Budhism Is Not A Religion

I agree, Buddhism is to complex to discuss it here (along with lots of other subjects, but what can we do about it, this place is to discuss and learn). Still, its the only "religious system" that allows you to have "spirituality" without gods or souls, and this alone makes it more compatible with skepticism that other religions.

Furthermore, in a way, I have to tell that some branches of it (like Zen) encourage you to be more skeptic than a "normal" skeptic. How much? Well, you have to doubt what you see, what you think is the world, and what you consider to be "you".

How many skeptics doubt that much? ;-)
 
That depends on your theorhetical bias, a behavioral materialist would say the self in no more than chemical interactions in a reverberating nueral network. A more spiritual immaterialist would say that there are transcendant qualities to consciousness such as 'qualia' that can not be 'reduced'.

I don't think that it even requires any theoretical bias, just the limitations on what we know.

We know from neurology that there are parts of the brain that can do speech, writing, and logic, and that they are connected fairly tightly together. We know that this subsystem sometimes produces such utterances as "I think, therefore I am." But all that is is those parts of the brain describing the model they use.

Nietzsche suggested that we don't know enough to be sure that "I think thoughts" is an accurate description, and "thoughts think themselves" might be just as good. Of course, he lived a long time ago, but I don't think that anything we've learned since then weakens that argument.

Consider split-brain patients. They often report reaching for clothes that they did not want to wear. It seems that the halves of the brain are operating more-or-less independently, and the half of the brain doing the reaching disagrees with the half of the brain that can talk. So where is the "I" in this?
 
Good post, epepke. I totally agree with you :)

(at least if you meant that last question as halfway rhethorical)

ETA : Spelling
 
Last edited:
Again, one thing is to think about it. Think its easy (the interesting part is that we think this from the very I that is doubted).

But another very different (inconceivable different) is to actually let the world to see "itself", in other words, let the ego disolve and let "you" become part of the noumena, forgetting phenomena.

Ahh!



(Now some guys are just happy to think about that intriguing possibility, from the comfort of their own ego. This is perfectly ok, but I dont see the point on discussing Buddhism if you are not going to submerge yourself in it. All you will be doing is discussing words, like we have seen in these threads regarding Buddhism).
 
Again, one thing is to think about it. Think its easy (the interesting part is that we think this from the very I that is doubted).

But another very different (inconceivable different) is to actually let the world to see "itself", in other words, let the ego disolve and let "you" become part of the noumena, forgetting phenomena.

Ahh!

(Now some guys are just happy to think about that intriguing possibility, from the comfort of their own ego. This is perfectly ok, but I dont see the point on discussing Buddhism if you are not going to submerge yourself in it. All you will be doing is discussing words, like we have seen in these threads regarding Buddhism).

Spoken like a true mystic.

So people are effing your ineffable using language. And what is this talk about other people's ego, if not a means for you to stroke your own ego and advertise it?
 
Oops a missunderstanding!

Im stating that you need and ego to see the world, nothing else implied. Should I use an "I" instead of an "ego" in the future?

The only difference about talking about this and becoming it is "the level of awareness" (horrible terminology, sorry about that). The "ineffable" I talk about is not mystical, just a different perspective from where one can see what is called world. A perspective that results as real as the one we have while living "a normal life".
 
Im stating that you need and ego to see the world, nothing else implied. Should I use an "I" instead of an "ego" in the future?

I think that would be better, if that's what you mean.

The only difference about talking about this and becoming it is "the level of awareness" (horrible terminology, sorry about that). The "ineffable" I talk about is not mystical, just a different perspective from where one can see what is called world. A perspective that results as real as the one we have while living "a normal life".

The "ineffable" I refer to is your seeming assuredness that you can suss out other people's minds and therefore claim a difference.

People are talking about things because this is a forum for talking about things. You've asserted that you're pretty sure what other people have access to, by virtue of the fact that they talk about things, but what do you really know about other people's minds?
 
Good post, epepke. I totally agree with you :)

(at least if you meant that last question as halfway rhethorical)

I think it's pretty rhetorical. Maybe I've just learned that rhetorical questions work on Buddhists. Maybe not. I'm not sure.

In any event, all this talk of "self," to me, has a kind of mid-18th-century flavor to it.
 
You've asserted that you're pretty sure what other people have access to, by virtue of the fact that they talk about things

I said, that its fairly easy to know who has been in that perspective, and that in order to discuss it, we need a common frame of reference.
 
Last edited:
If your version of Buddhism involves the concept of karma, then it is indeed a religion, because it involves some supernatural "thing" (even if it is unnamed) making decisions about what to do with your soul.
I'm not a Buddhist but I'd like to point out that if you should stick your hand in a fire nothing in the universe make any specific decision to teach you a lesson.

Buddhism has many sects, but I don't think the idea of any outside judging agent deciding (and enforcing) what's to happen to you in your next life figures into things very much. If anything, I'd say in Buddhist metaphysics it's probably the individual themselves who chooses to work off negative karma in their next life during some transient between-life state.
_
HypnoPsi
 
~"Materialism is the philosophy of the subject who forgets to take account of himself" (Arthur Schopenhauer)~

:-)

(note, nope, I sympathize with Zen and Advaita traditions, but also with skepticism and science in general. I do not consider that I can "label" myself, so Im not saying that "materialists" are wrong or that "subjectivists" are right by smiling at part of the signature of HypnoPsi. I just like the phrase).

(the things one has to do in order to not be missunderstood in this forum!!!)
 
Last edited:
Again, one thing is to think about it. Think its easy (the interesting part is that we think this from the very I that is doubted).

But another very different (inconceivable different) is to actually let the world to see "itself", in other words, let the ego disolve and let "you" become part of the noumena, forgetting phenomena.
I am not sure what that means, I can't quite parse it. Which may be the intention. There is perception, and then reactions to perceptions, so which is this noumena?

It seems that you are speaking of unfettered perception without cognition or memory, or are you discussing perception without perceptual organs?

Aumgn ha.
 
Non dualist perception. When there is no more I and objects around. Some call it "inmersion on the substance", in Zen is "the man and the bull are forgotten", its also called "pure awareness", Shunyata, the void, Kensho, Satori and lots of other things.

But the point is that all these concepts and names are wrong.
 
Pseudo ranting on sources adn labels

Ruyokan #92 said:
Originally Posted by yrreg :
What or who gives you the idea that I am quoting from Buddhist sources? Did I give any indications at all that I am quoting from Buddhist sources? Please read carefully those posts from me where I mentioned those stories, and see whether I gave any indications at all that I am citing from Buddhist sources​

I haven't got that idea at all. I have no idea what the source is, that's why I'm asking. Why won't you reveal your source to us, Yrreg? Why?

Originally Posted by yrreg :
In which case you don't have to call yourself a Buddhist, just call yourself a, for example, Truist-Pathist; and admit that you got your beliefs and practices from Buddha's allegedly original teachings, but they are good enough even without Buddha's saying so; just as the Theory of Relativity and the Theory of Evolution are good enough if people don't know absolutely nothing about Einstein and Darwin. You make so much of being called a Buddhist, that I do have the impression that you are a cultist -- no offense intended with the name, though.​

How many times must I explain to you that Buddhism is not named after Gautama Buddha, Yrreg? Buddhism is named after the experience all Buddhists seek, that of enlightenment.

I have explained this to you so many times now, I'm getting tired doing it over and over again. I don't see the point in further discussion with you.

Farewell, Yrreg.

I haven't got that idea at all. I have no idea what the source is, that's why I'm asking. Why won't you reveal your source to us, Yrreg? Why? -- Ryokan

Maybe the source is too modest and does not want to be revealed for his own personal reasons, starting with modesty.

But he tells me that you should study the thoughts in his words and decide whether they are worth anything of your intelligent attention -- and not to say that those words came from the a* of Yrreg because Yrreg retells them -- hahaha softly.

Maybe this bashful source is a present day Buddha but with the serious injunction on people who happen to read his words to not tell anyone that it is from him, unlike with the historical Buddha whose name is invoked by people who claim that his teachings are good enough in themselves, without any attribution to him, and yet continue to say that if anyone calls himself a Buddhist then it is most probable that he is one.

Maybe I read in his writings that whoever makes any mention of his ideas should not in any way and by any means reveal his identity, but just to tell people to think about his ideas and see whether they make any sense to themselves; because he says that if the words do not make any sense, even should they come from the historical Buddha they will just make people think even though they mean nothing sensible in modern times -- but since they come purportedly from the historical Buddha, people like Buddhist enthusaists of the West will just keep on imagining all kinds of most subtle meanings in them.

Maybe the source tells me that Ryokan should develop the habit of not seeking for hidden or absymally profound meanings in words which their authors, for example the historical Buddha, never ever even so much as dreamed about.

And lastly, maybe the source tells me that Ryokan and all Buddhists should stop finding out what Buddha said, and the habit also of finding out who said what, but concentrate instead on the words themselves, and see whether they make sense or not, and period -- in other words, strip all ipse dixit complex from your intellelctual baggage.

---------------

How many times must I explain to you that Buddhism is not named after Gautama Buddha, Yrreg? Buddhism is named after the experience all Buddhists seek, that of enlightenment. -- Ryokan

Well, then remove that description of yourself as Resident Buddhist and stop saying that you are proud to call yourself a Buddhist, Buddhism is your religion or philosophy; just call yourself as I proposed earlier, 4Truist-8Pathist, or now better, an Enlightenist, or best a [/]Nirvanist[/i] (if you are after Nirvana in this life, that is).

Why? Because if a name is used in a label, like for example Randian, then it is logical to presume that the person using that label is dependent upon the authority of the person owning that name; he may deny it, but his speech will show his true psychology even if he himself does not know nor admit it.

----------

I will be back. In the meantime, have a good laugh, that is the key to enlightenment; too much solemnity beclouds everything otherwise so lucid


Yrreg
 
you may see people who look like they are doing it.

If they are, they are not meant to.

budha is not a source of worship.

most real budhists know this.
There are numerous forms of Buddhism, and some do pray directly to Lord Buddha as they are taught. Other forms have ceremonies which have all the aspects of relgious ritual.

I surmise you lean toward the Ch'an or Zen form of Buddhism which certainly is non-religious in practice and does not deify Sakyamuni, the historical Buddha. But please do not make the mistake of thinking your version is the only correct version. That simply is not the case. http://en.wikipedia.org./wiki/Buddhism
 
Non dualist perception. When there is no more I and objects around. Some call it "inmersion on the substance", in Zen is "the man and the bull are forgotten", its also called "pure awareness", Shunyata, the void, Kensho, Satori and lots of other things.

But the point is that all these concepts and names are wrong.
Yes.

Do not mistake the finger pointing at the moon for the moon itself. ;)
 
Don't march off in exasperation.

Yrreg #116 said:
From Yrreg
In which case you don't have to call yourself a Buddhist, just call yourself a, for example, Truist-Pathist; and admit that you got your beliefs and practices from Buddha's allegedly original teachings, but they are good enough even without Buddha's saying so; just as the Theory of Relativity and the Theory of Evolution are good enough if people don't know absolutely nothing about Einstein and Darwin. You make so much of being called a Buddhist, that I do have the impression that you are a cultist -- no offense intended with the name, though. -- Yrreg

From Ryokan
How many times must I explain to you that Buddhism is not named after Gautama Buddha, Yrreg? Buddhism is named after the experience all Buddhists seek, that of enlightenment.

I have explained this to you so many times now, I'm getting tired doing it over and over again. I don't see the point in further discussion with you. -- Ryokan

From Yrreg
Well, then remove that description of yourself as Resident Buddhist and stop saying that you are proud to call yourself a Buddhist, Buddhism is your religion or philosophy; just call yourself as I proposed earlier, 4Truist-8Pathist, or now better, an Enlightenist, or best a Nirvanist (if you are after Nirvana in this life, that is).

Why? Because if a name is used in a label, like for example Randian, then it is logical to presume that the person using that label is dependent upon the authority of the person owning that name; he may deny it, but his speech will show his true psychology even if he himself does not know nor admit it. -- Yrreg

Honestly, I find it hard to understand Buddhists here, specially their apparently most revered spokesman, Ryokan (Resident Buddhist); because they use common words and expressions but give them their own meanings; and then also in regard to Ryokan I have a hard time trying to get definite answers from him.

That is why I accuse them of using double-talk, and got a confirmation of this attitude at least if not policy of theirs, when I read in a common consensus and declaration by a convention of various sects of Buddhists in the USA (yes, I know that Ryokan is not an American from his messages here), that they are not against the existence of God and the soul, but they give their own meanings to these words.*

For example at present I tried to check on what exactly Ryokan believes about Nirvana: Does he or doesn't he believe in Nirvana and in what sense. The most I can get from the nearest message from him as I work on this post is that Nirvana does not occur after death, but is supposed to occur during a Buddhist's lifetime, because there is no existence after death.

But I and you will not read something with finality in so many words from him saying the following essential statement: I believe in Nirvana.

If he is around, maybe he can say with definite finality: "I believe in Nirvana in a person's lifetime;" then he can go on to tell us what kind of Nirvana he believes in.

I think he does not see this kind of talk from himself, but that is my impression; and I invite posters here to share with me their impressions in this regard, generally from Buddhists, and in particular from Ryokan.

If and when he does reply to this request from yours truly, about Nirvana, let's see whether he will be wishy-washy or say something definite. You know what, he might as from his habit, react with a question asking me for evidence that he is wishy-washy in his language. Okay, let's not preempt his reaction.

---------------------

Ryokan also has the habit of complaining that he has already answered my questions and explained his answers, but I am not attending to them, instead I keep on repeating my questions and bringing up again the same objections to Buddhist beliefs and observances.

Indicating that whereas the whole world already knows about the answers and explanations from Buddhists about their beliefs and observances, it is only Yrreg who keeps on bringing them up again and again to his (Ryan's) exasperation.

So, he marches off with a "Farewell, Yrreg."

What do I say about that? I think that is his privilege; and I will miss him, because over and above Buddhism is the spirit of camaraderie, even some kind of negative camaraderie that should prevail among us here in this JREF forum, just like passengers in the same bus every morning and evening we have grown also familiar with each other's presence whether in delight or in gloom.

Tell you what, Ryokan, if you really feel justified in being querulous about my repetitious objections against Buddhism, I still recommend that you continue here to answer me and to explain your answers, patiently and with Buddhist joy if that be possible, not for my sake, but in view of any new members and guests here who might profit from your answers and explanations, and thereby find meaning in life from Buddhism or encouragement to continue in Buddhism.

Buddhism would not be around today, unlike some religions which are now studied by people interested in antiquities, if you Buddhist guys march away every time you meet recalcitrant opponents from guys like Yrreg.


Yrreg

*Yes, some Buddhists will challenge me about cites on that assertion. If you are good Buddhists then you should look that up yourselves; that's one way I use to find out whether you people are really generous with your time and labor on behalf of your profession of Buddhism. Incidentally, don't conclude from my mention of God and soul that I am a theist and an "animist" from religious or even just rational considerations.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom