Brain dead but still in treatment?

"The hospital released Jahi on Sunday to the Alameda County coroner, who then released her to her mother's custody, (for transport)..."

That is what happens if you want to arrange a body's transport to say, a crematorium- or the ashes to spread- the family signs for 'transport of remains'.

Family is now claiming that her body degenerated due to poor care by the hospital, after death.

I did look at her pics. I have seen LOTS of fatter people. She must have been pretty tall too.

According to the news today the coroner released her body after issuing a death certificate. SOP in these cases.
 
But people get all huffy if the topic is raised. It's bad for someone's self-esteem to criticise their weight. How dare you mention it! People have a right to be whatever shape they want without being judged!

Rolfe.

Judged? By whom and for what? They do have the right to be what ever size they want and are not subject to approval. Who walks around thinking; that person's fat, I need to remind them?
 
By their doctor, giving them health advice.

Rolfe.

But people get all huffy if the topic is raised. It's bad for someone's self-esteem to criticise their weight. How dare you mention it! People have a right to be whatever shape they want without being judged!

Rolfe.

Health advice sounds remarkably different than criticize and being judged. How is it you know the huffiness of their reaction to a conversation with their doctor?
 
It wasn't just because she overate. It wasn't that simple. She had severe sleep apnea, partially caused by her weight, compounded by the tonsils.

She underwent multiple surgeries while she was under, which was the responsible medical thing to do, based on her weight. After she woke up, something went horribly wrong, with all the bleeding going on.

Being fat isn't the only reason people have serious health issues. If so, football players would be dropping like flies.
 
Are there formal rules for when an autopsy has to be performed? I thought that in cases where there is uncertainty in the cause of death that an autopsy had to be performed.
 
So who's paying? I'm genuinely baffled. (And I thought you guys didn't have death panels! :rolleyes: )

Rolfe.

For the care provided after she was declared dead, the hospital is paying. They will no doubt be sued by the family as well. It will all get sorted out by the courts.

Another child underwent similar surgery there two years ago and suffered severe brain damage. Hospital settled for an undisclosed sum, probably hundreds of thousands, on top of $4.4 million from anesthesiologist, etc. Google Rebecca Jimenez Oakland Childrens Hospital for details.

ETA: the family is paying for Jahi's care now that she has been removed from the hospital, supported by donations it would seem.
 
Last edited:
Is there a reliable source that can provide the timeline of events from the surgery prep to the declaration of brain death?
 
Is there a reliable source that can provide the timeline of events from the surgery prep to the declaration of brain death?

Hospital would be primary reliable source, medical records are private. If there is a lawsuit and trial, detailed timeline might be made public.
 
....

Being fat isn't the only reason people have serious health issues. If so, football players would be dropping like flies.

Latest I heard is NFL players lifespans average 55 years.
 
Latest I heard is NFL players lifespans average 55 years.

I was going to post that but then checked it out. Not sure it's true. Two studied by NIOSH in the 1990s say that NFL players actually live longer but Harvard made this claim:

The result is a dramatically shortened life span: While white men in the United States on average live to age 78 and African-American men to about 70, “it appears that professional football players in both the United States and Canada have life expectencies in the mid- to late-50s,” Harvard researchers wrote in a summary of their project.

Of course, Harvard received $100 million to study the issue in 2012 so maybe it was wise of them to repeat the old claim.

I'm not sure which is correct.
 
These people remind me of a couple i watched a news report about. Their kid was essentially born without a cerebrum but since its brain stem was well developed it was still "alive", although i guess alive is not really a reasonable description. More like breathing and reflexively flailing about.

Yet they kept on playing with their kid, taking it for walks and so on, as if there really was a person in there. People just need to learn to let go.
 
These people remind me of a couple i watched a news report about. Their kid was essentially born without a cerebrum but since its brain stem was well developed it was still "alive", although i guess alive is not really a reasonable description. More like breathing and reflexively flailing about.

Yet they kept on playing with their kid, taking it for walks and so on, as if there really was a person in there. People just need to learn to let go.

If you're talking about Anencephaly then this may be what you're referring to

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ShMf1X6PqCk
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom