far as I can tell, at any point in the paper. Admittedly I skimmed some deal of it given that it is 135 pages long. Is there a section you want to quote or somehow direct us to the relevant point?

Here's the only thing I found that relates in any way to curtailing emissions (pg. 11):

Our understanding of climate is still insufficient to justify proclaiming any one model “best” or even showing metrics of model performance that imply skill in predicting the future. More appropriate in any assessments focusing on adaptation or mitigation strategies is to take into account, in a pertinently informed manner, the products of distinct models built using different expert judgments at centers around the world.

That doesn't say "it would be foolish to go beyond what's already being done to curtail emissions." It says that individual models cannot be relied upon, so their components should be broken down and studied.

Given that there's a whole chapter (7) dedicated to the application of models to climate catastrophes, that study hardly supports the claim you made.

But again, I didn't read every word, so please, direct me to the relevant section.
 
Last edited:
We also know that the climate has returned from greater extremes than present now due to natural negative feedbacks.

You have no idea what you are talking about.

Negative Feedback – reduces the amount of change in a system when a forcing is applied

Positive Feedback – increases the amount of change in a system when a forcing is applied

IOW Negative feedback prevents the climate from changing, you need positive feedback to “bring climate back from the extremes”

The increase in CO2 concentration has had a surprisingly small effect to date..


The planet has warmed by more then 1 deg C in the last 100 years and about 75% of that is due to greenhouse gasses. This is the most rapid climate change seen since the end of the last ice age. How is this “small”?
 
What's the best model?
The paper you quote say there is no "best model" - yet you expect people to pick one
:dl:
That is just about par for the course with you.

How about answering the question put to you numerous times before you bailed out of the moderated thread.

Is the sun closer to the earth in summer or winter?


•••

In the meantime you can provide us with the relevant material

Until then it would be foolish to go beyond what's already being done to curtail emissions. They make that clear in this paper.

that supports this bit of nonsense.
:popcorn1
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom