Brain dead but still in treatment?

Actually, it is G-d with a capital G. A form of respect for the all powerful being.

How is misspelling a name by replacing letters with hyphens respectful?

It's mostly a Jewish thing, though I don't know if the above poster is Jewish or not.

Yeah, I think it's quite silly, so I respond by inserting other symbols, like G-*******-d in between, which may be somewhat less than respectful.
 
Isn't there a law that says a body has to be interred/cremated within a set time frame after death has been declared?

In our country the time frames (as by law) are, not sooner than 36 hours and at the latest on the sixth workday (thus omitting Saturdays and Sundays).
 
But can we afford to throw a few hundred thousand dollars at every family that demands it, to let their loved ones go on their terms? Because I'm guessing that "we" are the ones paying for it, by either the insurance company or the hospital passing on the loss to others.

I just can't work up much sympathy for a nutty family that expects everyone to cater to their extremely expensive delusions.

Yeah... you're right.
 
Even people that have faith in God, look both ways before crossing the street. Don't they?
Well, that's a commonplace enough event that I wouldn't expect them to necessarily pray to their god(s) to follow their every single movement, and step out blindly. Also, I have read enough comments from injured believers - disabled ones mostly - to know that should they be hit, they will often consider that part of god's plan for them anyway.
When many people are praying for one specific thing, they should show conviction in that thing, imo, and not continue to interfere with whatever their god might be trying to do.

Believe it! Sadly, some can't make their case without throwing personal jabs.
Again, you did not answer any of my questions, either the earlier ones, or the one in the post you quoted. It's quite telling, and gives the appearance of dishonesty in this discussion. To recap - if you use faith as a potential solution, why would you take actions that contradict the act of faith you are calling on? And, if someone else uses up all the resources that you need to survive, would you be content to allow that, and die, because they are doing whatever is necessary to save themself?
 
Last edited:
Harder how?

At least now the mom will know she did everything she possibly could. IMO mom will never believe she should have let her go sooner. That will not happen. She sees everyday she spends holding her daughters hand and talking to her as a gift, a blessing. Who are you or anyone else to take that away from her?

Why do you think the mother holds that cadaver's hand every day?
 
If they talk to those folks that do the plasticized bodies do you think they can find a way to replace the rotting bits with plastic while keeping the ventilator going so that we can drag this out for even more time?

We may never have to grieve if we can just bring the right technology to bear on this problem . . . why should we ever pull the plug!
That's how the Cybermen got started.

$60,000 plus has already been donated to the family for her care.
And could be used for something productive if not for this fixation with a corpse.
 
Isn't there a law that says a body has to be interred/cremated within a set time frame after death has been declared?

In our country the time frames (as by law) are, not sooner than 36 hours and at the latest on the sixth workday (thus omitting Saturdays and Sundays).

Don't know about the US, but AFAIK, in the UK there's no maximum time limit on when a body may be buried/cremated. There are time specified requirements on registering a death, certainly.
 
There is no coping or worse. Only heartbreaking, inconsolable grief and it is forever.


That is just weird, coming from a person who seems to be presenting themselves as a Christian. It's positively contradicted by a fairly solid wodge of biblical teaching. In fact, I think it amounts to the specific sin of "despair".

Biblically, it's the heathens who "despair", knowing no better. Christian teaching firmly rejects this. Blessed are they that mourn, for they shall be comforted. Blessed are the dead which die in the Lord, and so on.

Christian teaching specifically encourages acceptance, moving on, respectful and happy memories, and a looking forward to a glorious reunion.

You're not actually a Christian at all, are you?

Rolfe.
 
For the medical professionals: Is the surgery this girl received, apparently quite a bit more extensive than a standard tonsillectomy, a common medical practice? Do the doctors share some blame for going to the scalpel before prescribing weight loss, CPAP, medication, etc.? I would do just about anything to avoid surgery, but some people seem to think an operation can solve any problem.

It would be interesting to know whether her doctors and parents were addressing her weight problem. There seems to be an assumption on this thread that they weren't, but we don't know that. It could also be that they hoped the surgery would help; maybe getting some decent sleep would have helped her be more active and have more impulse control with food.

Ha! I'm still waiting for you to dust off one of your psychology books and dazzle with some back up evidence that yanking the plug out of her daughter would be beneficial to treating the mother.

Is there any possible way that keeping up this charade is good for her mother? Does any slight good overcome the many negatives?
 
Ha! I'm still waiting for you to dust off one of your psychology books and dazzle with some back up evidence that yanking the plug out of her daughter would be beneficial to treating the mother.

Myths and Facts About Grief
MYTH: The pain will go away faster if you ignore it.
Fact: Trying to ignore your pain or keep it from surfacing will only make it worse in the long run. For real healing it is necessary to face your grief and actively deal with it.
MYTH: It’s important to be “be strong” in the face of loss.
Fact: Feeling sad, frightened, or lonely is a normal reaction to loss. Crying doesn’t mean you are weak. You don’t need to “protect” your family or friends by putting on a brave front. Showing your true feelings can help them and you.
MYTH: If you don’t cry, it means you aren’t sorry about the loss.
Fact: Crying is a normal response to sadness, but it’s not the only one. Those who don’t cry may feel the pain just as deeply as others. They may simply have other ways of showing it.
MYTH: Grief should last about a year.
Fact: There is no right or wrong time frame for grieving. How long it takes can differ from person to person.
Source: Center for Grief and Healing

From here

Grief puts a great stress on the physical body as well as on the psyche, resulting in wear and tear beyond what is normal. Further, grief is often accompanied by crying, lack of sleep, loss of appetite, and ceasing to care for one's physical and emotional well being. All these can contribute to a predisposition for illness in bereavement.

Many studies have looked at the bereaved in terms of increased risks for stress-related illnesses such as colitis and breathing difficulties, and so forth in the first six months following a death. Others have noted increased mortality rates a greater risk of suicide in teens following the death of a parent. Children may exhibit signs of delinquency, rage, introversion or other problems. Further, grief can insidiously work in family relationships as individual members sort or act through their feelings about the death.

Death of a child can take the form of a loss in infancy such as stillbirth or neonatal death, SIDS, or the death of an older child. In all cases, parents find the grief devastating and while persons may rate the death of a spouse as first in traumatic life events, the death of a child holds greater risk factors. This loss also bears a lifelong process; one does not get 'over' the loss but instead learns to assimilate and live with the death. Intervention and comforting support can make all the difference to the survival of a parent in this type of grief but the risk factors are great and may include family breakup or suicide. Feelings of guilt, almost always unfounded, are pervasive, and the dependent nature of the relationship disposes parents to a variety of problems as they seek to cope with this great loss. This, coupled with normal experiences of grief, can be overwhelming.

Both from here

The longer Jahi's mother refuses to accept her daughter's death, the more problems she opens herself up for when the inevitable occurs. What she needs right now is support from professionals who can help her to realize that her daughter is never coming back, and the only way to cope with it is to finally let her go.

There, that good enough for you?
 
The longer Jahi's mother refuses to accept her daughter's death, the more problems she opens herself up for when the inevitable occurs. What she needs right now is support from professionals who can help her to realize that her daughter is never coming back, and the only way to cope with it is to finally let her go.

On top of this, I would imagine that all the false hope being thrown in cannot help. This family is going to eventually come to terms with the fact that the daughter is dead; that is inevitable. However, having to come to that realization after being promised that she can be saved? That is only going to compound the sadness with anger, frustration, and a sense of betrayal.

Part of me hopes she ends up suing the hospice when the time comes.
 
That is just weird, coming from a person who seems to be presenting themselves as a Christian. It's positively contradicted by a fairly solid wodge of biblical teaching. In fact, I think it amounts to the specific sin of "despair".

Biblically, it's the heathens who "despair", knowing no better. Christian teaching firmly rejects this. Blessed are they that mourn, for they shall be comforted. Blessed are the dead which die in the Lord, and so on.

Christian teaching specifically encourages acceptance, moving on, respectful and happy memories, and a looking forward to a glorious reunion.


You're not actually a Christian at all, are you?

Rolfe.
Nope, not a Christian, but a fallen away Irish Catholic.
Jesus Christ is NOT my personal savior.
 
Last edited:
It's mostly a Jewish thing, though I don't know if the above poster is Jewish or not.

Yeah, I think it's quite silly, so I respond by inserting other symbols, like G-*******-d in between, which may be somewhat less than respectful.
We are responsible for our personal respect not others or their lack of respect.
 
As far as I know this G-d thing is actually an oldfashioned use to mask swearing, like the autocensor. Not used when the word is employed correctly and theologically within a sentence, but used for slightly embarrassing outbursts like "By G-d!"

Anyway, to me it looks like it's saying the word "God" is a swearword and needs to be masked for profanity every time it's used.

Nope, not a Christian....


I think I see the problem here.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
From here











Both from here



The longer Jahi's mother refuses to accept her daughter's death, the more problems she opens herself up for when the inevitable occurs. What she needs right now is support from professionals who can help her to realize that her daughter is never coming back, and the only way to cope with it is to finally let her go.



There, that good enough for you?


No, it isn't.
It does nothing to address this situation.
 
By the by, for the folks saying that Jahi had solid foods and that the family provided it...

All that I have been able to find is that she had a popsicle, and I have yet to find a source that says who gave it. I suppose that if she bit off pieces and swallowed them rather than sucking on the popsicle, that is what the whole 'solid food' thing is about.
 
On top of this, I would imagine that all the false hope being thrown in cannot help. This family is going to eventually come to terms with the fact that the daughter is dead; that is inevitable. However, having to come to that realization after being promised that she can be saved? That is only going to compound the sadness with anger, frustration, and a sense of betrayal.

Part of me hopes she ends up suing the hospice when the time comes.

Yes; this.

As I said upstream, the family members are the patients now, and they're not receiving what I would call a good "standard of care". I don't know what, exactly, should be said or done. But I do believe allowing them to cling so tight is poor form, and will only cause more and more problems for all of them.

I do believe *someone* is seeing dollar signs and is tossing this family's future well-being under a bus to make money providing worthless care or hoping for a huge legal settlement.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom