Budhism Is Not A Religion

We had some protracted discussion on the self and non-self.

Didn't I tell you and the Buddhists there? specially Ryokan, in my first thread, Skeptical Criticism on Buddhist Beliefs and Observances, that I can't accept your argument that there is no self, that it is only a collection of tissues, organs, and processes, for man, like the car is a collection of parts and assemblies and functions, and there is no car as we call it similar to a self in man.

Didn't I bring up the reminder to you guys? that in charge of the tissues, organs, and processes there is a subject that is conscious running the whole caboodle and monitoring them.

I know there has been several similar discussions in this forum, that had nothing to do with Buddhism but about the self, the soul and wether humans were just the sum of their parts, or more. I didn't participate in those threads, but it seemed like most atheist forum members shared my view on that there is no self. I'll see if I can find some of those threads later, right now I'm going to bed, as it's quite late.

Didn't I say to you guys? that it is not your bowel going to the CR but you, the self; and it is not your belly that is eating but you, the self -- in so many words about that anecdote of the famine, and the ruler, and the Buddhist monks with their headman applying to the ruler for their food ration.

Ah, yes. I remember well your argument by made up stories.

You never told us, yrreg, where you got those stories, although I did ask you. Why is that, yrreg? Why don't you dare show us the source of your stories on Buddhism?

What happened is that we had a deadlock, not that I did not attend to your answers; I attended to them, but I can't accept them as rationally convincing -- maybe I don't have the Buddhist enlightenment.

Strawman, none of the Buddhists in here has claimed to be enlightened.


Anyway, let's see what our physicist here, Epepke, has to say about the self and the non-self as explained and propounded by Buddhists, from the standpoint of the ultimate findings or theories in physics.


Yrreg

Seeing it from just a physics perspective, we would have to conclude that humans are just the sum of their parts, and that those parts are ever changing. In other words, there is no self.
 
I know there has been several similar discussions in this forum, that had nothing to do with Buddhism but about the self, the soul and wether humans were just the sum of their parts, or more.

Couldn't sleep, so I dug up the thread I remember most.

Here you go, are we more than just a machine?

Since you're still relatively new to this forum, yrreg, I'll let you know that Iacchus, who started the thread, is the resident religious/spiritual/woo nut.
 
the majority of Buddhist sects do not belive in reincarntion. So whilst your understanding may be true for some sects, it is by no means universaly accurate.Karma is basicly a way of saying "your actions will have consequences".

This is the first time I've heard of this. I was raised a Buddhist in Singapore. While I do not always agree with the way Buddhism is practised around here, mainstream Buddhism in Singapore, Hong Kong and Taiwan definitely believe in the "fact" of reincarnation. They believe that karma dictates your next life, rebirth is part of suffering, and that Nirvana is the ultimate state where one is free of karma and will therefore no longer be reborn. Having attended several dharma talks in my younger believer days, I have never once come across a single practioner, local or foreign, from the Mahayana or Theravada traditions, who ever rejected reincarnation.

During my high school days, it was compulsory for all students in Singapore to take a religious studies class of our own choice. I opted for Buddhist Studies. The syllabus adopted officially by the Ministry of Education also taught reincarnation as one of the central beliefs of Buddhism. No Buddhist organisation that I'm aware of challenged it.
 
Now, you being a physicist, Epepke, you talk about small hoses and in another thread about entangled or tangled amplitudes, and I presume you master Quantum Mechanics and all its siblings plus the illegitimate ones begotten by mystical writers.

Correction: I'm primarily a mathematician, but I spent 13 years collaborating with mostly physicists, so a fair amount of physics rubbed off on me.

Now, tell me, in your highest and deepest state of the science physics, for which I am sure you can produce some visible waves at least in some display equipment in the lab, like for example the old oscilloscope tube, where does the self or the non-self come in, the non-self specially as the Buddhists here are explaining it and appearing to be so secure about their explanations, and commiserative with shallow guys like yours truly.

Quite frankly, I'm not sure what they're talking about.

I think it's important to make a distinction between when we're talking about physics and when we're talking about something else, like philosophy or religion or metaphysics. But if and inasmuch it relates to physics, it seems to me a bit like how physics was understood more than a hundred years ago, and so I think a lot of the terms aren't relevant any more.

I'm not sure what the "self" is supposed to mean. Where is the self considering what has been discovered in neurology and psychiatry?
 
A rose by any other name, or not the singer but the song

Ah, yes. I remember well your argument by made up stories.

You never told us, yrreg, where you got those stories, although I did ask you. Why is that, yrreg? Why don't you dare show us the source of your stories on Buddhism?

This thought had alway been at the tip of my tongue but I always failed to bring it out into words, for having been attracted to many other also equally or more thrilling issues, namely, that -- and this is my impression, so it might not be exactly correct -- the Buddhists I meet here, specially the ones most enthusiastic in explaining and in defending Buddhist beliefs and practices, are obsessed with tracing a teaching to the Buddha in order to give it credence; aren't there insights in Buddhism already in their intrinsic character credible even if Buddha didn't formulate a statement for them?

I remember I suggested to Ryokan once that he might consider doing a project whereby he would rewrite the important core teachings of Buddhism, but leaving out altogether any mention of Buddha's name, and see whether people reading them without the mention whatsoever of Buddha's name, can be impressed by them as to adopt them for life's lessons reaching beyond the grave. I can't recall now what was his reaction; but I am inclined to feel that he dismissed the idea as not worth his attention or speculative curiosity.

I brought forth maybe three or is it two stories illustrating how non-self does not work in real life situations, and Ryokan now as before when those stories were told wanted to know the source. Here is where I think Ryokan and the Buddhists here, who have been conditioned to believe on the authority of the Buddha, also carry over this habit to illustrative narratives from non-Buddhist wit-crackers, intended to set forth perceptions of common everyday good sense.

What do you say? good Buddhist friends here, that you have been conditioned to believe on the authority of the Buddha, so that without knowing it you also tend to seek the authors of stories before seeing their worth in the plot and style alone without reference to the authors.

Allow me to address to you this suspicion: Did you first fall in love with the Buddha, and then accept Buddhistic teachings and exercises advocated by your instructors in the name of the Buddha?


Yrreg
 
This must be the undoing of Buddhism.

Karma, along with nirvana, is one of the most misunderstood concepts of Buddhism. One of the reasons for the misunderstandings is that the Buddha stole words from his contemporaries, but changed their meanings. No doubt, had the Buddha been born now and raised in a Christian country, karma would've been sin and nirvana would've been heaven.

Dear Ryokan:

On the one hand, you and Dancing David and I am sure a lot of Western Buddhists insist on the genuine, authentic, real, true, unadulterated teachings of the Buddha; on the other hand you tell us in the paragraph quoted above that "the Buddha stole words from his contemporaries, but changed their meanings."

I would propose seriously and sincerely that you undertake the solemn resolve to rewrite that paragraph, to effect a 180 degree turn of its main thrust? Otherwise, all Buddhists who claim to know the genuine, authentic, real, true, unadulterated teachings of the Buddha would not rest easy, for wondering what exactly Buddha means with the words he uses, which are from his contemporaries -- should they take you seriously, as a Buddhist master from the West, telling them that "Buddha stole words from his contemporaries, but changed their meanings."


Here is another example of changed meanings to words of contemporaries; look at this text below from an assembly of various sects of Buddhists in the US:

----------------

5) We hold, as central to the spirit and goals of Buddhism:
a. The Four Noble Truths: Suffering (dukkha), cause of suffering (samudaya), cessation of suffering (nirodha) and the Path to the cessation of suffering (dukkhanirodhagaminipatipada) Buddhism is neither pessimistic nor "escapist", nor does it deny the existence of God or soul, though it places its own meaning on these.​
​


---------------

As I said in the thread next door, "And I had a good laugh when I read that excerpt from some kind of statement of common articles of beliefs and practices agreed upon by various sects of US Buddhists. Now I am afraid it is no laughing matter; it's true, Buddhists do have the policy of double-talk."


Yrreg
 
Where philosophy ends and religion begins.

The reason for my categorical statement is that the world seems to have come to an agreement that Buddhism is a religion. I'm not ashamed of being a Buddhist, and although I feel Buddhism is more a philosophy than a religion, I have no problem answering the question 'What is your religion?' with 'I'm a Buddhist'.

Nonetheless, I think you are into religion with your Buddhism, not only as a philosophy, even on your protestation to the contrary; unless you tell me that you are not after attaining Nirvana.

So, assuming that you are professing and practicing your Buddhism in order to attain Nirvana, your Buddhism is a religion, and not because the world agrees to see Buddhism as a religion, but considering that Nirvana is a post grave and beyond grave objective of Buddhism, and possessed of a transcendental dimension.

What turns a philosophy into a religion? or when does philosophy in a person ends as a philosophy and begins as a religion?

When the philosophy is being employed as a means, a way, a medium, to attain an end objective that is post and beyond the grave and exhibits a transcendental orientation, namely in your case, Nirvana.

Consider that there are people who profess theism as a philosophy but not as a religion; we can even find scientific skeptics who accept philosophical theism, but they don't cultivate it as a religion, as for example, Christians, Muslims, and Jews do.

These philosophical theists are not into utilizing their theistic philosophy to acquire a post grave and beyond the grave objective of a transcendental dimension; and they are not after favors from the God in life prior to the grave and of this world.

In your case, your Buddhism is for you a means, a way, a medium to acquire the post and beyond grave goal of Nirvana, an objective possessed of a transcendental character, and also you are after the beneficial effects of practicing Buddhism while still in your life existence prior to the grave, most principally almost quintessentially, relief or emancipation from suffering.

You will tell me that I don't know what Nirvana is all about? You are right of course; but I do know that Nirvana, the final and definitive phase, is post and beyond the grave, and also that Nirvana is of a transcendental perspective -- from the way Buddhists talk about it.

Perhaps your religion of Buddhism is of a less worldly kind, unlike the Buddhism of the masses of Buddhists in traditional Buddhist lands, like Thailand, Burma, Cambodia, Sri Lanka, Nepal, China, Japan, Vietnam, Tibet, who are conspicuously after seeking earthly favors from Buddha and Buddhist saints; yet you are still after something from your embrace and practice of Buddhism, namely, to arrive at ultimate Nirvana, and while in this life liberation from suffering.

And who or what is your equivalent of a God? What else but the Dharma, even though it is not a personalistic God; yet you do negotiate with it to liberate yourself from suffering and to attain Nirvana. How? by meditation and good works, those right acts of the eightfold path -- that's how.


No, your Buddhism is not just philosophy, it is religion.


Yrreg
 
This thought had alway been at the tip of my tongue but I always failed to bring it out into words, for having been attracted to many other also equally or more thrilling issues, namely, that -- and this is my impression, so it might not be exactly correct -- the Buddhists I meet here, specially the ones most enthusiastic in explaining and in defending Buddhist beliefs and practices, are obsessed with tracing a teaching to the Buddha in order to give it credence; aren't there insights in Buddhism already in their intrinsic character credible even if Buddha didn't formulate a statement for them?

Yrreg, you must be new to scepticism, so I'm going to spell it out for you again.

When you make a claim on this board, you're supposed to back up your claim with external sources. If you don't, they're just empty words. When you tell us three stories of what Buddhists 'really' believe about the self, I would like to see the sources for those stories. Why won't you tell me the source?

I'm not asking because I want to 'trace the teachings to the Buddha', but because I'm fairly certain that the source is bogus. The fact that you refuse to admit the source of the stories just makes me more certain that they're just that, bogus. So what say you, Yrreg, will you show us the source of your Buddhist stories?

Epepke, I know you have some influence over Yrreg, could you please tell him the importance of backing up his sources and claims with external evidence?

I remember I suggested to Ryokan once that he might consider doing a project whereby he would rewrite the important core teachings of Buddhism, but leaving out altogether any mention of Buddha's name, and see whether people reading them without the mention whatsoever of Buddha's name, can be impressed by them as to adopt them for life's lessons reaching beyond the grave. I can't recall now what was his reaction; but I am inclined to feel that he dismissed the idea as not worth his attention or speculative curiosity.

Actually, the idea isn't bad at all. The Buddha really isn't needed at all, his teachings do not stand and fall on him.

I brought forth maybe three or is it two stories illustrating how non-self does not work in real life situations, and Ryokan now as before when those stories were told wanted to know the source. Here is where I think Ryokan and the Buddhists here, who have been conditioned to believe on the authority of the Buddha, also carry over this habit to illustrative narratives from non-Buddhist wit-crackers, intended to set forth perceptions of common everyday good sense.

Your three stories misrepresented the Buddhis view on non-self, and were probably made to make fun of Buddhists. You have made a claim that the stories show what Buddhists really believe. But how do we know you didn't just make those stories up? Are you going to show us the source of those stories, or are you afraid that once we know the source we'll dismiss it as unreliable?

Unless you show evidence that those stories contain what Buddhists really believe, they can be dismissed. If the source is unreliable, they can be dismissed. Farewell, stories.

What do you say? good Buddhist friends here, that you have been conditioned to believe on the authority of the Buddha, so that without knowing it you also tend to seek the authors of stories before seeing their worth in the plot and style alone without reference to the authors.

The Buddha has no authority whatsoever. He's dead. I want to know the author of your stories to see how credible they are.

Allow me to address to you this suspicion: Did you first fall in love with the Buddha, and then accept Buddhistic teachings and exercises advocated by your instructors in the name of the Buddha?


Yrreg

You can lay your suspicions at rest. My first meeting with Buddhism was through Zen, and they don't hold the Buddha as a central figure. It took many years, and a very sceptical approach, before I finally read the original teachings of the Buddha.
 
Dear Ryokan:

On the one hand, you and Dancing David and I am sure a lot of Western Buddhists insist on the genuine, authentic, real, true, unadulterated teachings of the Buddha; on the other hand you tell us in the paragraph quoted above that "the Buddha stole words from his contemporaries, but changed their meanings."

If you knew your Buddhism, you would know that the Buddha changed the meanings of Hindu words, just like the Christians changed the meaning of many Jewish words. For example, Dharma to a Hindu and to a Buddhist is two completely different things, as this Wikipeda article clearly shows.

I would propose seriously and sincerely that you undertake the solemn resolve to rewrite that paragraph, to effect a 180 degree turn of its main thrust? Otherwise, all Buddhists who claim to know the genuine, authentic, real, true, unadulterated teachings of the Buddha would not rest easy, for wondering what exactly Buddha means with the words he uses, which are from his contemporaries -- should they take you seriously, as a Buddhist master from the West, telling them that "Buddha stole words from his contemporaries, but changed their meanings."

Why do you place such a great emphasis on me being a Western Buddhist, Yrreg? Are you trying to say I'm not a real Buddhist?

We know what the Buddha meant with his words, just like a Christian knows what Christ meant when he used the words Heaven and Gehenna, although his Jewish contemporaries placed very different meanings on those words.

Here is another example of changed meanings to words of contemporaries; look at this text below from an assembly of various sects of Buddhists in the US:

----------------

5) We hold, as central to the spirit and goals of Buddhism:
a. The Four Noble Truths: Suffering (dukkha), cause of suffering (samudaya), cessation of suffering (nirodha) and the Path to the cessation of suffering (dukkhanirodhagaminipatipada) Buddhism is neither pessimistic nor "escapist", nor does it deny the existence of God or soul, though it places its own meaning on these.​
​


---------------

As I said in the thread next door, "And I had a good laugh when I read that excerpt from some kind of statement of common articles of beliefs and practices agreed upon by various sects of US Buddhists. Now I am afraid it is no laughing matter; it's true, Buddhists do have the policy of double-talk."


Yrreg

What is the double-talk here, Yrreg?

What is the source of the quote? How do I know you didn't just make it up?
 
Nonetheless, I think you are into religion with your Buddhism, not only as a philosophy, even on your protestation to the contrary; unless you tell me that you are not after attaining Nirvana.

It can be argued that I'm into religious Buddhism, especially since I'm a member of several religious Buddhist organizations. I've never hidden this fact, and if people ask me what my religion is, I will reply Buddhism.

However, the core of Buddhism is not religious.

So, assuming that you are professing and practicing your Buddhism in order to attain Nirvana, your Buddhism is a religion, and not because the world agrees to see Buddhism as a religion, but considering that Nirvana is a post grave and beyond grave objective of Buddhism, and possessed of a transcendental dimension.

You're supposed to attain Nirvana (enlightenment) in this life, not some mythical afterlife. The Buddha attained Nirvana under the Bodhi tree, and I have read no Buddhist texts that claim Siddharta Gautama went around as a zombie after his enlightenment. That alone suggests that Nirvana has nothing to do with a mythical afterlife.

I don't believe in an afterlife. When I'm dead, I'm dead, and that's the end of it. How can I practice to attain something I don't believe in?

If you want to counter this, all you need is to show us a credible source that says otherwise, not just make up strawmen and try to tell me what I believe in.

What turns a philosophy into a religion? or when does philosophy in a person ends as a philosophy and begins as a religion?

Those are good questions.

I would say that when philosophy turns into worship and/or the belief in the supernatural, it turns into a religion. That's a pretty weak definition, though, and does exclude a few religions, so it must be discarded.

Do you, or anyone else, have a better definition?

When the philosophy is being employed as a means, a way, a medium, to attain an end objective that is post and beyond the grave and exhibits a transcendental orientation, namely in your case, Nirvana.

I still don't believe in an afterlife, so how can I possibly be working towards it? Nirvana is enlightenment, and the goal is to reach it before you die. After you're dead, what use is it?

Remember, yrreg, one of your arguments against Buddhism is the belief in non-self. If we Buddhist don't believe there is a permanent self, how can there be an afterlife? You can't have it both ways.

Consider that there are people who profess theism as a philosophy but not as a religion; we can even find scientific skeptics who accept philosophical theism, but they don't cultivate it as a religion, as for example, Christians, Muslims, and Jews do.

These philosophical theists are not into utilizing their theistic philosophy to acquire a post grave and beyond the grave objective of a transcendental dimension; and they are not after favors from the God in life prior to the grave and of this world.

How can you profess theism as a philosophy? Can you show examples of this?

In your case, your Buddhism is for you a means, a way, a medium to acquire the post and beyond grave goal of Nirvana, an objective possessed of a transcendental character, and also you are after the beneficial effects of practicing Buddhism while still in your life existence prior to the grave, most principally almost quintessentially, relief or emancipation from suffering.

Thank you for telling me what I believe. You really should try to win Randi's million!

There is not afterlife, Yrreg, there is only this life. Make the best of it.

You will tell me that I don't know what Nirvana is all about? You are right of course; but I do know that Nirvana, the final and definitive phase, is post and beyond the grave, and also that Nirvana is of a transcendental perspective -- from the way Buddhists talk about it.

You don't know what Nirvana is. Did the Buddha die when he attained Nirvana? Or was he alive?

Perhaps your religion of Buddhism is of a less worldly kind, unlike the Buddhism of the masses of Buddhists in traditional Buddhist lands, like Thailand, Burma, Cambodia, Sri Lanka, Nepal, China, Japan, Vietnam, Tibet, who are conspicuously after seeking earthly favors from Buddha and Buddhist saints; yet you are still after something from your embrace and practice of Buddhism, namely, to arrive at ultimate Nirvana, and while in this life liberation from suffering.

My Buddhism matches that of Theravada Buddhism. In your list of Buddhist countries, Thailand, Burma, Cambodia and Sri Lanka are Theravada countries.

Please show evidence that the Buddhists of these countries seek earthly favors of the Buddha and Buddhist saints (Bodhisatvas?).

And who or what is your equivalent of a God? What else but the Dharma, even though it is not a personalistic God; yet you do negotiate with it to liberate yourself from suffering and to attain Nirvana. How? by meditation and good works, those right acts of the eightfold path -- that's how.

The Dharma is my god? Thank you, Yrreg, you gave me a laugh today :)



No, your Buddhism is not just philosophy, it is religion.


Yrreg

The core of Buddhism is still a philosophy, no matter how many strawmen you erect.
 
This is the first time I've heard of this. I was raised a Buddhist in Singapore. While I do not always agree with the way Buddhism is practised around here, mainstream Buddhism in Singapore, Hong Kong and Taiwan definitely believe in the "fact" of reincarnation. They believe that karma dictates your next life, rebirth is part of suffering, and that Nirvana is the ultimate state where one is free of karma and will therefore no longer be reborn. Having attended several dharma talks in my younger believer days, I have never once come across a single practioner, local or foreign, from the Mahayana or Theravada traditions, who ever rejected reincarnation.

During my high school days, it was compulsory for all students in Singapore to take a religious studies class of our own choice. I opted for Buddhist Studies. The syllabus adopted officially by the Ministry of Education also taught reincarnation as one of the central beliefs of Buddhism. No Buddhist organisation that I'm aware of challenged it.

Thanks for this insight.

I have two reactions. One is that there is a subtle difference between the concept of rebirth and concept of reincarnation. Reincarnation generally means that the self continues from one life to the next. I think it's more of a Hindu belief, based on the notion of an eternal soul. Whereas rebirth in Buddhism generally refers to the rippling effects of ones "karma," I guess, so that habit patterns are passed from one lifetime to the next, but nothing else about a person lasts beyond death. Rebirth also refers with equal validity to the moment-to-moment process of change during this lifetime, and within Buddhism, I think it's just as "correct" to view every new day as a kind of "rebirth," and every meditation session as a kind of "rebirth," etc.

My second reaction is that the notion of rebirth when it is understood as "reincarnation" probably is viewed by many Buddhist teachers as not particularly relevant to the practice of Buddhism. People will have lots of different notions about God, the afterlife, the nature of reality, etc., and none of those notions is ever going to be anything we can have intellectual certainty about. So probably, there's no reason for a Buddhist organization to challenge some particular notion of rebirth, because there's no real point in refining such notions too precisely. Buddhist practice doesn't need them.
 
Epepke, I know you have some influence over Yrreg, could you please tell him the importance of backing up his sources and claims with external evidence?

I'm not big on authority figures myself, especially if they're me. I can't set myself up as an authority figure or try to mediate discussions between other people without violating what I think skepticism is about.

Of course, I do occasionally try to mediate, but I like to keep as light a hand as possible. Right now, people are actually talking.
 
Last edited:
In the UK "the Sun" encouraged people to prey to David Beckham, to help England win some match or other, that doesn't make "footbalism" a religion.

I think you'll find that it is a religion in Liverpool !
 
We have several communication gaps here, Ryokan. 1

Thanks, Yrreg for your reactions. I will just bring out your post, the present one I am replying to, outside its quotation box, to respond to your reactions in each of their places.

Before anything else, I want you to know that I am not doing this skeptical criticism of Buddhism out of some kind of advocacy. As I said several times in this JREF forum, I am just doing it for fun. I can accept non-self and everything you accept and not accept of Buddhism, except practice the inconvenient observances like sitting on my haunches to do meditation -- I can even do that for a living if it is the better way for me to make a living, earn a livelihood, than what I am doing for a living at present.

Is that being wicked to Buddhists, to you? I do feel a bit of qualms, to be honest; but you guys are of tougher stuff than kids who still believe in Santa Claus.

And besides, if you should lose your Buddhist faith or philosophy owing to my skeptical criticism here -- just to indulge in self-adulation here -- there are others who are greatly relieved to have passed out of Buddhism, people even deeper and higher into Buddhism than the Buddhists here. And I am almost certain that one day you might decide with courage to step out altogether from Buddhism and just live like everyone else non-Buddhist, without what I might say carrying all that knapsack of Buddhist beliefs and observances all the time on your shoulders -- like student travelers on a string budget.

A flash of enlightenment: string budget... if your budget of thinking and feeling and living were much more luxurious, I am sure that you would not have to bear that knapsack everywhere and every time, and keep on explaining the knapsack and defending it to people curious with your condition.


Yrreg, etc., etc., etc.

Proceed to next post.

Yrreg
 
I'm not big on authority figures myself, especially if they're me. I can't set myself up as an authority figure or try to mediate discussions between other people without violating what I think skepticism is about.

Of course, I do occasionally try to mediate, but I like to keep as light a hand as possible. Right now, people are actually talking.

It's just that I would like to see Yrreg back up his claims a bit, instead of having to defend every notion he pulls out of his ass.

Ah well.
 
I cannot find it on Google, but isn't there an old saying something like "before one can knock down a Buddha, one must grow a gold fist"?
 
This is the first time I've heard of this. I was raised a Buddhist in Singapore. While I do not always agree with the way Buddhism is practised around here, mainstream Buddhism in Singapore, Hong Kong and Taiwan definitely believe in the "fact" of reincarnation. They believe that karma dictates your next life, rebirth is part of suffering, and that Nirvana is the ultimate state where one is free of karma and will therefore no longer be reborn. Having attended several dharma talks in my younger believer days, I have never once come across a single practioner, local or foreign, from the Mahayana or Theravada traditions, who ever rejected reincarnation.

During my high school days, it was compulsory for all students in Singapore to take a religious studies class of our own choice. I opted for Buddhist Studies. The syllabus adopted officially by the Ministry of Education also taught reincarnation as one of the central beliefs of Buddhism. No Buddhist organisation that I'm aware of challenged it.


Thanks for the information about the state of Buddhism in your country. I didn't know much about the Buddhism of Singapore, so I looked around on Wikipeda and found these articles :

Religion in Singapore.

Buddhism in Singapore.

It seems the Buddhist population in Singapore is very varied, with both Mahayana and Theravada populations, so I'm guessing it's very hard to find a common ground and a singular teaching to teach.

As for the Buddhist view on Reincarnation, we can once again turn to Wikipeda. This is what Wikipeda has to say about reincarnation in Buddhism :

Since according to Buddhism there is no permanent and unchanging soul there is no metempsychosis in the strict sense. However, Buddhism never rejected samsara, the process of rebirth or reincarnation; there is debate, however, over what is transmitted between lives.

See also: Rebirth (Buddhist)

Reincarnation and rebirth are often confused with each other. Are Singapore school books in English, or in a more native language? Perhaps there are some translation problems?

The Buddha has this to say on reincarnation.

Kutadanta continued: "Thou believest, O Master, that beings are reborn; that they migrate in the evolution of life; and that subject to the law of karma we must reap what we sow. Yet thou teachest the non-existence of the soul! Thy disciples praise utter self-extinction as the highest bliss of Nirvana. If I am merely a combination of the sankharas, my existence will cease when I die. If I am merely a compound of sensations and ideas and desires, wither can I go at the dissolution of the body?" [7] Said the Blessed One: "O Brahman, thou art religious and earnest. Thou art seriously concerned about thy soul. Yet is thy work in vain because thou art lacking in the one thing that is needful. [8] "There is rebirth of character, but no transmigration of a self. Thy thought-forms reappear, but there is no egoentity transferred. The stanza uttered by a teacher is reborn in the scholar who repeats the word. [9]
 
We have several communication gaps here, Ryokan. 2

I consider Epepke as an adviser, even a teacher, in skeptical criticism, but I don't know the man from Jupiter and Juno. He is a real skeptic because he doesn't harbor any sacred cows, which I can't say about the Buddhists here. But sometimes rarely I am disappointed, when I asked him for information or his educated opinion, he appeared to be wanting or to be non-committal. Nevertheless, he gives me the impression of a skeptic with a lot of learning and thinking and years of experience in skeptical criticism.

------------

Dear Ryokan, you use the word 'strawman' rather freely in your messages to me, just like D David with his favorite epithet on me of a troll, as though these words for you and for D David are ejaculations (pun not intended) uttered by Christians, for example, Holy God, Mother Mary. If you would be genuinely skeptical, you would look into what you think to be strawmen or troll instances, as so many occasions to think along the lines introduced in the strawman or the trollish statement.

------------

Yrreg, you must etc., etc., etc.
My responses in bold

========================

  • Originally Posted by yrreg :
    [*]This thought had alway been at the tip of my tongue but I always failed to bring it out into words, for having been attracted to many other also equally or more thrilling issues, namely, that -- and this is my impression, so it might not be exactly correct -- the Buddhists I meet here, specially the ones most enthusiastic in explaining and in defending Buddhist beliefs and practices, are obsessed with tracing a teaching to the Buddha in order to give it credence; aren't there insights in Buddhism already in their intrinsic character credible even if Buddha didn't formulate a statement for them?​

  • Yrreg, you must be new to scepticism, so I'm going to spell it out for you again.

  • When you make a claim on this board, you're supposed to back up your claim with external sources. If you don't, they're just empty words. When you tell us three stories of what Buddhists 'really' believe about the self, I would like to see the sources for those stories. Why won't you tell me the source?

  • I'm not asking because I want to 'trace the teachings to the Buddha', but because I'm fairly certain that the source is bogus. The fact that you refuse to admit the source of the stories just makes me more certain that they're just that, bogus. So what say you, Yrreg, will you show us the source of your Buddhist stories?

    What or who gives you the idea that I am quoting from Buddhist sources? Did I give any indications at all that I am quoting from Buddhist sources? Please read carefully those posts from me where I mentioned those stories, and see whether I gave any indications at all that I am citing from Buddhist sources

  • Epepke, I know you have some influence over Yrreg, could you please tell him the importance of backing up his sources and claims with external evidence?

  • Originally Posted by yrreg :
    [*]I remember I suggested to Ryokan once that he might consider doing a project whereby he would rewrite the important core teachings of Buddhism, but leaving out altogether any mention of Buddha's name, and see whether people reading them without the mention whatsoever of Buddha's name, can be impressed by them as to adopt them for life's lessons reaching beyond the grave. I can't recall now what was his reaction; but I am inclined to feel that he dismissed the idea as not worth his attention or speculative curiosity.​

  • Actually, the idea isn't bad at all. The Buddha really isn't needed at all, his teachings do not stand and fall on him.

    In which case you don't have to call yourself a Buddhist, just call yourself a, for example, 4Truist-8Pathist; and admit that you got your beliefs and practices from Buddha's allegedly original teachings, but they are good enough even without Buddha's saying so; just as the Theory of Relativity and the Theory of Evolution are good enough if people don't know absolutely nothing about Einstein and Darwin. You make so much of being called a Buddhist, that I do have the impression that you are a cultist -- no offense intended with the name, though.

  • Originally Posted by yrreg :
    [*]I brought forth maybe three or is it two stories illustrating how non-self does not work in real life situations, and Ryokan now as before when those stories were told wanted to know the source. Here is where I think Ryokan and the Buddhists here, who have been conditioned to believe on the authority of the Buddha, also carry over this habit to illustrative narratives from non-Buddhist wit-crackers, intended to set forth perceptions of common everyday good sense.​

  • Your three stories misrepresented the Buddhist view on non-self, and were probably made to make fun of Buddhists. You have made a claim that the stories show what Buddhists really believe. But how do we know you didn't just make those stories up? Are you going to show us the source of those stories, or are you afraid that once we know the source we'll dismiss it as unreliable?

    I am not claiming to faithfully represent any Buddhist doctrines, nor quoting any Buddhist sources. My point is that if you use language other people also use before you started with your system of thinking and acting, then people will draw conclusions leading to absurd situations, based on their traditional and common and ordinary understanding of the words you use, which they have always used but understand in their accustomed from long ago meanings and senses. Tell you what, you have to invent new terms in English, just as Buddha should have invented new terms to introduce into his mother tongue be it Pali or Sanskrit or whatever. Take the lead from that guy who goes around telling people that religion is a meme, that word, 'meme,' is his contribution (correct me if I am wrong) to English even though it is from the Greek.

  • Unless you show evidence that those stories contain what Buddhists really believe, they can be dismissed. If the source is unreliable, they can be dismissed. Farewell, stories.

  • Originally Posted by yrreg :
    [*]What do you say? good Buddhist friends here, that you have been conditioned to believe on the authority of the Buddha, so that without knowing it you also tend to seek the authors of stories before seeing their worth in the plot and style alone without reference to the authors.​

  • The Buddha has no authority whatsoever. He's dead. I want to know the author of your stories to see how credible they are.

  • Originally Posted by yrreg :
    [*]Allow me to address to you this suspicion: Did you first fall in love with the Buddha, and then accept Buddhistic teachings and exercises advocated by your instructors in the name of the Buddha?​

  • You can lay your suspicions at rest. My first meeting with Buddhism was through Zen, and they don't hold the Buddha as a central figure. It took many years, and a very sceptical approach, before I finally read the original teachings of the Buddha.

    That's what I find most amazing and most disappointing with Buddhists here who claim to have Skeptic's mind and nature or Skeptic-hood, that you keep on hammering about the original teachings of the Buddha, when in your critical intelligence you should know that no one can in fact point out any final definitive documentary record or manuscript written by the Buddha; and writing in his time and place was already practiced widely among people like himself who liked to talk religion and philosophy for a worldview. I for one appreciate tremendously any ancient writers who took the trouble and care to write their corrections, retractions, revisions, additions on their earlier writings before they died, in order that posterity would know their definitive mind. But not the Buddha, and you folks, skeptical Buddhists keep on insisting on the original teachings of the Buddha; this is what I call swashbuckling in the air. Are you guys, seriously now, Buddhists first and skeptics second, or the other way around?



[Hahaha softly]


Yrreg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom