Brain dead but still in treatment?

I don't disagree that we have a childhood obesity problem in the United States. However, one author has raised the possibility that Jahi suffered from hypothyroidism. It seems a bit of a stretch to me, but I thought it was worth pointing out.

The point being raised that the lawyers have a different set of incentives versus the family is a troubling one.

She was a fat pig haven't you been paying attrntion to this thread? Why bring up hypothetical illnesses that are irrelevant anyway.
 
Many doctors tend to report this. Naming no names, of course, because that would be unprofessional.

Rolfe.
 
Isn't that because they aren't allowed to declare someone dead?

A paramedic cannot do that here, for all I know. If a doctor is on the ambulance, they might get to make that decision.

But I am sure that the doctor receiving the patient needs to decide whether the patient was dead on arrival (implying that the ambulance transported a corpse) or died just as they arrived in the ER.

Now, like I said, this is no more than anecdote related to me; so it might still not be true.
 
My sister the MICU nurse mentioned that "anybody can declare a person dead".

When 90 year old Dad died at home with us, she made a call to the hospice, and the crematorium sent a van. No doctor ever saw the body, though the death certificate has a doc's sig.

Because his death might have been accident related, the coroner did review the file, and decide no autopsy was necessary. He had fallen off his chair and broken a hip, but was suffering from brain degeneration already. Sis had talked to him about his hallucinations earlier in the day he fell, and called hospice to enroll him. I guess there are signs that the end is nigh. He made it three weeks, at home, on meds for pain and sedation for brain.

It was the least good time ever, inspite of being educational to watch the final degradation. The nurses see it- degeneration of the autonomic systems, inability to cough, swallow, finally to breath.
 
Last edited:
These people remind me of a couple i watched a news report about. Their kid was essentially born without a cerebrum but since its brain stem was well developed it was still "alive", although i guess alive is not really a reasonable description. More like breathing and reflexively flailing about.

Yet they kept on playing with their kid, taking it for walks and so on, as if there really was a person in there. People just need to learn to let go.

I had a friend that this happened to. It took them a long time to get pregnant, then they had been in a severe car accident when the wife was three months along. They both recovered but then the baby was born with only a brain stem.

They did the right thing and had life support removed after a few days of consideration.

Then a social worker stepped in and said she had seen the baby "smile." The doctors said that wasn't possible. It turned into a length battle between them trying to do what they felt was right and CPS stepping in and removing the child from their care.

Their marriage survived the accident, the child with no brain, and the decision to remove support but it didn't survive the harassment and lengthy court battle to do what was right for their daughter. They separated after 2 years of fighting but he continued the fight and finally won.

One judge's decision basically said that because the child was a ward of the court, he couldn't understand why they would care what happened to it, and so he allowed the life support to continue and CPS to be in control.

It was a terrible thing. Two lives destroyed for no reason.
 
Many doctors tend to report this. Naming no names, of course, because that would be unprofessional.

Rolfe.

Well if this is the case, a) I am sure you will have no problem backing it up and if a) then b) the doctors can try approaching with professionalism instead of critism and judging.
 
Hospital would be primary reliable source, medical records are private. If there is a lawsuit and trial, detailed timeline might be made public.

Yes, I understand that the hospital is prohibited by law from releasing medical records. I was wondering if the mother had made enough public statements that a timeline could be put together.
 

Not sure what you are confused about. If enough doctors are reporting that fat people get all huffy when doctors criticize and judge them, to make such a sweeping statement about how "they" react, it should be supportable. If that is the case, though, perhaps it is the doctor's bedside manner that is the problem. Perhaps the doctors should be more focused on numbers and health risks rather than judging and criticizing waist size because the two are not always cofactors.
 
I thought the Cryonics mob had already demonstrated that the law is ok with elaborate burial practices.
 
Not sure what you are confused about. If enough doctors are reporting that fat people get all huffy when doctors criticize and judge them, to make such a sweeping statement about how "they" react, it should be supportable.

Fifty two per cent of GPs and 28% of practice nurses had concerns about raising the issue of overweight; the most common being that patients would react emotionally to the message

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17828672

If that is the case, though, perhaps it is the doctor's bedside manner that is the problem.

AMA already offers advice on this point:

http://www.ama-assn.org/resources/doc/public-health/talking-about-weight-kushner.pdf

Perhaps the doctors should be more focused on numbers and health risks rather than judging and criticizing waist size because the two are not always cofactors.

"waist size" is a number.
 
Of course they have. Every "pro-life" whack-a-loon is going to come crawling out of the woodwork for this one.

I have to wonder if any politicians are making noise about this yet?

Should be quite entertaining.

I could be wrong but I'm thinking they may be disappointed by the lack of support from pro-life folks. The Catholic position is that brain death means that the person is dead. This isn't a case of removing life support because there is no life to support. She is atificially being kept alive. Schiavo case was different because she was not considered brain dead and it was involved the removing of a feeding tube. Since we have a duty to take care of the sick, purposfully starving someone isn't an option, even if they are severly brain damaged.

I read article by a pastor that called their holding out for a miricle to be tempting God. Here's one from the Catholic perspective.

http://www.ewtnnews.com/catholic-news/US.php?id=9080
 
Yes, I understand that the hospital is prohibited by law from releasing medical records. I was wondering if the mother had made enough public statements that a timeline could be put together.

I would not consider such statements "reliable," which was a condition of your original question.
 
IMO it's more about parental rights and religious beliefs.

The child was a minor when she went into that hospital for surgery and it required her mothers consent. the hospital shouldn't be able to terminate her mothers parental rights because the child suffered a medical catastrophe. The parents IMO must be part of the final decision.
 
I had a friend that this happened to. It took them a long time to get pregnant, then they had been in a severe car accident when the wife was three months along. They both recovered but then the baby was born with only a brain stem.

They did the right thing and had life support removed after a few days of consideration.

Then a social worker stepped in and said she had seen the baby "smile." The doctors said that wasn't possible. It turned into a length battle between them trying to do what they felt was right and CPS stepping in and removing the child from their care.

Their marriage survived the accident, the child with no brain, and the decision to remove support but it didn't survive the harassment and lengthy court battle to do what was right for their daughter. They separated after 2 years of fighting but he continued the fight and finally won.

One judge's decision basically said that because the child was a ward of the court, he couldn't understand why they would care what happened to it, and so he allowed the life support to continue and CPS to be in control.

It was a terrible thing. Two lives destroyed for no reason.

That's strange for many reason. For one anencephalic kid usually do not survive long, the longest on record was 3 years with a lot of treatment. Most die off with hours, if not days. Usually the doctor and the hospital hold either a no "treatment" only giving water a primary care, or even not doing anything and let nature work. There is no person, there is no cortex there is nothing, it is "deadborn". Are you sure it was anencephalic ?
 
IMO it's more about parental rights and religious beliefs.

The child was a minor when she went into that hospital for surgery and it required her mothers consent. the hospital shouldn't be able to terminate her mothers parental rights because the child suffered a medical catastrophe. The parents IMO must be part of the final decision.

The family's lawyer has this to say about that:
Link

“There are very significant issues that never been addressed in the Ninth Circuit in California before which is the right of a parent to make health care decisions relating to whether or not a ventilator gets removed from their child,” he said.
Dolan said that families—not a doctor—should determine death and that anything less would be a violation of the family’s right to freedom of religion."
:jaw-dropp
 
What if the family keeps a dead corpse around?
Don't we consider this weird and inappropriate in movies?

Families should be part of the decision making process, but should not have exclusive rights to make the decision alone. In this case the family would make the wrong decision. You need a dispassionate expert as well.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom