Budhism Is Not A Religion

Hear, hear, people proud to call themselves Buddhists.

Certainly, we can dispense with all the supernatural stuff about achieving an end to Suffering via Nirvana, and simply adopt the Noble Eightfold Path without the encumbrance of its metaphysical aim. In that case, it is no different from a personal moral code. Just as a person who chooses not to steal, kill , covet his neighbour and generally live a moral life does not necessarily have to be a Christian, so why the need to define ourselves as Buddhists? This was the reason I stopped calling myself a Buddhist.

Anyhow, a Buddhist of any flavour should understand that labels are meaningless. :)

Exactly what I am telling the Buddhists here: if they remove everything woo-ish from Buddhism, then it is just a naturalistic code of conduct to be a good peaceable man within oneself and with one's fellow humans; which code is common to civilized societies even prescinding from any philosophy and religion, and common in any philosophy and religion that civilized society will allow, tolerate in its entrails to keep the community well-ordered and keep members in harmony and useful to each other.

Now, as regards Nirvana, however the Buddhists define it and whether attainable in this life or beyond the grave, it is still woo-ish; because I ask who or what is in charge of measuring the worth of Eightfold Path acts sufficient enough to gain Nirvana for the faithful observant Buddhist? a physical agent like gravity or magnetism? or some agent not of the physical world, then of what world if not woo-ish, i.e., supernatural?


Yrreg
 
yrreg
Exactly what I am telling the Buddhists here: if they remove everything woo-ish from Buddhism, then it is just a naturalistic code of conduct to be a good peaceable man within oneself and with one's fellow humans; which code is common to civilized societies even prescinding from any philosophy and religion, and common in any philosophy and religion that civilized society will allow, tolerate in its entrails to keep the community well-ordered and keep members in harmony and useful to each other.
Buddhism isn't just anything...

anything that can be reduced into what one would like it to be reduced.


Now, as regards Nirvana, however the Buddhists define it and whether attainable in this life or beyond the grave, it is still woo-ish; because I ask who or what is in charge of measuring the worth of Eightfold Path acts sufficient enough to gain Nirvana for the faithful observant Buddhist? a physical agent like gravity or magnetism? or some agent not of the physical world, then of what world if not woo-ish, i.e., supernatural?

Yrreg
Measuring? 206.225.95.123/forumlive/showthread.php?p=1372811#post1372811
 
Exactly what I am telling the Buddhists here: if they remove everything woo-ish from Buddhism, then it is just a naturalistic code of conduct to be a good peaceable man within oneself and with one's fellow humans; which code is common to civilized societies even prescinding from any philosophy and religion, and common in any philosophy and religion that civilized society will allow, tolerate in its entrails to keep the community well-ordered and keep members in harmony and useful to each other.
There are truths to what you say, however the buddha's teaching have some very unique elements that are not found in other places, I feel that parts of the eightfold path and the other virtues are unque in the record of human thought. They may have existed and been taught prior to the historic buddha, but the teachings are the first know example of the comprehensive compilation of those thoughts and beliefs.

In fact they were directly oppossed by the followewrs of Confucious, another product of asia that teaches self control and societal harmony. So not all naturalistic teachings will agree with each other.

Have you found any records for the eigtfold path or the four truths that predate the buddha?
Now, as regards Nirvana, however the Buddhists define it and whether attainable in this life or beyond the grave, it is still woo-ish; because I ask who or what is in charge of measuring the worth of Eightfold Path acts sufficient enough to gain Nirvana for the faithful observant Buddhist?
An individual themselves if the only one that can make that choice. And by some teachings nibbanna is not a place, it is a state of mind that can be described very acurately without any reference to any woo elements.

The state of nibbanna is this: to have practice in techniques which eliminate or reduce thought patterns to achieve an ability to act freely in thought and deed. The reduction of attachment to ideas, the view of approaching all things with a balanced view which takes into account the uniqueness of each situation and it's unique history without any thought or act habits which might impede the freedom of choice and lastly an acceptance of things as they are without need to glamorise or detract.

I would be willing to see what is woo about that?
a physical agent like gravity or magnetism? or some agent not of the physical world, then of what world if not woo-ish, i.e., supernatural?
the statements of human are events in the matarial world, one can judge the acts of the mind and self through verbal description and observation.. Where do physical laws come from?

They too are verbal acts.
 
KISS: keep it simple and short.

The state of nibbanna is this: to have practice in techniques which eliminate or reduce thought patterns to achieve an ability to act freely in thought and deed. The reduction of attachment to ideas, the view of approaching all things with a balanced view which takes into account the uniqueness of each situation and it's unique history without any thought or act habits which might impede the freedom of choice and lastly an acceptance of things as they are without need to glamorise or detract.

First, you are filtering Nirvana so that it is the kind you happen to accept. There are you are certain yourself myriads even the greatest majority of Buddhists in the whole world who have a different and even opposite idea of Nirvana.

If you ask me to produce evidence for my statement here above, then I take back that statement.

As regards your own customized definition of Nirvana, allow me to break it up into shorter phrases:

  1. The state of nibbanna is this:
  2. to have practice in techniques
  3. which eliminate or reduce thought patterns
  4. to achieve an ability to act freely in thought and deed.
  5. The reduction of attachment to ideas,
  6. the view of approaching all things with a balanced view
  7. which takes into account
  8. the uniqueness of each situation
  9. and it's unique history
  10. without any thought or act habits
  11. which might impede the freedom of choice
  12. and lastly an acceptance of things
  13. as they are without need to glamorise or detract.

Do I understand you correctly that Nirvana for you then is a state of mind which enables you to view things in your mind in certain ways, and to execute acts from that state of mind?

In which case, please, for the love of humanity and on the assumption that Nirvana is a possible state to acquire, spell that state out in simple language like you would do in writing a manual of operation for your CD player, plus simple trouble shooting tips.

Otherwise, I wonder how anyone even and specially a genius can comprehend your definition of Nirvana.

There, D David, you have your work mapped out for you, how to say Buddhist beliefs and practices in simple intelligible and executable language.


Yrreg
 
The state of nibbanna is this: to have practice in techniques which eliminate or reduce thought patterns to achieve an ability to act freely in thought and deed. The reduction of attachment to ideas, the view of approaching all things with a balanced view which takes into account the uniqueness of each situation and it's unique history without any thought or act habits which might impede the freedom of choice and lastly an acceptance of things as they are without need to glamorise or detract.
Dancing David,

I think this definition is outstanding, and it shows an excellent depth of research. Thanks for spelling it out for me. Yet it is incomplete, though, isn't it? Most Buddhists believe that achieving Nirvana has "after-life" consequences and benefits--one being that as an enlightened being, one can choose to refuse the bliss of a transcendent after-life in favor of returning to earth (reincarnate) in order to bring more people to buddha-hood as a bodhisattva.

This is pretty standard Buddhist fare, isn't it? Why then not include it in your excellent definition of Nirvana?

P.S. I hope this isn't tasking you. I don't let people task me over the internet, and I hope I'm not doing it to you now. :)
 
Last edited:
Dancing David,

I think this definition is outstanding, and it shows an excellent depth of research. Thanks for spelling it out for me. Yet it is incomplete, though, isn't it? Most Buddhists believe that achieving Nirvana has "after-life" consequences and benefits--one being that as an enlightened being, one can choose to refuse the bliss of a transcendent after-life in favor of returning to earth (reincarnate) in order to bring more people to buddha-hood as a bodhisattva.

This is pretty standard Buddhist fare, isn't it?

Nope.

It is pretty standard Hindu fare, but not Buddhist fare. Hinduism and Budddhism cross evolved in the same place/time/culture and due to Hindu-Buddhists some Hindu elements are seen as Buddhist elements.

Go to the source and see the difference.

There are somewhere around 1.32 zillion buddhists who do not subscribe to reincarnation, past lives or any form of afterlife. The remainder are largely Hindu or Christian majors with a minor in Buddhism.
 
First, you are filtering Nirvana so that it is the kind you happen to accept. There are you are certain yourself myriads even the greatest majority of Buddhists in the whole world who have a different and even opposite idea of Nirvana.
I have no idea of the prevalence of which view of nibbanna breaks into the various categories. I aknowledge and have spoken to the overt nature of buddhism as a faith based religion in current practise. I am sceptical of many of the religous and mystics practices of buddhists.

They are in contradiction of the 'teachings of the buddha'.
;)
If you ask me to produce evidence for my statement here above, then I take back that statement.

As regards your own customized definition of Nirvana, allow me to break it up into shorter phrases:

  1. The state of nibbanna is this:
  2. to have practice in techniques
  3. which eliminate or reduce thought patterns
  4. to achieve an ability to act freely in thought and deed.
  5. The reduction of attachment to ideas,
  6. the view of approaching all things with a balanced view
  7. which takes into account
  8. the uniqueness of each situation
  9. and it's unique history
  10. without any thought or act habits
  11. which might impede the freedom of choice
  12. and lastly an acceptance of things
  13. as they are without need to glamorise or detract.

Do I understand you correctly that Nirvana for you then is a state of mind which enables you to view things in your mind in certain ways, and to execute acts from that state of mind?
The viewing might create fetters and therefore it would be beyond that. I doubt I will be able to speak directly on the subject myself.
In which case, please, for the love of humanity and on the assumption that Nirvana is a possible state to acquire, spell that state out in simple language like you would do in writing a manual of operation for your CD player, plus simple trouble shooting tips.
I hope that they aren't the instructions I have enountered. It is not my path.
Otherwise, I wonder how anyone even and specially a genius can comprehend your definition of Nirvana.
I don't know, I supopse you you could do a survey of the comprehensibility of my statement.
It was written in about a minute in common psychological speach with out the use of jargon.
There, D David, you have your work mapped out for you, how to say Buddhist beliefs and practices in simple intelligible and executable language.


Yrreg

No need to do so, you asked for a defintion, I am not going to preach nor shall I try to convert. You asked for a statement and you got it, there are many sources which are simple expositions of nibbanna as you have requested. Thich Naht Hahn and many buddhists define nibbanna in this way.
 
Last edited:
Dancing David,

I think this definition is outstanding, and it shows an excellent depth of research. Thanks for spelling it out for me. Yet it is incomplete, though, isn't it? Most Buddhists believe that achieving Nirvana has "after-life" consequences and benefits--one being that as an enlightened being, one can choose to refuse the bliss of a transcendent after-life in favor of returning to earth (reincarnate) in order to bring more people to buddha-hood as a bodhisattva.

This is pretty standard Buddhist fare, isn't it? Why then not include it in your excellent definition of Nirvana?

P.S. I hope this isn't tasking you. I don't let people task me over the internet, and I hope I'm not doing it to you now. :)

Those are standard teaching in the Mahayana schools, and especialy the Amitahba, but I prefer the simpler ones myself. I have no belief in the after life, I am not sure what constitutes a bohdisattva in my materialistic defintion.

I have used Quan Yin in a devotional sense and have prayed to Avalohieshavara at times. But then I am a pagan nihilist buddhist.

I do not include it in my interpretation of nibbanna because it does not match my personal habits and preferences. I may pray but I don't beleive in divine intervention.
 
There are somewhere around 1.32 zillion buddhists who do not subscribe to reincarnation, past lives or any form of afterlife. The remainder are largely Hindu or Christian majors with a minor in Buddhism.

Source for your figures of 1.32 zillion Buddhists, please.

It is true that Buddhism does not believe in an eternal soul. However, it teaches that the "eternal soul" is an illusion, and it is our attachment to the illusion of the "eternal soul" that condemns us to be forever trapped in the cycle of samsara (death and rebirth).

The Jatakas (part of the Pali canon beloved by some "Buddhism has no woo; it's just misunderstood" Buddhists) describe the 547 rebirth stories of the Buddha. The Buddha clearly believes in the existence of his past lives.

In closing the Dhammacakka Sutta, the Buddha says, "This is the last existence; now there is no more rebirth for me." If rebirth is merely about how one's life and teachings have touched others after death, the Buddha's message should have died with him. This contradicts the Buddha's statement.

This site (xxx.buddhanet.net/wheel_d.htm) [replace "x" with "w" as I can't post URLs yet] has a great discourse on the Dhammacakka Sutta, which includes the Buddha's teachings on the Four Noble Truths and the Noble Eightfold Path. Rebirth certainly involves some form of transmigration of the soul into new physical bodies on different planes of existence, and that rebirth is a bad thing that the Buddha sought to remove through his teachings.

I was raised a Buddhist. Though my outlook has veered away from the supernatural, I continue to respect many teachings of Buddhism. I feel that it is intellectually dishonest to whitewash and reinterpret Buddhism into something that it isn't in order to satisfy our sceptical sensibilities.
 
Philosophical theists, and skeptical theists

Ryokan #71 said:
Originally Posted by yrreg :
Consider that there are people who profess theism as a philosophy but not as a religion; we can even find scientific skeptics who accept philosophical theism, but they don't cultivate it as a religion, as for example, Christians, Muslims, and Jews do.

These philosophical theists are not into utilizing their theistic philosophy to acquire a post grave and beyond the grave objective of a transcendental dimension; and they are not after favors from the God in life prior to the grave and of this world.​

-------------

How can you profess theism as a philosophy? Can you show examples of this? -- Ryokan

You can play this new and educational game with the Internet, what I might call a kind of Net Scrabble -- my humble invention.

Put any group of words together that can be apparently meaningful and look it up in the Internet with Google.

For example: philosophical theists, philosophical theism, skeptical theists, skeptical theism.

And see what you will discover.

Don't be surprised if you come across one Martin Gardner who is a professing philosophical and skeptical theist, if you patiently look up enough hits found by Google and read them carefully.

Have fun.


Yrreg
 
Oops, Net Scrabble is a game in the web.

I thought that I have coined a new phrase with Net Scrabble, but after the preceding post I got curious and looked up Net Scrabble with Google, and Google found a good number of hits on that phrase in the web.

---------------

netscrabble3fk.gif


------------

Very awkward.


Yrreg
 
You can play this new and educational game with the Internet, what I might call a kind of Net Scrabble -- my humble invention.

Put any group of words together that can be apparently meaningful and look it up in the Internet with Google.

For example: philosophical theists, philosophical theism, skeptical theists, skeptical theism.

And see what you will discover.

Don't be surprised if you come across one Martin Gardner who is a professing philosophical and skeptical theist, if you patiently look up enough hits found by Google and read them carefully.

Have fun.


Yrreg

Mr. Pott please to meet Mr. Kettle!
 
I feel that it is intellectually dishonest to whitewash and reinterpret Buddhism into something that it isn't in order to satisfy our sceptical sensibilities.
But isn't that exactly what every culture that embraced Buddhism has done? Namely, reinterpret Buddhism into something new. Over the centuries, this is how "Buddhism" came to be such a big tent, with so many different interpretations and traditions.

I don't know if I would call that intellectual dishonesty, although maybe in some cases it is. But I get the sense that the folks who post here are being very intellectually honest, in that they are providing their own interpretations of Buddhism.

I don't see how a person can intellectually reach for Buddhism and explore it without interpreting it (or reinterpreting it) for oneself.

Of course, when one looks at the whole category of "Buddhism" that's out there in the world, it's going to includes lots and lots of seemingly contradictory things. This is a western, skeptical forum, so it's natural that some people will try to offer for discussion an interpretation of Buddhism that seems more relevant within this forum. There clearly are other forms of Buddhism as well.
 
Honesty is my essence and nature and substance plus skepticism.

Yeah, well at least he's honest about it.

Honesty is my essence and nature and substance plus skepticism.

But I most seriously doubt the mental honesty and candor of Buddhists here in the JREF forum, the ones I have met like Ryokan, Username, D David, Complexity, and others. They appear to me to be without pure 100% carat gold and diamond honesty, or more particularly intellectual candor.

But they don't know themselves for what they are; it is natural and endemic for dishonest people to not know themselves to be dishonest.

I am writing this post spontaneously but honestly. And I am very disappointed with the Buddhists here, almost all of them; for while they profess to be true to the original, genuine, authentic, unadulterated, pure, clear, certain, etc., teachings of Buddhism, they are more after winning an argument, having the last word, and in calling people harsh unkind unfair unjustified names, than in patiently explaining to people what exactly is Buddhism in scientific terms, as they should be able were they inured to talk and explain in accordance to what highschool kids learn to be the scientific method.

Merentha is one Buddhist who for having come out of Buddhism, done and over with, can look at it with detachment but with true skeptical criticism, not for the sake of just plain faultfinding criticism, but in order to tell us what exactly Buddhism is all about.

And what is it all about? Honestly, my sentiment is that it is all a grand illusion or delusion whereby the Buddhists here are attached to, because they find it the current fad -- a hundred years will find them out to be in fact faddists; but no need to wait that long, just see what they will be in the next 20 years of their lives, if not shorter.

For I am always wondering what these folks are up to, aside from Buddhism. Do they run a home, lead a family, raise kids? make a living just like the ants and the bees and every John and Jane Does.

Or are they into the luxury of talking about Buddhism and how to get to the true genuine unadulterated pure true teachings of Buddha, when they should they have a bit of cerebral matter inside their skulls know that such teachings of the original Buddha are not and have never been available since the man died and never returned, and he cleverly left no writings preserved however rudimentary now still surviving in certifiably faithful copies.

I have written this post honestly and I hope the Buddhists here can be honest and talk honest, instead of using words to beguile and win arguments and feel so enlightened, smug in their double-talking logorrhea. For example, see that definition of Nirvana by D David, and there be people who think they can make heads and tails of it.

But hahaha softly, I am being carried away by emotions.

So all together now:

Om Mani Padme Hum -- Om Mani Padme Hum -- Om Mani Padme Hum​

Honestly again, No, I haven't read one honest sentence from the Buddhists interacting with me in this JREF forum, it's all rote talking from their masters and from their readings, but never any genuine penetration into what the Buddha is all about if ever he was into anything serious, aside from groaning about the sufferings of life and existence which even the ants and the bees have to bear with but they continue on and on with their life and work, to keep alive and to raise kids to be alive and surviving and continuing their existence in their turns, and improving their survival rating.

But again hahaha softly, I should really not be carried away by emotions.

So again all together now:

Om Mani Padme Hum -- Om Mani Padme Hum -- Om Mani Padme Hum​

Yrreg
 
Wait, I forgot something I wanted to say also.

I have been thinking seriously how to grab the horns of this bull called Buddhism. And I have come to the idea that the best way to do it is to delve into the cibus, potus, coitus, and alimentary refuse of this bull.

So, if soon you come to a thread on Coitus and Buddha, then you will know that I have gathered some enlightening materials on coitus and Buddha from that most convenient research source present to mankind today, the Internet.

------------------

Now, back to Buddhism is not a religion, up to the present I have not come across any formulation from the Buddhists here on a definition of Buddhism that can pass scientific and logic analysis, unlike the one from my favorite opinion maker, Pes Oir Amsus:

Religion is a human behavior founded upon a belief in an unknown power resulting in affections and actions intended by the believer to influence the unknown power to react favorably toward the believer.​
​

This is one definition that will enable anyone to discern a religion when he sees one, by comparing what he sees with the definition here provided by Pes Oir Amsus.

Let's see now, Is Buddhism a religion?

Yes, it is; because it is a belief in a power unknown but believed to be efficacious to the believer, so that the believer elicits affections and actions in order to influence the unknown power to react toward the believer favorably.

What unknown power is in Buddhism? The whole system, the Buddha, the Dharma, the Sangha, most in particular the Buddha.

And what is that favor sought by believers in Buddhism, the Western intellectual socalled types? What else but to be relieved of sufferings of the kinds and degrees they understand sufferings to be, whatever, and to come to the possession of Nirvana, whatever Nirvana is supposed to mean to them if anything at all some kind of a good, a desirable item -- and they are supposed to be after the banishment of desires. Hahahaha softly.

And the actions, what actions do they perform or enact in order that the unknown power will give them things, namely, in their case, help them to rid themselves of their sufferings and get to Nirvana? What else but first meditation and then all those right thinking, right speaking, and right acting.

But if you study them, the Buddhists here, you might just realize that they are not into all the right operations and right non-operations that those monks in Thailand, Burma, and also China, Japan, Tibet are into. They make exceptions.

------------

Now, I challenge the Buddhists here to produce a definition of religion that can pass as scientific and drafted in logic, to compare with the definition of Pes Oir Amsus, my favorite opinion maker.


Paging D Daving: Please redraft your definition of Nirvana to emulate the definition of religion by Pes Oir Amsus, above; so that people can easily discern who is possessed of Nirvana when they see one such person.


Yrreg
 
Lived it, ate it, slept with it.

Originally Posted by username :
There are somewhere around 1.32 zillion buddhists who do not subscribe to reincarnation, past lives or any form of afterlife. The remainder are largely Hindu or Christian majors with a minor in Buddhism.
​

--------------------

Source for your figures of 1.32 zillion Buddhists, please.

It is true that Buddhism does not believe in an eternal soul. However, it teaches that the "eternal soul" is an illusion, and it is our attachment to the illusion of the "eternal soul" that condemns us to be forever trapped in the cycle of samsara (death and rebirth).

The Jatakas (part of the Pali canon beloved by some "Buddhism has no woo; it's just misunderstood" Buddhists) describe the 547 rebirth stories of the Buddha. The Buddha clearly believes in the existence of his past lives.

In closing the Dhammacakka Sutta, the Buddha says, "This is the last existence; now there is no more rebirth for me." If rebirth is merely about how one's life and teachings have touched others after death, the Buddha's message should have died with him. This contradicts the Buddha's statement.

This site (xxx.buddhanet.net/wheel_d.htm) [replace "x" with "w" as I can't post URLs yet] has a great discourse on the Dhammacakka Sutta, which includes the Buddha's teachings on the Four Noble Truths and the Noble Eightfold Path. Rebirth certainly involves some form of transmigration of the soul into new physical bodies on different planes of existence, and that rebirth is a bad thing that the Buddha sought to remove through his teachings.

I was raised a Buddhist. Though my outlook has veered away from the supernatural, I continue to respect many teachings of Buddhism. I feel that it is intellectually dishonest to whitewash and reinterpret Buddhism into something that it isn't in order to satisfy our sceptical sensibilities.

First, Merentha, welcome to this forum.

I am new myself. I thought I would do something different by taking up skeptical criticism of Buddhism, since everyone in the Net is praising Buddhism to the sky. Try this experiment, enter Buddhism in Google search box, and you will find nothing but encomium on Buddhism; it's the hottest kid in the internet block on religion today.

And horror of horrors, when you get to the skeptics' sites, they also have such a most loud silence on criticizing Buddhism, which is worth another most skeptical criticism on skeptics holding Buddhism with kids gloves.

Glad that you have my kind of sentiment in re Buddhism.

As regards how to indicate in your writing here internet reference what they call urls, I am a new hand myself and learned the trade by self-instructions with plenty f trials and errors and darings -- no, don't fear, nothing will happen bad to you or your computer for being experimental with how to do things in writing posts here.

Look up at the bottom of this page to the left, there is a list of things on or off, click on that link vB Code, and you will find instructions on how to do things here in making your posts more functional to readers.

------------------

It is true that Buddhism does not believe in an eternal soul. However, it teaches that the "eternal soul" is an illusion, and it is our attachment to the illusion of the "eternal soul" that condemns us to be forever trapped in the cycle of samsara (death and rebirth).​
​

This is to me a word game, because an illusion implies something that the illuded person is illuded about. Not that I am a believer in the soul, but the use of the word illusion is more into a protestation of non-attachment or giving it no importance, than that the person supposedly illuded does not accept any kind of existence that continues after the death of a person.

So also with all these endless explanations by Buddhists of their concept and insistence on the non-self.

---------------

I will be back, have to get the garbage out for the haulers coming already, with their chimes announcing their proximity in the neighborhood.


But I want to ask you for some time now but always forgot, quickly: What is the Chinese term for Buddhism in the Chinese you use at home and also the more academic terms; are they purely phonetic, meaning as with many English words trans-phonetized into Chinese vocalization, or what. I guess you know what I mean; because I tend to think that Buddhism is a misnomer like Mohammedanism was a misnomer; now the term used is Islam, as the Muslims had been insisting since way back.

I will be back.


Yrreg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom