Budhism Is Not A Religion

Some quick questions: If Buddhism is not a religion, then why give it a name? Why not teach the philosophies as philosophies of life, rather than giving it the attributes of an organization? If I came up with the same ideas and practices without a knowledge of Buddha, would I be a Buddhist? I wouldn't call myself that. So, other than the philosophical aspects that one could arrive at without the knowledge of Buudha, there must be some reason for the organization, even if it is only in the way of fellowship.

Any thoughts?
 
Some quick questions: If Buddhism is not a religion, then why give it a name? Why not teach the philosophies as philosophies of life, rather than giving it the attributes of an organization? If I came up with the same ideas and practices without a knowledge of Buddha, would I be a Buddhist? I wouldn't call myself that. So, other than the philosophical aspects that one could arrive at without the knowledge of Buudha, there must be some reason for the organization, even if it is only in the way of fellowship.

Any thoughts?

The Buddhist philosophy of the Noble Eightfold Path (NEP) can be adopted as a secular moral code. However, the reasons for adopting the NEP, as explained in the Four Noble Truths, contain elements from the supernatural. NEP is supposed to lead to the end of suffering, which in Buddhist terms mean an end to the continuous karmic cycle of deaths and rebirths. The end of suffering lies nirvana, an ultimate state that can only be understood by those who are enlightened enough to experience it. Rebirth, karma and nirvana are tenets which Buddhists accept by faith since they're not falsifiable. In that sense, Buddhism becomes a religion based on the teachings of the Buddha.
 
Dear yrreg,

What's your point about acupuncture and Buddhism? It's like trying to link Christians with homeopathy just because both ideas were brought over from the West. While some Asians may be Buddhists and also believe in the efficacy of acupuncture, the two beliefs are independent of each other. You can be a Buddhist and not accept acupuncture. You can believe in acupuncture and yet be a Christian here.

Finally, some words of advice. The athiests who engage Christians in debating these forums know well enough to arm themselves with knowledge from biblical and extra-biblical sources in order to form cogent arguments against the theistic challenges. If you truly wish to criticise Buddhism, then I would advise that you actually read up some Buddhist texts. It doesn't have to be the sutras. Even an introductory text to the history and teachings of Buddhism would go a long way to improve your arguments. As I see it, you are attacking Buddhism from a position of ignorance, which can only damage your credibility.
 
The Buddhist philosophy of the Noble Eightfold Path (NEP) can be adopted as a secular moral code. However, the reasons for adopting the NEP, as explained in the Four Noble Truths, contain elements from the supernatural. NEP is supposed to lead to the end of suffering, which in Buddhist terms mean an end to the continuous karmic cycle of deaths and rebirths. The end of suffering lies nirvana, an ultimate state that can only be understood by those who are enlightened enough to experience it. Rebirth, karma and nirvana are tenets which Buddhists accept by faith since they're not falsifiable. In that sense, Buddhism becomes a religion based on the teachings of the Buddha.


Would it be correct in saying that if I were to drop the religious/supernatural aspects, then it would no longer be Buddhism, but simply independent philosophical ideas, since it is not excplicitly what Buddha had taught? Anyone who claims that they are a non-religion-Buddhist are mistaken; they have borrowed some philosophies that they find useful, but they do not follow the teachings of Buddha and are not Buddhists. Is this right?
 
Would it be correct in saying that if I were to drop the religious/supernatural aspects, then it would no longer be Buddhism, but simply independent philosophical ideas, since it is not excplicitly what Buddha had taught? Anyone who claims that they are a non-religion-Buddhist are mistaken; they have borrowed some philosophies that they find useful, but they do not follow the teachings of Buddha and are not Buddhists. Is this right?

You are correct.

If you look at the NEP's message to practise Right View, Right Intention, Right Speech, Right Action, Right Livelihood, Right Effort, Right Mindfulness and Right Concentration, they are commonsense guidelines to leading a moral and fulfilling life of little regret. You don't have to be a Buddhist to follow them. In contrast, the first three of the 10 Commandments commonly accepted by Christians are totally inapplicable if you don't believe in God, and the other 7 form a poor subset of the NEP.

I've always been amused that a mere man (the Buddha) has the ability to compile a more sophisticated moral system using only 8 simple rules than an allegedly all-knowing deity with 10 wordy ones. ;)
 
Some quick questions: If Buddhism is not a religion, then why give it a name?
The buddha never claimed to have devine inspiration or extranatural powers. It is a religion in the sense that it is a teaching concerning spirituality, as defined by some.
Why not teach the philosophies as philosophies of life, rather than giving it the attributes of an organization? If I came up with the same ideas and practices without a knowledge of Buddha, would I be a Buddhist?
The buddha never taught his thoughts as an organised religion in the sense of modern religion, he was immersed in a very religous culture. And his foolowers added most of the religous elements. IMO.
And no you would not be a direct buddhist, as a buddhist is someone who calls themselves a buddhist.
I wouldn't call myself that. So, other than the philosophical aspects that one could arrive at without the knowledge of Buudha, there must be some reason for the organization, even if it is only in the way of fellowship.

Any thoughts?

The last part is true, the sangha is meant to be a refuge to aid in the path of enlightenment.
 
Some quick questions: If Buddhism is not a religion, then why give it a name? Why not teach the philosophies as philosophies of life, rather than giving it the attributes of an organization? If I came up with the same ideas and practices without a knowledge of Buddha, would I be a Buddhist? I wouldn't call myself that. So, other than the philosophical aspects that one could arrive at without the knowledge of Buudha, there must be some reason for the organization, even if it is only in the way of fellowship.

Often, names are given to philosophies (Idealism, Existentialism, Objectivism, etc.)

As far as I can tell, there are a number of reasons to consider Buddhism a religion:

1) It has concepts that are essentially religious (karma, nirvana, rebirth, and sometimes reincarnation).

2) It has the trappings of religion (monks, monasteries, temples, holy sites, idols).

3) Our friend who has experience with Chinese Buddhism says that it's treated as a religion.

4) Buddhist organizations qualify as religious organizations in the US.

5) You can write "Buddhist" on the line that asks for religion, and nobody will bat an eye.
 
Yrreg's definition of religion.

When I was in high school I wrote a five page composition on what is religion; and to this day I still see my definition to be the most decisive for mankind since the dawn of religion, to judge something to be a religion as distinct from apples, oranges, dogs, cats, jungle, business, politics, and philosophy, yes sciences and arts.

Here it is:

Religion is a human behavior founded upon a belief in an unknown power resulting in affections and actions intended by the believer to influence the unknown power to react favorably to the believer.​

On the basis of my definition of religion, Buddhism is certainly a religion; it satisfies all the elements of my definition of a religion.

But Buddhists of the West, they are all converts not born to Buddhism, they love to insist that Buddha is an atheist; the dude is actually a polytheist, a believer in gods with no one god above all gods.

Buddhist converts from the West can read anything and everything they want to or not want to in the Buddhist scriptures, because like other scriptures of other religions, peoples following the religion can read anything and everything in the scriptures which they want to or not want to. Why? because there are so many materials in them scriptures that if you have just 10% resourcefulness in the use of your imagination, and you have an obsession to embrace some idea however crazy or reject one however sane, you will find some grounds in the scriptures of your religion.

However, to know the most general and thus most concurring positions about Buddhism, you must go to the peoples who have been identified by outsiders as Buddhists for millennia, in the Far East: they are the peoples to tell Westerners what is Buddhism and what Buddha taught, not any newcomer from the West hoping for therapy to their difficult adjustments to the reality of life, its difficulties and its challenges and its trials, but remember the normal life is replete with pleasures, joys, and good instances and durations of happiness.

But I digress, we are talking about how and why Buddhism is a religion, and according to my definition of religion, it satisfies all the elements in my definition.

Yes, I was going to dwell on what is the unknown power in Buddhism if we grant though not conceding that Buddha was an atheist and Buddhists are atheists -- which again is patently false, just visit the nearest Buddhist sangha even in the US and UK and Continental Europe and Australia, and you will see that even Western converts to Buddhism are not atheists but polytheists, their gods are all superior to humans but none of them a one supreme chief of all gods and men and animals and plants and the rest of the inanimate and impersonal universe.

Okay, no more digression, what is the unknown power of Buddhism and Buddhists, including the converts among Westerners to Buddhism (careful now, I might digress a little bit but relevantly, again)?

It is the whole caboodle of Buddhist ontology, consisting of karma, rebirth, and nirvana. I call it the unknown power in the sense that you cannot really know it like you know your pet dog and cat at home; but it is this unknown power that Buddhists are trying to influence by affections and actions for it to react favorably to themselves, so that they will reach enlightenment and get to nirvana, even though they confess themselves to be beyond comprehension exactly what this nirvana is all about, except and here is the tragedy, it is no longer life as we have it today and want to improve on, and on and on; nirvana for the Buddhists is everything that is opposite to what we count most precious, life and its pleasures, joys, happiness, that is why it is if we would attend to the etymology of the word nirvana, extinction of the self or the universe, everything, all in the name of liberation, from what? from suffering.


Talk about throwing out the baby with the bathwater, that is Buddhism.

If you would like to exercise your brain cells, tell me something that is known and called by mankind to be religion, then show me that it is not a religion on the basis of my definition of religion.

Next, give me any world-view or system of thought and action that is known by mankind to be not religion, and thus not included in mankind's idea of religion, and try to show me on the basis of my definition of religion that it is in fact a religion.


You, everynoe, can use my definition of religion freely, but for my vanity if you will cater to it, just also mention that is comes from Yrreg, who does criticism and critique of Buddhism for fun as a hobby, for a workout of his brain cells.


There, that's part of my workout for my brain cells this morning.


Yrreg

=========================================

My words may not be soothing, but consider the ideas

The Buddhist non-self, and its implications, living the everyday non-self existence?
http://www.lioncity.net/buddhism/ind...ost&pid=500486

[From the Kalama Sutra by Gautama]

01. Do not believe in anything simply because you have heard it long ago.
02. Do not believe in traditions simply because they have been handed down for many generations.
03. Do not believe in anything simply because it is spoken and rumored by many.
04. Do not confirm anything just because it agrees with your scriptures.
05. Do not foolishly make assumptions.
06. Do not abruptly draw conclusions by what you see and hear.
07. Do not be fooled by outward appearances.
08. Do not hold on tightly to any view or idea just because you are comfortable with it.
09. Do not accept as fact anything that you yourself find to be logical.
10. Do not be convinced of anything out of respect and deference to your spiritual teachers.
11. Do not believe in anything merely on the authority of your teachers and elders.​

But after observation and analysis, when you find that anything agrees with reasons and is conducive to the good and benefit of one and all, then accept it and live up to it.

See: http://www.buddhistinformation.com/the_kalama_sutra.htm
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom