Brain dead but still in treatment?

What if the family keeps a dead corpse around? Don't we consider this weird and inappropriate in movies?
Families should be part of the decision making process, but should not have exclusive rights to make the decision alone. In this case the family would make the wrong decision. You need a dispassionate expert as well.

Only when they are named 'Bates'. :boxedin:
 
hypothetical

She was a fat pig haven't you been paying attrntion to this thread? Why bring up hypothetical illnesses that are irrelevant anyway.
The essay in the link I provided made clear that she was overweight, a fact with which I was already acquainted. Hypothetical,yes--irrelevant, no. I don't disagree with the notion that the parents bear some responsibility in this sad affair, but the thread up until the point I commented was (besides being about as speculative as what I mentioned) a bit over-the-top in its criticism of them. No one responded to an earlier comment that I made, which documented that at least one doctor appeared to support their position. I don't happen to believe that his point of view was helpful to them, but that is a separate question. MOO.
 
I agree with the lawyer. Families need to be a part of the decision making process.

They were part of the process. They refused to accept the declaration of death. They demanded and received continuation of the ventilator beyond a reasonable medical standard for a whole brain dead person. They held out for a miracle, according to their religious beliefs. The miracle did not occur. God worked his miracle in 3 days in the case of His Only Begotten Son, and yet He has thus far declined to resurrect Jahi McMath after 3 weeks of prayer and bargaining. Are the girl's family challenging God as well? So it would seem.

These people are delusional, driven by grief, anger, guilt and (probably) greed. Their lawyer is facilitating this circus. Fortunately, nature will soon take its course and Jahi's heart will stop beating. Then maybe this deluded family can find some peace. I hope so.
 
They were part of the process. They refused to accept the declaration of death. They demanded and received continuation of the ventilator beyond a reasonable medical standard for a whole brain dead person. They held out for a miracle, according to their religious beliefs. The miracle did not occur. God worked his miracle in 3 days in the case of His Only Begotten Son, and yet He has thus far declined to resurrect Jahi McMath after 3 weeks of prayer and bargaining. Are the girl's family challenging God as well? So it would seem.

These people are delusional, driven by grief, anger, guilt and (probably) greed. Their lawyer is facilitating this circus. Fortunately, nature will soon take its course and Jahi's heart will stop beating. Then maybe this deluded family can find some peace. I hope so.

Not just brain dead, but d-e-a-d dead. Declared on December 12. I'll re-post this link by the attending physician:

Heidi Flori

That spells it out in no uncertain terms, that girl is deceased. Death is not an opinion, it's an objective fact that isn't determined or altered by anyone's opinion. The participation of the family in determining death is irrelevant and is as inappropriate as the doctor dictating funeral decisions.

I'm not harping on you bc, your post just gave me something to build on.

ETA: to correct spelling.
 
IMO it's more about parental rights and religious beliefs.

The child was a minor when she went into that hospital for surgery and it required her mothers consent. the hospital shouldn't be able to terminate her mothers parental rights because the child suffered a medical catastrophe. The parents IMO must be part of the final decision.
There's nothing to decide, healthcare-wise. The girl is dead.
 
I agree with the lawyer. Families need to be a part of the decision making process.

To what stage ?

Can I prevent someone from dying by continuing to ignore the medical opinion that the person is dead ? If there is no brain activity can I simply insist that the hundreds of thousands are spent keeping a corpse animated ?

Families are very poorly placed to determine whether someone is dead - they typically lack medical training and are too emotionally invested.

Involving families in decision regarding whether to switch off life support or deny treatment to a live patient is an entirely different matter.
 
Then maybe this deluded family can find some peace. I hope so.

I fear that they won't because then it will progress to the courts to determine damages for injuries which occurred pre, peri (and sadly I fear they will seek) post mortem.
 
This is disgusting.
"McMath is reported to be in the process of being stabilized so she can be given a feeding tube... "

According to dr Flori, the cadaver's intestines are already decomposing.
 
Last edited:
Gone are the days where doctors were considered authorities in their field. Now obviously doctors are human and make mistakes, but still...

As an aside, I encounter "cafeteria minded" patients all the time.
"What's that? No, I'm not going to take that."
If you think you (or your favorite website) know better than the medical professionals, why are you even in the hospital??
 
Wel, one former politician has weighed in on this issue in a sadly predictable way:

Mike Huckabee: Brain dead girl could lead to Nazi death camps, forced abortions

Fox News host Mike Huckabee on Saturday warned that a California girl who was declared brain dead after tonsil surgery last month could lead to situations like Nazi death camps and forced abortions in China if the hospital took her off life support.

The former Arkansas governor and ordained pastor began his Fox News show by admitting that he did not have the medical experience necessary to understand 13-year-old Jahi McMath's condition but he encouraged her family to fight against any attempts to remove her from life support even though doctors said she technically "died several weeks ago."

Re the bolded part: Looks to me like he should have stopped at that point.
 
""Let's hope and pray that the courts continue to do what every court should do, respect parents over government, family over hospitals and, above all, protect Jahi from them all." - See more at: http://crooksandliars.com/2014/01/mike-huckabee-brain-dead-girl-could-lead#sthash.Ssnl6FPT.dpuf"

Fascinating.
Parental ignorance, abuse and neglect trump eebil gummint.
Right.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom