Brain dead but still in treatment?

As far as I know this G-d thing is actually an oldfashioned use to mask swearing, like the autocensor. Not used when the word is employed correctly and theologically within a sentence, but used for slightly embarrassing outbursts like "By G-d!"

IIRC, I first came across the Jewish custom of spelling God as G-d in the Usenet forum rec.humor.funny, some years ago. The link in Adman's post explains the reasoning quite well.

As for masking swearing, a long underscore was used in place of swearwords; I've several novels where profanity is basically "__________".
 
Though now we seem to be on some bizarre god tangent, I did look up more info to try and determine where the solid foods claim was coming from.

Most news articles are in agreement that Jahi ate a popsicle while in the recovery room (before even being transferred to ICU - so directly after surgery). All the doctors commenting on the news articles (random doctors, not involved ones) seem in agreement that the hospital could not/would not have ever given the girl a popsicle that soon after surgery because you can't chew it and swallow bits, nor can you suck on it that soon afterward.

There are also claims that the family gave Jahi a cheeseburger, but this has not been reported in the news articles. Rather, it seems that someone on the inside of the case has been running around to all the news outlets and writing in the comments. So I guess I'd take that part with a grain of salt.
 
So I guess I'd take that part with a grain of salt.

If you cook your burgers at home they don't have to be so high in sodium.

/sarcasm

Thanks for digging into this. It really irks me that this hit the news as "girl dies from tonsillectomy".
 
Dr. Keith said:
...It really irks me that this hit the news as "girl dies from tonsillectomy".
Indeed. A routine tonsillectomy?

More like an adenotonsillectomy (removal of the tonsils and adenoids), a uvulopalatopharyngoplasty (removal of the uvula) and a submucous resection of bilateral inferior turbinates, according to wiki.

And all that on a 13 year old who weighed 100 kilos, which made her a high risk patient.
Poor child.
 
Last edited:
Indeed. A routine tonsillectomy?

More like an adenotonsillectomy (removal of the tonsils and adenoids), a uvulopalatopharyngoplasty (removal of the uvula) and a submucous resection of bilateral inferior turbinates, according to wiki.

And all that on a 13 year old who weighed 100 kilos, which made her a high risk patient.
Poor child.


What medical steps were previously taken to address the weight issue?
 
What medical steps were previously taken to address the weight issue?

Dunno and I can find nothing on the subject. Perhaps when the medical records are released, if ever, there'll be information in them indicative of what was done about the weight issue.
 
Well, the number of facts refuted by denial so far is zero but go ahead and keep at it if it gets you through.


Thank you so much for your permission. It means everything to me.

I was addressing the motivation some claim for yanking the plug thereby helping this mother. I find it hard to believe that there is some altruistic reason for such lust to force reality on this mother right now.
 
And I find it hard to believe that there is some altruistic reason for such lust to keep reality from this mother indefinitely and thereby impair her ability to grieve for the loss of her child.
 
I don't claim an altruistic reason.

I believe, it needs to be a family decision. Or the law needs to be clear.
The case in Texas highlights my position as well.
 
And you must have missed the part in your own post that states there is no "right" way or timeframe.

I never claimed that there is a right way, or a timeframe; I merely gave you cited evidence that states prolonging denial of a situation that will cause grief can have both physical and mental repercussions to the one denying it. The fact that you do not understand that just tells me that there is no point in continuing any conversation with you at this point.
 
I never claimed that there is a right way, or a timeframe; I merely gave you cited evidence that states prolonging denial of a situation that will cause grief can have both physical and mental repercussions to the one denying it. The fact that you do not understand that just tells me that there is no point in continuing any conversation with you at this point.


I find it amusing & quite telling that you feel the need to attack me personally.
This is the second time that you've commented you do not wish to communicate with me. Yet you keep doing just that.

Very amusing.
 
I never claimed that there is a right way, or a timeframe; I merely gave you cited evidence that states prolonging denial of a situation that will cause grief can have both physical and mental repercussions to the one denying it. The fact that you do not understand that just tells me that there is no point in continuing any conversation with you at this point.


Perhaps you should actually read the link you posted. It deals generically on the topic of grief.
Does not address this unique set of circumstances but does point out the death of a child increases risk factors.
It doesn't address the defense mechanism denial in conjunction with the brain death of a ventilated child whose mother is asked to decide to stop her child's heart from beating.
It doesn't address cultural, religious beliefs.
Doesn't address any possible intellectual or education deficits.

And that's just off the top of my head.

For you to link and point to that article as some sort of "evidence" to back up your blanket statement is beyond laughable.
 
I find it amusing & quite telling that you feel the need to attack me personally.
This is the second time that you've commented you do not wish to communicate with me. Yet you keep doing just that.

Very amusing.

Sabrina didn't attack you personally. Stating that you failed to understand something is not a personal attack, it's a fact.
 
It's about time. This whole thing has been a horror show for the family. Maybe now their healing can begin. Hope the hospital doesn't try to stick the family with the bill for all this.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom