Brain dead but still in treatment?

She was declared brain dead on 12 Dec. How long has she been without a feeding tube? Is she getting water? Is she being otherwise treated like a comatose patient on life support (being bathed periodically, being moved to prevent bedsores, etc)? If she wasn't dead on 12 Dec and she's now been without a feeding tube or water for a couple of weeks isn't she certainly dead now?

See post #6 above:
"We keep talking about her being on life support. She's not on life support. She's on a mechanical ventilator that is usually used to support life, but in this case it's used to pump air into a corpse."

I have to assume she has not had a feeding tube, as reported above the doctors will not do the procedure on a deceased person.
 
See post #6 above:
"We keep talking about her being on life support. She's not on life support. She's on a mechanical ventilator that is usually used to support life, but in this case it's used to pump air into a corpse."

I have to assume she has not had a feeding tube, as reported above the doctors will not do the procedure on a deceased person.

I'm still very confused, as I'm sure everyone is. So the hospital is currently refusing to insert a feeding tube into "the body of a deceased person" but was there a feeding tube in there on 12 Dec? If so, then when was it taken out? If not, then hasn't she indisputably starved to death by now?
 
This sad spectacle has the makings of Terri Schiavo part II

The thing is that Terri Schiavo was in a persistent vegetative state, and the medical issue was about whether to withdraw life support. This girl has already been declared dead.
 
I'm still very confused, as I'm sure everyone is. So the hospital is currently refusing to insert a feeding tube into "the body of a deceased person" but was there a feeding tube in there on 12 Dec? If so, then when was it taken out? If not, then hasn't she indisputably starved to death by now?

She has never been connected to a gastric feeding tube. She hasn't starved yet because she was obese at the time of her surgery. Contrary to a lot of media reports, she did not undergo a "routine" tonsillectomy but a series of procedures to remove her tonsils, adenoids, and tissue in her nasal cavity, sinuses, and throat in an attempt to alleviate obstructive sleep apnea, which is frequently caused by obesity.
 
Last edited:
If she was dead on 12 Dec and all she's got is the ventilator is she decomposing?
 
Last edited:
No, her brain is decomposing but life support is delivering oxygen to body tissues so they haven't started dying off and decomposing yet.
 
Last edited:
I have a feeling once they get her out of there and somewhere where they feel they have more control and dignity, they will let her go on their terms.

What leads you to suspect that?

........................

ETA:
This quote from the mother leads me to the opposite conclusion:


"She's definitely showing the improvements," Winkfield said Friday. "If I felt that my child was suffering in any type of way, I would not keep her on that machine. I love her that much that I would let her go. But because I see those improvements every day, I will fight for Jahi every day until my heart stops or her heart stops."
 
Last edited:
No, she's brain dead but life support is delivering oxygen to body tissues so they haven't started dying off and decomposing yet. Since it's dead, her brain is decomposing.

Oh wow, that's horrible. I think the family is being manipulated by the lawyer and the right-to-life crowd that want to make an example of this case like Terri Schiavo. Since she's black they can say that Jahi's not getting the same attention and consideration as a white woman even though the circumstances appear to be completely different. Many of the race-orientated articles I read today emphasized that this was a routine tonsillectomy and made no mention of obesity or sleep apnea or multiple surgeries or inpatient treatment.

I can't imagine what its going to be like when the lawyer has to give the family the bill ("sorry about your daughter, we did everything we could, that will be $150,000.00. We accept cash and credit card- no personal checks, please). I imagine the lawyer is banking on getting a big settlement from the hospital but its very possible that the family contributed to the complications that led to the severe bleeding and heart attack (giving her solid food even though she shouldn't be eating, letting her talk even though she shouldn't be talking). I wouldn't be surprised if a complete investigation absolves the hospital of wrongdoing although that doesn't mean they won't settle out of court.

The family talks about not letting the doctors play god but god didn't hook her to the ventilator, science did. When it was up to god all she got was a heart attack and brain death. It seems like using the ventilator is playing god.
 
Last edited:
What leads you to suspect that?

........................

ETA:
This quote from the mother leads me to the opposite conclusion:


"She's definitely showing the improvements," Winkfield said Friday. "If I felt that my child was suffering in any type of way, I would not keep her on that machine. I love her that much that I would let her go. But because I see those improvements every day, I will fight for Jahi every day until my heart stops or her heart stops."

She is correct in one sense. Her child is not suffering.
 
I was on Schiavo's parent's side in that case. But in this one, I think the parents are just willfully refusing to accept the facts.

Not that I blame them; if it were one of my children, I'd likely be acting the same way. :(
 
I was on Schiavo's parent's side in that case. But in this one, I think the parents are just willfully refusing to accept the facts.

Not that I blame them; if it were one of my children, I'd likely be acting the same way. :(

I think the problem is that a lot of people around the family stand to benefit financially from their willful refusal to accept the facts and from willfully encouraging them to reject the facts. It stands to be a very lucrative controversy that will probably do more harm than good to the family.
 
It seems to me that the hospital has created a Catch 22. They are glad to have her transferred to another facility, but they refuse to insert the feeding tube that is required for such a transfer to take place.

If I were the hospital director, I would say, insert the tube and get her out of here.
 
The thing is that Terri Schiavo was in a persistent vegetative state, and the medical issue was about whether to withdraw life support. This girl has already been declared dead.


Like I said, it'll only be a matter of time before the body starts to rot.

Can't help fools.
 
Schiavo's family has thrown their support behind this girls family.


Of course they have. Every "pro-life" whack-a-loon is going to come crawling out of the woodwork for this one.

I have to wonder if any politicians are making noise about this yet?

Should be quite entertaining.
 
It's just a tragedy, any way you look at it.

I was a bit shocked when I saw the photos of the "13-year-old". This girl was indeed obese. The operation was necessary to try to relieve some symptoms a 13-year-old should never be having, but she was having because of her weight.

I wonder if there is a bit of guilt involved in the family's refusal to accept reality?

Rolfe.
 
I'll go for the con.
Brain deathWP is a definition of death, after all.

ETA
I have read various articles about 'brain dead' people recovering, but on a closer reading, the cases are actually of comas, not brain death. So I'll go for the con, definitely.

Many people confuse persistent vegetative state, coma, and brain death.

terry schavio was in PVS, and more or less the frontal cortex was 70% gone, many specific interconnecting neuron were gone, what was left were more or less the autonomic function. ETA: in other word the person "terry schavio" was gone, dead, long before the body was dead.

In this case it is brain death, I read somewhere that the brain swelled, cut off the blood supply, and stayed that way, and is now as an organ fully dead.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom