Brain dead but still in treatment?

Two and a half years ago, when this thread started, it seemed pretty certain she was dead as dead can be. I read predictions of sloughing intestinal lining and rotting from the inside out. That didn't happen. Maybe it is time to reevaluate the case.

Right, let's reassess 2.5 years in a coma and pretend a miracle is just around the corner.

So she hasn't yet died of multi-organ failure and/or massive infection. Hooray for medical science.

And how much has that cost? An intensive effort to address the anti-vaxxer nonsense? An investment in developing a Zika virus vaccine? Investment in improving influenza or RSV intervention?

Definitely let's reassess, but could we possibly be honest about it?
 
Right, let's reassess 2.5 years in a coma and pretend a miracle is just around the corner.

So she hasn't yet died of multi-organ failure and/or massive infection. Hooray for medical science.

And how much has that cost? An intensive effort to address the anti-vaxxer nonsense? An investment in developing a Zika virus vaccine? Investment in improving influenza or RSV intervention?

Definitely let's reassess, but could we possibly be honest about it?

Yes, we should be honest. There is no need to make it a choice between compost and miracle. There's a lot more gray than a tidy philosophy demands.

As to the, "but there are starving children in Bangladesh" argument, that has a nice emotional appeal, but wouldn't we want to balance it with the learning opportunity here? If the kid is dead from an ethical point of view then the experiment isn't unethical either.

I'm curious to know how her body has performed/failed under these conditions.
 
I'm curious to know how her body has performed/failed under these conditions.

I'm curious, too. I didn't think this would ever go on for so long -I thought the truth of her death would become blindingly obvious long ago. I'd like to know more about her actual physical condition now.
 
Two and a half years ago, when this thread started, it seemed pretty certain she was dead as dead can be. I read predictions of sloughing intestinal lining and rotting from the inside out. That didn't happen. Maybe it is time to reevaluate the case.

Keep in mind that at the time there was 100 extra pounds of body for the body to feed on.

I wonder what the body weighs today.

So far as a re-evaluation, it is still brain dead. Unless there is a EEG to show otherwise? I think we would have heard that.
 
Keep in mind that at the time there was 100 extra pounds of body for the body to feed on.

I wonder what the body weighs today.

So far as a re-evaluation, it is still brain dead. Unless there is a EEG to show otherwise? I think we would have heard that.

I admit to morbid curiosity as well as professional. With the court case mentioned above, we'd expect to see some assessment presented for the judge to preview. Not sure if that's public though.

As to the ramifications, it might resurface in organ donation where you can delay harvesting? Don't know.
 
A few updates on McMath:

Stories from the Trauma Bay: Jahi McMath update(April 2017)

In summary, Nakagawa and Schneider exhaustively evaluated everything that had been done to and for Jahi from her surgery up until her release to her mother on August 25, 2014 (there was no evidence that Jahi had been re-evaluated for brain death since that day), and all of the brain death evaluations that were done in California were deemed completely valid. There was no evidence that anything was awry in any way. They also both stated, quite definitively, that nothing that had been done since her declaration of death -- no subsequent tests, no exams done at St. Peter's University Hospital, no nothing -- could . . . well, I'll let Dr. Nakagawa sum it up:
There is nothing in McMath's medical records from Saint Peter's University Hospital that would cause a reputable expert in pediatric or adult brain death to question or reconsider the accepted brain death assessments of Dr. Robin Shanahan, Dr. Robert Heidersbach, and Dr. Paul Fisher.
He makes the same statement regarding additional tests she had done in September of 2014, none of which are accepted tests for brain death. Dr. Schneider then says this, which Nakagawa also averred:
There is absolutely no medical possibility that J. McMath has recovered, or will someday recover, from death.

And, for balance:

Is Jahi McMath alive?(July 2017)

At the time, I believed Jahi was dead, and so wrote. But I also wrote that if she did not deteriorate as almost all people with properly determined brain death do, my eyebrows would raise. Since then, Jahi has not deteriorated, but apparently, her body’s condition has improved. My eyebrows are above my hairline.

What the above evidence and reasoning show is…that Jahi McMath was never truly dead, even though she fulfilled the accepted medical criteria for death in December 2013. She exhibited to brain function at the time, but the cessation of at least two functions — consciousness and hypothalamic regulation of menstruation and sexual development — has proved not to be irreversible. (Shewmon’s emphasis).
Jahi McMath is a living, severely disabled young lady, who currently fulfills neither the standard diagnostic Guidelines for brain death nor California’s statutory definition of death.


Back when this was all over the news, much of the reporting was very inaccurate. I would guess she could stay in half-life for decades if her family keeps up the effort.


(ETA: It seems like the McMath family may be getting Medicaid to pay for life support. I didn't know that.)
 
Last edited:
From the MRI I could find, the central part and the hypothalamus is near completely gone. Or at least they show a void. The other part are difficult to see and one would need to have more lateral picture to diagnose (e.g. you would need a lot of picture like this : https://radiopaedia.org/cases/mri-findings-in-brain-death) but to jump to a "diagnose of brain death was wrong" well terry shavio's body was kept alive a very long time in irreversible pvs. There was not much left of her brain either.
 
... to jump to a "diagnose of brain death was wrong" well terry shavio's body was kept alive a very long time in irreversible pvs. There was not much left of her brain either.

I agree - I am not arguing that reports of her brain death are wrong.

The inaccurate reporting I that I referenced spoke of her body decomposing. Many articles of at the time state unequivocally that it would be impossible to keep the body and heart going for more than a few weeks, regardless of what sort of medical intervention was attempted.

That much was pretty clearly wrong.
 
I agree - I am not arguing that reports of her brain death are wrong.

The inaccurate reporting I that I referenced spoke of her body decomposing. Many articles of at the time state unequivocally that it would be impossible to keep the body and heart going for more than a few weeks, regardless of what sort of medical intervention was attempted.

That much was pretty clearly wrong.

The question is what state the body is now, and what has been done ? Without knowing it is hard to say. It could be that a lot of surgery / treatment was done to keep the body alive, and it is now in a pitiful state. Or it could be the initial prognoses of body decomposing was wrong.

also :

Today, with ventilators, blood-pressure augmentation and hormones, the body of a brain-dead person could, in theory, be kept functioning for a long time, perhaps indefinitely, Greene-Chandos said. But with time, Greene-Chandos added, the body of a brain-dead person becomes increasingly difficult to maintain, and the tissue is at high risk for infection.

https://www.livescience.com/42301-brain-death-body-alive.html

So with technological advance it could very well be that you can replace those basal function the brain has, and maintain a body for years.
 
From the MRI I could find, the central part and the hypothalamus is near completely gone. Or at least they show a void. The other part are difficult to see and one would need to have more lateral picture to diagnose (e.g. you would need a lot of picture like this : https://radiopaedia.org/cases/mri-findings-in-brain-death) but to jump to a "diagnose of brain death was wrong" well terry shavio's body was kept alive a very long time in irreversible pvs. There was not much left of her brain either.

Look at this guys X-rays.

http://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(07)61127-1/fulltext

His brain was basically no more than a "skim" around the internal surface of the skull. Nevertheless he was perfectly functional. Worked as a civil servant, married, fathered two children.
 
Look at this guys X-rays.

http://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(07)61127-1/fulltext

His brain was basically no more than a "skim" around the internal surface of the skull. Nevertheless he was perfectly functional. Worked as a civil servant, married, fathered two children.

I am aware of this special case, but he has a thalamus and a brain stem, which are connected to the rest (and he had a history of hydrocephalus, starting 6 month old, with the brain having time to adapt with all shunts). She does not. it is gone.

And that is a key difference.

ETA: I added in bold what is the key difference.
 
Last edited:
From the MRI I could find, the central part and the hypothalamus is near completely gone. Or at least they show a void. The other part are difficult to see and one would need to have more lateral picture to diagnose (e.g. you would need a lot of picture like this : https://radiopaedia.org/cases/mri-findings-in-brain-death) but to jump to a "diagnose of brain death was wrong" well terry shavio's body was kept alive a very long time in irreversible pvs. There was not much left of her brain either.

The problem is definitions.
Brain death (in the UK) means that the life sustaining functions of the brain are not functioning, most crucially there are no spontaneous breathing efforts so the patient is ventilator dependent. There is also no response to physical stimuli. Differing conditions are locked in syndrome - where patients are variably conscious but have no control of movement so can respond but are aware of stimuli. This can be detected by monitoring brain waves of functional MRI. There is persistent vegetative state where the autonomic activity continues, so the patient breathes but is unconscious probably with irreversible damage to the higher brain function so no possibility of gaining any degree of consciousness exists. There can be autonomic movements in response to stimuli.

As alluded to above classical brain death is not survivable long term, the child's continued survival suggests the diagnosis was wrong.

On the other hand at this point there is likely to be no significant improvement, at this point.
http://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJM199406023302206#t=article

My view is continued life support is cruel and should be withdrawn. There are others who would disagree particularly from some religious view points.

Bad things happen with surgery, the hospital may have been negligent, but a bad outcome may not necessarily be due to negligence. If negligent they should probably pay the parents care costs.
 
Five years. Jesus.

I'm well aware she had little or no brain function, so she wasn't suffering... but I think it is utterly reprehensible that her mother kept her alive to essentially milk her daughter's body for sympathy. I hope she doesn't have any other children; I'd be concerned she'd harm them in order to keep getting the attention from medical professionals she seemed to crave. I'm not a psychologist or psychiatrist by a long shot, but I can't help but wonder if her mother was ever evaluated by a doctor for Munchausen by proxy. Keeping your brain dead daughter on machines for five years and constantly suing for medical care seems rather too close to that diagnosis for my comfort.
 
Five years. Jesus.

I'm well aware she had little or no brain function, so she wasn't suffering... but I think it is utterly reprehensible that her mother kept her alive to essentially milk her daughter's body for sympathy. I hope she doesn't have any other children; I'd be concerned she'd harm them in order to keep getting the attention from medical professionals she seemed to crave. I'm not a psychologist or psychiatrist by a long shot, but I can't help but wonder if her mother was ever evaluated by a doctor for Munchausen by proxy. Keeping your brain dead daughter on machines for five years and constantly suing for medical care seems rather too close to that diagnosis for my comfort.

At least she can't be used as a political football anymore.
 
Not sure if you are aware the parents healthcare costs are zero.

The parents may be paying zero, but the costs of maintaining a corpse (and let's tell the truth, that's what she was) in a medical facility must have been enormous, and wherever the money was coming from, it could have been better spent.
 
Five years. Jesus.

I'm well aware she had little or no brain function, so she wasn't suffering...
....

Doctors in 2014 determined that she was brain dead. That would mean zero function. Machines have been simulating life functions, not maintaining them.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom