Budhism Is Not A Religion

Please, in normal language

Originally Posted by yrreg :
Perhaps, dear Epepke, you might want to tell us specifically and exactly, what these three elements are which have to be present in the best definition of religion, you have been able to come up with.
​

I did. But everything looks better in LaTeX, so I'll try again:

[latex]\forall~religions~R~\exists ~X:
\begin{enumerate}
\item R involves a high emphasis on X
\item R holds X to be ineffable
\item R holds X to exist in a real sense
\end{enumerate}[/latex]

Please, good and most profound, learned, and subtle Epepke, not flattering either, say those three elements of religion in your view, in normal language as Bodhi Dharma Zen tells us he prefers, in place of rational or metaphysical and I presume mathematical languages.

I want to learn more precisely your definition of religion, and see how it compares with the one given by my favorite opinion maker.

Yreg said:
My favorite opinion-maker, Res Oir Amsus, defines religion thus:

Religion is a human behavior founded upon a belief in an unknown power resulting in affections and actions intended to influence the power to react favorably to the believer.
​

Can you do me the favor, please; as I said some several posts back, I count you as an adviser, teacher, in skeptical criticism.


Yrreg
 
practicing budhists does not adapt anything from anywhere

Um no, I am a Buddhist, and I am also an aitheist, the terms are not mutaly exclusive. (and no, I am not talking abbout "cultural Buddhism" in the same way that you can be a "cultural Jew" or a "cultural Catholic")I am prepared to believe that buddhism is an agnostic religion, or phillosophy, but to say that the worship of any gods (borrowed from wherever) is centeral to "modern buddhism" is just wrong.Oh and BTW excatly which mdoern Buddhist sect is "modern buddhism" ?


and say what they adaptd is part of budhism.
 
it is ok

Excuse me..? :boxedin:

I may have some 'silly ideas' on karma and Buddhism, but metaphor for life?! You must be confusing me with someone else...

This is the first time since I joined this board someone has made me feel not welcome.


they are ideas, even if it seems silly to others, it may make many others to think.

as long as we do not bound our selves, we will grow together.

finding the balace with which to do so, is often the process we do not agree with.
 
definition of a religion

Please, good and most profound, learned, and subtle Epepke, not flattering either, say those three elements of religion in your view, in normal language as Bodhi Dharma Zen tells us he prefers, in place of rational or metaphysical and I presume mathematical languages.

I want to learn more precisely your definition of religion, and see how it compares with the one given by my favorite opinion maker.



Can you do me the favor, please; as I said some several posts back, I count you as an adviser, teacher, in skeptical criticism.


Yrreg


Religion:
* a 'belief' where one's life, while alive and/or after death, is assumed to be determind by a 'superior being'.
* the beliefs are mostly based on unknown or unseen, yet tobe proved, ideas/objects/events/beings.
* has their own laws regarding how a person should live life(which are translated in many ways by many people)

does this help?
personaly, without negativity on your part, i find hard to understand what you are saying in your posts. they dont seem to indicate anything about you. your thoughts. your understanding. i am making this view by only reading yourposts in this thread.

so maybe i should wait...
 
Definitions of religion, a contest of sorts

Originally Posted by yrreg :
Now that he (Ryokan) tells us:

My religion is Buddhism, and Buddhism is my religion. -- Ryokan​

That is absolutely and most certainly a very definitively categorical statement.

Now, the whole world is waiting for him to define religion for us to know what he means by proclaiming most unreservedly:


My religion is Buddhism, and Buddhism is my religion. -- Ryokan


Let's see how long we have to wait.

​
​

I don't reply much to your posts, yrreg, because I feel like I'm just participating in a monologue, and because you have a habit of making bold statements without backing them up with evidence or sources.

The reason for my categorical statement is that the world seems to have come to an agreement that Buddhism is a religion. I'm not ashamed of being a Buddhist, and although I feel Buddhism is more a philosophy than a religion, I have no problem answering the question 'What is your religion?' with 'I'm a Buddhist'.

Dear Ryokan, imagine that before joining this JREF forum there is a requirement that we should write a very succinct definition of religion, what is your definition of religion?

Now that you tell us for you Buddhism is actually a philosophy, suppose you give us your definition of philosophy, also?

I will appreciate your definitions most seriously.


Yrreg
 
Dear Ryokan, imagine that before joining this JREF forum there is a requirement that we should write a very succinct definition of religion, what is your definition of religion?

Now that you tell us for you Buddhism is actually a philosophy, suppose you give us your definition of philosophy, also?

I will appreciate your definitions most seriously.


Yrreg

If that was the requirement, I would probably not have been here. I have problems making a definition of religion, because however I word it, some religions always fall outside my definition.

As for my definiton of philosophy... What's wrong with the original meaning, the love of wisdom? ;) If that's unacceptable, how about a collection of investigations of the nature, causes, or principles of reality, knowledge, or values?
 
yes

If that was the requirement, I would probably not have been here. I have problems making a definition of religion, because however I word it, some religions always fall outside my definition.

As for my definiton of philosophy... What's wrong with the original meaning, the love of wisdom? ;) If that's unacceptable, how about a collection of investigations of the nature, causes, or principles of reality, knowledge, or values?


it could be said that budhism stemed into the science of that time.
 
it could be said that budhism stemed into the science of that time.
I think Taoism is closer to that distinction than Buddhism was. Buddhism, by principle, considers everything objective (phenomenal) absurd and unessential. Taoism was a more dualistic view of the world that embraced both in practice.
 
I have wondered about the issue of what Buddhism is for awhile. Unfortunately, the effort required to form an informed understanding of this has always exceeded my level of interest in the question.

This thread has probably been the most informative source on the topic that I have read, although as usual it seems the answer is a bit ambiguous.

My understanding based on what has been said in this thread:

Assuming a definition of religion something like this, "A belief that some form of supernatural being or beings exist", Buddhism is not necessarily a religion, however many of the most common sects of Buddhism include a belief in supernatural entities and thus are reasonably classed as religions.

Questions:
Do Buddhist sects exist that could be clearly identified as non-religious? If so what are thoses sects?

Are there Buddhist sects that are clearly religious? If so what are those sects? Assuming that they exist do the clearly religous buddhist sects tend to exclude people with other religious beliefs (such as Christianity) or atheists?
 
Last edited:
My understanding of karma is that if you don't reach "enlightenment" in this life, you are destined to be reborn (possibly as a gnat!) so that you will have another chance. The object is to reach enlightenment and not be reborn. That is the antithesis of a desirable "afterlife."

Comments, anyone?

M.

As I have stated in other threads: "That is not a teaching of the buddha", the teachings alleged to be derived from Sidhartha, Gautama Shakyamuni, the historical figure reffered to as the buddha, emphaticaly deny spirit, soul and re-incarnation. Now this has not prevented many of his followers from preching such stuff. Karma/kamma as explained by Thich Naht Hahn is that suufering begets more suffering, our acts and thoughts have consequences in the world.
 
say those three elements of religion in your view, in normal language as Bodhi Dharma Zen tells us he prefers, in place of rational or metaphysical and I presume mathematical languages.

Now I've had my absurdist little joke, and you've had yours.

Lexicography doesn't have much to do with skepticism but mostly to try to get a, usually approximate, understanding in a few words that describes how people use the language. Of course, skepticism can be used to test a proposed definition, which is what I hope will happen here. However, definitions in common language are usually heuristic, so we have to weigh degrees of evidence.

The definition is an attempt to model how people use the term religion, including things that people call religions and excluding things that people don't call religions.

We have to deal with the fact that people use the word "religion" to describe a number of things. Of course, they use it to describe Christianity, Islam, and Judaism (at least to the extent that Judaism is a religion and not a cultural group). They use it to describe Animism, Buddhism, Hinduism, and Shintoinsm. They also use it to describe, sometimes, Communism, Capitalism, the behavior of Star Trek, Macintosh, Windows, and Linux fans. Often this is half-joking, but the word "religion" does in all these cases describe something that is readily comprehended by most other people.

However, most people are very good at being able to figure out what something means, but they're relatively poor in describing what it means. The goal of a definition, here, is to describe what people mean by "religion."

This is what I wrote before:

The sine qua non of a religion is that it places a great deal of emphasis on something that is ineffable and usually poorly defined and is also said to exist in a real sense.

The only difficult bit here is the sine qua non, which just means "without which, not," meaning that it is a necessary condition.

In a classical religion, this thing is a God or some supernatural. It satisfies the requirements:

1) God is said to exist in a real sense.
2) In the system, there is a great deal of emphasis on the concept of God.
3) God is ineffable and poorly defined.

Now, we can examine something else, so let's take an example. In 1927, the Soviet Union, in an official encyclopedia, declared that Einstein's theory of relativity could not be right because it was said to conflict with "dialectical materialism." Even much later, there was resistance to the theory of Evolution by Natural Selection for the same reason, leading to all that stuff with Lysenko. These strike most people essentially as religious edicts. So let's test them:

1) Dialectical materialism is said to exist in a real sense.
2) In the system, there is a great deal of emphasis on the concept of God.
3) Dialectical materialism is ineffable and poorly defined.

So now we can test them.

1: Dialectical materialism is presumed to be a direct result of the thought of Marx/Engels and is held to be true by many Marxists, and certainly by the folks who were in power in the Soviet Union at the time. Furthermore, the idea that dialectical materialism can be said to trump the experiments that support Einsteinian relativity must mean that it is held to be at least as real as the results of those experiments. So the idea that it's said to exist in a real sense is strongly supported.

2: There was indeed a strong emphasis on dialectical materialism by Soviet Communists of the time. Just the fact that it could affect the writing of an encyclopedia or dominate biology for a time shows that there was a strong emphasis. So this is strongly supported.

3: Dialectical materialism has been reasonbly well defined. There is a good wikipedia article on it. However, if you look at it, you will notice that the definition resembes definitions such as of the Tao or many Newage concepts. The terms in which it is defined are really quite fuzzy. Furthermore, by examining the claim that dialectical materialism versus, say, Einsteinian Relativity, it isn't at all clear that any of the terms support the conclusion. So, does this fit my definition? I think it fits somewhat, more weakly than strong, but stronger than weak. I'll call it "moderate."

So of the three terms, those particular instances of Soviet Communism have two strong agreements and one moderate agreement. This reasonably seems to model the behavior of people when deciding that Soviet Communism in this instance was a religion. Most would see it as religious, though perhaps not as strongly religious as Christianity, and a few would disagree.

WRT Buddhism, substitute whatever you like for "God" or "dialectical materialism." If you substitute "karma," I think you get a strong confirmation. If you substitue "Nirvana" or "enlightenment," I think you get at least a moderate confirmation.
 
Last edited:
What an abundance of tripe you bring to this place. Karma is what becomes of your silly ideas about karma, and Buddhism, and a "metaphor for life," etc. etc.

There is no misunderstanding, only a misapprehension.

M.


These are harsh words and Ryokan deserves no derison for his post, please to explain the errors in his logic and where you feel that he is incorrect. Then we may all understand why you feel that his statements are tripe.


Unless of course you use psychic powers rather than scepticism to reach your judgement!
 
I do not consider this to be what the buddha taught. -- Dancing David​
​
-------------

Tell me, Dancing David, at what time the earliest written records of Buddha's teaching appeared in the history of manuscripts? And how the writers of these records came to know what teachings to be genuinely authentic teachings of the Buddha?*
There is no way to verify them as the teachings of the historical figure refered to as the buddha, unlike Mohamed, the teachings became oral for a long time before writing them down.
You seem to harbor the complacency of possessing the true teachings of Buddha as opposed to a lot of spurious accretions from outside his lifetime and his clime.
Evidences? I suupose you have no need to prove your statements because of your psychic authority?
;)

They are the source as explained to you by Ryokan, that are credited by almost all buddhists to be the 'teachings of the buddha' as the historical figure as opposed to the Mhayana schools and the 'teachings of the buddha' as anyone who has found budh or may lead to budh.
I would not be so sure if I were you -- and you claim to be a skeptical critic of Buddhism.
I would claim the million dollars prize if I was you as you seem to be divining who I am from just reading two or three posts. I have always been willing to explain my use of language, unlike some posters.
That is why you should rather find out what is the most conventionally agreed upon broad lineaments of beliefs and observances the greatest number of people calling themselves Buddhists concur on to profess and propound; then tell us what you can and cannot accept as a Buddhist -- if indeed you also call yourself a Buddhist; and no longer claim to adhere to the true teachings of Buddha, unlike so many others who mix truths taught by the Buddha with a lot of superstitious impurities.
this has been explained to you before, the Pali canon and especialy the part that is allegedly ascribed to the historical buddha is generaly accepted as the teachings of the historical buddha by most buddhists.

To derive the actual teachings of the buddha would be as likely as me telling your gender from reading your posts.
Yrreg

*That's why the Buddhists in this forum have no valid reasons to take me to task for not being disposed to spend time and labor to search the sutras for the teachings of Buddha,
Sigh, if even you would quote them, the derivation of the pali canon and it's origins and authenticity (unlikely to be) have been discussed with you before.
Are you having a senior moment?
for insisting that I would rather look up the standard established reference works like encyclopedias of religions and manuals of comparative religion -- when they themselves are at dissonance on what the true teachings or Buddha are indeed.


Hiya yrreg!
Once again you demonstrate that you have not read my previous posts in response to the threads in which you have participated. I have discussed this on at least two occasions, including one of the more recent threads in which you pretended to be participating. ;)

As I have stated before this is how the story goes, and I suppose that you will just ignore this post and call it politeness again:

The buddha taught an oral tradition in a society that had writing but also relied upon oral tradition very heavily. Upon the death of the buddha a conclave was called of 500 arhats(the word somewhat means one who has found nirvana originaly but had acdcumulated some silly baggaage as well). At this conclave Annada and Sariputa and those alleged to have been the closest to the buddha recited the teachings of the buddha in the precense of the five hundred light bulbs.
What was agreed to be the teachings of the buddha was passed on in a further oral history written down for the first time on the island of Sri Lanka, in Pali five hundred years later.

Ryokan also explained this to you as well.

Carry on your merry way!
 
Ryokan is a man who can explain to his own satisfaction and the satisfaction of fellow Buddhists, what is the non-self in Buddhism, and gets impatient so as to lose his Buddhist equanimity with people who still can't accept that he makes any sense with his conceptual scaffolding of non-self.

Now that he tells us:

My religion is Buddhism, and Buddhism is my religion. -- Ryokan​
​

That is absolutely and most certainly a very definitively categorical statement.

Now, the whole world is waiting for him to define religion for us to know what he means by proclaiming most unreservedly:

My religion is Buddhism, and Buddhism is my religion. -- Ryokan​
​


Let's see how long we have to wait.


Yrreg

Just further proof that you don't read other people's posts and have no memory!

Remeber the 'moral' self as defined by you yrreg?

That is the self that does not exist, there are bodies, the bodies contain thoughts, feelings, perceptions and habits. There is no self.
 
you may see people who look like they are doing it.

If they are, they are not meant to.

budha is not a source of worship.

most real budhists know this.

Rxcept for the fact that many people do pray to the buddha for protection and favors, that can be easily established, It would be much harder to prove that there are not a substantial numer of buddhists who do not do so.

Remeber that you and I and all individual buddhists do not comprise buddhism, it is an agrregate of people and beliefs, trhere are many , especialy in Tibet who pray to the buddha and the Taras.
 
I am not saying that Buddhism is not faith based, but I have never seen a workable definition of "religion" which did not contain a theistic element. Buddhism had no theistic element in its teaching and is therefore not a religion. It is however a "similar philosophical belief".If you can redefine religion for me in such a way that theism is not a requirement, but which does not water down the concept of "religion" to include "Jedi knight", then I am prepared to change my position.
I usualy like the American Heritage Dictionary:

re·li·gion (r-ljn) KEY

NOUN:


1.Belief in and reverence for a supernatural power or powers regarded as creator and governor of the universe.
2.A personal or institutionalized system grounded in such belief and worship.
3.The life or condition of a person in a religious order.
4.A set of beliefs, values, and practices based on the teachings of a spiritual leader.
5.A cause, principle, or activity pursued with zeal or conscientious devotion.

If we call George Lucas a spiritual leader the 4 fits the foot.
 
Questions:
Do Buddhist sects exist that could be clearly identified as non-religious? If so what are thoses sects?

Are there Buddhist sects that are clearly religious? If so what are those sects? Assuming that they exist do the clearly religous buddhist sects tend to exclude people with other religious beliefs (such as Christianity) or atheists?

The Buddhist world is roughly divided in two, Theravada and Mahayana.

Theravada, the Teachings of the Elders, is an orthodox Buddhist denominations that stays close to the original teachings of the Buddha.

Mahayana, the Great Vehicle, has assimilated local religions and beliefs, and sects within this denomination are very varied, from the very theistic, almost monotheistic, Pure Land to the atheistic Zen.

Tibetan Buddhism is sometimes mentioned as being the third of the major Buddhist denominations, but is just as often disregarded because it's so small compared to the first two. It has, like Mahayana, assimilated the local religion and beliefs of Tibet, but to a much greater degree than most Mahayana sects.
 
Tell me more.

Originally Posted by yrreg :
"I'm sure we all remember from 5th grade that in Euclidean geometry, points, lines, and planes are undefined."
but they can be drawn on a drawing board like a sand box with any writing implement like your finger; then based on the drawings you can construct the Great Wall of China, the Colosseum of Rome and the pyramids of Egypt. -- Yrreg

----------

Yes, that's true. You can approximate them well enough for someone to get an intuitive understanding. But, still, they're left undefined in a mathematical sense.

This is good enough for Euclidean geometry, though it isn't good enough for topology, which is why knot theory uses small hoses instead of lines.

Definitions of point, line, plane, and solid...

What I remember from my geometry class are the following:

point -- intersection between two lines

line -- extension of a point

plane -- extension of a line

solid -- extension of a plane

That much I remember and I was so excited about those definitions which can be illustrated on the blackboard by the teacher, and you can design all kinds of things with them, and build them.

Now, you being a physicist, Epepke, you talk about small hoses and in another thread about entangled or tangled amplitudes, and I presume you master Quantum Mechanics and all its siblings plus the illegitimate ones begotten by mystical writers.

That's all very instructive to me.

Now, tell me, in your highest and deepest state of the science physics, for which I am sure you can produce some visible waves at least in some display equipment in the lab, like for example the old oscilloscope tube, where does the self or the non-self come in, the non-self specially as the Buddhists here are explaining it and appearing to be so secure about their explanations, and commiserative with shallow guys like yours truly.


Yrreg
 
The subject of consciousness is the self.... no, not?

Remeber the 'moral' self as defined by you yrreg?

That is the self that does not exist, there are bodies, the bodies contain thoughts, feelings, perceptions and habits. There is no self.

We had some protracted discussion on the self and non-self.

Didn't I tell you and the Buddhists there? specially Ryokan, in my first thread, Skeptical Criticism on Buddhist Beliefs and Observances, that I can't accept your argument that there is no self, that it is only a collection of tissues, organs, and processes, for man, like the car is a collection of parts and assemblies and functions, and there is no car as we call it similar to a self in man.

Didn't I bring up the reminder to you guys? that in charge of the tissues, organs, and processes there is a subject that is conscious running the whole caboodle and monitoring them.

Didn't I say to you guys? that it is not your bowel going to the CR but you, the self; and it is not your belly that is eating but you, the self -- in so many words about that anecdote of the famine, and the ruler, and the Buddhist monks with their headman applying to the ruler for their food ration.

What happened is that we had a deadlock, not that I did not attend to your answers; I attended to them, but I can't accept them as rationally convincing -- maybe I don't have the Buddhist enlightenment.


Anyway, let's see what our physicist here, Epepke, has to say about the self and the non-self as explained and propounded by Buddhists, from the standpoint of the ultimate findings or theories in physics.


Yrreg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom