Brain dead but still in treatment?

Before the family took possession, the body appeared to be breaking down, which people described as decomposition. However, at that time, the body was not receiving any nourishment. Once the parents had the body, they bean to tube feed her.

To me at least, the earlier claims seemed a bit hyperbolic. The person may be dead, but the body is alive is a basic way.
 
Two questions Dr. Keith.

How long can she "live" like this wrt organ faiures?

What are we seeing in that video with her movements?

I have only one answer: Not all doctors are of the medical sort. :D

Maybe Dr. Imago will chime in again to give his more informed opinion.
 
Jahi MdMath's family is suing for personal injury and wrongful death

All right, IANAL, but... don't you have to believe someone is dead before suing for "wrongful death"? And her family, as far as I know, still does not believe Jahi is dead. All the other stuff they're suing for I can sort of understand; although I'm not about to believe what they're saying happened without seeing the medical records and reports and hearing testimony from the doctors and nurses as well as other witnesses. But the "wrongful death" part sort of predicates on Jahi being actually dead, which as far as I know the family is still unwilling to admit.

Maybe this is the last gasp of their feelings on the matter. If so, I'd say about time; the poor girl has now been kept on those machines for far too long. It's time to let her be at peace.
 
Jahi MdMath's family is suing for personal injury and wrongful death

All right, IANAL, but... don't you have to believe someone is dead before suing for "wrongful death"? And her family, as far as I know, still does not believe Jahi is dead. All the other stuff they're suing for I can sort of understand; although I'm not about to believe what they're saying happened without seeing the medical records and reports and hearing testimony from the doctors and nurses as well as other witnesses. But the "wrongful death" part sort of predicates on Jahi being actually dead, which as far as I know the family is still unwilling to admit.

Maybe this is the last gasp of their feelings on the matter. If so, I'd say about time; the poor girl has now been kept on those machines for far too long. It's time to let her be at peace.

Your link took me to an article about the San Jose Sharks; maybe this is the article you meant.

I'm no lawyer either, but I'd guess that the rationale for the "wrongful death" suit is that it's the doctors' definition that counts as the legal one, not the family's. I agree it's jarringly counter-intuitive (at the least) to be able to base a suit on something you won't admit is true, but I suppose law has taken stranger turns.
 
Yes, that is the link; I apologize, I thought I'd copied it correctly. My bad.
 
Jahi MdMath's family is suing for personal injury and wrongful death

All right, IANAL, but... don't you have to believe someone is dead before suing for "wrongful death"? And her family, as far as I know, still does not believe Jahi is dead. All the other stuff they're suing for I can sort of understand; although I'm not about to believe what they're saying happened without seeing the medical records and reports and hearing testimony from the doctors and nurses as well as other witnesses. But the "wrongful death" part sort of predicates on Jahi being actually dead, which as far as I know the family is still unwilling to admit.

Maybe this is the last gasp of their feelings on the matter. If so, I'd say about time; the poor girl has now been kept on those machines for far too long. It's time to let her be at peace.


Check that URL.
 
Call me a cynic, but from the article:

Jahi remains at an apartment in Somerset, New Jersey, receiving care from nurses. Dolan has threatened to take the state to court to revoke a death certificate on file for Jahi in California, which the family says has prevented them from bringing her home to Oakland for care.

Then a little further down:

There is a cap of $250,000 on medical malpractice lawsuits involving children who die as a result of surgery. The court would have to decide if this cap applies to Jahi, as the family and attorney are prepared to argue that she is alive and should be compensated for the care and damage from her surgery.

Revoking that death certificate would go a long way towards arguing she's "alive".

This is a sad case.
 
Maybe this is the last gasp of their feelings on the matter. If so, I'd say about time; the poor girl has now been kept on those machines for far too long. It's time to let her be at peace.

I propose the following correction :
"Maybe this is the last gasp of their feelings on the matter. If so, I'd say about time; the corpse has now been kept on those machines for far too long. It's a waste of resource. Luckily the girl has already been at peace/in oblivion/dead right at the start."
 
But I thought she was getting better last year, and would be up doing Yoga by now.
 
This nonsense rumbles on; the McMath family are suing UCSF Benioff Children's Hospital and, as part of the suit, claim their dead daughter is still alive. It seems this effort is motivated by the far greater financial payout for a living victim.

Link.
 
Two and a half years ago, when this thread started, it seemed pretty certain she was dead as dead can be. I read predictions of sloughing intestinal lining and rotting from the inside out. That didn't happen. Maybe it is time to reevaluate the case.
 
Sad case.

Those prayers are sure taking a long time to work. I bet God is waiting for the judge to declare her dead, then just as the gavel falls, she will burst through the courtroom doors.
 
Sad case.

Those prayers are sure taking a long time to work. I bet God is waiting for the judge to declare her dead, then just as the gavel falls, she will burst through the courtroom doors.

One thing for sure - if she does ever wake up, she'll have awesome superpowers.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom