Hear, hear, people proud to call themselves Buddhists.
Exactly what I am telling the Buddhists here: if they remove everything woo-ish from Buddhism, then it is just a naturalistic code of conduct to be a good peaceable man within oneself and with one's fellow humans; which code is common to civilized societies even prescinding from any philosophy and religion, and common in any philosophy and religion that civilized society will allow, tolerate in its entrails to keep the community well-ordered and keep members in harmony and useful to each other.
Now, as regards Nirvana, however the Buddhists define it and whether attainable in this life or beyond the grave, it is still woo-ish; because I ask who or what is in charge of measuring the worth of Eightfold Path acts sufficient enough to gain Nirvana for the faithful observant Buddhist? a physical agent like gravity or magnetism? or some agent not of the physical world, then of what world if not woo-ish, i.e., supernatural?
Yrreg
Certainly, we can dispense with all the supernatural stuff about achieving an end to Suffering via Nirvana, and simply adopt the Noble Eightfold Path without the encumbrance of its metaphysical aim. In that case, it is no different from a personal moral code. Just as a person who chooses not to steal, kill , covet his neighbour and generally live a moral life does not necessarily have to be a Christian, so why the need to define ourselves as Buddhists? This was the reason I stopped calling myself a Buddhist.
Anyhow, a Buddhist of any flavour should understand that labels are meaningless.![]()
Exactly what I am telling the Buddhists here: if they remove everything woo-ish from Buddhism, then it is just a naturalistic code of conduct to be a good peaceable man within oneself and with one's fellow humans; which code is common to civilized societies even prescinding from any philosophy and religion, and common in any philosophy and religion that civilized society will allow, tolerate in its entrails to keep the community well-ordered and keep members in harmony and useful to each other.
Now, as regards Nirvana, however the Buddhists define it and whether attainable in this life or beyond the grave, it is still woo-ish; because I ask who or what is in charge of measuring the worth of Eightfold Path acts sufficient enough to gain Nirvana for the faithful observant Buddhist? a physical agent like gravity or magnetism? or some agent not of the physical world, then of what world if not woo-ish, i.e., supernatural?
Yrreg