Another Vaccination Scare?

Kellyb is correct, pandemic flu arises form the type A influenza only. Type A viruses originate in birds.


On rare occasions, these bird viruses can infect other species, including pigs and humans. The vast majority of avian influenza viruses do not infect humans. An influenza pandemic happens when a new subtype emerges that has not previously circulated in humans.
http://www.who.int/csr/disease/influenza/pandemic10things/en/index.html

The bird flu bug also mutates in pigs, then it spreads to humans, and voila... pandemic. Influenza that we vaccinate against does originate in pig populations. Pigs can get bird flu bugs that just might lead to a pandemic too.

Right now we are eyeing H5N1 as a prime suspect. Another could pop up.
 
Totally off topic...
But exactly how incompetent can the US DHHS be?

http://www.hhs.gov/nvpo/concepts/intro6.htm

The burden of suffering caused by Hib disease includes coma, seizures, paralysis, temporary or permanent brain damage, developmental delays, speech and language disorders, deafness, inner ear inflammation, sinus infection, brain abscess, conjunctivitis, bronchitis, pneumonia, epyema, bacterial meningitis, and death. There is no treatment for the Hib virus itself; only the symptoms can be treated, and very high doses of antibiotics are given for bacterial complications. Thousands of children were spared these complications when they received the Hib vaccine.

WTF?

ETA: I nominate Skeptigirl to write them a letter.
 
Isolation and quarantine?

The thing about influenza is that it's highly contagious before symptom onset.
So I don't see how quarantine can work well in ther long run. You might be able to slow it down a bit that way, but there's a limit to it's effectiveness after that.

From what I understand about the 1918 pandemic, virtually everyone was eventually infected and developed (some) immunity.

Quarantine was the solution, but even in the worst hit areas, where infection rates were at 50%, most people didn't die from it. It was an ugly time in History, with travel restricted and masks being worn, and people not wanting to gather together, or being prevented from gathering.

There was never any cure for it. It ran its course, and vanished. One source on it http://virus.stanford.edu/uda/

If you visit a Hospital, you might be surprised at how little is done to prevent the obvious paths of infection from bacteria. A sick, infectious person can walk into a Hospital, walk through the halls, enter a patients room, use the public bathroom, eat in the cafeteria, and visit the gift shop and chapel.

Interesting enough, while researching this, I found a very woo sounding method that stops or reduces airborne transmission of bacteria.
 
robinson said:
Quarantine was the solution, but even in the worst hit areas, where infection rates were at 50%, most people didn't die from it.

I think that would be expected since the virus was "only" deadly in about one or two percent of the population.

Interesting enough, while researching this, I found a very woo sounding method that stops or reduces airborne transmission of bacteria.

Since you mentioned it...what is it?
 
Haemophilus Influenzae Type b (despite it's somewhat misleading name) is bacterial. Obviously whoever wrote the blurb just made an error by calling it the Hib virus.

If you read the whole paragraph, it's pretty clear that whoever wrote it literally thinks it's a virus.
"you can only treat the symptoms"..."antibiotics are given for bacterial complications"..."there is no treatment for the Hib virus itself".
 
If I didn't have a link for this, I wouldn't mention it here. (you know how some people get, if it sounds woo, it must be woo)

Tests of new machine at a hospital have found it could be effective in the battle against the superbug MRSA.

Consultants at Wythenshawe Hospital found that using a vaporiser to spray essential oils into the atmosphere killed off micro-organisms.

Airborne bacterial counts dropped by 90% and infections were reduced in a nine-month trial at the burns unit.

The recipe of oils used in the machine was refined by microbiologists at Manchester Metropolitan University.

Scent Technologies, the Wigan-based company which makes the machine, developed the device to mask smells on wards but found it had a beneficial effect on infections...(more at link)

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/manchester/6471475.stm
 
If you read the whole paragraph, it's pretty clear that whoever wrote it literally thinks it's a virus.
"you can only treat the symptoms"..."antibiotics are given for bacterial complications"..."there is no treatment for the Hib virus itself".

Amazing. Yes, sick skeptigirl on them.

Of course they do define it as
Hib disease: Disease caused by Haemophilus Influenzae type b. Until recently, this disease was the most common cause of deadly bacterial meningitis in children. It can also cause infection of the bloodstream, pneumonia, epiglottis, and otitis media, among other conditions.
http://www.hhs.gov/nvpo/glossary.htm#Hib disease
 
I wonder how it works. There are many claims about essential oils and health. It may be that there is actually something to it, from a scientific point of view.

If essential oils can negate seriously dangerous superbugs in the air, there may be other properties to them that could be beneficial.
 
If you read the whole paragraph, it's pretty clear that whoever wrote it literally thinks it's a virus.
"you can only treat the symptoms"..."antibiotics are given for bacterial complications"..."there is no treatment for the Hib virus itself".

That's because when you have a Hib bacterial infection it spreads through the body and you get numerous bacterial infections, the worst and most common being meningitis but many others including: pneumonia, ear infections, bone infections...

The proper (or most common) way to refer to it would have been Hib disease or infection.

It appears to be a case of a lack of proof reading, or maybe they just gave whoever typed it up the basics and they weren't familiar themselves with the facts (a secretary or something perhaps). Remember that the vast majority of almost any government entity is not field experts, but rather bureaucrats and administrative staff.

I don't think it is indicative in any way that a whole department of the government is incompetent or wrong, rather that one employee of that department is. I am sure if someone wrote to them they would be happy to correct it.
 
The bird flu bug also mutates in pigs, then it spreads to humans, and voila... pandemic.
It's important to keep in mind that the forefront of influenza science is advancing rapidly. Not long ago, the accepted wisdom was that reassortment (rather than mutation) is the primary means by which an influenza virus aquires the changes required to turn it into a pandemic strain -- with pigs as the ideal "vessel", because they are more easily infected with strains of either human or avian origin than are humans with avian strains or vice versa. A lot of the basis of that has to do with "ciliated" versus "non-ciliated" cells and their relative distributions in humans and pigs, and on some assumptions about the relative ease with which these different types of cells are infected by influenza.

More recently, some of these assumptions have been challenged. Virologists are getting schooled by the H5N1 virus, and if it goes pandemic, a lot of others will as well. The key lessons have to do with the fragility of social structures which feature enormous numbers of spoiled, stupid people crammed into huge, power-hungry cities where they are utterly dependent on long, brittle chains of supply.
 
Last edited:
BlackKat said:
That's because when you have a Hib bacterial infection it spreads through the body and you get numerous bacterial infections, the worst and most common being meningitis but many others including: pneumonia, ear infections, bone infections...

The proper (or most common) way to refer to it would have been Hib disease or infection.

It appears to be a case of a lack of proof reading, or maybe they just gave whoever typed it up the basics and they weren't familiar themselves with the facts (a secretary or something perhaps).
I think the statement "There is no treatment for the Hib virus itself; only the symptoms can be treated" demonstrates beyond a shadow of a doubt that whoever wrote that thought Hib was a virus. My wild guess would be that the word "influenzae" was what led to that assumption. (back when the bacteria was discovered, way, way back in the day, they thought it was the causitive organism behind "the flu" since catching "the flu" often preceeds bacterial infections, and bacteria, being much larger than viruses, were discovered first).

I am sure if someone wrote to them they would be happy to correct it.
Ha!
In the year 2019 when they get around to reading it. :D
 
What do you think about the 68 year cycle, Dymanic?

Did you look over that Hillman paper? What do you think of his general take on influenza? (not just the 68 year cycle).
 
I think the statement "There is no treatment for the Hib virus itself; only the symptoms can be treated" demonstrates beyond a shadow of a doubt that whoever wrote that thought Hib was a virus. My wild guess would be that the word "influenzae" was what led to that assumption. (back when the bacteria was discovered, way, way back in the day, they thought it was the causitive organism behind "the flu" since catching "the flu" often preceeds bacterial infections, and bacteria, being much larger than viruses, were discovered first)...

It was actually suspected as the cause of the 1918 influenza... but that was when microbiology was a in its infancy. Check out the bit about Pfeiffer: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Friedrich_Johannes_Pfeiffer

Actually, it is one of those bacterial infections that are very difficult to treat with antibiotics. It is possible, but very difficult. Like pertussis and tetanus, and some pneumonias (like the on that killed Jim Henson)... antibiotics may not act fast enough. From http://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/pubs/pinkbook/downloads/hib.pdf

Hospitalization is generally required for invasive Hib disease.
Antimicrobial therapy with an effective third-generation
cephalosporin (cefotaxime or ceftriaxone), or chloramphenicol
in combination with ampicillin should be begun immediately.
The treatment course is usually 10 days. Ampicillin-resistant
strains of Hib are now common throughout the United
States. Children with life-threatening illness in which
Hib may be the etiologic agent should not receive ampicillin​
alone as initial empiric therapy.

One of the reasons that vaccines for Hib, pertussis, tetanus and other bacterial infections were created. Prevent the problems before the need to be treated.
 
What do you think about the 68 year cycle, Dymanic?

Did you look over that Hillman paper? What do you think of his general take on influenza? (not just the 68 year cycle).
As for the 68 year thing, I've seen some similar ideas recently. Shifting serology in host populations plays a role in the severity of epidemics. That's obvious. Just how great a role? Much less obvious.

As for the rest, I'm a little PDF challenged right now, but I'll note that a lot has happened since the publication date on that paper. (And btw, I did know about the accident involving H1N1).

As for the topic of this thread, we've noted in previous discussions that ramping up vaccine production capacities, considered a vital part of pandemic response, is a challenge in societies where such activities are profit-driven. This is especially true for flu vaccines, because they are among the least profitable products a pharmaceutical company can dedicate its resourses to. I don't have the answer to that, but I'd count more on my skills as an isolator than on living to see an effective pandemic vaccine anyway. I'd love to be able to pitch the idea that vaxing against seasonal flu significantly reduces the threat of a pandemic, but I find it hard to do that, because I'm no longer convinced that reassortment is necessary, or even the most likely scenario; at least not with H5N1.
 
dymanic said:
As for the 68 year thing, I've seen some similar ideas recently. Shifting serology in host populations plays a role in the severity of epidemics. That's obvious. Just how great a role? Much less obvious.

Can you "see in your head" how that might "work"?
The only thing I can think of is maybe that it would be a matter of 'young' people being immunologically naive, and 'older' people sort of locked into a limited immune response because of the original antigenic sin thing? And the two populations combined fueling rapid transmission?

I guess if the 68 year cycle isn't even true, or has just been a coincidence, it doesn't matter, and it's a waste of time to wonder about too deeply...

As for the rest, I'm a little PDF challenged right now, but I'll note that a lot has happened since the publication date on that paper.

What do you think the great discoveries of the past 5 years have been?

(And btw, I did know about the accident involving H1N1).
Well nannynannybooboo to you, too.:p
 
Can you "see in your head" how that might "work"?
If I close one eye and scrunch up my face just right. But I don't trust it. I think this is one area where complexity overwhelms intuition; the only way to get a clear picture is to ignore some of the variables. There's a quote attributed to John von Neumann: "In mathematics you don't understand things. You just get used to them." That seems to apply to epidemiology as well.

The only thing I can think of is maybe that it would be a matter of 'young' people being immunologically naive,
Right. A fresh batch of susceptible hosts. Easier to see that in birds.

...and 'older' people sort of locked into a limited immune response because of the original antigenic sin thing? And the two populations combined fueling rapid transmission?
I believe in original antigenic sin. I just question whether it plays as significant a role in influenza epidemiology as some would suggest.

What do you think the great discoveries of the past 5 years have been?
I think they've been more of the nature of un-discoveries, really; instances where what was believed to be so turned out to be either wrong or a lot more complicated than was thought. Much of the focus has been on receptor binding, partly because it's one of the things that can be studied in a laboratory. Remarkably little is know about what takes place inside a cell infected with influenza. You look where the light is good.

I guess if the 68 year cycle isn't even true, or has just been a coincidence, it doesn't matter, and it's a waste of time to wonder about too deeply...
I wonder if it's a waste of time to wonder deeply about whether wondering too deeply is a waste of time?
 
dymanic said:
If I close one eye and scrunch up my face just right. But I don't trust it. I think this is one area where complexity overwhelms intuition; the only way to get a clear picture is to ignore some of the variables. There's a quote attributed to John von Neumann: "In mathematics you don't understand things. You just get used to them." That seems to apply to epidemiology as well.

Well, the epidemiology of some diseases is pretty easy to grok. Influenza's just more mysterious than many of them.

I think they've been more of the nature of un-discoveries, really; instances where what was believed to be so turned out to be either wrong or a lot more complicated than was thought. Much of the focus has been on receptor binding, partly because it's one of the things that can be studied in a laboratory. Remarkably little is know about what takes place inside a cell infected with influenza. You look where the light is good.

Can you think of anything that's been discovered or un-discovered that specifically relates to Hillman's "take" on influenza?
 
Well, the epidemiology of some diseases is pretty easy to grok. Influenza's just more mysterious than many of them.
I agree.

Can you think of anything that's been discovered or un-discovered that specifically relates to Hillman's "take" on influenza?
Not really, but I've barely skimmed the article anyway. Is there something in particular that catches your interest? How would you summarize Hillman's "take" on influenza?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom