Brain dead but still in treatment?

She has never been connected to a gastric feeding tube. She hasn't starved yet because she was obese at the time of her surgery. Contrary to a lot of media reports, she did not undergo a "routine" tonsillectomy but a series of procedures to remove her tonsils, adenoids, and tissue in her nasal cavity, sinuses, and throat in an attempt to alleviate obstructive sleep apnea, which is frequently caused by obesity.

It's frustrating how the media sensationalizes and oversimplifies. That's nothing like routine, routine isn't a word that comes close to the description you just gave.
 
It seems to me that the hospital has created a Catch 22. They are glad to have her transferred to another facility, but they refuse to insert the feeding tube that is required for such a transfer to take place.

If I were the hospital director, I would say, insert the tube and get her out of here.

And she "dies" in transit and the hospital is sued for putting in the tube wrong... It's a no-win situation.
 
And she "dies" in transit and the hospital is sued for putting in the tube wrong... It's a no-win situation.

She is already dead, she can't die twice.

The hospital will be sued no matter what, you can be sure of that. I think the hospital is simply standing on ethical grounds and refusing to perform a life support procedure on a dead person. They have already taken this position so it would not look good to reverse themselves now. They have nothing to gain by putting in the feeding tube at this point. In fact, who says it is a "requirement" for a feeding tube to be in place so she can be moved? A feeding tube is hardly required to move a dead person. I am guessing the family's lawyer is asking for this for reasons of his own.
 
It's just a tragedy, any way you look at it.

I was a bit shocked when I saw the photos of the "13-year-old". This girl was indeed obese. The operation was necessary to try to relieve some symptoms a 13-year-old should never be having, but she was having because of her weight.

I wonder if there is a bit of guilt involved in the family's refusal to accept reality?
Rolfe.

I read one comment in another article that indicated this. The mother is trying to do everything she possibly can to reassure herself that she did all the right things. Sadly, at the end of the day she will have to let go of her daughter and try to forgive herself for her mistakes.

Parents must begin to take this childhood obesity problem much more seriously.
 
It did sound a bit that way. Of course the USA is full of obese children, and most of them don't die of it at thirteen, but it's a fair conclusion that the obesity was the actual underlying cause of death. It would be understandable if the parents were in denial about all this now.

Rolfe.
 
Is it a cemetery?

It's a rehabilitation center in New York for sufferers of traumatic brain injury and other forms of brain damage. It is called New Beginnings Community Center and they have a website. It remains to be seen whether she will actually go there.
 
She is already dead, she can't die twice.

You'd think so. But how dead could she have been, really, if her transport did require a feeding tube? :boxedin:

I can think of a few other problems:

Are doctors allowed to operate or perform procedures on dead people?
Under what circumstances?
At which locations, and using what kind of equipment? Specifically, can they use stuff that's meant to be used for the living?

I've heard from Paramedics that they *never* have a patient die en route to the hospital in their ambulance. Patients *always* survive until the stretcher has passed through the hospital doors, at which point some of them occasionally decease. I am sure they are all very happy about that, seeing how an exitus in the vehicle would end up with the vehicle being grounded for a considerable length of time ...
 
link. "Dr. Paul Byrne, a pediatrician who has questioned the definition of brain death, says in court documents that he visited Jahi's bedside and observed her responding to her grandmother's voice and touch with a squirming movement.

'In my opinion this signifies she is not dead,' Byrne said. "She should receive treatment as she is alive just like everyone else with severe head injury. ... If she gets treatment, she will have a chance to recover brain function."

I have no special knowledge or training in these issues, and for all I know Dr. Byrne might be completely wrong. My reason for bringing this up is that it may be relevant to the question of why the family is taking the path that it is.
 
As of last night, she has been moved out of the hospital and is en route to an undisclosed location.

According to the San Francisco Chronicle:

Jahi's family and her attorney do not believe the girl is dead, citing her beating heart and occasional movements.

"She's not passed," Dolan said Sunday. "Her heart beats. Her kidneys function. She regulates her body temperature. ... She should not be treated as a dead person."

In documents filed in federal court on Friday, the director of Children's pediatric intensive care unit said that movements by a brain-dead person are not uncommon and are not an indication that Jahi is alive.

The movements are caused by spinal and muscular reflexes, said Dr. Heidi Flori.

"We anticipate that muscle activity will continue over time, given that Ms. McMath's body is being sustained" by a ventilator, nursing care, and an IV drip providing fluids, salt and carbohydrates, she said.

Nonetheless, the condition of Jahi's body is declining overall, she said.

"The body continues to deteriorate, with a gradual decrease in blood pressure," she said.
 
Last edited:
You'd think so. But how dead could she have been, really, if her transport did require a feeding tube? :boxedin:

I can think of a few other problems:

Are doctors allowed to operate or perform procedures on dead people?
Under what circumstances?
At which locations, and using what kind of equipment? Specifically, can they use stuff that's meant to be used for the living?

I've heard from Paramedics that they *never* have a patient die en route to the hospital in their ambulance. Patients *always* survive until the stretcher has passed through the hospital doors, at which point some of them occasionally decease. I am sure they are all very happy about that, seeing how an exitus in the vehicle would end up with the vehicle being grounded for a considerable length of time ...

Isn't that because they aren't allowed to declare someone dead?
 
"In some jurisdictions, a police officer or a paramedic may be allowed to sign a death certificate under specific circumstances. This is usually when the cause of death seems obvious and no foul play is suspected, such as in extreme old age. In such cases, an autopsy is rarely performed. This varies from jurisdiction to jurisdiction; in some areas police officers may sign death certificates for victims of SIDS,[citation needed] but in others all deaths of individuals under 18 must be certified by a physician. Accident deaths where there is no chance of survival (decapitations, for instance) may be certified by police or paramedics, but autopsies are still commonly performed if there is any chance that alcohol or drugs played a role in the accident." Death certificateWP
 
Of course they have. Every "pro-life" whack-a-loon is going to come crawling out of the woodwork for this one.

I have to wonder if any politicians are making noise about this yet?

Should be quite entertaining.

This isn't an abortion issue.
 
Okay, here's my perspective...

(1) I'm deeply concerned about a judge offering a restraining order interfering with a medical diagnosis of brain death. This sets a terrible precedent in California.

(2) I am equally concerned about the joke that HIPAA has become in this case. While it doesn't change my opinion that this law is primarily geared towards punishing co-workers rather than protecting patient information, I'd like some reassurance that a minor's medical information is being discussed in the public with at least someone's consent.

(3) I don't have access to the medical records but, having had to be in this difficult situation with family members in the past, I can tell you it takes tremendous patience, reassurance, and explanation that your diagnosis is correct. If they did a cerebral blood flow study and an MRI - which, in this case, I have almost absolute certainty that they did - and there is no blood flow to the brain stem, she is dead. The movement they are seeing are spinal reflexes.

(4) Not to sound callous, but how does a 13-year-old girl get to 225 lbs and need a tonsillectomy and palatoplasty for obstructive sleep apnea in the first place? This is the bigger story, in my opinion.

(5) Who's paying for all this? Presumably the bill for all the extra and unnecessary care tjos dead body is getting will be covered by whatever settlement the plaintiff's attorneys get from all of the healthcare workers they will be suing. Welcome to medical practice in America. It's never the patient's (or their parents') fault; it's always the doctor's fault (see #4).

~Dr. Imago
 
Do we know the brain is decomposing? Do they do brain scans to prove this?
 
The lawyers may have another motive. Malpractice is CA is limited to $250,000 in non-economic damages. Since the girl is dead, the amount of non-economic damages is very low at this point. If she requires a lifetime of care and treatment as a living victim, the economic damages will be astronomical. It might be in the lawyer's best financial interest to keep this going indefinitely. Unfortunately at the emotional cost of this poor family.

Terribly sad. I feel for the family. When you hear them in interviews, they are counting 100% on a religious type of miracle.
 
Do we know the brain is decomposing? Do they do brain scans to prove this?

If there is not adequate blood flow to and through the brainstem (which a cerebral blood flow study would show), the brain starts to "die" in about 6-12 minutes (depending on which sources you want to credit). Irreversible brain damage occurs in less than a half-hour.

An initial brain CT would show diffuse loss of gray-white matter differentiation. This far out, you would expect to see massive gliosis and apoptosis consistent with loss of brain matter and replacement with non-neuronal cell matter.

So, "decomposing" is not really the right term. Something more like "permanent, irreversible damage" would be better. And, a brain cannot function once apoptosis and global gliosis has occurred. It is no longer really a brain, per se.

~Dr. Imago
 
Dr. Imago, how long can they keep an acerebrate body "alive" like this? It's not something I have any experience with, obviously. But could they keep this macabre charade up for years if the parents don't wise up and someone is providing the money?

Rolfe.
 
When you hear them in interviews, they are counting 100% on a religious type of miracle.

Been there, done that. Numerous times. I could tell you stories.

But, will give you just one... There was a trisomy 13 baby born on our unit when I was in residency. The parents, from Haiti, threatened to sue anyone who refused to give her full care, despite the death sentence that this diagnosis carried, the multiple heart defects the child had, and that this mother had come to the hospital with zero prenatal care. The family even played the racial card. I personally heard, "You wouldn't be telling us this if we weren't black!"

We tortured that poor baby for more than six months. Fortunately, I was off service so I didn't see it happening. What was the end result? Of course, death. That, and all the care that they ultimately didn't pay being passed-off onto other insured patients and their families. That's the way it works in the U.S.

Without including tort reform, you can propose any type of "healthcare reform" you want in this country. It ain't ever gonna fly in the long run while doctors have to function under the scepter of constant lawsuits, even when they do the right thing. It's not worth the hassle of trying to do the right thing when there are any number of ambulance-chasers out there willing to take a case, regardless of actual merit, hoping for a quick settlement. So, we take the path of least resistance.

That's precisely what's happening in the Jahi McMath case.

~Dr. Imago
 
(4) Not to sound callous, but how does a 13-year-old girl get to 225 lbs and need a tonsillectomy and palatoplasty for obstructive sleep apnea in the first place? This is the bigger story, in my opinion.


My God, I was only going by the photos, but that's over 16 stones, over 100 kg.

That is the story, and I suspect the underlying reason for the parents' denial. The real cause of death was obesity, and unless she had some rare eating compulsion, whose fault is that in a 13 year old girl?

I suppose the parents are morbidly obese themselves? Maybe there's a bit of PC "don't criticise anyone's bodyweight or body shape choices" going on? It's just a tragedy whichever way you look at it.

Rolfe.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom