Budhism Is Not A Religion

*shrugs*

All I know is, with the exception of certain Buddhists on this forum, every Buddhist I've personally known has adopted either Shinto or Hindi gods as part of their Buddhism. Given that I'm largely exposed to Korean Buddhists, and the occasional Indian Buddhist, that may be a cultural artifact. If so, I stand corrected, of course.

Many Buddhist directions include gods, yes. When Buddhism was spread to other countries, it adapted to local cultures and their beliefs and religions was assimilated into Buddhism. You can be a Buddhist and believe in all sort of gods, there's nothing that 'forbids' it. In theory, you can even be a Christian and a Buddhist. I know in New York there are several Christian Zen centers.

In Japan, most people are both Buddhists and Shinto, so their belief in Shinto gods comes directly from Shinto, not from Buddhism. Japanese Zen Buddhism is an atheistic religion.

But Gautama Buddha himself was an agnostic. He once said that if there are gods, they are obviously as flawed and prone to desire/craving/attachments as mortal humans.
 
Perhaps, but that definition of karma is demonstrably wrong. Rotten bastards are quite often some of the happiest people around. Having no conscience will do that.

Well, the whole thread is a discussion of semantics, is it not? It is trying to define what is a religion. Here's my take on it.

Religion = worship of or belief in a god.
God = supernatural entity which has power over your life or soul.

I've heard Buddhists argue that karma is not supernatural, similar to what you said above, and in that case, it is arguably not a religion. The vast majority of "karma" believers that I've met (and admittedly, many of them are pagans, not Buddhists) believe that karma is something that pays you back for being a rotten bastard and rewards you for being a nice guy, usually, but not always, in the next life.


My understanding of karma is that if you don't reach "enlightenment" in this life, you are destined to be reborn (possibly as a gnat!) so that you will have another chance. The object is to reach enlightenment and not be reborn. That is the antithesis of a desirable "afterlife."

Comments, anyone?

M.
 
My understanding of karma is that if you don't reach "enlightenment" in this life, you are destined to be reborn (possibly as a gnat!) so that you will have another chance. The object is to reach enlightenment and not be reborn. That is the antithesis of a desirable "afterlife."

Comments, anyone?

M.
the majority of Buddhist sects do not belive in reincarntion. So whilst your understanding may be true for some sects, it is by no means universaly accurate.Karma is basicly a way of saying "your actions will have consequences".
 
Perhaps, but that definition of karma is demonstrably wrong. Rotten bastards are quite often some of the happiest people around. Having no conscience will do that.
</p>True, but for those members of soceity who are not psycopaths, the general principel will hold true. Guilt can ruin your happyness, treat people badly and they are unlikley to treat you well in return. There may be exceptions to these points, but I contend that they will hold true for the vast majority of the population.
 
the majority of Buddhist sects do not belive in reincarntion. So whilst your understanding may be true for some sects, it is by no means universaly accurate.Karma is basicly a way of saying "your actions will have consequences".

I think even a gnat knows that "actions will have consequences."

My point is that in Buddhism, reincarnation is not something to be sought after.

The aim of enlightenment is to step off this "wheel of becoming."

Recognizing that "actions have consequences" ought to go a long way toward ensuring that one becomes less stupid/moronic/idiotic. Not so?

Personally, the perfect chili dog has yet to be created.

M.
 
I'm afraid karma rewards or punishes no one.

First off, most Buddhist denominations (except Tibetan Buddhism, and probably a few other minor sects as well) reject the concepts of soul and reincarnation. Gautama Buddha himself rejected both. When you have no soul and no reincarnation, your understanding of karma must be rejected.

To understand karma, you must see beyond the individual. Karma works on a greater scale. If a people do bad things, those actions will reflect on the future of that people. One generation doesn't reinforce the levees, future generations suffer for it. One generations turns their government over to terrorists and fundamentalists, and future generations suffer from it. One generations spends too much money on things that does not advance society, and future generations suffer for it.

Karma, along with nirvana, is one of the most misunderstood concepts of Buddhism. One of the reasons for the misunderstandings is that the Buddha stole words from his contemporaries, but changed their meanings. No doubt, had the Buddha been born now and raised in a Christian country, karma would've been sin and nirvana would've been heaven.


What an abundance of tripe you bring to this place. Karma is what becomes of your silly ideas about karma, and Buddhism, and a "metaphor for life," etc. etc.

There is no misunderstanding, only a misapprehension.

M.
 
I am not saying that Buddhism is not faith based, but I have never seen a workable definition of "religion" which did not contain a theistic element.

I have, or at least I came up with one.

The sine qua non of a religion is that it places a great deal of emphasis on something that is ineffable and usually poorly defined and is also said to exist in a real sense.

Under this, Buddhism would be a religion. So would, in some instances, Communism (dialectical materialism) and Capitalism (the invisible hand), and Taoism (the Tao).

Since people do commonly use the term "religion" to describe Communism and/or Capitalism, it seems to fit well with common usage.

It's just that the ineffable thing is often a god, and the emphasis is often faith or something like that.

Note that all three elements have to be present. I'm sure we all remember from 5th grade that in Euclidean geometry, points, lines, and planes are undefined. Euclidean geometry isn't a religion, because there's no pretense that these things really exist, and not a great deal of importance is placed on "point nature." (One could construct a religion out of Euclidean geometry; the "perfect solid" notion of the solar system that Kepler wasted so much of his time on would qualify, I think.)

Feel free to rip it apart, but this is the best definition I've been able to come up with.
 
I have, or at least I came up with one.

The sine qua non of a religion is that it places a great deal of emphasis on something that is ineffable and usually poorly defined and is also said to exist in a real sense.

Under this, Buddhism would be a religion. So would, in some instances, Communism (dialectical materialism) and Capitalism (the invisible hand), and Taoism (the Tao).

Since people do commonly use the term "religion" to describe Communism and/or Capitalism, it seems to fit well with common usage.

It's just that the ineffable thing is often a god, and the emphasis is often faith or something like that.

Note that all three elements have to be present. I'm sure we all remember from 5th grade that in Euclidean geometry, points, lines, and planes are undefined. Euclidean geometry isn't a religion, because there's no pretense that these things really exist, and not a great deal of importance is placed on "point nature." (One could construct a religion out of Euclidean geometry; the "perfect solid" notion of the solar system that Kepler wasted so much of his time on would qualify, I think.)

Feel free to rip it apart, but this is the best definition I've been able to come up with.


Humans seem to be "hard-wired" to turn anything into a religion. Hence the the Fellowship of the Big Mac.

Unlike some here, I'm not on a first-name basis with "the enlightened one" (Buddha) or anyone else. I knew a bricklayer named Jesus once, but that is besides the point. He died of a high-fat diet, and didn't save anyone. Poor beggar couldn't even afford decent healthcare.

Two words: Tom Cruise.

Need I say more?

M.
 
Points, lines, and planes can be portrayed by drawing

I have, or at least I came up with one.

The sine qua non of a religion is that it places a great deal of emphasis on something that is ineffable and usually poorly defined and is also said to exist in a real sense.

Under this, Buddhism would be a religion. So would, in some instances, Communism (dialectical materialism) and Capitalism (the invisible hand), and Taoism (the Tao).

Since people do commonly use the term "religion" to describe Communism and/or Capitalism, it seems to fit well with common usage.

It's just that the ineffable thing is often a god, and the emphasis is often faith or something like that.

Note that all three elements have to be present. I'm sure we all remember from 5th grade that in Euclidean geometry, points, lines, and planes are undefined. Euclidean geometry isn't a religion, because there's no pretense that these things really exist, and not a great deal of importance is placed on "point nature." (One could construct a religion out of Euclidean geometry; the "perfect solid" notion of the solar system that Kepler wasted so much of his time on would qualify, I think.)

Feel free to rip it apart, but this is the best definition I've been able to come up with.

"I'm sure we all remember from 5th grade that in Euclidean geometry, points, lines, and planes are undefined."​
but they can be drawn on a drawing board like a sand box with any writing implement like your finger; then based on the drawings you can construct the Great Wall of China, the Colosseum of Rome and the pyramids of Egypt.

Which you can't do with God and Nirvana, unless you reduce them to points, lines, and planes, but then you wouldn't do them justice -- not that I am proclaiming myself a theist from rational considerations, much less a believer in Nirvana from trying Buddhism and reaching enlightenment.

Yrreg
 
Defintion of religion from Res Oir Amsus, from consulting users of the word

My favorite opinion-maker, Res Oir Amsus, defines religion thus:

Religion is a human behavior founded upon a belief in an unknown power resulting in affections and actions intended to influence the power to react favorably to the believer.​


​

He reaches this definition of religion by studying peoples of different languages, having a definite name in their respective languages for a similar behavior, which we call by the name of religion.

And what is that similar behavior in peoples with different languages, which Res Oir Amsus and we call by the name of religion? That behavior described above, here repeated as follows:

Religion is a human behavior founded upon a belief in an unknown power resulting in affections and actions intended to influence the power to react favorably to the believer.​


​

By 'influence' we mean moral causality as opposed to physical causality. If the causality is physical, then it's not religion, it's science and technology.

What about philosophy? Here is Res Oir Amsus' definition of philosophy for our times:

Philosophy is the ceaseless search for the programming that exists or might exist or should exist in everything by speculative thinking.​

In philosophy there is no attempt at any causality whether moral or physical on any unknown or known powers; there is just the endeavor by speculative thinking to arrive at the programming that exists or might exist or should exist in everything.

When a philosophical thinker comes to the idea of a programming which he thinks should exist to order man's body, heart and mind, then he might take efforts to realize the programming or ordering of man, for example: communism, capitalism.

That's why communism and capitalism are politico-economic philosophies but not religions, because there is no attempt at influencing any unknown power(s), i.e., by moral causality.

What then is moral causality? Essentially it consists in affections and actions to move the unknown power to act or not act, for example saying please to the power on on your knees, or meditating on your haunches.

And what is physical causality? All the chain of processes you set going, when you turn on the electrical switch or strike a match or, say, pull the trigger.

-----------

I have, or at least I came up with one.

The sine qua non of a religion is that it places a great deal of emphasis on something that is ineffable and usually poorly defined and is also said to exist in a real sense.

Under this, Buddhism would be a religion. So would, in some instances, Communism (dialectical materialism) and Capitalism (the invisible hand), and Taoism (the Tao).

Since people do commonly use the term "religion" to describe Communism and/or Capitalism, it seems to fit well with common usage.

It's just that the ineffable thing is often a god, and the emphasis is often faith or something like that.

Note that all three elements have to be present. I'm sure we all remember from 5th grade that in Euclidean geometry, points, lines, and planes are undefined. Euclidean geometry isn't a religion, because there's no pretense that these things really exist, and not a great deal of importance is placed on "point nature." (One could construct a religion out of Euclidean geometry; the "perfect solid" notion of the solar system that Kepler wasted so much of his time on would qualify, I think.)

Feel free to rip it apart, but this is the best definition I've been able to come up with.

Note that all three elements have to be present. -- Epepke​
​

Perhaps, dear Epepke, you might want to tell us specifically and exactly, what these three elements are which have to be present in the best definition of religion, you have been able to come up with.


Yrreg
 
Who knows what the Buddha taught?

You and I may feel that what the buddha taught was not a religion, but after 2,500 years it has become a faith based religion in many areas. I do not consider this to be what the buddha taught. But a google search on the word 'merit' and buddhism will point out that about seventy percent religion and faith in current development.
I do not consider this to be what the buddha taught. -- Dancing David​
​
-------------

Tell me, Dancing David, at what time the earliest written records of Buddha's teaching appeared in the history of manuscripts? And how the writers of these records came to know what teachings to be genuinely authentic teachings of the Buddha?*

You seem to harbor the complacency of possessing the true teachings of Buddha as opposed to a lot of spurious accretions from outside his lifetime and his clime.

I would not be so sure if I were you -- and you claim to be a skeptical critic of Buddhism.

That is why you should rather find out what is the most conventionally agreed upon broad lineaments of beliefs and observances the greatest number of people calling themselves Buddhists concur on to profess and propound; then tell us what you can and cannot accept as a Buddhist -- if indeed you also call yourself a Buddhist; and no longer claim to adhere to the true teachings of Buddha, unlike so many others who mix truths taught by the Buddha with a lot of superstitious impurities.


Yrreg

*That's why the Buddhists in this forum have no valid reasons to take me to task for not being disposed to spend time and labor to search the sutras for the teachings of Buddha, for insisting that I would rather look up the standard established reference works like encyclopedias of religions and manuals of comparative religion -- when they themselves are at dissonance on what the true teachings or Buddha are indeed.
 
Sir, then your definition of religion, please?

As I've said often enough in here, I'm a Buddhist, an atheist and a sceptic. My religion is Buddhism, and Buddhism is my religion.

But good luck finding a definition of 'religion' where both theistic religions and Buddhism fits equally well.

Ryokan is a man who can explain to his own satisfaction and the satisfaction of fellow Buddhists, what is the non-self in Buddhism, and gets impatient so as to lose his Buddhist equanimity with people who still can't accept that he makes any sense with his conceptual scaffolding of non-self.

Now that he tells us:

My religion is Buddhism, and Buddhism is my religion. -- Ryokan​
​

That is absolutely and most certainly a very definitively categorical statement.

Now, the whole world is waiting for him to define religion for us to know what he means by proclaiming most unreservedly:

My religion is Buddhism, and Buddhism is my religion. -- Ryokan​
​


Let's see how long we have to wait.


Yrreg
 
"I'm sure we all remember from 5th grade that in Euclidean geometry, points, lines, and planes are undefined."​
but they can be drawn on a drawing board like a sand box with any writing implement like your finger; then based on the drawings you can construct the Great Wall of China, the Colosseum of Rome and the pyramids of Egypt.

Yes, that's true. You can approximate them well enough for someone to get an intuitive understanding. But, still, they're left undefined in a mathematical sense.

This is good enough for Euclidean geometry, though it isn't good enough for topology, which is why knot theory uses small hoses instead of lines.
 
Perhaps, dear Epepke, you might want to tell us specifically and exactly, what these three elements are which have to be present in the best definition of religion, you have been able to come up with.

I did. But everything looks better in LaTeX, so I'll try again:

[latex]\forall~religions~R~\exists ~X:
\begin{enumerate}
\item R involves a high emphasis on X
\item R holds X to be ineffable
\item R holds X to exist in a real sense
\end{enumerate}[/latex]
 
Now that he tells us:

My religion is Buddhism, and Buddhism is my religion. -- Ryokan​
​

That is absolutely and most certainly a very definitively categorical statement.

Now, the whole world is waiting for him to define religion for us to know what he means by proclaiming most unreservedly:

My religion is Buddhism, and Buddhism is my religion. -- Ryokan​
​


Let's see how long we have to wait.

I don't reply much to your posts, yrreg, because I feel like I'm just participating in a monologue, and because you have a habit of making bold statements without backing them up with evidence or sources.

The reason for my categorical statement is that the world seems to have come to an agreement that Buddhism is a religion. I'm not ashamed of being a Buddhist, and although I feel Buddhism is more a philosophy than a religion, I have no problem answering the question 'What is your religion?' with 'I'm a Buddhist'.
 
Under this, Buddhism would be a religion. So would, in some instances, Communism (dialectical materialism) and Capitalism (the invisible hand), and Taoism (the Tao).

Since people do commonly use the term "religion" to describe Communism and/or Capitalism, it seems to fit well with common usage.

.

Sorry, any definition of "religion" which includes communism and capitalism just because "people do commonly use the term religion to describe [them]" would render the whole concept of religion as meaningless.

people commonly use the word "science" to describe ID, that doesn't make it so.

Ho weave thinking about it if you add a 4th point, which is that a religion must have a ritualised practise for "worship", you would be getting towards possibly the best definition of religion i could find, which covers Buddhism, as well as theistic religions, whilst excluding political beliefs or hobbies.
 
What an abundance of tripe you bring to this place. Karma is what becomes of your silly ideas about karma, and Buddhism, and a "metaphor for life," etc. etc.

There is no misunderstanding, only a misapprehension.

M.

Excuse me..? :boxedin:

I may have some 'silly ideas' on karma and Buddhism, but metaphor for life?! You must be confusing me with someone else...

This is the first time since I joined this board someone has made me feel not welcome.
 
Ryokan - don't let Moochie get to you. He has a few personal issues he needs to work on.
 
no people do not pray to budha

In theory, perhaps. In practice, people pray to the Buddha.


you may see people who look like they are doing it.

If they are, they are not meant to.

budha is not a source of worship.

most real budhists know this.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom