Climate change scepticism - its sources and origins

Status
Not open for further replies.
And yet another reason for growing skepticism.

The misrepresentation of what we know and what we don't know by people not in the know. Why? Because the people in the know know enough to keep discussion to what they know and not what they think they know.

It's clear from the article I linked and the IPCC report itself what is known and to what extent.

But I understand for some people "CO2-bad, warming-bad" is good enough.

So you're sceptical because a couple of people on the internet are allegedly misrepresenting a couple od arguments, and that is good enough to trump all the evidence gathered over the past century that confirms AGW? Ahhhh... OK :eek:

And, as for your other comments about the connection between other woo deniers and climate deniers, you don't have to share a belief in two forms of denial, simply employ the same tactics. That's why you people (and I use that term broadly because you personally are better than most on this forum) get called deniers, because of the uncritical swallowing of denial tactics employed by the very same people who have denied other sciences throughout the last few decades.
 
lol.
So water vapor is not a part of the gas we usually call air according to you?

You quoted something but didn't give the source. Was it wiki?

It's heating the water vapour, not the air. I already explained to you the thermal capacity of water is significantly higher than "air". In about grade 6 we teach our children this by boiling water in a paper cup. The paper cup doesn't get hot and burn, the water does and boils.

Yes, you have told this many times but you are still wrong and have never managed to give any source for your theory.

Why don't we just test who is correct with a bet?

So for the last time fred, it's the water vapour in air that creates the predominant form of convection on this planet. "Dry" convection can occur, but is almost non-existent due to the fact that almost everywhere on this planet there is water vapour in the air. Your talk of it in relation to cloud formation is utterly nonsensical.

Back up your gibberish with a source, take the bet or shut up.

"Dry" convection using the definition you used before happens all the time on the earth.

When have I talked about dry convection in regard to cloud formation? Learn to read.
I hope you finally get this fred.
Hope you finally want to stand behind your words with a bet. You are the one that are incorrect.

Did you read my link about thermals that completely contradicts most everything you have written?
 
So you're sceptical because a couple of people on the internet are allegedly misrepresenting a couple od arguments, and that is good enough to trump all the evidence gathered over the past century that confirms AGW? Ahhhh... OK :eek:

And, as for your other comments about the connection between other woo deniers and climate deniers, you don't have to share a belief in two forms of denial, simply employ the same tactics. That's why you people (and I use that term broadly because you personally are better than most on this forum) get called deniers, because of the uncritical swallowing of denial tactics employed by the very same people who have denied other sciences throughout the last few decades.

I'm skeptical because I see a lot of scientists saying "We're getting a handle on what's going on here. We're running tests and creating models and doing proxy searches and verifications and we know this isn't good but we're not sure to what extent exactly and we'd like to know for sure, but yah we were right fyi" and then there's a lot of people latching on and going "OMG what do we do, tell us what to do, for the love of dog we need to something" and big business is going "oh we've got your fix right here, a trillion dollar scheme that no one can really validate one way or the other if it will be cost effective or not"

It kinda plays out like one of those cheesy sci-fi flicks where there's an asteroid heading our way. Nobody is sure if it's going to hit us, but we know there will be fallout. Some say it
s too late to do anything, some say we've got to act now, some say we've got to wait and see, some want to launch a missile, some want to send Bruce Willis, the rest Will Smith, some want to move the Earth out of it
s orbit, some want to push the moon into it's trajectory. You get the point.

It's the cool level head that prevails. I say we are doing what we can. I know I am. I think we can do more, but I also realize there are other on this planet that can't.

If we need to do more, we might have to force people to do more. I honestly believe it could come down to this and if it does we have to be damn sure we are right. At this point I'm not sure we are prepared to fight for it beyond what we do here on the internet. "Sorry India, you can make our cars, but you can't buy and use them" "Sorry China, no HVAC for you"

So before I go all hog wild I'd like my ducks in a row. I don't think we're there yet.
 
I'm skeptical because I see a lot of scientists saying "We're getting a handle on what's going on here. We're running tests and creating models and doing proxy searches and verifications and we know this isn't good but we're not sure to what extent exactly and we'd like to know for sure, but yah we were right fyi" and then there's a lot of people latching on and going "OMG what do we do, tell us what to do, for the love of dog we need to something" and big business is going "oh we've got your fix right here, a trillion dollar scheme that no one can really validate one way or the other if it will be cost effective or not"

It kinda plays out like one of those cheesy sci-fi flicks where there's an asteroid heading our way. Nobody is sure if it's going to hit us, but we know there will be fallout. Some say it
s too late to do anything, some say we've got to act now, some say we've got to wait and see, some want to launch a missile, some want to send Bruce Willis, the rest Will Smith, some want to move the Earth out of it
s orbit, some want to push the moon into it's trajectory. You get the point.

It's the cool level head that prevails. I say we are doing what we can. I know I am. I think we can do more, but I also realize there are other on this planet that can't.

If we need to do more, we might have to force people to do more. I honestly believe it could come down to this and if it does we have to be damn sure we are right. At this point I'm not sure we are prepared to fight for it beyond what we do here on the internet. "Sorry India, you can make our cars, but you can't buy and use them" "Sorry China, no HVAC for you"

So before I go all hog wild I'd like my ducks in a row. I don't think we're there yet.

I seriously don't get your position at all. You say scientists are saying that they aren't sure, while scientists are saying we're fairly sure. You say some people say we shouldn't do anything, some say we should wait to do something, while scientists say we should do something now.

I mean, you seem to trust the scientists enough to realize that they are saying that there is a problem, you just don't trust them enough when they say we need to act now. Why is that?
 
I mean, you seem to trust the scientists enough to realize that they are saying that there is a problem, you just don't trust them enough when they say we need to act now. Why is that?

Where exactly do you live where they aren't already doing things to curtail CO2 emissions? I'd like to know because AFAIK we are acting now. And the extent we are acting is fairly well represented by how well we know what will happen based on current model predictions.
 
Where exactly do you live where they aren't already doing things to curtail CO2 emissions? I'd like to know because AFAIK we are acting now. And the extent we are acting is fairly well represented by how well we know what will happen based on current model predictions.

Not at all. Nations like the US and Canada have no emission curtailing plans at the moment (to my knowledge). Only a weak ass plan for CO2 "intensity" cutbacks, meaning that CO2 emissions should reflect the current economic climate in the country. This means emissions are likely to go up from both the US and Canada. Sweden (where I live) has had a carbon tax in place for close to 19 years. Our government has a plan for complete carbon neutrality by the year 2025 I believe (not 100% on the year).

As you can see, some nations are doing their part while others aren't. Why aren't you?
 
Not at all. Nations like the US and Canada have no emission curtailing plans at the moment (to my knowledge). Only a weak ass plan for CO2 "intensity" cutbacks, meaning that CO2 emissions should reflect the current economic climate in the country. This means emissions are likely to go up from both the US and Canada. Sweden (where I live) has had a carbon tax in place for close to 19 years. Our government has a plan for complete carbon neutrality by the year 2025 I believe (not 100% on the year).

As you can see, some nations are doing their part while others aren't. Why aren't you?

This is an entirely different debate, but one that I would participate in. Suffice to say I live in Ontario and with the nuclear, wind, solar and hydroelectric we should be carbon neutral in terms of electricity well before 2025. Reducing total carbon footprint is no small task for task for a province based on manufacturing and not, I don't know, people walking around taking pictures :p

I believe I will respectfully defer any argument in this matter to macdoc. I'm sure he knows much more than I do on this and could easily teach me a thing or two in this matter. As far as I can tell most European countries have only succeeded in raising the price of energy without actually reducing emissions.
 
I dunno 3BP, that's a hell of a rant and there is much wrong with it but I have limited time to reply atm. You say you haven't been affected by the PR campaign against climate science, but you seem to have swallowed the 'doubt is our product' meme hook, line and sinker. For an apparently smart guy who, from what I can tell from that rant, doesn't actually dispute the science, but thinks that the uncertainties involved are reason enough to argue until your blue in the face with people you object to on an ideological level. I dunno, I'd say the PR has been pretty damned effective in this case, because that is EXACTLY what the think tanks have been selling for the last 20 years.
 
I dunno 3BP, that's a hell of a rant and there is much wrong with it but I have limited time to reply atm. You say you haven't been affected by the PR campaign against climate science, but you seem to have swallowed the 'doubt is our product' meme hook, line and sinker. For an apparently smart guy who, from what I can tell from that rant, doesn't actually dispute the science, but thinks that the uncertainties involved are reason enough to argue until your blue in the face with people you object to on an ideological level. I dunno, I'd say the PR has been pretty damned effective in this case, because that is EXACTLY what the think tanks have been selling for the last 20 years.

At the same time if I am a product of that PR it isn't working. I gave up my car 5 years ago, get physically ill at the sight of plastic bags and found a second career in electricity generation after being in the automotive sector. I've been pretty green and support green measure for quite a while.

I just don't buy that the science is settled and there isn't room to improve drastically on what we know before taking drastic measures to mitigate the consequences of our thirst for cheap energy. I posted an amusing link in the lies thread which may give you a better idea where I'm coming from. Let's just say I'm not new to this and I've seen some pretty outrageous claims in the past by some well well meaning and highly educated people. The science and the people aren't infallible.

"Oh this is the top of the line model brother, this one will be good for years" I know a guy that paid $4000 for an Intel 386 back in the day. I know this isn't directly related, but you understand what I'm getting at. I've seen the latest and greatest being sold as the best of the best only to become junk a few short years later. Climate science is a little more lasting, but the money we put into it is going to be HUGE. That makes it all the more reason to be we know where are money is going before we give it to those PR guys you're talking about right? Something to consider.
 
Yes, but as models have improved have you ever seen the projections they compute revised down? Hell no, as the science gets better the projections get more dire and we realise we have been too conservative in our estimates.
 
Yes, but as models have improved have you ever seen the projections they compute revised down? Hell no, as the science gets better the projections get more dire and we realise we have been too conservative in our estimates.

This is exactly why you can't pin your entire stake in the global warming debate on normal scientific uncertainty. Scientists are generally a pretty conservative bunch, and they normally don't say things that they cannot back up. This means that they generally underestimate reported findings. That seems to be the case with AGW. As more research is made, predictions become more dire. This highlights the importance of acting now, as opposed to when we are 100% sure (which means not acting at all, as we'll never be 100% sure).

We have hard science telling us we have a problem. The scientific consensus is overwhelming. Among scientists in related fields, the consensus is as strong as that on the theory of evolution. That's about as certain as a scientist can be. This makes it so incredible that there are people who doubt the science for anything but religious or ideological reasons.

As for European nations just raising the price of energy without being able to cut emissions, I'm sure that applies to some, but not all. Again, Sweden has managed to cut emissions and there is a plan in place for carbon neutrality. That's one of the reasons I participate in this debate. I'm hopping mad about the fact that some nations just won't commit, even in the face of nations that have committed and succeeded. Why should I bear the economic burden (because yes, energy is more expensive, and taxes are higher) while you get to sit it out, arguing about "uncertain science"? Pitiful.
 
Yes, but as models have improved have you ever seen the projections they compute revised down? Hell no, as the science gets better the projections get more dire and we realise we have been too conservative in our estimates.

That I'm afraid is a difficult question to answer. There is certainly a difference in what I've heard than what I've seen in print.

This is why I try to stay away from alarmists and keep to the science and respected journals. Then I enter back into the debate to hear the science and journals might be a tad alarmist! I've been relieved to find that for the most part the science remains fairly rational (or conservative as you put it).

It get tough to filter out the background noise from those with an agenda, for whatever reasons. The internet only serves to confuse in some cases. This information was at one time filtered through by those in position to do so. Now any quack with an internet connection can get online and cut and paste an argument to his liking. The nature of the problem compounds this effect as well. It's very easy to get confused, or turned around as terms get bantered about. That's just on the surface layer, as you dig deeper into the science it becomes that much more complex. Not to say that I'm there by any means, but I actually do know enough to say I don't know enough. But I certainly can know enough to carry on a conversation if it suits me. There's a tendency for people to jump to conclusions and start from the premise my position stems from not knowing anything. That just degenerates into a free for all ad hom sling fest all too often here.

Long story short, from what I've seen over the last few months the science is progressing quite nicely. The models are approaching accuracy to begin making predictions we can be reasonably certain will occur. I still maintain however that very slight perturbations in the models will/can have profound effects on these predictions. That's the nature of climate as an extension of weather. To say we've exhausted the possibility of some negative feedback that could stabilize the climate in the next 10 or 15 years is a little presumptuous. But I'm certainly not in denial that this is slowly becoming less and less of a possibility. And I'm certainly not waiting for some divine intervention. :D
 
That I'm afraid is a difficult question to answer. There is certainly a difference in what I've heard than what I've seen in print.

This is why I try to stay away from alarmists and keep to the science and respected journals. Then I enter back into the debate to hear the science and journals might be a tad alarmist! I've been relieved to find that for the most part the science remains fairly rational (or conservative as you put it).

It get tough to filter out the background noise from those with an agenda, for whatever reasons. The internet only serves to confuse in some cases. This information was at one time filtered through by those in position to do so. Now any quack with an internet connection can get online and cut and paste an argument to his liking. The nature of the problem compounds this effect as well. It's very easy to get confused, or turned around as terms get bantered about. That's just on the surface layer, as you dig deeper into the science it becomes that much more complex. Not to say that I'm there by any means, but I actually do know enough to say I don't know enough. But I certainly can know enough to carry on a conversation if it suits me. There's a tendency for people to jump to conclusions and start from the premise my position stems from not knowing anything. That just degenerates into a free for all ad hom sling fest all too often here.

Long story short, from what I've seen over the last few months the science is progressing quite nicely. The models are approaching accuracy to begin making predictions we can be reasonably certain will occur. I still maintain however that very slight perturbations in the models will/can have profound effects on these predictions. That's the nature of climate as an extension of weather. To say we've exhausted the possibility of some negative feedback that could stabilize the climate in the next 10 or 15 years is a little presumptuous. But I'm certainly not in denial that this is slowly becoming less and less of a possibility. And I'm certainly not waiting for some divine intervention. :D

So, if I have understood you correctly, you don't feel there is enough scientific grounds to do anything further to reduce carbon emissions than what is already being done (very little in most parts of the world)?

If so, what do you feel should have been accomplished before we should start acting? Who should be convinced that the science is solid? You? The laymen of the world? The politicians? The scientists?
 
This is exactly why you can't pin your entire stake in the global warming debate on normal scientific uncertainty. Scientists are generally a pretty conservative bunch, and they normally don't say things that they cannot back up. This means that they generally underestimate reported findings. That seems to be the case with AGW. As more research is made, predictions become more dire. This highlights the importance of acting now, as opposed to when we are 100% sure (which means not acting at all, as we'll never be 100% sure).

We have hard science telling us we have a problem. The scientific consensus is overwhelming. Among scientists in related fields, the consensus is as strong as that on the theory of evolution. That's about as certain as a scientist can be. This makes it so incredible that there are people who doubt the science for anything but religious or ideological reasons.

As for European nations just raising the price of energy without being able to cut emissions, I'm sure that applies to some, but not all. Again, Sweden has managed to cut emissions and there is a plan in place for carbon neutrality. That's one of the reasons I participate in this debate. I'm hopping mad about the fact that some nations just won't commit, even in the face of nations that have committed and succeeded. Why should I bear the economic burden (because yes, energy is more expensive, and taxes are higher) while you get to sit it out, arguing about "uncertain science"? Pitiful.

I don't know dude, I've been around this for a while and the baseline seems to be about 2 degrees over the next century, but the claims of what will have vary a lot. It might be interesting to compile what's been said over the last 20 years about it for a reference. Sadly the internet came along a little too late for that. It's possible however.

The whole issue of mitigation is going to be equally complex to measure. It's not as easy as just trading carbon credits and saying "Look what I did". It's reasonable to assume there will be a way, but not at first. Some countries are going to get royally screwed I think.
 
To say we've exhausted the possibility of some negative feedback that could stabilize the climate in the next 10 or 15 years is a little presumptuous. But I'm certainly not in denial that this is slowly becoming less and less of a possibility. And I'm certainly not waiting for some divine intervention. :D

Well, I'm glad you added the caveat at the end of this statement, because it seems to me a lot of those holding out for some magical negative feedback really DO seem to be holding out for divine intervention! But, as I pointed out in the moderated thread, and which to your credit you acknowledged, I think the real test for whether there is some yet unknown and magical negative feedback that will save the day is simply to look back through history. I'm sure we can agree that, say, a 7 degree C. temp rise would be a very bad thing for the world, or at least the world our species inhabits, yet we have ample evidence to show the planet has reached those temperatures in the past, yet no negative feedback kicked in to prevent that from happening. If it has happened before then why on Earth would you pin your hopes on some Gaia-like equilibrium maintaining the perfect climate for humans to thrive in, in the face of all evidence? I mean, hell, we get accused of being religious all the time but this concept that there is some kind of salvation is waaaay more religious and anthropocentric than anything climate science has ever said. And it defies all reason in my humble opinion.
 
Last edited:
Well, I'm glad you added the caveat at the end of this statement, because it seems to me a lot of those holding out for some magical negative feedback really DO seem to be holding out for divine intervention! But, as I pointed out in the moderated thread, and which to your credit you acknowledged, I think the real test for whether there is some yet unknown and magical negative feedback that will save the day is simply to look back through history. I'm sure we can agree that, say, a 7 degree C. temp rise would be a very bad thing for the world, or at least the world our species inhabits, yet we have ample evidence to show the planet has reached those temperatures in the past, yet no negative feedback kicked in to prevent that from happening. If it has happened before then why on Earth would you pin your hopes on some Gaia-like equilibrium maintaining the perfect climate for humans to thrive in, in the face of all evidence? I men, hell, we get accused of being religious all the time but this concept that there is some kind of salvation is waaaay more religious and anthropocentric than anything climate science has ever said. And it defies all reason in my humble opinion.

Yes, I tend to agree here.

There is however a substantial variability in cloud formation and effect we have yet to understand. Will it hold the the rise to 0.5 degrees as I had predicted? Probably not. I'm genuinely curious what the possibility of this is however. In terms of mitigating it's very important to establish if there will be an equilibrium and if we can use some forcing to our advantage. Until we do this it's hard to say for me at least if reducing CO2 will accomplish what we need as fast as we need it to. I haven't seen anything to indicate that the "sprtizer bottle" won't in fact work in light of increased temperature and continuous emission by man made sources. Or perhaps a man made nuclei for cloud formation? I haven't seen any evidence, other than a few misguided videos that don't address this in its entirety to rule that out as a possible solution. Or even the bubbling of the ocean water to decrease absorption. What are the combined effects? I think the science is a little immature to even address these mitigations just yet. Perhaps I just don't know that they have already been soundly ruled out.
 
Last edited:
Maybe it is still too immature, but are you prepared to bet your and your children's future on the chance that it might have missed something? I'm not. The science might not be "settled", no science ever is, but the evidence is persuasive enough, and has been for at least twenty years now, that we should act to limit emissions. And that's just the thing, we have wasted twenty years in which we could have had a much more gradual decline in emissions with a much more limited effect on the economy, but instead we got caught up in the thrall of politics and the doubt-mongers who said we should just wait and see. That's what irks me about your attitude, yeah we can wait and see but if you're wrong then the level of action we have to take to have any impact is going to get more and more severe. The longer we leave it the more painful it will be.
 
Last edited:
It seems you are prepared to bet the economies of the western world on soemthing as yet unproven?

Which is why I have asked time and time again, arent we all interested in making sure the science behind Mann Made Global Warming is correct. If we are going to bet our childrens prosperity on this, then lets get it right!

Dont you agree?

Mailman
 
,,,,What are the combined effects? I think the science is a little immature to even address these mitigations just yet. Perhaps I just don't know that they have already been soundly ruled out.
Of course the "mitigation vs adaptation" argument can't simply be left to be decided in the direction of higher taxes, propaganda, and lame excuses. That's the current case.

Stern's arguments for mitigation were based on weak premises, easily refuted, and that is presuming that the 3.0C number he used for his study for a temperature increase in the case of a doubling of CO2 is correct.

His entire argument, and all other arguments for attempting to lower carbon emissions, collapse if the number is not 3.0C, but even 2.0C. And that's using his premises, which are ridiculous.

In other words, economic fallacies of various sorts - not just in one dimension - underlie much of this nonsense.

Or to simplify it: "Let's save the world's climate through jacking up taxes".

Yeah, sure, bud.
 
Maybe it is still too immature, but are you prepared to bet your and your children's future on the chance that it might have missed something? I'm not. The science might not be "settled", no science ever is, but the evidence is persuasive enough, and has been for at least twenty years now, that we should act to limit emissions. And that's just the thing, we have wasted twenty years in which we could have had a much more gradual decline in emissions with a much more limited effect on the economy, but instead we got caught up in the thrall of politics and the doubt-mongers who said we should just wait and see. That's what irks me about your attitude, yeah we can wait and see but if you're wrong then the level of action we have to take to have any impact is going to get more and more severe. The longer we leave it the more painful it will be.

That's why I'm interested in the model predictions. I'm not certain the effects of a radical transformation in our CO2 output will have the effect some people think it will have. A pee in the ocean as the saying goes. If we put all that money into expensive renewables and it gets concentrated into the elite carbon brokers without doing much of anything then where are we? Because we know without massive government intervention that's bound to happen. Even with it. And that's not denial, that's being realistic. I'd prefer to see what's being done if that's in any way possible. I've already read about carbon credits and funny business.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom