Brain dead but still in treatment?

Bob001

Penultimate Amazing
Joined
Dec 21, 2006
Messages
16,613
Location
US of A
There doesn't seem to be a thread about the tragic case of Jahi McMath, the teenage girl who suffered terrible complications during a tonsillectomy. Multiple doctors have determined that she is brain-dead, but her family disagrees. CNN just reported that she is being transferred to a long-term care facility whose representative was interviewed and claimed that her own father and other patients had recovered from brain death and "prayer is powerful" and girl is inside just waiting to come out.

What's going on here? Dead is dead, right? Is this heartbroken family being victimized by con artists, or is there any guesswork associated with a determination of brain death, or what? I understand that machines can (and in this case will) maintain heartbeat, breathing etc., but is there any doubt about brain death? How is this possible?
http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2014/01/03/jahi-mcmath-brain-dead-hospital/4307907/
 
There doesn't seem to be a thread about the tragic case of Jahi McMath, the teenage girl who suffered terrible complications during a tonsillectomy. Multiple doctors have determined that she is brain-dead, but her family disagrees. CNN just reported that she is being transferred to a long-term care facility whose representative was interviewed and claimed that her own father and other patients had recovered from brain death and "prayer is powerful" and girl is inside just waiting to come out.

What's going on here? Dead is dead, right? Is this heartbroken family being victimized by con artists, or is there any guesswork associated with a determination of brain death, or what? I understand that machines can (and in this case will) maintain heartbeat, breathing etc., but is there any doubt about brain death? How is this possible?
http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2014/01/03/jahi-mcmath-brain-dead-hospital/4307907/

Yes, several doctors have refused to put in feeding tubes. Sad case.
 
Sad, the wishful thinking of the family only prolongs their own suffering.
 
There doesn't seem to be a thread about the tragic case of Jahi McMath, the teenage girl who suffered terrible complications during a tonsillectomy. Multiple doctors have determined that she is brain-dead, but her family disagrees. CNN just reported that she is being transferred to a long-term care facility whose representative was interviewed and claimed that her own father and other patients had recovered from brain death and "prayer is powerful" and girl is inside just waiting to come out.

What's going on here? Dead is dead, right? Is this heartbroken family being victimized by con artists, or is there any guesswork associated with a determination of brain death, or what? I understand that machines can (and in this case will) maintain heartbeat, breathing etc., but is there any doubt about brain death? How is this possible?
http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2014/01/03/jahi-mcmath-brain-dead-hospital/4307907/

I'll go for the con.
Brain deathWP is a definition of death, after all.

ETA
I have read various articles about 'brain dead' people recovering, but on a closer reading, the cases are actually of comas, not brain death. So I'll go for the con, definitely.
 
Last edited:
Is this heartbroken family being victimized by con artists, or is there any guesswork associated with a determination of brain death, or what?


They're being victimized by their own self-delusion.
 
They went looking for care facilities that would take her, not the other way around, so I wouldn't call it a con. Just delusional.

It was very refreshing to hear a discussion on NPR that didn't do the "give both sides" narrative thingy:

YOUNG: Well so she has been declared brain dead, and it's interesting because in reading some of the articles, people are tripping over their words. There was a facility that was going to take her in California, but then somebody issued a statement from Children's Hospital, where she is, saying we're not sure how to transport the deceased.

So, you know, already Children's Hospital is talking about her as being deceased. This other facility that said they might take her said that they couldn't because of the relationship with their doctors who refuse to treat people who have been declared brain dead.

ANNAS: They refuse to treat corpses, that's exactly correct, because they can't benefit them and medicine is done to try to benefit the patient, and once you're dead, you're dead. But you're absolutely right. It's the language we use. We just can't get over it. We keep talking about her being on life support. She's not on life support. She's on a mechanical ventilator that is usually used to support life, but in this case it's used to pump air into a corpse.

YOUNG: Yeah. So what are the family's options going forward? We were hearing early reports that there might be a New York hospital that might take her.

ANNAS: I just cannot imagine any hospital taking her, especially not with the publicity here. She's dead. She's really dead. And the courts recognized it. It shouldn't have gotten to court, but having gone to court a judge gets to make that call with the medical advice he got from his expert witness, from another physician.

I mean, that's all you can expect of a hospital, I think, is to give the family the option to get a second opinion. But once you have that second opinion, two physicians using traditional brain death criteria to declare death, that's the end. It's very sad. The only question after that is whether there's going to be organ donation, as well. I don't think that's a question in this case because I don't - but I don't know.

Linky.
 
The child's family is running a fundraiser on gofundme.com, which has raised over $47,000 so far, to help pay for getting her moved to another care facility. Given the unlikelihood of any facility (other than a mortuary) agreeing to accept a dead person, you have to wonder who is being conned here.
 
Someone on another site pointed out that they most likely just want her out of the hospital. Referring to someone's newly dead child as a "dead body" is a low blow.

I have a feeling once they get her out of there and somewhere where they feel they have more control and dignity, they will let her go on their terms.
 
Someone on another site pointed out that they most likely just want her out of the hospital. Referring to someone's newly dead child as a "dead body" is a low blow.

I have a feeling once they get her out of there and somewhere where they feel they have more control and dignity, they will let her go on their terms.

I read an article where they defended the wording by saying that they are trying, very hard, to make this clear to the parents - and that mild wording and kind phrasing was actually making it harder for them to understand.
 
The child's family is running a fundraiser on gofundme.com, which has raised over $47,000 so far, to help pay for getting her moved to another care facility. Given the unlikelihood of any facility (other than a mortuary) agreeing to accept a dead person, you have to wonder who is being conned here.


There's a place in New York that has already agreed to take her.
 
An interesting opinion piece here mentions
"The family’s lawyer has asked Children’s Hospital Oakland to perform a tracheotomy and insert a feeding tube, procedures necessary before any transfer.

The hospital had said it “does not believe that performing surgical procedures on the body of a deceased person is an appropriate medical practice.” It said transferring the girl would require the approval of the coroner, as she is considered legally dead."
 
She was declared brain dead on 12 Dec. How long has she been without a feeding tube? Is she getting water? Is she being otherwise treated like a comatose patient on life support (being bathed periodically, being moved to prevent bedsores, etc)? If she wasn't dead on 12 Dec and she's now been without a feeding tube or water for a couple of weeks isn't she certainly dead now?
 
She was declared brain dead on 12 Dec. How long has she been without a feeding tube? Is she getting water? Is she being otherwise treated like a comatose patient on life support (being bathed periodically, being moved to prevent bedsores, etc)? If she wasn't dead on 12 Dec and she's now been without a feeding tube or water for a couple of weeks isn't she certainly dead now?

There was a restraining order against removing her from life support. The order runs out on Tuesday at 5 pm.

http://www.reuters.com/article/2014/01/06/us-usa-braindead-california-idUSBREA020XW20140106
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom