Brain dead but still in treatment?

So I am very confused again about the terms being used here. If, as has been stated, a brain dead person being kept alive on a respirator will still begin to decay, how is it possible for a brain dead woman to carry a child to term? It seems people here or in the media are getting sloppy with their terms or is there a proper medical definition?
 
So I am very confused again about the terms being used here. If, as has been stated, a brain dead person being kept alive on a respirator will still begin to decay, how is it possible for a brain dead woman to carry a child to term? It seems people here or in the media are getting sloppy with their terms or is there a proper medical definition?

You can be brain dead and keep the vital functions going for indefinite period of time. Eventually, being hooked up to all the tubing (etc.) will result in a bad body decomposition (e.g., bed sores, other infections, etc.) even with meticulous care.

Christopher Reeves' ultimate demise immediately comes to mind. And, he was far from brain dead. The body is meant to move around and not be connected to artificial equipment.

~Dr. Imago
 
So I am very confused again about the terms being used here. If, as has been stated, a brain dead person being kept alive on a respirator will still begin to decay, how is it possible for a brain dead woman to carry a child to term? It seems people here or in the media are getting sloppy with their terms or is there a proper medical definition?

This article goes into some detail about the process of maintaining bodily processes and delivering a viable baby. It would not necessarily need to be the full 9 month term. It is rarely done (only 30 cases reported, and of those, only 12 of the infants survived the neonatal period. They are not born healthy.)

Link

"As far as fetal development, as long as we can control delivery of blood to the fetus and make sure the mother is nutrient-enriched, and as long as the mother's got enough glucose and oxygen, she can serve as a vessel," said R. Phillips Heine, director of maternal fetal medicine at Duke University. "If they can get to a reasonable gestation, there's potential for a very good outcome [for the fetus], so it would be a reasonable option."
 
What I want to know is, is the family going to be slammed with the bill for all these extraordinary measures?

Who should pay for it?

And, at 14 weeks, I disagree with Rick Perry's administration: it's not a "separate person" in the clinical sense as the fetus is not viable at that point... but that's a topic perhaps for a separate discussion.

~Dr. Imago
 
Who should pay for it?

And, at 14 weeks, I disagree with Rick Perry's administration: it's not a "separate person" in the clinical sense as the fetus is not viable at that point... but that's a topic perhaps for a separate discussion.

~Dr. Imago

The hospital or the state of Texas. Certainly not the family, they never asked for this to happen and should not be held responsible.
 
The hospital or the state of Texas. Certainly not the family, they never asked for this to happen and should not be held responsible.

Ah but the husband did when he called 911. Events unfolded after that, once she was put on the ventilator. It is easy to put patients on, but difficult to take them off. For sure, the hospital will be eating the bill and charging it off in Hill-Burton, perhaps. I am sorry this young woman and baby lost their life.
 
Last edited:
The hospital or the state of Texas. Certainly not the family, they never asked for this to happen and should not be held responsible.

I guess the courts will settle that one, if he (the husband) is allowed to sue the State of Texas. Ain't sovereign immunity a :rule10 ?

~Dr. Imago
 
I guess the courts will settle that one, if he (the husband) is allowed to sue the State of Texas. Ain't sovereign immunity a :rule10 ?

~Dr. Imago

Sue Texas??? So much for hubs pure interest in following the woman's wishes and of course as usual, the defenseless baby did not get a vote.
 
Sue Texas??? So much for hubs pure interest in following the woman's wishes and of course, the baby did not get a vote.

I don't understand what you're saying here? All I said up above was the husband should sue anyone and everyone that put this family through this ordeal. Both the mother and the fetus are incapable of voting on anything. They both died in November when the mother collapsed. The hospital has been prolonging this much longer than it should have been.

From what I've read, all the husband wants is to bury his wife and the fetus, and begin the healing process.
 
Who should pay for it?

All of the people and entities who are forcing a dead woman to remain on "life support" in order to gestate a non-viable fetus, against the express wishes of the fetus's father and the patient's husband and parents, that's who should pay for it. In other words, if the state of Texas and this hospital want to play god with these people's lives, the least they can do is foot the bill for this lunacy.

And, at 14 weeks, I disagree with Rick Perry's administration: it's not a "separate person" in the clinical sense as the fetus is not viable at that point... but that's a topic perhaps for a separate discussion.

~Dr. Imago

This particular fetus isn't viable no matter the age, there has been too much damage caused by oxygen deprivation and fluid accumulation. Even the hospital, which still refuses to obey the court order to remove life support, stipulates that this is true.
 
Guys, there's a thread about the case in Texas. Please keep this thread to the girl from California.
Posted By: Lisa Simpson
 
SHOCKING UPDATE . . .

. . . is what you would say if there was any real improvement. Instead there is just this claim by the mother that she is doing "much better physically", but not real mention of what that means or what makes her say that.

Just thought I'd update the thread.
 
SHOCKING UPDATE . . .

. . . is what you would say if there was any real improvement. Instead there is just this claim by the mother that she is doing "much better physically", but not real mention of what that means or what makes her say that.

Just thought I'd update the thread.
Thought for sure this was going to be the death announcement.
 
What?
As of today the deceased has yet to be interred?
Is that legal?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom