Brain dead but still in treatment?

That is the story, and I suspect the underlying reason for the parents' denial.

Rolfe, you wouldn't believe the number of kids this age I see who are just like this girl. It is really depressing. I had a 300+ lb 16-year-old boy recently for surgery to correct urinary retention and phimosis. He was on hypertensive and diabetes meds!

I also recently had a 396 lbs. pregnant patient (who had received IVF to get pregnant) who just delivered on our L&D unit. Putting aside the incredibly complex and risky technical considerations that challenges the anesthesiologist and obstetrician with, what kind of future is that baby going to have?

It's a real epidemic. That's the real story.

~Dr. Imago
 
But people get all huffy if the topic is raised. It's bad for someone's self-esteem to criticise their weight. How dare you mention it! People have a right to be whatever shape they want without being judged!

Rolfe.
 
But people get all huffy if the topic is raised. It's bad for someone's self-esteem to criticise their weight. How dare you mention it! People have a right to be whatever shape they want without being judged!

Rolfe.

I know. That's also part of the problem. That, and the fact that our idea of what "normal" weight is has shifted upwards. People that are healthy and have a normal BMI are seen as "too skinny".

It's equally ironic for someone to say to that person, "Wow, you are so skinny! Don't you eat?" But, the-great-purple-unicorn-in-the-sky forbid someone were to say something similar to an overweight person... "Wow, you are so fat! Do you do anything besides eat?"

Quelle ironie, non?

~Dr. Imago
 
You just have to look at films from 50 years ago and more, to see the difference.

Rolfe.
 
hypothyroidism?

I don't disagree that we have a childhood obesity problem in the United States. However, one author has raised the possibility that Jahi suffered from hypothyroidism. It seems a bit of a stretch to me, but I thought it was worth pointing out.

The point being raised that the lawyers have a different set of incentives versus the family is a troubling one.
 
That's a string of speculation, with no actual fact incorporated. Hypothyroidism can be treated, so if she was undiagnosed and untreated hypothyroid that's yet another conundrum.

The whole article smells of someone with an agenda, but no actual clinical information about the case.

Rolfe.
 
That's a string of speculation, with no actual fact incorporated.

In the politest possible way I'd like to point out that most of this thread is precisely that. Suggesting that the parents are doing this because they feel guilty for having a fat kid? Suggesting that it's eeeevul lawyers wanting to keep her alive on machines as a cash cow? Those are whole ropes of speculation.
 
That's true, but the thread isn't dressed up as an authoritative article.

Rolfe.
 
Suggesting that it's eeeevul lawyers wanting to keep her alive on machines as a cash cow?

http://www.mercurynews.com/breaking...mcmath-brain-dead-girl-moved-undisclosed-care

"Jahi McMath's body had "deteriorated so badly," that her chances for survival seemed bleak, said attorney Christopher Dolan. "Right now," he added, "we don't know if she's going to make it.""

Care to speculate on an alternative, saintly lawyer reasoning for torturing these poor people? Does he honestly believe people come back from the dead after testimony of multiple physicians, including an impartial expert (Paul Graham Fisher, MD, MHS) from Stanford?
 
Care to speculate on an alternative, saintly lawyer reasoning for torturing these poor people? Does he honestly believe people come back from the dead after testimony of multiple physicians, including an impartial expert (Paul Graham Fisher, MD, MHS) from Stanford?

Perhaps as a lawyer he feels his duty is to use his skills on his clients' behalf, regardless of whether he personally approves or not. Rumpole always compared himself to an old taxi, dutybound to take on any passenger, however repellent, because to pick and choose based on personal feelings would lead to a system where only sympathetic people get justice.
 
That is tempered by a requirement to be realistic with your client though.

Rolfe.
 
Gone are the days where doctors were considered authorities in their field. Now obviously doctors are human and make mistakes, but still...
 
However, one author has raised the possibility that Jahi suffered from hypothyroidism.

Apply the principle of Occam's razor. She does not appear (based on albeit a distant, non-direct view of her past medical history) to have suffered from the constellation of problems that hypothyroidism causes, namely its inevitable march towards myxedema coma.

Basal metabolic rate + activity = daily calorie requirements. Exceed this, you gain weight.

She overate. Who's fault this was... well, that's a complex psychosocial problem.

Either way, the primary treatment for hypothyroidism is not surgery. It's medication and eventual weight loss. So, either someone blew the diagnosis, or they had it right and had failed to exhaust all other options electing for the "quick fix" of operating on her retropharynx.

The results speak for themselves. Bad decision. Now, someone will be forced to pay.

I've dealt with such parents. They are a nightmare. It's always someone else's fault.

~Dr. Imago
 
Perhaps as a lawyer he feels his duty is to use his skills on his clients' behalf, regardless of whether he personally approves or not. Rumpole always compared himself to an old taxi, dutybound to take on any passenger, however repellent, because to pick and choose based on personal feelings would lead to a system where only sympathetic people get justice.

That seems honorable and relevant to the criminal justice system and undesirable defendants. Most civil cases with an underdog element are highly motivated by a payout for the legal team (and the client also). So assuming the client is not driven by profit and only wants her daughter back....

It is my position that someone of his education and experience is likely deceiving this client about the chances of bringing her dead daughter back to life. Why would he do this?

Does he truly believe dead people can come back to life and his "duty bound skills" are the path to a modern day resurrection? And you accuse me of wild speculation?

What is with the 49er's ball cap front and center in the press conference photo?

I can't imagine what this family is going through (regardless of their parenting skills) and giving false hopes will help neither the healing processes, nor the deceased.
 
Last edited:
"The hospital released Jahi on Sunday to the Alameda County coroner, who then released her to her mother's custody, (for transport)..."

That is what happens if you want to arrange a body's transport to say, a crematorium- or the ashes to spread- the family signs for 'transport of remains'.

Family is now claiming that her body degenerated due to poor care by the hospital, after death.

I did look at her pics. I have seen LOTS of fatter people. She must have been pretty tall too.
 
The child's family is running a fundraiser on gofundme.com, which has raised over $47,000 so far, to help pay for getting her moved to another care facility. Given the unlikelihood of any facility (other than a mortuary) agreeing to accept a dead person, you have to wonder who is being conned here.
At a guess, the ambulatory brain-dead?

So yeah. Taxpayers.
 
So who's paying? I'm genuinely baffled. (And I thought you guys didn't have death panels! :rolleyes: )

Rolfe.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom