Brain dead but still in treatment?

A visit to a lengthy article from February in the New Yorker that I had not seen before. I hope it is not behind a paywall for others:

https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/...pJobID=1541880026&spReportId=MTU0MTg4MDAyNgS2

Presents more of the family's side of the events and issues than I've typically read, some of which may have "evolved' in their memory over time. But whatever one's perspective I believe it provides a lot more information about specific events and facts than anything else I've come across before. At the minimum it reveals some of the complexities involved that are often lost in the simplified politically polarized public discussions of this case.

My own conclusion remains that Jahi McMath was "brain-dead" by what to me were adequate criteria to be "dead-enough." I would not have wanted to be maintained as she was. But it does appear that the family was not completely irrational in their early reactions to the medical care she received nor did they have zero reason to question the declarations of medical brain death.

It is undoubtably true that Jahi sustained permanent and extraordinarily severe brain damage that would lead to her immediate physical death without intense constant medical support. And which indeed did result in her undeniable death after the article was published. To say that she was in a deep, deep coma before that would be under-estimating her condition. However the precise nature and locations of the damage may have left her with a very, very weak level of consciousness, perhaps barely beyond pure reflex. Or not and any of her apparently weak responses were purely reflexive and desperately latched on as evidence of consciousness by her family. Whichever was true may be impossible to ever know.

An interesting article no matter one's viewpoint.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom