Defintion of religion from Res Oir Amsus, from consulting users of the word
My favorite opinion-maker, Res Oir Amsus, defines religion thus:
Religion is a human behavior founded upon a belief in an unknown power resulting in affections and actions intended to influence the power to react favorably to the believer.
He reaches this definition of religion by studying peoples of different languages, having a definite name in their respective languages for a similar behavior, which we call by the name of religion.
And what is that similar behavior in peoples with different languages, which Res Oir Amsus and we call by the name of religion? That behavior described above, here repeated as follows:
Religion is a human behavior founded upon a belief in an unknown power resulting in affections and actions intended to influence the power to react favorably to the believer.
By 'influence' we mean moral causality as opposed to physical causality. If the causality is physical, then it's not religion, it's science and technology.
What about philosophy? Here is Res Oir Amsus' definition of philosophy for our times:
Philosophy is the ceaseless search for the programming that exists or might exist or should exist in everything by speculative thinking.
In philosophy there is no attempt at any causality whether moral or physical on any unknown or known powers; there is just the endeavor by speculative thinking to arrive at the programming that exists or might exist or should exist in everything.
When a philosophical thinker comes to the idea of a programming which he thinks should exist to order man's body, heart and mind, then he might take efforts to realize the programming or ordering of man, for example: communism, capitalism.
That's why communism and capitalism are politico-economic philosophies but not religions, because there is no attempt at influencing any unknown power(s), i.e., by moral causality.
What then is moral causality? Essentially it consists in affections and actions to move the unknown power to act or not act, for example saying please to the power on on your knees, or meditating on your haunches.
And what is physical causality? All the chain of processes you set going, when you turn on the electrical switch or strike a match or, say, pull the trigger.
-----------
I have, or at least I came up with one.
The sine qua non of a religion is that it places a great deal of emphasis on something that is ineffable and usually poorly defined and is also said to exist in a real sense.
Under this, Buddhism would be a religion. So would, in some instances, Communism (dialectical materialism) and Capitalism (the invisible hand), and Taoism (the Tao).
Since people do commonly use the term "religion" to describe Communism and/or Capitalism, it seems to fit well with common usage.
It's just that the ineffable thing is often a god, and the emphasis is often faith or something like that.
Note that all three elements have to be present. I'm sure we all remember from 5th grade that in Euclidean geometry, points, lines, and planes are undefined. Euclidean geometry isn't a religion, because there's no pretense that these things really exist, and not a great deal of importance is placed on "point nature." (One could construct a religion out of Euclidean geometry; the "perfect solid" notion of the solar system that Kepler wasted so much of his time on would qualify, I think.)
Feel free to rip it apart, but this is the best definition I've been able to come up with.
Note that all three elements have to be present. -- Epepke
Perhaps, dear Epepke, you might want to tell us specifically and exactly, what these three elements are which have to be present in the best definition of religion, you have been able to come up with.
Yrreg