Brain dead but still in treatment?

Thought for sure this was going to be the death announcement.

You're going to have to wait for the coroner from Munchkinland to make that pronouncement.

Munchlinland Coroner said:
As coroner I must report, I thoroughly examined her. And she's not only merely dead, she's really most sincerely dead.
 
Last edited:
What this case highlights to me, is that the knowledge about human brains and how they work - not to mention how they don't work - needs to stop being passive knowledge, and start becoming active knowledge.

In other words, I think that we need to teach in school things such as the brain's need for (oxygen-rich) blood to function; not to mention that without certain parts functioning - such as the frontal cortex - there simply is nothing left that can think like a human being thinks. That while the body might still function, there is no longer a person in that body as we reckognise as a person. That, in fact, there isn't any real evidence for a soul (as per most common definitions) that somehow functions without the brain also functioning.

Because when people aren't taught these things, then this case is the result. And it's one of those cases where there are no winners. And as much as I oppose the actions of Jahi McMath's family, I find it hard to be able to condemn them, because I strongly suspect they were never really taught these facts, and they're not really in a position to learn it right now.
 
Has this family actually said what they would accept as proof their daughter's dead?

My understanding is, these machines can keep someone "fresh" for a long time.
 
Has this family actually said what they would accept as proof their daughter's dead?

My understanding is, these machines can keep someone "fresh" for a long time.
Depends on your definition of "a long time" and, no, machines cannot keep someone "fresh". Total organ failure is not preventable. But given her gut was supposed to be non-functioning it's had to imagine her heart and kidneys continuing. Perhaps they are giving her TPN. But even with that the kidneys and heart will still eventually fail and even with dialysis and any number of cardiac drugs.
 
Depends on your definition of "a long time" and, no, machines cannot keep someone "fresh". Total organ failure is not preventable. But given her gut was supposed to be non-functioning it's had to imagine her heart and kidneys continuing. Perhaps they are giving her TPN. But even with that the kidneys and heart will still eventually fail and even with dialysis and any number of cardiac drugs.


Everyone dies ...she will one day, just like everyone else.
 
Is she still on 'Life support'? Or has that finally been stopped?
 
Thank you for this update, I think that article is around 5 weeks old (the URL seems to show that it's from 28 March 2014). HotNostril gave the impression that they knew the current position.

The lack of updates is telling. Terribly sad state of affairs. I cannot foresee how the family will suddenly change their belief. Would the family be getting constantly counselled through this? Or now that they have more 'control' this poor girl can be left hooked to the machine for an undefined amount of time?
 
The lack of updates is telling. Terribly sad state of affairs. I cannot foresee how the family will suddenly change their belief. Would the family be getting constantly counselled through this? Or now that they have more 'control' this poor girl can be left hooked to the machine for an undefined amount of time?

If I was a company unscrupulous enough to hook up a dead body to a life support machine, I'd probably protect my income stream by making sure that no counselling was taking place (meaning less money for me). Of course as soon as the money ran out, I'd switch everything off.

Jahi's mother, Nailah Winkfield insists that Jahi is only sleeping and is responding:

Describing her daughter as "very responsive," Winkfield told the TV station that Jahi has physical therapy three or four times a week and moves her head from side to side.

Her comments come roughly a month after she posted similar comments on Facebook, saying Jahi had improved physically.

.....at least according to SomedayGirl's link
http://articles.latimes.com/2014/mar/28/local/la-me-ln-brain-dead-jahi-mcmath-mother-speaks-20140328
 
I don't know if I buy the following commands claims but the brain isn't liquified and circulation has been detected is certainly interesting.
 
I don't know if I buy the following commands claims but the brain isn't liquified and circulation has been detected is certainly interesting.

Do you have a citation for the circulation?

ETA
Nevermind, I misread your post. I mistakenly thought that you were referring to circulation in the brain.
 
Last edited:
Do you have a citation for the circulation?

ETA
Nevermind, I misread your post. I mistakenly thought that you were referring to circulation in the brain.
It was from the above link:

http://news.yahoo.com/girls-family-seeks-reversal-brain-death-ruling-195714462.html

DeFina also said brain scans showed electrical activity, and other tests showed blood flowing to the brain.

Arthur Caplan, head of medical ethics at New York University's Langone Medical Center, said he knows of no cases of a brain death determination being reversed. He cautioned that the data collected on Jahi has to be examined by other researchers and experts in the field before any conclusions can be made.

I'm just going by what was reported, I'm not arguing the facts will be confirmed.
 
Attorney Chris Dolan said doctors at the non-profit International Brain Research Foundation have found signs of brain functions after running a series of tests on the girl at Rutgers University last week.

I am curious as to what "signs of brain functions" means. I guess that will be explained in the process of trying to get the court order to declare her alive.
Here is a link to the International Brain Research Foundation. I couldn't find anything there about Jahi McMath.

http://www.ibrfinc.org/index.htm
 
Unless the test were done with a MRI and properly can be independentely verified I am very very doubtful. Twitch of limb can also be gotten independentely of a functionning brain by stimulating the leg itself or part of the spinal cord. So unless it is demonstred by independent party I am rather doubtful.
 
When we left off this thread in January, the picture was of a corpse being manipulated to appear alive. There was talk of rotting and decay. Now it's October. Were those claims mere hyperbole?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom