Does anyone know anything about this?
This paper appears to be Maurice Hillman's "manifesto" on influenza, written shortly before his death. He was an unusually bright guy, and he has an interesting idea here:
http://www.daimi.au.dk/~roald/evolu...04/EV04_litt/uge_4/Hilleman_InfVaccine_02.pdf
Any of you have any opinions about that?
Does that seem correct, or plausible, or was he getting fuzzy-headed in his old age?
There was an old hypothesis about an 80 year influenza cycle. Current research on influenza doesn't support it but the questions are not completely resolved.
We know a number of infections like chicken pox and measles go through the population then subside until enough new susceptibles are born to replace the ones immune from having been infected. There needs to be a certain number of susceptible people in order for an epidemic to be sustained.
Early hypotheses about why the pandemic flu was so severe in young adults but seemed to spare a lot of people over age 80 led to speculation the older generation had been infected with a similar strain years earlier.
It looks now more like the immune response triggered by influenza (the cytokine storm hypothesis) was responsible for the 'W' shaped death curve rather than the 'U' shape we normally see. Obviously the population has to be susceptible, but that would make it 20-30 years if you were just looking at the high death rate in young adults. It is more likely there is more randomness to when the next deadly mutation is going to arise.
As to this paper's assumptions and conclusions, a number of them are iffy.
Genetic analyses showed the 1977 Russian isolate [28,29] to be of near genetic identity with the H1N1 viruses that were circulating in 1950. This indicates that the virus had been preserved at some undefined location, probably in frozen storage [28].
Lakes and other bodies of water have been found to harbor influenza virus. So I'm not sure this assumption about a lab escape is the only possible explanation. I'd like to look a little deeper into the actual genetic research.
This claim
It is now proposed, based on seroepidemiologic data [22,23,30] that the pandemics of 1889 and 1900 were caused by H2N2 and H3N8 viruses, respectively.
is news to me and I just finished reading
"The Great Influenza: The Epic Story of the Deadliest Plague In History" which is a tediously detailed account of the pandemic and I don't recall any mention was in there of any such conclusion. Again, I want to look at the references.
[22] Dowdle WR. Influenza A virus recycling revisited. Bull Who 1999;77:820–8.
[23] Reid AH, Taubenberger JK. The 1918 flu and other pandemics: over there and back again. Lab Invest 1999;79:95–101.
[28]Nakajima K, Desselberger U, Palese P. Recent human influenza A viruses are closely related genetically to strains isolated in 1950. Nature 1978;274:334–9.
[29] Palese P, Young JF. Molecular epidemiology of influenza virus. In: Palese P, Kingsbury DW, editors. Genetics of influenza viruses. New York: Springer, 1983. p. 321–36.
[30] Davenport FM, Hennessy AV, Francis Jr T. Epidemiologic and immunologic significance of age distribution of antibody to antigenic variants of influenza virus. J Exp Med 1953;98:641–56.
A reference from 1978 and even 1983 are just not current enough to accept conclusions from at face value. The science has moved too quickly and I'll have to see something more current to buy these conclusions. What concerns me is this paper was written in 2002. There has been such a wealth of research on influenza in the last 5 years you have to wonder about these conclusions.
I'll look into these things a bit more when I have the time. It's an interesting paper. I just question the authority with which conclusions are stated which may not be as well supported as implied.