We had some protracted discussion on the self and non-self.
Didn't I tell you and the Buddhists there? specially Ryokan, in my first thread, Skeptical Criticism on Buddhist Beliefs and Observances, that I can't accept your argument that there is no self, that it is only a collection of tissues, organs, and processes, for man, like the car is a collection of parts and assemblies and functions, and there is no car as we call it similar to a self in man.
Didn't I bring up the reminder to you guys? that in charge of the tissues, organs, and processes there is a subject that is conscious running the whole caboodle and monitoring them.
I know there has been several similar discussions in this forum, that had nothing to do with Buddhism but about the self, the soul and wether humans were just the sum of their parts, or more. I didn't participate in those threads, but it seemed like most atheist forum members shared my view on that there is no self. I'll see if I can find some of those threads later, right now I'm going to bed, as it's quite late.
Didn't I say to you guys? that it is not your bowel going to the CR but you, the self; and it is not your belly that is eating but you, the self -- in so many words about that anecdote of the famine, and the ruler, and the Buddhist monks with their headman applying to the ruler for their food ration.
Ah, yes. I remember well your argument by made up stories.
You never told us, yrreg, where you got those stories, although I did ask you. Why is that, yrreg? Why don't you dare show us the source of your stories on Buddhism?
What happened is that we had a deadlock, not that I did not attend to your answers; I attended to them, but I can't accept them as rationally convincing -- maybe I don't have the Buddhist enlightenment.
Strawman, none of the Buddhists in here has claimed to be enlightened.
Anyway, let's see what our physicist here, Epepke, has to say about the self and the non-self as explained and propounded by Buddhists, from the standpoint of the ultimate findings or theories in physics.
Yrreg
Seeing it from just a physics perspective, we would have to conclude that humans are just the sum of their parts, and that those parts are ever changing. In other words, there is no self.