Budhism Is Not A Religion

Im this and Im that, whats the point of labels? furthermore, whats the point behind this talk? All I see is angry people, not a productive discussion.

Why must a discussion be productive at all?

oh, ok, I will remain in silence ;-)
 
I am not angry with anyone, but having a hell of a lot of fun.

Im this and Im that, whats the point of labels? furthermore, whats the point behind this talk? All I see is angry people, not a productive discussion.

Why must a discussion be productive at all?

oh, ok, I will remain in silence ;-)

I am not angry with anyone, but having a hell of a lot of fun.

Good, Bodhi Dharma Zen, you are one guy for bringing in perspectives.

About productive discussion, just being funny as in fun, What has Zen produced in the way of relieving say backache? -- just on the common level of everyday mundane annoyances and inconveniences.


[Hahaha softly]


Yrreg
 
Didn't I bring up the reminder to you guys? that in charge of the tissues, organs, and processes there is a subject that is conscious running the whole caboodle and monitoring them.
Now that is truely interesting, so I will ask, what is consiousness except a bunch of processes confabulated together and called consiousness?
Didn't I say to you guys? that it is not your bowel going to the CR but you, the self; and it is not your belly that is eating but you, the self -- in so many words about that anecdote of the famine, and the ruler, and the Buddhist monks with their headman applying to the ruler for their food ration.
You lost me there, what are you trying to say?
The body excretes, are you saying that consiousness is responsible for the autonomic functions?
I am not comrehending you train of thought.
What happened is that we had a deadlock, not that I did not attend to your answers; I attended to them, but I can't accept them as rationally convincing -- maybe I don't have the Buddhist enlightenment.
I did not say that you had not attended I tried to recap the statement about the non-self in term we had used already. There is no self, there is a body and the other heaps. Are you saying that consciousness is like a little yrreg that sits behind the exterior yrreg? Or what is you definition of consciousness?
Is it perception, memory, cognition?
Anyway, let's see what our physicist here, Epepke, has to say about the self and the non-self as explained and propounded by Buddhists, from the standpoint of the ultimate findings or theories in physics.


Yrreg

I think you might benefit more from the teachings of Mercutio, the resident psychologist.
 
Dear Ryokan:

On the one hand, you and Dancing David and I am sure a lot of Western Buddhists insist on the genuine, authentic, real, true, unadulterated teachings of the Buddha;
Yrreg


I hope I had been more careful than that, there is an oral history that was written down five hundred years after the buddhas death. These teachings are most likely greatly altered and heavily edited, although they are accepted widely as the teachings of the buddha.

The Mahayan tradition, which comprises the majority of practises currently in evidence, has a much broader standard of what comprises the teachings of the buddha, in that they accepts the teachins of all enlightened beings or in some schools any teaching that might lead to the budh/bodh (light).

Given that they are all mythical in nature , the actual teachings of the historical buddha can not be known. Any more than we can know the actual poem written by Omeru and now called the Illyiad.
 
I'm not sure what the "self" is supposed to mean. Where is the self considering what has been discovered in neurology and psychiatry?

That depends on your theorhetical bias, a behavioral materialist would say the self in no more than chemical interactions in a reverberating nueral network. A more spiritual immaterialist would say that there are transcendant qualities to consciousness such as 'qualia' that can not be 'reduced'.
 
Im this and Im that, whats the point of labels? furthermore, whats the point behind this talk? All I see is angry people, not a productive discussion.

Why must a discussion be productive at all?

oh, ok, I will remain in silence ;-)

Production is in the pocket of the capitalist?

Sorry Mr. Zen I hope we didn't trash the lawn too bad, the party will break up once we all pass out drunk.

I hope you continue to intersperse our conversations with your wit , wisdom and whimsey.
 
About productive discussion, just being funny as in fun, What has Zen produced in the way of relieving say backache? -- just on the common level of everyday mundane annoyances and inconveniences.

I dont know! But I guess it was invented by someone with lots of available time.
 
I hope you continue to intersperse our conversations with your wit , wisdom and whimsey.

My pleasure ;-) and thanks for the adjectives, I hardly deserve any of them. In any case, I believe we all (at least the ones in these Buddhism discussions) have dedicated lots of time to research and to learn.

Now, the problem as I see it, is that this learning require words and concepts, but those are the things that are avoided when one enters what is "behind" the religious concepts.

Yes, Im sad, Im speaking gibberish. I can see that there is a point there made by yrreg and the other guy.

mmm lets see if I can explain better what I have in mind:

Scientific views are interpretations of experimental data viewed from certain conceptual models.

It is assumed (often pressumed) that our individual conceptual model is "truer" or more "real" or "based on facts", but, how do we KNOW that our model is correct and everyone else's is wrong?

Yes yes, I know. We are more intelligent or wiser or intuitive or have a deeper understanding of what is going on.

But, is that true? how do we know? a Christian is certain, an UFO fan is certain, a Buddhist is certain, an skeptic is certain. Whats the difference?

Ahh the question. Which are the grounds for our individual certainity?

Logic?

For a Christian, the works of a genetician are, logically, the works of evil. Its EVIDENT.

Reasonements? we all feel we are "reasonable enough" (whatever that means)

That the data "fits" our other interpretations of what we call reality? bah, not interested. A model is A MODEL, no rocketscience needed to understand that.

We all try to explain things with our respective models, but what is an explanation except for some words that sound good together (and are more or less coherent with our models?

Words and concepts have an end. This is what Buddhism (at least Zen) tries to reach, a world without concepts, a world without interpretations.

You can breathe "there" and all there is is breathing, no questions, no answers.




Illogical? absurd? idiotic? yep, for some people (why not?, everyone can think whatever they want)

But its also something that certain individuals are seeking or have learned to enjoy. Im among them. There is a certain sense of "new" about everything, when you reach "there", and I like it. Enough saying.
 
Last edited:
nirvana

nirvana

is not a place.
is not a dimention.
is not anything, anywhere, what so ever.

because there is a name to it, we asumme that it is something.

budha aslo had a delema when explaining this.

he decided to call it? nirvana.

but really nothing should be said about it..

like i said. budhism is about doing it
no philosophy
theory
or belief

if you dont do it...
you will never never know... ^^

it is just all words and somethings that we think have a meaning.

action and reaction.
cycle of life.
cycle of existance.

matter and/or energy is neither created or destroyed. just changes...
budha realised this
long long time ago.
in a mountain far far away~^^

for the people who are worshipping budha. i am sorry to say...
there is nothing to "worship"
dudha you are thinking of is not there...

just as a curiosity...what do you guys think about the next phrase?

" the only correct discription, explannation, or meaning that can be given in a word or sentance is verb "
 
Thanks for this insight.

I have two reactions. One is that there is a subtle difference between the concept of rebirth and concept of reincarnation. Reincarnation generally means that the self continues from one life to the next. I think it's more of a Hindu belief, based on the notion of an eternal soul. Whereas rebirth in Buddhism generally refers to the rippling effects of ones "karma," I guess, so that habit patterns are passed from one lifetime to the next, but nothing else about a person lasts beyond death. Rebirth also refers with equal validity to the moment-to-moment process of change during this lifetime, and within Buddhism, I think it's just as "correct" to view every new day as a kind of "rebirth," and every meditation session as a kind of "rebirth," etc.

Which might be a valid idea except that "rebirth" or "reincarnation" is specifically viewed as a bad thing which Nirvana is supposed to eradicate. Within Buddhism practised by the Chinese, there is a phrase "liu4 dao4 zong4 sheng1", roughly translating as "beings from the six realms". Humans being one of the 3 upper realms of existence. It is believed that people who accumulate bad karma in this life will be reborn into one of the three lower states of animals/insects, hungry ghosts or hell. The Buddhist festival of Ullambana, cross celebrated by the Chinese as part of the Hungry Ghost Festival, originated from the story of one of the Buddha's disciple, Maha Mogallana, whose mother had been reborn into the realm of the hungry ghosts. You can read about the origins at: 4ui.com/eart/160eart2.htm (I can't post direct urls yet). Unless the Ullambana sutra is not considered canon, it would appear false to disregard reincarnation of the soul as part of the tenets of Buddhism.

Furthermore, if mainstream Buddhism does not believe in the concept of souls, then the common practice of transference of merits to ease the suffering of the dead and departed makes no sense.
 
Which might be a valid idea except that "rebirth" or "reincarnation" is specifically viewed as a bad thing which Nirvana is supposed to eradicate. Within Buddhism practised by the Chinese, there is a phrase "liu4 dao4 zong4 sheng1", roughly translating as "beings from the six realms". Humans being one of the 3 upper realms of existence. It is believed that people who accumulate bad karma in this life will be reborn into one of the three lower states of animals/insects, hungry ghosts or hell. The Buddhist festival of Ullambana, cross celebrated by the Chinese as part of the Hungry Ghost Festival, originated from the story of one of the Buddha's disciple, Maha Mogallana, whose mother had been reborn into the realm of the hungry ghosts. You can read about the origins at: 4ui.com/eart/160eart2.htm (I can't post direct urls yet). Unless the Ullambana sutra is not considered canon, it would appear false to disregard reincarnation of the soul as part of the tenets of Buddhism.

Furthermore, if mainstream Buddhism does not believe in the concept of souls, then the common practice of transference of merits to ease the suffering of the dead and departed makes no sense.

This is very interesting, thanks. I appreciate hearing the perspective of someone who grew up in a Buddhist culture.

I have several reactions to this. First, my understanding is that rebirth in itself is not viewed within Buddhism as a bad thing, but rather as a natural consequence of the way we live. The idea, as I understand it, is that suffering leads to rebirth, and the cessation of suffering can lead to the cessation of rebirth. I believe it is suffering that is viewed as the thing that needs to be addressed, not rebirth.

The hierarchy of different realms and the cosmology of some Buddhist traditions is pretty weird from a Western perspective. Here's a typical roadmap: http://web.ukonline.co.uk/buddhism/bhumis.htm
But so far I have not come across a Buddhist tradition that teaches that followers must accept this. Rather, the message seems to be, if you don't think it's true, then set it aside, and don't let it be a hinderance to your practice. None of these notions is fundamentally important to the practice. That said, there may well be more "fundamentalist" Buddhist sects out there with which I am not familiar. But Buddhism does not seem to lend itself to religious fundamentalism.

With regard to the Buddhist canon, my understanding is that it's not regarded in quite the same way as a canon in Christianity or Islam or other religions. The tripitaka is vast and complex, and I don't believe any of it is taken as literal truth in the same way that, for example, some Christians take the Bible to be the literal truth. An acceptance of the Buddhist canon as literal truth is not considered necessary to be a "good Buddhist."

Accordingly, stories of rebirth in the different realms as found in some sutras might reasonably be viewed as teaching tales rather than as statements of historic fact that must be accepted literally.

With regard to the soul, an overarching teaching in most of the Buddhist traditions that I have encountered is that there is no eternal soul. That's pretty fundamental. The sutras probably are best understood in the context of the basic principles. Those that seem to regard the reincarnation of a soul as part of a tenet of Buddhism probably are pointing to a different, more subtle truth. But who knows? The point of Buddhist practice is to draw such conclusions for oneself rather than to rely on some authority or canon.

If there is no eternal soul, the common practice of transference of merits to ease the suffering of the dead and departed makes perfect sense in the context of lovingkindness meditation.

In such a meditation, one directs lovingkindness to all beings (including, presumably, those who have taken rebirth in the lower realms, if one accepts such things). This type of meditation often incorporates a focus on things relative (specific loved ones living and dead) as well as the ultimate (all beings). Those who adopt the notion of reincarnation of an eternal soul may find that this belief makes lovingkindness meditation easier to grasp. While the notion of an eternal soul may not stem from core Buddhist principles, the practice of lovingkindness certainly does. In many cultures, Buddhist practice has become intermingled with local beliefs.
 
What or who gives you the idea that I am quoting from Buddhist sources? Did I give any indications at all that I am quoting from Buddhist sources? Please read carefully those posts from me where I mentioned those stories, and see whether I gave any indications at all that I am citing from Buddhist sources

I haven't got that idea at all. I have no idea what the source is, that's why I'm asking. Why won't you reveal your source to us, Yrreg? Why?

In which case you don't have to call yourself a Buddhist, just call yourself a, for example, Truist-Pathist; and admit that you got your beliefs and practices from Buddha's allegedly original teachings, but they are good enough even without Buddha's saying so; just as the Theory of Relativity and the Theory of Evolution are good enough if people don't know absolutely nothing about Einstein and Darwin. You make so much of being called a Buddhist, that I do have the impression that you are a cultist -- no offense intended with the name, though.

How many times must I explain to you that Buddhism is not named after Gautama Buddha, Yrreg? Buddhism is named after the experience all Buddhists seek, that of enlightenment.

I have explained this to you so many times now, I'm getting tired doing it over and over again. I don't see the point in further discussion with you.

Farewell, Yrreg.
 
With regard to the Buddhist canon, my understanding is that it's not regarded in quite the same way as a canon in Christianity or Islam or other religions. The tripitaka is vast and complex, and I don't believe any of it is taken as literal truth in the same way that, for example, some Christians take the Bible to be the literal truth. An acceptance of the Buddhist canon as literal truth is not considered necessary to be a "good Buddhist."

I didn't mean it in that sense. By canonical, I meant that the Ullambana Sutra is part of the official body of teachings; not some made up later day fables. While Buddhism does not demand its followers to accept all its teachings as the Truth(tm), one cannot deny that reincarnation is part of its teachings. It is also incorrect to label Buddhists who believe in reincarnation as members of "small fringe denominations". Perhaps Western Buddhists prefer to strip the teachings of most of its supernatural elements, nonetheless these elements are very much in the core beliefs of the practitioners in the east.

It is commendable that Buddhists attempt to delve deeper into the core teachings and strip Buddhism of the embellishments introduced by later cultural influences. However, one must always remember that the direct teachings of the Buddha were first passed down via an oral tradition and only set in writing much later. Words and even entire passages could have been altered. The original teachings might have less (or more) supernatural woo, but we'll never be sure. It is perhaps this understanding that nobody has the one true interpretation that most Buddhist denominations are able to coexist peacefully through the centuries.

Much of my exposure to Buddhism is in Chinese. As I can recall, there were no direct mentions of a "soul", but many references to the concept of "self". The "self" both exists and does not exist. Beings continue to enter into the cycle of deaths and rebirths because they try desperately to cling on to their "self". However, if they were to understand the transient nature of the "self", they would be able to break free from the cycle and attain Nirvana. In that sense, there is no eternal soul. It is apparently our craving for existence that causes our souls to be reborn indefinitely. The Buddha's mission was to enlighten the people on the transitory nature of all things. Try reading the Heart Sutra, it can give anyone a brain aneurysm, but it is one of the most popular sutras in the Mahayana tradition.
 
Last edited:
Nasty buisness... "isims". I don't think Bhuddisim is a religion either, but alot of people shure like to pretend it is. ;)
 
Nasty buisness... "isims". I don't think Bhuddisim is a religion either, but alot of people shure like to pretend it is. ;)

Perhaps the issue is with the definition of religion. Buddhism as practised in Asia for centuries is a religion, with all the attendant rituals and festive days. Unlike most religions which are god-centered, Buddhism is non-theistic. However, the long history of cultural immersion has produced a pantheon of supernatural beings that are actively worshipped.

The Mahayana tradition has a pantheon of Boddhisattvas, beings who are one step from attaining Buddhahood but through their compassion have chosen to postpone their final Nirvana in order help the less enlightened sufferers. The most popular is Avalokiteshvara, commonly but wrongly translated as the "Goddess of Mercy". The Buddhas are also worshipped, most notably Amitabha Buddha. Followers believe that by chanting his name, especially just before death, would ensure that they avoid rebirth by having a direct train to the Western Paradise overseen by this venerable buddha. The Western Paradise is apparently conducive for attaining Nirvana in the shortest possible time.

The Theravada tradition as practised in Thailand has its fair share of monks who are believed to have become Arhants, the first step of enlightenment towards the road to Nirvana. Some of these "Arhants" are still alive. Thais wear pendants with representations of the Arhants either for protection or to grant them good luck.

Nonetheless, if one chooses to strip away most of the supernatural elements, the core message of Buddhism as defined by the Four Noble Truths and the Noble Eightfold Paths is a valid philosophy. It is still not completely free from the supernatural. For example, how does one define Nirvana satisfactorily?

Finally, I tend to avoid describing Buddhism as an atheistic religion. Though Buddhism is not characterised by the worship of a god (or many gods), Buddhists do believe in the existence of gods. However, the realm of gods, like that of humans, are but one of the six realms of existence. Hence, one who has acquired enough positive karma may be reborn in the godly realm in the next existence.
 
very good insight. thank you. however

Perhaps the issue is with the definition of religion. Buddhism as practised in Asia for centuries is a religion, with all the attendant rituals and festive days. Unlike most religions which are god-centered, Buddhism is non-theistic. However, the long history of cultural immersion has produced a pantheon of supernatural beings that are actively worshipped.

The Mahayana tradition has a pantheon of Boddhisattvas, beings who are one step from attaining Buddhahood but through their compassion have chosen to postpone their final Nirvana in order help the less enlightened sufferers. The most popular is Avalokiteshvara, commonly but wrongly translated as the "Goddess of Mercy". The Buddhas are also worshipped, most notably Amitabha Buddha. Followers believe that by chanting his name, especially just before death, would ensure that they avoid rebirth by having a direct train to the Western Paradise overseen by this venerable buddha. The Western Paradise is apparently conducive for attaining Nirvana in the shortest possible time.

The Theravada tradition as practised in Thailand has its fair share of monks who are believed to have become Arhants, the first step of enlightenment towards the road to Nirvana. Some of these "Arhants" are still alive. Thais wear pendants with representations of the Arhants either for protection or to grant them good luck.

Nonetheless, if one chooses to strip away most of the supernatural elements, the core message of Buddhism as defined by the Four Noble Truths and the Noble Eightfold Paths is a valid philosophy. It is still not completely free from the supernatural. For example, how does one define Nirvana satisfactorily?

Finally, I tend to avoid describing Buddhism as an atheistic religion. Though Buddhism is not characterised by the worship of a god (or many gods), Buddhists do believe in the existence of gods. However, the realm of gods, like that of humans, are but one of the six realms of existence. Hence, one who has acquired enough positive karma may be reborn in the godly realm in the next existence.

that is not what budhism is about.

those are the stories that are told.

the essence of budhism is not what you or i or people 'believe in'

it is more about 'knowing'. not as in knowledge.

and doing.

i spose in the sence as you discribe. you could put budhist in to two catagories.

practicing and belief based...

but you have to take into account the human aspects that comes into essences of everything.
 
that is not what budhism is about.

those are the stories that are told.

the essence of budhism is not what you or i or people 'believe in'

it is more about 'knowing'. not as in knowledge.

and doing.

i spose in the sence as you discribe. you could put budhist in to two catagories.

practicing and belief based...

but you have to take into account the human aspects that comes into essences of everything.

What, then, is True Buddhism? As mentioned before, no one can safely claim to have an accurate knowledge of the Buddha's original teachings. That Buddhism encourages its followers to examine its teachings and acept/reject as they see fit is a very appealing concept for sceptics. However, this does not necessarily equate to Buddhism adopting the scientific method of inquiry. Certain ideas like Nirvana and Karmic rebirth requires acceptance on faith.

BTW, the practice and the belief of Buddhism are not necessarily distinct.

Certainly, we can dispense with all the supernatural stuff about achieving an end to Suffering via Nirvana, and simply adopt the Noble Eightfold Path without the encumbrance of its metaphysical aim. In that case, it is no different from a personal moral code. Just as a person who chooses not to steal, kill , covet his neighbour and generally live a moral life does not necessarily have to be a Christian, so why the need to define ourselves as Buddhists? This was the reason I stopped calling myself a Buddhist.

Anyhow, a Buddhist of any flavour should understand that labels are meaningless. :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom