Climate change scepticism - its sources and origins

Status
Not open for further replies.
How is it "peeing in the ocean"?

OK, so you accept that CO2 has radiative forcing qualities, no? You accept that it is largely responsible for trapping heat in the atmosphere and keeping us from being the temperature of Mars, no? OK, so how is raising levels by 40%, and potentially doubling them by the end of the century, "peeing in the ocean"? That's like saying increasing the socium in your body by 40-100% is peeing in the ocean because sodium only makes up a fraction of your overall body mass. That's *********** retarded and you know it.

As for mitigation, yeah, carbon trading is kinda sh*tty, you'll find that some of the giants in the climate science community (Dr. Hansen for one) are dead against it. But do you have a better solution? It's always going to be cheaper to burn coal than to invest in renewables or even nuclear, how do you propose we send signals to the market that investing in renewables is going to be a smart and profitable venture when there are cheaper means of generating energy?

Not the addition, the reduction. It's going up before it goes down. And Asia is huge! I don't see them being on board with crippling their economies to save the planet just yet.

As for the latter I'm just not sure. Make it uncool?
 
That's why I'm interested in the model predictions. I'm not certain the effects of a radical transformation in our CO2 output will have the effect some people think it will have. A pee in the ocean as the saying goes. If we put all that money into expensive renewables and it gets concentrated into the elite carbon brokers without doing much of anything then where are we? Because we know without massive government intervention that's bound to happen. Even with it. And that's not denial, that's being realistic. I'd prefer to see what's being done if that's in any way possible. I've already read about carbon credits and funny business.

My question, once again: Who should be convinced about the effects of mitigating CO2? Is it really necessary for YOU to be convinced (understand) that the science is fairly solid as it stands, and as more research is done, predictions get more dire? Why do you feel that the world needs to wait for YOU and people like you before we act? At risk of being presumptuous, you aren't a climatologist, nor a scientist of any kind. You don't understand climate like a climatologist does. Yet you presume to argue that the climate scientists' understanding of climate is too poor to act on the information they give us?

This kind of extreme arrogance really gets to me, and I see it in denialism all the time. It gets to me even more knowing that some nations in this world aren't so caught up in internal politicking that they foster that kind of arrogance. Sure, there are denialists in Sweden as well, but they are found only in fringe groups and among crack-pots. Some people in the world are doing their part already. Who are you to say that they are acting prematurely when they are only following the advice science gives - science that has let humans emerge as the dominant species on this planet?

In short: why don't YOU trust science as a method of learning about the universe around us, and why do YOU feel that anyone should give your mistrusting opinion equal value when our civilization is on the line?
 
My question, once again: Who should be convinced about the effects of mitigating CO2? Is it really necessary for YOU to be convinced (understand) that the science is fairly solid as it stands, and as more research is done, predictions get more dire? Why do you feel that the world needs to wait for YOU and people like you before we act? At risk of being presumptuous, you aren't a climatologist, nor a scientist of any kind. You don't understand climate like a climatologist does. Yet you presume to argue that the climate scientists' understanding of climate is too poor to act on the information they give us?

This kind of extreme arrogance really gets to me, and I see it in denialism all the time. It gets to me even more knowing that some nations in this world aren't so caught up in internal politicking that they foster that kind of arrogance. Sure, there are denialists in Sweden as well, but they are found only in fringe groups and among crack-pots. Some people in the world are doing their part already. Who are you to say that they are acting prematurely when they are only following the advice science gives - science that has let humans emerge as the dominant species on this planet?

In short: why don't YOU trust science as a method of learning about the universe around us, and why do YOU feel that anyone should give your mistrusting opinion equal value when our civilization is on the line?

No, I'm not a professional scientist. I don't presume to know more than people engaged in the study of climatology.

I do however represent a portion of the population trained in the fundamentals of climate science and heavily invested my time and energy in the pursuit of producing power for human use. I'd say there are possibly 5% of the population in a better position than myself to lead the way. I've positioned myself to be in the business of running, buying and selling power plants within the next 10 years. With an MBA I could probably achieve this sooner, but that would take another 2 years of University.

I realize to you I am just another kitty kat picture on a forum in cyber space. You're just a talking fish.

I think we need to get over this however and try to discuss this with one another with some respect. Otherwise the entire exchange is flawed and based on the premise that everything we say is meaningless and we're both idiots.

Let's try assuming we have the power to make change and influence people, and that will influence more people and we can achieve something meaningful in the process.

I mean you never know right?
 
It seems you are prepared to bet the economies of the western world on soemthing as yet unproven?

Which is why I have asked time and time again, arent we all interested in making sure the science behind Mann Made Global Warming is correct. If we are going to bet our childrens prosperity on this, then lets get it right!

Dont you agree?

Mailman

This is nonsense. No one is "betting the economies of the Western World."

If we spent half the money and a third of the manpower we spent in Iraq, the United States could be carbon neutral in 20 years.

And the science is correct. You haven't offered a single reason to think otherwise. Just tired, long debunked nonsense.
 
No, I'm not a professional scientist. I don't presume to know more than people engaged in the study of climatology.

You have quite literally spent 30 pages presuming just that. Every time you're given the work of actual climate scientists you either ignore or comedically misrepresent their work.

I think we need to get over this however and try to discuss this with one another with some respect. Otherwise the entire exchange is flawed and based on the premise that everything we say is meaningless and we're both idiots.

Respect means providing support for you're own arguments. It is not respectful to link a 135 page paper, make some coy claim about it, then refuse to quote the section you're referring to.

I have no problem "getting beyond" whatever you want to get beyond, but you need to understand that respectful behavior on a science forum is more than not calling someone an *******.
 
This is nonsense. No one is "betting the economies of the Western World."

Cap and trade, carbon trading, green energy...yeah, no one is betting the economies of the western world on woo! :D

If we spent half the money and a third of the manpower we spent in Iraq, the United States could be carbon neutral in 20 years.
Proof of this is where?

But hang on, why didnt you say "if we spent half the money we give in aid to third world dictators rah rah rah"...?

And the science is correct. You haven't offered a single reason to think otherwise. Just tired, long debunked nonsense.

Really, the science is correct? Like the science behind claiming 1998 was the hottest year evah recorded in Amerikkka or the science that went in to the hockey stick was correct? :D

Mailman
 
no one is betting the economies of the western world on woo! :D

Only true thing you've said so far.

Proof of this is where?

But hang on, why didnt you say "if we spent half the money we give in aid to third world dictators rah rah rah"...?

Proof of this is in the fact that no environmental legislation remotely approaches what we've spent on Iraq. Right now direct spending is up to $900 billion, but that number will swell when the amount we spend on health care for veteran (to pick one factor) over the rest of their lifetime. It will cost several trillion dollars.

Take 1 trillion. Yes, we could easily create an alternative energy infrastructure, subsidize costs, and basically eliminate carbon reliance if that money was used wisely. It's a matter of will, not ability.

Really, the science is correct? Like the science behind claiming 1998 was the hottest year evah recorded in Amerikkka or the science that went in to the hockey stick was correct? :D

Mailman

Yes, these are the silly, long discredited lies to which I referred.

Until 2009, 1998 was the warmest year on record. The deniers used this to pretend like the Earth was cooling even though the trend was constantly upward.

Note this very easy to understand graph:

http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/05/16/how-will-they-spin-this/

Though you will completely ignore this, here is yet another debunking of that hockey stick BS:

http://www.realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2004/12/myths-vs-fact-regarding-the-hockey-stick/
 
Pap like that may explain the lack of respect your position receives.

And contentless replies like this define your position. I'm not surprised in the least. Why attempt to argue on the merits when snide comments are so much easier?

Given it is so (how much will sealevel rise in the next 100 years, and when; what will temperature/rainfall/etc, that is, useful predictions be for specific areas), then, how will you arrive at political solutions?

As of 1998 (there hasn't been a more recent study), the real price of gasoline was hidden at a 15-1 ratio. In other words, every $1 a consumer spent on gas costed the United States $15:

http://www.icta.org/doc/Real Price of Gasoline.pdf

Forget the Iraq War, if we just subsidized alternative energy sources at half that rate, they instantly would become more competitive in the market place, making for an easy transition.

All this handwringing and these crocodile tears about the economy are based on ignorant nonsense meant to instill fear in stupid American voters (it works, unfortunately). We can spend trillions of dollars on useless wars, but investing in energy sources to end our dependence on fossil fuels will destroy us. Riiiiiight.

But "arriving at political solutions" is a far different question from the quality and strength of the science. We can go on about that sort of thing, though it's probably more appropriate for the economics forum, but realize all you're doing is trying to take the discussion away from science.

None of you denier goofballs can remotely criticize the science, so you just distract and whine and concern troll about our ability to convince people of our position. You have nothing.
 
lol, you're so busy trying to run off at the mouth you can't even be bothered to read the thread. (if we could only harness that energy)

Don't let our discussion interupt your victory dance.

Instead of getting into one of the flame matches that you claim to not like, how about you answer his question? While you're at it, how about you answer mine?

Who needs to be convinced that there is a problem before we take action, and why? Do you feel that you personally have to be convinced (i.e, had everything explained to you), or are you willing to trust people who have spent decades studying the climate when they say that there is a problem? I realize skepticism is in order, and we shouldn't take anything only on trust, but when you have an entire field of science saying that we're headed for disaster and they try their best to explain to everyone what the problem is, don't you think that a change is in order?

I sure do.

It's not like taking action necessitates ruining the economy either. Sweden is a good example of that. All it takes is the will to do it. Chances are the economy will be better from it, at least in the long run.
 
Without convincing people, you do "have nothing".

Hmmm lets follow that line of logic for a moment:

When biologists fails to convince a Young Earth Creationist about evolution does that mean the biologist “has nothing” or that the YEC will not allow himself to be convinced by any amount of fact or logic?

When a skeptic fails to convince the anti-Vaccination crowd about there is no evidence Vaccinations cause Autism does that mean the skeptic “has nothing” or that the anti-Vaccination crowd will not allow itself to be convinced by any amount of fact or logic?

When a structural engineer fails to convince a Truther about the WTC collapse does that mean the biologist “has nothing” or that the Truther will not allow himself to be convinced by any amount of fact or logic?

When a researcher fails to convince a Birther about the Obama was born in Hawaii does that mean the researcher “has nothing” or that the Birther will not allow himself to be convinced by any amount of fact or logic?

Just as the climate deniers being addressed here the deniers in the above examples have no intention of ever allowing fact or logic to influence to influence what they believe, this is the essence of what a denier is.
 
The whole thread is rather a one sided strawman, isn't it ? I think very few people deny there is climate change or that human activity has cause a significant increase in atmospheric CO2. The interesting questions are what the precise quantitative relationship is and whether the current climatic models are sufficiently accurate to justify the panic attack. That's where the rational skepticism remains.


The fossil companies themselves know the score, knew it for 15 years.
Where have you been??

Why are you not stamping and complaining about them hiding the findings of their own scientists.....

Gets in the way of your agenda eh?

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/04/24/science/earth/24deny.html

Macdoc, you cherry picked your quote and took it out of context. That 1995 industry paper states that, yes the greenhouse effect and impact of CO2 on climate is undeniable. Then you failed to cite the rest of the context - that same paper states that climate cannot be predicted accurately for several reasons, that claims climate change is anthropomorphic are not justified, b/c of the inaccurate model, and that other factors could account for observed changes.

I'm NOT suggesting that the 1995 industry paper is correct. I am stating as a conclusion, that you Macdoc radically misrepresented the content, are a dishonest debater and a distorter of evidence. Yet another Randi-ite incapable of critical thought, spewing agenda motivated lies.

Here is the content:
http://documents.nytimes.com/global-climate-coalition-aiam-climate-change-primer#p=1

=========

The whole Al Gore create panic, stifle debate, indoctrinate children with images of drowning polar bears methodology has been counter productive to an intelligent debate. It's a horrible sort of propagandea campaign contributed to by some of the climate researchers. This thread topic is a bit of navel gazing too. I am always surprised at how many people who have absolutely no background in the sciences and probably couldn't pass a HS earth sciences course are cocksure that anthropomorphic catastrophic global warming is certain. Apparently these "critical thinkers" of the Randi forum don't understand that "argument from authority" is a logical fallacy.

If we ignore the impact of CO2 on climate due to lack of sufficiently accurate climatic models, we still can't ignore the impact of the CO2 levels on the biosphere. Why get bogged down in a debate over a very important but highly complex and arguable effect of CO2 on climate, while the impact of CO2 on ocean pH and land plant growth are clear-cut ?

The other interesting question is - what can be done about it ? This is a classic problem that recurs in many places, which can be characterized by personal motives being at odds with the general welfare; tragedy of the commons is the economic name for the phenomena. We'd all benefit from less atmospheric CO2, but each individual benefits from using the atmosphere as their parsonal CO2 disposal system. The problem is compounded by crossing international borders. This sort of problems seldom ends well.
 
Last edited:
The whole thread is rather a one sided strawman, isn't it ? I think very few people deny there is climate change or that human activity has cause a significant increase in atmospheric CO2. The interesting questions are what the precise quantitative relationship is and whether the current climatic models are sufficiently accurate to justify the panic attack. That's where the rational skepticism remains.

I disagree completely, with every part of this paragraph. "Very few people" would make claims denying warming, denying the anthropological part of warming, or denying that current warming is extraordinary rare. Yet, we see just those claims in various forms from our resident denialists.

As for rational skepticism about climate models being sufficiently accurate to justify a "panic attack", I'd say, no, there's no room for rational skepticism there. Rational skepticism would mean you possess all the data and the necessary education to interpret said data. None of us do. We must rely on people who do. Those people are in consensus. We have a warming problem, we're doing it, and if we don't stop, it's going to get bad.

Nobody is having a panic attack. The climatologists are trying to warn the world of impending danger. Do you think they should sugar coat it? Well, they sort of have. It seems they have been underestimating our impact on the climate, as well as the consequences.

/Edit: Jeez, you had to go add more bunk, did you?

The whole Al Gore create panic, stifle debate, indoctrinate children with images of drowning polar bears methodology has been counter productive to an intelligent debate.

Nobody cares about Al Gore except denialists.

It's a horrible sort of propagandea campaign contributed to by some of the climate researchers.

No. The climate researchers tell us what their research show. Nothing more. The horrible propaganda is coming from ideologically, religiously or economically driven politicos dead set in delaying any action.

This thread topic is a bit of navel gazing too. I am always surprised at how many people who have absolutely no background in the sciences and probably couldn't pass a HS earth sciences course are cocksure that anthropomorphic catastrophic global warming is certain.

We are cocksure that AGW is certain because that's what the scientists researching our climate are telling us in unison.

Apparently these "critical thinkers" of the Randi forum don't understand that "argument from authority" is a logical fallacy.

Absolutely wrong. Argument from authority isn't a logical fallacy. It goes hand in hand with critical thinking. Argument from FALSE authority, on the other hand, is a logical fallacy. No wonder you have trouble believing the experts when you think it's a logical fallacy to do so.

If we ignore the impact of CO2 on climate due to lack of sufficiently accurate climatic models, we still can't ignore the impact of the CO2 levels on the biosphere.

We shouldn't ignore the impact of CO2 on climate because the climate models are pretty accurate and getting better.

Why get bogged down in a debate over a very important but highly complex and arguable effect of CO2 on climate, while the impact of CO2 on ocean pH and land plant growth are clear-cut ?

Why get bogged down in a debate at all when action is required? Well, go ask the people sowing doubt.

The other interesting question is - what can be done about it ? This is a classic problem that recurs in many places, which can be characterized by personal motives being at odds with the general welfare; tragedy of the commons is the economic name for the phenomena. We'd all benefit from less atmospheric CO2, but each individual benefits from using the atmosphere as their parsonal CO2 disposal system. The problem is compounded by crossing international borders. This sort of problems seldom ends well.

Things are already being done in parts of the world that isn't North America. Nations have shown not only a willingness to act, but real results. It's only in those parts of the world where ignorance is allowed to reign free in government that action is being delayed. Unfortunately, those parts of the world are substantial.
 
Last edited:
I think very few people deny there is climate change or that human activity has cause a significant increase in atmospheric CO2

We see all of these questioned from time to time and have seen it disputed in this thread.

The interesting questions are what the precise quantitative relationship is and whether the current climatic models are sufficiently accurate to justify the panic attack.


You argument has not more support in the scientific literature then the ones you dismissed above. Climate models are being advanced to improve regional predictions, not things like global temperature trends. There is neither evidence nor even debate in the literature that climate models are not can’t produce useful results for global temperature trends in the 30-100 year range.

TBH your argument is not much different then the IDer who suggests that because there is debate about the particulars of the fossil record the whole thing is suspect and doesn’t support Evolution.
 
The whole thread is rather a one sided strawman, isn't it ? I think very few people deny there is climate change or that human activity has cause a significant increase in atmospheric CO2. The interesting questions are what the precise quantitative relationship is and whether the current climatic models are sufficiently accurate to justify the panic attack. That's where the rational skepticism remains.

In all seriousness, are you reading this thread? I wish the argument that AGW was false was a strawman, but it isn't. It's being made over and over again on this very thread. From just the first couple of pages:

...The truth is, those heavily invested in climate science have been anything but open and transparent about the data they have used to create Mann Made Global Warming (tm)...

...But lets be honest here for a second. All of todays problems with the transparency of the science that has gone in to Mann Made Global Warming (tm) could have, and SHOULD have, been avoided with people like Jones being completely transparent in everything they have done...

...What, are those invested in Mann Made Global Warming (tm) now going to release their data so that their work can be checked and verified and experiments repeated etc?

Because that is EXACTLY what has gone on in climate science. Those scientists who are so heavily invested in Mann Made Global Warming have been for years with holding their data back or, as is the case with CRU, purposely ignored FOI requests so that their work could not be truly independently checked and verified.

[...]

Surely we all want the same thing here? For the science behind Mann Made Global Warming (tm) to be correct?...

...Irrelevant to this discussion (although I suspect you will now go in to over drive to distract this thread from questioning the science behind Mann Made Global Warming?:D ).

[...]

Do you want the science behind Mann Made Global Warming (tm) to be correct...yes or no?...

...In fact, there is no zero point of climate, no ideal to return to, all was always flux. The point of flux that is now, is no better or worse than the point of flux that was 1900 AD or 1900 BC. And what from the child's eye was a period of stability and shelter was for the adults living through it a society riven by uncontrollable seismic forces.

Perhaps all Climate Scientists need is a good therapist?

Yes, I wonder how much money has flowed in to the coffers of those who support Mann Made Global Warming (tm)?

But really...this is yet another rediculous effort by those who believe man is solely responsible for Mann Made Global Warming (tm) in deligitimising those who are sceptical of mans role in Mann Made Global Warming(tm).

[...]

"Do you want the science behind Mann Made Global Warming (tm) to be correct...yes or no?"...

...Keep trying to draw lines that clearly don't exist. The fact remains, the number of people in the general public who don't believe in AGW is growing, and that has nothing to do with the holocaust or the creationism...

Good PR by who? Considering the near complete strangle hold the belief in Mann Made Global Warming (tm) has on the main stream media...just where is this so called "good PR" getting propogated from/through?

[...]

Sadly for you the reality is that the growth in scepticism is in direct proportion to discovery of the lack of science that has gone in to the science of Mann Made Global Warming (tm).

I know, you can continue to pretend that the science is settled but again, the reality is that the science on Mann Made Global Warming (tm) is anything BUT settled...

...I think Ive already asked for this a number of times...but where is all this "subtle PR" coming from? So far no one has offered up any evidence that any evil group is corrupting climate science to counter what those who believe in Mann Made Global Warming (tm)?

[...]

Sorta like how spring is supposedly 11 days earlier now...even though exhibitors at this years Chelsea Flower show have had to move their flowers in to glass houses cause spring hasnt actually arrived early...or that the northern hemisphere being covered in snow is now proof of Mann Made Global Warming (even though no one has pointed out where exactly it was warmer this past winter).

...As an example, Uke wanted proof that CRU had broken the laws in relation to FOI, which I provided him with a link to the BBC which discussed the FOI request and the ruling passed down (stating that I provieded the BBC link because the BBC is squarely on the side of Mann Made Global Warming (tm) so that he COULDNT accuse me of bias) and included a link to the FOI ruling itself.

[...]

So the challenge is there, provide the proof or accept your belief in Mann Made Global Warming (tm) is nothing but woo! :D...

Deleted by popular demand.

The problem here isnt ideoligucal like it is with the lefts need to believe in Mann Made Global Warming (tm). No, the real problem here is the more we get to look in to the bubble that is climate science...the dodgier that science looks. YET, people want to bankrupt Western economies on the advice of this science?

Lets not forget that it was climate science that claimed 98 was the hottest year evah in the history of the planet in Amerikkka (bolded for insanity) BUT it was a mere statistician that pointed out problems with that claim...which lead to that claim be rescinded.

[...]

I think you will find that 11 times out of 5 that the name calling comes from those who are ideoligically committed to Mann Made Global Warming (tm)...

We're not replying to a strawman, although all these deniers should now focus their ire on you for ridiculing their stance. They actually think AGW is false, and they're tragically repetitive.
 
Last edited:
"The increase in CO2 concentration has had a surprisingly small effect to date. Whether or not this is a result of lag in the system remains to be seen. "

We're not replying to a strawman, although all these deniers should now focus their ire on you for ridiculing their stance. They actually think AGW is false, and they're tragically repetitive.

How is that in any way denial of AGW?
 
How is that in any way denial of AGW?

Fair enough, I was going through those pretty quick.

It looked to me like you were arguing that negative feedback could compensate for warming trends and that CO2 had a small effect (note that no citation was provided for either).

I suppose that isn't necessarily a rejection of AGW, I'll go delete it for you.

Note that it's still very silly.
 
Who needs to be convinced that there is a problem before we take action, and why?

Who ever is paying for the action, because it's their money and they would like to make sure it is being used effectively.

Do you feel that you personally have to be convinced (i.e, had everything explained to you), or are you willing to trust people who have spent decades studying the climate when they say that there is a problem?

I am one of many being asked to pay for said actions, so yes I need to be convinced as long as I am in the majority. I don't "trust" science, I know it to be true.

I realize skepticism is in order, and we shouldn't take anything only on trust, but when you have an entire field of science saying that we're headed for disaster and they try their best to explain to everyone what the problem is, don't you think that a change is in order?

Change is in order, I support change, I've made that clear. I'm not sure why you keep asking this?
 
Fair enough, I was going through those pretty quick.

It looked to me like you were arguing that negative feedback could compensate for warming trends and that CO2 had a small effect (note that no citation was provided for either).

I suppose that isn't necessarily a rejection of AGW, I'll go delete it for you.

Note that it's still very silly.

Why? I think a lot of people are surprised the temperature hasn't risen very much (yet) due to the huge amount of CO2 we've released into the atmosphere.
 
Why? I think a lot of people are surprised the temperature hasn't risen very much (yet) due to the huge amount of CO2 we've released into the atmosphere.

Look, I've given up on convincing you of anything to do with the science of AGW, but please, if you take anything away from these multiple threads, let it be the notion of supporting your claims withe evidence.

Who are you talking about? Over the course of the last 30 years we have literally multiplied our understanding of climate dynamics by a large factor. Maybe we thought CO2 should have done more in 1990, but then scientists discovered more information about sinks and other related factors.

You're making a blanket statement based on something that no one here but you has any notion of. If you just give us a reference, we can have a discussion, but what exactly do you want me to say about that claim you just made? I have no idea what you're talking about.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom