Budhism Is Not A Religion

10001

Thinker
Joined
Jul 20, 2005
Messages
181
yes, it is not.

DO PEOPLE REALLY KNOW WHAT THE WORD "BUDHIST' MEAN?

A BUDHIST SCRIPTURE is probably a more detailed discription of 'existance and life' that 'bible' would have become, if jesus managed to live to the age of the so called 'budha' (sok ha mo ni) did.

except for some espects and ultimate being part, the philosophy of life is pretty much the same. the nagain they all sound the same... if you really compare them.

Anyway,

budhism, IS NOT A RELIGION!!!!

OVER THE YEARS IT TOOK THE CHARACTERISTIC OF A RELIGION.
HOWEVER, IF YOU BECAME A MONK YOU WILL KNOW THAT.

IT HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH

* GOING TO A BETTER PLACE.
* LIVING A 'BETTER' LIFE.
* SOME SUPER BEINGS OR GODS.

BUDHISM IS ABOUT.. TO PUT IT SHORTLY

* SEEING/KNOWING/REALISING THE REALITY AS THEY ARE
* HAVING/ACHIEVING/LEARNING THE RIGHT UNDERSTANDING
* BEING MINDFUL OF THE EXISTANCE. PRESENCE/PRESENT(NOW)/PERPETUITY

TO ACHIEVE THE ABOVE BUDHISTS PRACTICE

*LETTING GO. (OF THE THINGS INSIDE YOU, BE IT SADNESS, CETAIN THOUGHTS OR WHAT EVER)

* MEDITATION. (LEAVE THIS TO INDIVIDUALS READING THIS TO DECIDE WHAT MEDITATION IS)

* HPPINESS OF GIVING. (BE IT GIVEN TO THEM, OR GIVEN BY THEM)
PLEASE REMEMBER MATERIAL GIFT/GAIN IS REALLY NOT WORTH ANYTHING IF NOT ACCOMPANIED WITH EMOTIONS INVOLVED.

DO PEOPLE REALLY UNDERSTAND WHAT THE WORD 'BUDHIST' MEANS?

***** IF BUDHISM IS A RELIGION *****
SINCE RELIGIONS ARE FOR HUMAN BEINGS
THEN THE WORD 'BUDHIST' CAN BE TRANSLATED AS 'HUMANITY'
A RELIGION OF 'PEOPLE', 'PERSON'
NOTHING ELSE ATTACHED.
NO ULTIMATE GOD
NO HEAVEN
NO HELL

BECAUSE...
EVEN THOUGH, THE WORD 'BUDHA' MEANS 'THE ENLIGHTENED ONE'
BUDHA SPECIFICALLY TELLS..
THAT WE ARE ALL 'BUDHA'
INFACT ALL EXUSTANCE EMBODIES THE BUDHA NATURE

IN BUDHISM.. THERE IS NO 'BELIEF'
YOU JUST... DO


OVER 100,000 TEXTS AND SCRIPTURES WERE WRITTEN.
TO ASSIST PEOPLE IN ALL KINDS OF SITUATIONS
AND LEVELS/DIFFERENCES OF UNDERSTANDING.

YOU DON'T HAVE TO READ THEM ALL.
'YOU' ARE NOT STUPID
YOU DONT EVEN HAVE TO HAVE A 'BELIEF' IN ANYTHING/ONE/IDEAOLOGY
EVEN BUDHA...

GOING THE WAY, ON THE WAY, DURING THE WAY - YOU WILL KNOW.
WHEN 'ONE' DOES, AS 'ONE' DOES, WHILE 'ONE' DOES, - YOU WILL REALISE.

A SAYING THAT I LIKE...

IT IS MORE LIKE 'AS YOU GO YOU WILL GET TO KNOW' AND ' WHILE YOU DO YOU WILL REALISE'

THANKS FOR READING MY NONSENSE.

LIKE I SAID... I HAVEN SAVED MY SELF..... YET!
 
Last edited:
OK, dude, the caps lock key is on the left side of the keyboard. Make sure that it's not depressed when you type, 'kay?

That being said, there is a fine line between religion and life-philosophy. Modern Buddhism is a religion, as it has adopted many gods from Hinduism, etc.
 
If your version of Buddhism involves the concept of karma, then it is indeed a religion, because it involves some supernatural "thing" (even if it is unnamed) making decisions about what to do with your soul.
 
That being said, there is a fine line between religion and life-philosophy. Modern Buddhism is a religion, as it has adopted many gods from Hinduism, etc.
Um no, I am a Buddhist, and I am also an aitheist, the terms are not mutaly exclusive. (and no, I am not talking abbout "cultural Buddhism" in the same way that you can be a "cultural Jew" or a "cultural Catholic")I am prepared to believe that buddhism is an agnostic religion, or phillosophy, but to say that the worship of any gods (borrowed from wherever) is centeral to "modern buddhism" is just wrong.Oh and BTW excatly which mdoern Buddhist sect is "modern buddhism" ?
 
If your version of Buddhism involves the concept of karma, then it is indeed a religion, because it involves some supernatural "thing" (even if it is unnamed) making decisions about what to do with your soul.
That all depends on your view of karma, and whether you believe in reincarnation or not (not all Buddhists do). Also many philosophies deal with the supernatural, but they are not all considered religious.I like the UK government definition, that Buddhism is not a religion per se, but is a "similar philosophical belief".
 
You and I may feel that what the buddha taught was not a religion, but after 2,500 years it has become a faith based religion in many areas. I do not consider this to be what the buddha taught. But a google search on the word 'merit' and buddhism will point out that about seventy percent religion and faith in current development.
 
You and I may feel that what the buddha taught was not a religion, but after 2,500 years it has become a faith based religion in many areas. I do not consider this to be what the buddha taught. But a google search on the word 'merit' and buddhism will point out that about seventy percent religion and faith in current development.
I am not saying that Buddhism is not faith based, but I have never seen a workable definition of "religion" which did not contain a theistic element. Buddhism had no theistic element in its teaching and is therefore not a religion. It is however a "similar philosophical belief".If you can redefine religion for me in such a way that theism is not a requirement, but which does not water down the concept of "religion" to include "Jedi knight", then I am prepared to change my position.
 
That all depends on your view of karma, and whether you believe in reincarnation or not (not all Buddhists do). Also many philosophies deal with the supernatural, but they are not all considered religious.I like the UK government definition, that Buddhism is not a religion per se, but is a "similar philosophical belief".
That's why I put the "if" in there. But karma is not just "dealing with the supernatural", it is a supernatural entity that decides what to do with your soul. That satisfies the definition of "god" in my opinion. But I do understand that not all Buddhists embrace the concept of karma.
 
That's why I put the "if" in there. But karma is not just "dealing with the supernatural", it is a supernatural entity that decides what to do with your soul. That satisfies the definition of "god" in my opinion. But I do understand that not all Buddhists embrace the concept of karma.
It is also possible to embrace A concept of karma, without embracing THAT concept of karma. Karma can be understood to be a kind of "do unto others" philosophy, with an added bit of, "if you are a rotten bastard, your guilt, and the way people around you react to you, will make you unhappy. " I will concede that some Buddhists cross the (artificial) line between faith based philosophy and religion. That does not mean that Buddhism itself is a religion. Although I do fail to see the importance of this discussion its just matter of semantics really.
 
It is also possible to embrace A concept of karma, without embracing THAT concept of karma. Karma can be understood to be a kind of "do unto others" philosophy, with an added bit of, "if you are a rotten bastard, your guilt, and the way people around you react to you, will make you unhappy. "
Perhaps, but that definition of karma is demonstrably wrong. Rotten bastards are quite often some of the happiest people around. Having no conscience will do that.

I will concede that some Buddhists cross the (artificial) line between faith based philosophy and religion. That does not mean that Buddhism itself is a religion. Although I do fail to see the importance of this discussion its just matter of semantics really.
Well, the whole thread is a discussion of semantics, is it not? It is trying to define what is a religion. Here's my take on it.

Religion = worship of or belief in a god.
God = supernatural entity which has power over your life or soul.

I've heard Buddhists argue that karma is not supernatural, similar to what you said above, and in that case, it is arguably not a religion. The vast majority of "karma" believers that I've met (and admittedly, many of them are pagans, not Buddhists) believe that karma is something that pays you back for being a rotten bastard and rewards you for being a nice guy, usually, but not always, in the next life.
 
Um no, I am a Buddhist, and I am also an aitheist, the terms are not mutaly exclusive. (and no, I am not talking abbout "cultural Buddhism" in the same way that you can be a "cultural Jew" or a "cultural Catholic")I am prepared to believe that buddhism is an agnostic religion, or phillosophy, but to say that the worship of any gods (borrowed from wherever) is centeral to "modern buddhism" is just wrong.Oh and BTW excatly which mdoern Buddhist sect is "modern buddhism" ?

*shrugs*

All I know is, with the exception of certain Buddhists on this forum, every Buddhist I've personally known has adopted either Shinto or Hindi gods as part of their Buddhism. Given that I'm largely exposed to Korean Buddhists, and the occasional Indian Buddhist, that may be a cultural artifact. If so, I stand corrected, of course.
 
yes, it is not.

DO PEOPLE REALLY KNOW WHAT THE WORD "BUDHIST' MEAN?

A BUDHIST SCRIPTURE is probably a more detailed discription of 'existance and life' that 'bible' would have become, if jesus managed to live to the age of the so called 'budha' (sok ha mo ni) did.

except for some espects and ultimate being part, the philosophy of life is pretty much the same. the nagain they all sound the same... if you really compare them.

Anyway,

budhism, IS NOT A RELIGION!!!!

OVER THE YEARS IT TOOK THE CHARACTERISTIC OF A RELIGION.
HOWEVER, IF YOU BECAME A MONK YOU WILL KNOW THAT.

IT HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH

* GOING TO A BETTER PLACE.
* LIVING A 'BETTER' LIFE.
* SOME SUPER BEINGS OR GODS.

BUDHISM IS ABOUT.. TO PUT IT SHORTLY

* SEEING/KNOWING/REALISING THE REALITY AS THEY ARE
* HAVING/ACHIEVING/LEARNING THE RIGHT UNDERSTANDING
* BEING MINDFUL OF THE EXISTANCE. PRESENCE/PRESENT(NOW)/PERPETUITY

TO ACHIEVE THE ABOVE BUDHISTS PRACTICE

*LETTING GO. (OF THE THINGS INSIDE YOU, BE IT SADNESS, CETAIN THOUGHTS OR WHAT EVER)

* MEDITATION. (LEAVE THIS TO INDIVIDUALS READING THIS TO DECIDE WHAT MEDITATION IS)

* HPPINESS OF GIVING. (BE IT GIVEN TO THEM, OR GIVEN BY THEM)
PLEASE REMEMBER MATERIAL GIFT/GAIN IS REALLY NOT WORTH ANYTHING IF NOT ACCOMPANIED WITH EMOTIONS INVOLVED.

DO PEOPLE REALLY UNDERSTAND WHAT THE WORD 'BUDHIST' MEANS?

***** IF BUDHISM IS A RELIGION *****
SINCE RELIGIONS ARE FOR HUMAN BEINGS
THEN THE WORD 'BUDHIST' CAN BE TRANSLATED AS 'HUMANITY'
A RELIGION OF 'PEOPLE', 'PERSON'
NOTHING ELSE ATTACHED.
NO ULTIMATE GOD
NO HEAVEN
NO HELL

BECAUSE...
EVEN THOUGH, THE WORD 'BUDHA' MEANS 'THE ENLIGHTENED ONE'
BUDHA SPECIFICALLY TELLS..
THAT WE ARE ALL 'BUDHA'
INFACT ALL EXUSTANCE EMBODIES THE BUDHA NATURE

IN BUDHISM.. THERE IS NO 'BELIEF'
YOU JUST... DO


OVER 100,000 TEXTS AND SCRIPTURES WERE WRITTEN.
TO ASSIST PEOPLE IN ALL KINDS OF SITUATIONS
AND LEVELS/DIFFERENCES OF UNDERSTANDING.

YOU DON'T HAVE TO READ THEM ALL.
'YOU' ARE NOT STUPID
YOU DONT EVEN HAVE TO HAVE A 'BELIEF' IN ANYTHING/ONE/IDEAOLOGY
EVEN BUDHA...

GOING THE WAY, ON THE WAY, DURING THE WAY - YOU WILL KNOW.
WHEN 'ONE' DOES, AS 'ONE' DOES, WHILE 'ONE' DOES, - YOU WILL REALISE.

A SAYING THAT I LIKE...

IT IS MORE LIKE 'AS YOU GO YOU WILL GET TO KNOW' AND ' WHILE YOU DO YOU WILL REALISE'

THANKS FOR READING MY NONSENSE.

LIKE I SAID... I HAVEN SAVED MY SELF..... YET!



SIR, YES SIR!

M.
 
As I've said often enough in here, I'm a Buddhist, an atheist and a sceptic. My religion is Buddhism, and Buddhism is my religion.

But good luck finding a definition of 'religion' where both theistic religions and Buddhism fits equally well.
 
I've heard Buddhists argue that karma is not supernatural, similar to what you said above, and in that case, it is arguably not a religion. The vast majority of "karma" believers that I've met (and admittedly, many of them are pagans, not Buddhists) believe that karma is something that pays you back for being a rotten bastard and rewards you for being a nice guy, usually, but not always, in the next life.

I'm afraid karma rewards or punishes no one.

First off, most Buddhist denominations (except Tibetan Buddhism, and probably a few other minor sects as well) reject the concepts of soul and reincarnation. Gautama Buddha himself rejected both. When you have no soul and no reincarnation, your understanding of karma must be rejected.

To understand karma, you must see beyond the individual. Karma works on a greater scale. If a people do bad things, those actions will reflect on the future of that people. One generation doesn't reinforce the levees, future generations suffer for it. One generations turns their government over to terrorists and fundamentalists, and future generations suffer from it. One generations spends too much money on things that does not advance society, and future generations suffer for it.

Karma, along with nirvana, is one of the most misunderstood concepts of Buddhism. One of the reasons for the misunderstandings is that the Buddha stole words from his contemporaries, but changed their meanings. No doubt, had the Buddha been born now and raised in a Christian country, karma would've been sin and nirvana would've been heaven.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom