Another Vaccination Scare?

{snip} So you would recommend as few people as possible take a first aid course or know how to perform mouth to mouth?
Do you know what a straw man is? I did not say that. Get a clue.
What robinson said was perfectly sensible and could probably save someone's life {snip}
Robinson said "Medical knowledge isn't ultra hard to learn." Outside a severely restricted realm, that is absurd; and that is the point I made.
 
First aid is a very specific subset dealing with immediate, acute problems that must be dealt with right away.

It's relevant in a way, though: I teach first aid courses, including basic CPR. It depresses me a bit, because I end up passing a lot of people who probably don't deserve it.

If I were to be as strict about competence as I am in lifeguarding courses, or for that matter, as strict as medical schools would be, I'd pass about one in ten.

And this is one thousandth of a percent of the competence an MD has demonstrated.
 
But you'd have to teach them about all 40,000 because you don't know which one any individual is going to get:confused:
That's what you still have doctors for. If an individual fails to properly diagnose something, he's still free to consult a doctor.
Right...and it's the physicians who are having to act as barriers to people being medicated for illnesses thay don't even have.
You mean the very same doctors that make money off sick people? And off medicating sick people? Seriously, doctors are very far from being barriers to capitalism.
Medical knowledge isn't ultra hard to learn. The posters in the Doctors office, as well as the pamphlets and stuff, are about education. It's a concept.
Here's the problem. Those pamphlets and posters, they're not education. They're marketing. They're not put there by people who want you to be healthy, but by people who want you to give them your money for the latest treatment they just invented a syndrome for. I don't want pharma industries' Marketing ploys to make up the majority of peoples' medical education.
 
Last edited:
That's what you still have doctors for. If an individual fails to properly diagnose something, he's still free to consult a doctor.
.

And how will he/she know when he/she does this? How often will it be too late to prevent permanent damage?

You mean the very same doctors that make money off sick people? And off medicating sick people? Seriously, doctors are very far from being barriers to capitalism.
.

This is a BS argument and you know it. Doctors have to make a living, and I would expect they would want to make a good one after eight + years of formal training and the hell that is after medical school. I guesss all doctors are shams who exist only to make money off of the diseased and keep them that way. Play me a violin. Your thinking on this subject is so obviously skewed it's almost incomprehensible.

Here's the problem. Those pamphlets and posters, they're not education. They're marketing. They're not put there by people who want you to be healthy, but by people who want you to give them your money for the latest treatment they just invented a syndrome for. I don't want pharma industries' Marketing ploys to make up the majority of peoples' medical education.

This is your problem. You are so biased and CYNICAL that you can't see clearly. You can't differentiate between the charts that are there for self-education and the ones that are there from a pharm company. Instead you lump them all in big basket. Must be nice in your world, where everything is so simple.
 
Do you know what a straw man is? I did not say that. Get a clue.

You claimed that emergency treatment and (for example) knowing the difference between a potentially cancerous mole and a normal one are a tiny subset of medicine.

Robinson said "Medical knowledge isn't ultra hard to learn." Outside a severely restricted realm, that is absurd; and that is the point I made.

No, it is not absurd. Some insecure doctors may like to give that impression to bolster their self-esteem, but the most useful medical knowledge, such as emergency treatment and warning signs of potentially serious conditions, are not "ultra-hard" to learn.

Robinson was not advocating people treating themselves for conditions such as skin cancer. That is your straw man. For a condition like this, what I believe he was pointing out was that if more people were aware of what to look out for in moles many more people would seek professional medical help earlier and thus have a much higher chance of a good outcome.
 
And how will he/she know when he/she does this? How often will it be too late to prevent permanent damage?
Through education. And significantly less often than with remote doctors and no medical training.
This is a BS argument and you know it. Doctors have to make a living, and I would expect they would want to make a good one after eight + years of formal training and the hell that is after medical school. I guesss all doctors are shams who exist only to make money off of the diseased and keep them that way. Play me a violin. Your thinking on this subject is so obviously skewed it's almost incomprehensible.
You agree with me and then you call my view skewed? What convoluted logic is this?
This is your problem. You are so biased and CYNICAL that you can't see clearly. You can't differentiate between the charts that are there for self-education and the ones that are there from a pharm company. Instead you lump them all in big basket. Must be nice in your world, where everything is so simple.
Oh, there's charts for self-education and the ones from the pharma industry. Here's a couple questions to you:
What's the proportion of "pharma pamphlets" and "self-edu fliers"?
Who pays for the self-edu fliers?
How to differentiate self-edu fliers from pharma pamphlets?

Oh, and yeah, being a cynic sure makes living a whole lot easier.


Here's a self help flier that I'd write:
Get the hell out of this doctor's office!
If you're sick, stay home till you feel alright again. The chances, that you've got something serious that should be looked at, are miniscule if you're not over the age of 70. This will however not stop any doctor from selling you a huge number of highly expensive, and usually worthless drugs, after diagnosing you with a number of conditions that were considered normal and benign only years ago.


I'm sure this sort of pamphlet would really fly in the doctor's office. Or out of.
 
Shouldn't you be posting in the Conspiracy Theories subsection?

Linda
 
You claimed that emergency treatment and (for example) knowing the difference between a potentially cancerous mole and a normal one are a tiny subset of medicine.

They are. However, that is not what JJM was refering to as a straw man. You said he was recomending that people should not take first aid courses, which is very clearly nothing to do with what he actually said.

No, it is not absurd. Some insecure doctors may like to give that impression to bolster their self-esteem, but the most useful medical knowledge, such as emergency treatment and warning signs of potentially serious conditions, are not "ultra-hard" to learn.

In fact, it's so easy to learn that people spend six years in medical school, several years as junior doctors and then the rest of their lives as senior doctors learning about it.

The thing is, no one piece of medical knowledge is hard to learn. That is not the point. The point is that there is far more to learn than any one person can manage in their whole life. Doctors have to specialise precisely because they can't learn everything, yet Dabljuh is not only saying that they should know everything, but that every single person on the planet should. Which is blatantly ridiculous.

Robinson was not advocating people treating themselves for conditions such as skin cancer. That is your straw man. For a condition like this, what I believe he was pointing out was that if more people were aware of what to look out for in moles many more people would seek professional medical help earlier and thus have a much higher chance of a good outcome.

And no-one has disagreed with this. However, Dabljuh is advocating people diagnosing and treating themselves for skin cancer, and everything else. That is what we are arguing against. Robinson has just introduced his own little straw man by trying to imply that we are arguing against first aid and education rather than what Dabljuh is actually saying.
 
They are. However, that is not what JJM was refering to as a straw man. You said he was recomending that people should not take first aid courses, which is very clearly nothing to do with what he actually said.

"A little [medical] knowledge, such as you possess, is a dangerous thing." is the exact quote he used.

I would say a little medical knowledge goes a long way and can direct someone in the right direction (a specialist) earlier on than if they waited for more blatant symptoms to become apparent.

What is dangerous is when people think they are more capable than they actually are.

In fact, it's so easy to learn that people spend six years in medical school, several years as junior doctors and then the rest of their lives as senior doctors learning about it.

You could say that about any scientific profession. Should we stop teaching kids a little bit about physics because they might feel inclined to test the theory of gravity by jumping out of a 2nd floor window?

If you teach anybody anything there will always be those who think they know more than they do, or do daft things with the knowledge. The question is how many people are harmed by having a little bit of useful knowledge that they may misuse compared to no knowledge?

The thing is, no one piece of medical knowledge is hard to learn. That is not the point. The point is that there is far more to learn than any one person can manage in their whole life. Doctors have to specialize precisely because they can't learn everything, yet Dabljuh is not only saying that they should know everything, but that every single person on the planet should. Which is blatantly ridiculous.

Yes, Dabljuh's idea is ridiculous. However, I am confident there is a reasonably small subset of medical knowledge that would be advantageous to many people because it would enable correct self-treatment, and/or get them to seek the help of a professional sooner than they otherwise would have.

And no-one has disagreed with this. However, Dabljuh is advocating people diagnosing and treating themselves for skin cancer, and everything else. That is what we are arguing against. Robinson has just introduced his own little straw man by trying to imply that we are arguing against first aid and education rather than what Dabljuh is actually saying.

Again, Dabljuh idea is ridiculous and his suggested pamphlet harmful. This is so obvious why is anybody arguing with him?

What is annoying me is the condescending tone of some people here (_not_ Linda;)) who think medical knowledge is so dangerous or hard to apply correctly that only relative few people in society (doctors) should have it in any significant quantity.
 
"A little [medical] knowledge, such as you possess, is a dangerous thing." is the exact quote [JJM] used.

I would say a little medical knowledge goes a long way and can direct someone in the right direction (a specialist) earlier on than if they waited for more blatant symptoms to become apparent. {snip}
Sorry, I was not clear. My point was that you have a little medical knowledge and seem to be saying the rest is as trivial.

{snip} What is annoying me is the condescending tone of some people here (_not_ Linda;)) who think medical knowledge is so dangerous or hard to apply correctly that only relative few people in society (doctors) should have it in any significant quantity.
I don't know where you get that idea. Certainly, only doctors should be allowed to apply medical knowledge under normal circumstances; but, I see no reason to restrict information.
 
Dabljuh clearly is of the mind that all doctors manufacture diseases out of thin air in order to flog expensive treatments to patients at great personal profit. He dismisses or rejects evidence to the contrary (without even considering facts presented to him).

And what is Dabljuh's job?
He markets homeopathic remedies and colonic irrigation - so absolutely no conflict of interest nor any possible sales of expensive useless therapies for imagined diseases there, then.....
:D

His most revered source of medical advice and opinion is a website run by a chiropractor selling a range of supplements and vitamins as well as his own books and CDs. I think we can all get a proper perspective on his views if we bear these salient facts in mind.

Perhaps someone can consider what happens in the NHS in the UK? Primary Care practitioners (GPs) are independently contracted to work for the NHS, being paid according to contracts they have with a Primary Care Trust. They have indicative budgets for pharmaceuticals. So it is actually in every GP's best financial interest to avoid prescribing expensive treatments - the more of their bugdet they use in this way, the less their "profit".

I know several GPs who would love to pursue the type of strategy that Dubljuh would advocate - a form of "Get out of this surgery, there is nothing wrong with you!" policy.

There is a major Government campaign in the UK to get fewer patients clogging up their doctors waiting rooms with trivial complaints, and part of this response is NHS Direct, which is very widely advertised throughout the UK.

This gives all the advice Dabljuh wishes patients could receive, without a single drug manufacturer in sight. It is all funded through general taxation.

I doubt these facts will make Dabljuh change his opinion (as regards the UK at least) - He tends to makes things up as he goes along.
 
Sorry, I was not clear. My point was that you have a little medical knowledge and seem to be saying the rest is as trivial.

Ok, a misunderstanding. I'm going for a hat-trick:)

What I was trying to say was that for most people, most of the time, the extensive knowledge and skills of a doctor are not required for effective treatment, but people would seek out such expertise more appropriately and earlier if they had some basic medical knowledge (assuming they were aware of their limited abilities).

E.g., knowing enough to be able to rewire a plug, but also that fixing your TV is going to require someone with more knowledge and the appropriate skills.

I don't know where you get that idea.

From the "A little knowledge..." bit in your previous post.

Certainly, only doctors should be allowed to apply medical knowledge under normal circumstances; but, I see no reason to restrict information.

I agree, which is why I commented "learning to "do" the clinical and surgical aspects of medicine requires lots of practical experience and tuition." in an previous post. I'll add that advanced knowledge in a particular field (medical or otherwise) also takes many years to acquire.
 
Interesting sidetrack, but yet somehow on topic, considering the issue of people wanting to know all about vaccines, the medical studies showing the safety of them, the side effects to look for in their children after they are injected or infected, the known risk, the manufacturing path,etc etc etc, none of which is trivial.

I'm missing out on all the fun here this week, :hb: , so a quick response because my name showed up in a few responses, and my ego just won't let me ignore it, :) , and because I really like skeptics, even when they completely disagree with me. This is because a real skeptic can change their mind, if evidence is provided, from sources that they trust. This is such a rare trait, I value it in you, and anyone else who has acquired it.

What I was trying to say was that for most people, most of the time, the extensive knowledge and skills of a doctor are not required for effective treatment, but people would seek out such expertise more appropriately and earlier if they had some basic medical knowledge (assuming they were aware of their limited abilities).


I would add that preventative medicine, in which education is vital, leads to lower cost, an important issue in the rare country with no government medical system in place.

E.g., knowing enough to be able to rewire a plug, but also that fixing your TV is going to require someone with more knowledge and the appropriate skills.

Good example. If you screw up your CRT by putting a magnet or speakers too near, a quick Net search will show you how to fix that problem with a power drill and a magnet. If you don't know this, it means you take it to a shop, or have a very expensive tech show up to wipe it for you.

I'll add that advanced knowledge in a particular field (medical or otherwise) also takes many years to acquire.

Understatement of the month! The specialization in other fields is as bad as Medicine these days. Speaking of, even a trained M.D. depends on many other Doctors to diagnose and treat. But not for the majority of health problems that most people have. The huge rise in chronic and hard to treat ailments in the industrialized world has changed the game a lot, IMO.

Sorry, I was not clear. My point was that you have a little medical knowledge and seem to be saying the rest is as trivial.

I don't know where you get that idea. Certainly, only doctors should be allowed to apply medical knowledge under normal circumstances; but, I see no reason to restrict information.

Indeed, but restricting medications has very good reasons behind it. Even a specialist might depend on a Pharmacist when prescribing treatment. I think part of what is being proposed involves teaching about drugs, which is another field. And not one to be self educated in, but at the same time, that is just what people do, all the time. I know people on many medications, and they have become experts on the meds they take, or can't take.

I would say a little medical knowledge goes a long way and can direct someone in the right direction (a specialist) earlier on than if they waited for more blatant symptoms to become apparent.

What is dangerous is when people think they are more capable than they actually are.

Good point. Even more so when it comes to self medicating. Drugs are extremely dangerous.

Should we stop teaching kids a little bit about physics because they might feel inclined to test the theory of gravity by jumping out of a 2nd floor window?

I've seen desperate pleas by qualified people to teach kids about gravity, and why movies and TV shows are wrong about how they show it. Many kids do try to imitate what they see, with terrible results.

The question is how many people are harmed by having a little bit of useful knowledge that they may misuse compared to no knowledge?

A crucial point. Those damn drug Ads on TV are a good example. 30 seconds of self diagnosis with the cure being offered. Madness.

What is annoying me is the condescending tone of some people here (_not_ Linda;)) who think medical knowledge is so dangerous or hard to apply correctly that only relative few people in society (doctors) should have it in any significant quantity.

Ya, but I try to ignore bait. :D Anyone who has lived a while, and is intelligent, probably has more Medical knowledge about them self than any Doctor, based on a lifetime of education the hard way. I can recognize immediately any symptom or ailment I have had before. Long before a test would show any problem, I am aware of it starting. Same for injuries. I can tell what will heal without aid, and what won't.

Except for the rare instance, in which case a Doctor and an X-ray/MRI/CAT scan needs to involved. And lots of money.

... it's so easy to learn that people spend six years in medical school, several years as junior doctors and then the rest of their lives as senior doctors learning about it.

The thing is, no one piece of medical knowledge is hard to learn. That is not the point.

I'm hearing something different. That common obvious conditions could be treated by the person, rather than the Doctor. And in fact, in my lifetime many Prescription Meds have indeed become over the counter, and millions of people treat themselves with them.

The point is that there is far more to learn than any one person can manage in their whole life. Doctors have to specialise precisely because they can't learn everything, yet Dabljuh is not only saying that they should know everything, but that every single person on the planet should. Which is blatantly ridiculous.

If that was what was said, I would agree. But it isn't, so strawman gets dragged around and abused. The horror, the horror.

Robinson has just introduced his own little straw man by trying to imply that we are arguing against first aid and education rather than what Dabljuh is actually saying.

No, and I commend those who can read and understand stuff. I am countering with another proposal, adding info into the mix. Please don't put words in my mouth, I might bite your fingers off. :wackywink:

... but the most useful medical knowledge, such as emergency treatment and warning signs of potentially serious conditions, are not "ultra-hard" to learn.

Robinson was not advocating people treating themselves for conditions such as skin cancer. That is your straw man. For a condition like this, what I believe he was pointing out was that if more people were aware of what to look out for in moles many more people would seek professional medical help earlier and thus have a much higher chance of a good outcome.

Indeed, and other conditions as well. It is very important information, and you just don't see it on TV, or in school.

Doctors have to make a living, and I would expect they would want to make a good one after eight + years of formal training and the hell that is after medical school.

Indeed, indeed. Just to throw in a little more off topic stuff, there is vast difference between Medicine in advanced countries, and in backward ones. Advanced civilizations remove profit from the Doctors duties, and after school they have no debt to repay. The trade off for reduced stress and financial freedom, is that they can't make vast profits from medicine. A trade off.


Robinson said "Medical knowledge isn't ultra hard to learn." Outside a severely restricted realm, that is absurd; and that is the point I made.

Hmmm, I should have qualified my claim with, "for an intelligent person". The dumb should never be allowed anywhere near medicine or treatment.

Let me add a simple statement that may help clarify, I'm finding it hard to get everything down into a few sentences and remain clear.
...

The teaching, though, is going to be long and expensive. You're essentially talking about giving everyone the equivalent of pre-med and PA school, at least. It's not a feasible option.

I agree. The problem with removing competent trained Doctors from the equation is that there are other factors that can either complicate or threaten, even if some simple maladies. Most people are not smart enough to be trained, especially in Meds, and all the other factors.














Whew.

That was a lot more than I planned on. Carry on. Interesting times ...
 
Last edited:
Dabljuh is not only saying that they [doctors] should know everything, but that every single person on the planet should.
No.

Dabljuh clearly is of the mind that all doctors manufacture diseases out of thin air in order to flog expensive treatments to patients at great personal profit. He dismisses or rejects evidence to the contrary (without even considering facts presented to him).
considering facts... to what end? recent evidence to the contrary? WHERE? You just conjured this stuff in order to be able to dismiss my opinion?

His most revered source of medical advice and opinion is a website run by a chiropractor selling a range of supplements and vitamins as well as his own books and CDs. I think we can all get a proper perspective on his views if we bear these salient facts in mind.
Anything to be able dismiss my claims, huh?
Perhaps someone can consider what happens in the NHS in the UK? Primary Care practitioners (GPs) are independently contracted to work for the NHS, being paid according to contracts they have with a Primary Care Trust. They have indicative budgets for pharmaceuticals. So it is actually in every GP's best financial interest to avoid prescribing expensive treatments - the more of their bugdet they use in this way, the less their "profit".
That's actually good. But countries have different legislations, and there is a constant push in social market economies to make the latest (and most useless and expensive) treatments "available to everyone" under the guise of medical welfare. The behaviour is called rent-seeking.

But I never said the entirety of the medical complex is corrupt. There's been a number of studies, paid for by health insurers and public institutions that have had interesting results.

I know several GPs who would love to pursue the type of strategy that Dubljuh would advocate - a form of "Get out of this surgery, there is nothing wrong with you!" policy.
The key word here being would. Because even these doctors who have a bit of integrity in them, know that the patients will just go to the next doctor. Hence it doesn't happen, and when it happens, it doesn't change anything about the problem.

This gives all the advice Dabljuh wishes patients could receive, without a single drug manufacturer in sight. It is all funded through general taxation.
Because state institutions are known for being completely independent from privately owned business, right?

Hmmm, I should have qualified my claim with, "for an intelligent person". The dumb should never be allowed anywhere near medicine or treatment.
Basic problem there. You can't properly tell the dumb from the good. Any attempt to try to discriminate against any sort of people will be abused. Basically it'd just be "Only doctors may XY" because obviously anyone who's not a doctor, may.

But consider the alternative. People are getting drugs, and are getting drugged. Regardless of their supposed intelligence, or even, because of. Ritalin, anyone? Free trade with drugs would benefit everyone.
 
Just FYI: I started this thread to redirect the "medical education" topic. Click here and love

Back to vaccination.

Alright, to me, there's clear evidence that at least a number of vaccinations are at best worthless, and some others at worst dangerous.

I'm not saying vaccination never works. I haven't seen a comprehensive and critical investigation on ALL individual vaccinations yet. But to the people who think vaccines are the bestest thing ever: Think again.

The problem I see with this sort of statement is that there shouldn't be a "Vaccinations" thread, but instead, for each individual vaccine, there should be a critical investigation.
 
Alright, to me, there's clear evidence that at least a number of vaccinations are at best worthless, and some others at worst dangerous.

You have not shown this evidence to us.

... I haven't seen a comprehensive and critical investigation on ALL individual vaccinations yet.
...for each individual vaccine, there should be a critical investigation.

Just because you have not seen the studies they don't exist already?
 
I have never seen any actual evidence that shows any current vaccines are remotely "dangerous" (especially compared to the disease) or even close to worthless. When vaccines are administered the persons are monitored at the clinic for 15-30 minutes afterwards for the side-effects (fever, soreness at spot, allergies). I'm allergic to eggs, and I can still get the flu shot with no complications.

The fact that diseases are being irradicated and are now so uncommon in populations getting routine vaccinations speak volumes about their effectiveness. Only someone with their head stuck in the ground can deny this glaringly obvious truth aound them all day long. The fact that most children actually make it past age 2 now is also an indicator as to the effectiveness of vaccination.

I've presented tons of information and evidence as to this, but people like dab stick to their misinformed and untruthful sources like a flea on a dog they think is a cat.

Diseases kill and maim people for life. Vaccines do not. If you'd rather subject your child to life-long pain or even death because of unfounded fears delievered to you by morons on the internet, then so be it. I'm glad I have the chance to get my kids all of their vaccines in attempt to contribute to herd immunity and the prevention of things like shingles, meningitis, liver cancer (from hepatitis), post-polio syndrome, etc.

An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure.

More sources if dab is ever willing to look at information over misinformation:
http://www.time.com/time/printout/0,8816,1576829,00.html
http://www.spiked-online.com/index.php?/site/issues/C30/
http://www.geocities.com/healthbase/vaxquotes.html
http://www.apologia.com/vaccines/vac_test.html
http://www.slate.com/id/2123647/
http://skeptico.blogs.com/skeptico/2005/06/robert_f_kenned.html

Read through those, and come back with some intellegent questions about the issue.
 
I have never seen any actual evidence that shows any current vaccines are remotely "dangerous" (especially compared to the disease) or even close to worthless.

Does this mean you refuse to look at the evidence, or that you have looked, and decided none of it was evidence?
 
Does this mean you refuse to look at the evidence, or that you have looked, and decided none of it was evidence?
Here's an idea, and maybe I'm just thinking crazy here, but why don't you try providing something you'd regard as evidence that a vaccine is dangerous, and we'll see if Eos refuses to look at it?
 
Gosh darn, what a concept. Or, people could do their own research, and find out for themselves, and I don't have to do your homework for you.

Hmmm.... tough choice there ...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom