The whole thread is rather a one sided strawman, isn't it ? I think very few people deny there is climate change or that human activity has cause a significant increase in atmospheric CO2. The interesting questions are what the precise quantitative relationship is and whether the current climatic models are sufficiently accurate to justify the panic attack. That's where the rational skepticism remains.
I disagree completely, with every part of this paragraph. "Very few people" would make claims denying warming, denying the anthropological part of warming, or denying that current warming is extraordinary rare. Yet, we see just those claims in various forms from our resident denialists.
As for rational skepticism about climate models being sufficiently accurate to justify a "panic attack", I'd say, no, there's no room for rational skepticism there. Rational skepticism would mean you possess all the data and the necessary education to interpret said data. None of us do. We must rely on people who do. Those people are in consensus. We have a warming problem, we're doing it, and if we don't stop, it's going to get bad.
Nobody is having a panic attack. The climatologists are trying to warn the world of impending danger. Do you think they should sugar coat it? Well, they sort of have. It seems they have been underestimating our impact on the climate, as well as the consequences.
/Edit: Jeez, you had to go add more bunk, did you?
The whole Al Gore create panic, stifle debate, indoctrinate children with images of drowning polar bears methodology has been counter productive to an intelligent debate.
Nobody cares about Al Gore except denialists.
It's a horrible sort of propagandea campaign contributed to by some of the climate researchers.
No. The climate researchers tell us what their research show. Nothing more. The horrible propaganda is coming from ideologically, religiously or economically driven politicos dead set in delaying any action.
This thread topic is a bit of navel gazing too. I am always surprised at how many people who have absolutely no background in the sciences and probably couldn't pass a HS earth sciences course are cocksure that anthropomorphic catastrophic global warming is certain.
We are cocksure that AGW is certain because that's what the scientists researching our climate are telling us in unison.
Apparently these "critical thinkers" of the Randi forum don't understand that "argument from authority" is a logical fallacy.
Absolutely wrong. Argument from authority isn't a logical fallacy. It goes hand in hand with critical thinking. Argument from FALSE authority, on the other hand, is a logical fallacy. No wonder you have trouble believing the experts when you think it's a logical fallacy to do so.
If we ignore the impact of CO2 on climate due to lack of sufficiently accurate climatic models, we still can't ignore the impact of the CO2 levels on the biosphere.
We shouldn't ignore the impact of CO2 on climate because the climate models are pretty accurate and getting better.
Why get bogged down in a debate over a very important but highly complex and arguable effect of CO2 on climate, while the impact of CO2 on ocean pH and land plant growth are clear-cut ?
Why get bogged down in a debate at all when action is required? Well, go ask the people sowing doubt.
The other interesting question is - what can be done about it ? This is a classic problem that recurs in many places, which can be characterized by personal motives being at odds with the general welfare; tragedy of the commons is the economic name for the phenomena. We'd all benefit from less atmospheric CO2, but each individual benefits from using the atmosphere as their parsonal CO2 disposal system. The problem is compounded by crossing international borders. This sort of problems seldom ends well.
Things are already being done in parts of the world that isn't North America. Nations have shown not only a willingness to act, but real results. It's only in those parts of the world where ignorance is allowed to reign free in government that action is being delayed. Unfortunately, those parts of the world are substantial.