Another Vaccination Scare?

Not really, but I've barely skimmed the article anyway. Is there something in particular that catches your interest? How would you summarize Hillman's "take" on influenza?

Well, he doesn't seem particularly worried about animal versions jumping into people, for one. He doesn't even seem convinced that the 1918 version necessarily had anyhing to do with birds, and says that when the animal influenza viruses infect humans, it's rare and the spread usually remains limited, even when H2H transmission happens on a small scale.

He seems to think the biggest threat has to do with recombinations happening among circulating strains and gentic drifts and shifts.

ETA:
Read the paper. I'm sure you'll disagree with him on a lot of things, but it's interesting. And different.
 
Last edited:
Does anyone know anything about this?

This paper appears to be Maurice Hillman's "manifesto" on influenza, written shortly before his death. He was an unusually bright guy, and he has an interesting idea here:

http://www.daimi.au.dk/~roald/evolu...04/EV04_litt/uge_4/Hilleman_InfVaccine_02.pdf

Any of you have any opinions about that?
Does that seem correct, or plausible, or was he getting fuzzy-headed in his old age?
There was an old hypothesis about an 80 year influenza cycle. Current research on influenza doesn't support it but the questions are not completely resolved.

We know a number of infections like chicken pox and measles go through the population then subside until enough new susceptibles are born to replace the ones immune from having been infected. There needs to be a certain number of susceptible people in order for an epidemic to be sustained.

Early hypotheses about why the pandemic flu was so severe in young adults but seemed to spare a lot of people over age 80 led to speculation the older generation had been infected with a similar strain years earlier.

It looks now more like the immune response triggered by influenza (the cytokine storm hypothesis) was responsible for the 'W' shaped death curve rather than the 'U' shape we normally see. Obviously the population has to be susceptible, but that would make it 20-30 years if you were just looking at the high death rate in young adults. It is more likely there is more randomness to when the next deadly mutation is going to arise.

As to this paper's assumptions and conclusions, a number of them are iffy.
Genetic analyses showed the 1977 Russian isolate [28,29] to be of near genetic identity with the H1N1 viruses that were circulating in 1950. This indicates that the virus had been preserved at some undefined location, probably in frozen storage [28].
Lakes and other bodies of water have been found to harbor influenza virus. So I'm not sure this assumption about a lab escape is the only possible explanation. I'd like to look a little deeper into the actual genetic research.

This claim
It is now proposed, based on seroepidemiologic data [22,23,30] that the pandemics of 1889 and 1900 were caused by H2N2 and H3N8 viruses, respectively.
is news to me and I just finished reading "The Great Influenza: The Epic Story of the Deadliest Plague In History" which is a tediously detailed account of the pandemic and I don't recall any mention was in there of any such conclusion. Again, I want to look at the references.

[22] Dowdle WR. Influenza A virus recycling revisited. Bull Who 1999;77:820–8.
[23] Reid AH, Taubenberger JK. The 1918 flu and other pandemics: over there and back again. Lab Invest 1999;79:95–101.
[28]Nakajima K, Desselberger U, Palese P. Recent human influenza A viruses are closely related genetically to strains isolated in 1950. Nature 1978;274:334–9.
[29] Palese P, Young JF. Molecular epidemiology of influenza virus. In: Palese P, Kingsbury DW, editors. Genetics of influenza viruses. New York: Springer, 1983. p. 321–36.
[30] Davenport FM, Hennessy AV, Francis Jr T. Epidemiologic and immunologic significance of age distribution of antibody to antigenic variants of influenza virus. J Exp Med 1953;98:641–56.
A reference from 1978 and even 1983 are just not current enough to accept conclusions from at face value. The science has moved too quickly and I'll have to see something more current to buy these conclusions. What concerns me is this paper was written in 2002. There has been such a wealth of research on influenza in the last 5 years you have to wonder about these conclusions.

I'll look into these things a bit more when I have the time. It's an interesting paper. I just question the authority with which conclusions are stated which may not be as well supported as implied.
 
These two books go into great detail about that:
http://www.amazon.com/Flu-Story-Great-Influenza-Pandemic/dp/0743203984/
and
http://www.amazon.com/Great-Influenza-deadliest-pandemic-history/dp/0143036491/

(they should both be read because they go over different aspects... but the first one should be read first)
Great, I just finished the second one with incredibly long passages of details and you tell me I need to read the other one as well. ;)

Barry's book might be of more interest to someone in the medical profession because he describes a lot of the history of medicine at the time. What it lacked though was much history of the pandemic outside the US. He touched on it but not in the detail he went into re the US events.

One thing I was struck by was the actual death rates. You hear about the actual death rate being 2% or something and that doesn't jive with the image you get of massively high death rates. Well the reason is it depends on what time frame and locations you average together. There were places and times when the fatality rate was 20-50%. But after time the virus attenuated so if you average the fatalities over 2 years the rates are much lower.
 
Last edited:
Most of the time that happens now. The only exception I can think of in very recent years is when the ACIP expanded the recommendation for inactivated influeza vaccines to include babies and children without doing any safety or effectiveness studies in that age group first, sans one effectivness study which found that they works "similar to placebo" in them. Then there was a bit of a backlash and a hoohaa over that, so the CDC mass vaccinated a bunch of kids in one city, and then looked for a cluster of kids turning up at the ERs and clinics with reactions, and then called it a "safety study" and declared it "safe".
That's the deal with individual vaccines, at least. Looking at the effects of lots of them being given at once, or over the first year of life is a whole 'nother creature.
You don't have any citations here, while the ACIP has hundreds backing their recommendations. I have given my son a flu vaccine every year since he was very young. I can't remember when I started them but were he 6 months old now, I'd be giving him one. You always seem to leave out the deaths and complications from flu when you spout this anti-vaccine stuff. One year after my son and my friends' kids had all had their flu shots (because my friends trust my decisions) there was a rash of pediatric deaths from H3N2 influenza. People were desperate to get their kids vaccinated. There wasn't a lot left because most of it had been given.

No one seems to feel very threatened until they are reminded that influenza kills kids, including healthy kids. I am not aware of a single death of a child from influenza vaccine in the last decade. Why do you start with the assumption the vaccine is more dangerous than influenza? 35,000 deaths a year vs zero. I have no problem starting with the opposite assumption. Give my child the vaccine! If it turns out to have risks not yet known, well so what? Influenza is one of the deadliest infections known.
 
Nonsense. There are two large populations in the US alone that don't receive vaccines. And remember, most of the world never received the Polio vaccines.



Deaths from Influenza each year, in people without any vaccine, are very very small, with most of them occurring in the elderly with other health problems. Flu shots are a scam, always have been.



OK. I usually do anyway. :wackywink:
This is so stupid I can't even be polite about it. The few places left in the world not getting widespread polio vaccine are the only few places left where the tragedy of preventable polio is still occurring. And if 35,000 people die every year from flu in the US on average, and 90% had existing health problems or advanced age, that leaves 3500 healthy people dying from flu every year. Again, vs zero dying from the vaccine. You are simply ignorant!
 
Maybe because you are looking at one flawed data analysis.

Appropriate measures of influenza immunization program effectiveness.
Kwong JC, Stukel TA, McGeer AJ, Manuel DG.
Groll and Thomson's evaluation of the effectiveness of Ontario's Universal Influenza Immunization Campaign used per capita cases of laboratory-confirmed influenza. We argue that these data are susceptible to various biases and should not be used as an outcome measure. Laboratory data are traditionally used to identify the presence of influenza activity rather than to identify levels of influenza activity. A better measure of viral activity is the proportion of influenza tests positive; whereas the weekly proportion of tests positive was relatively consistent, a marked increase over time in the numbers of laboratory-confirmed cases paralleled an increase in the number of tests performed. Regardless, for evaluating universal influenza immunization program effectiveness, other established and available measures employed in previous studies describing the epidemiology of influenza should be used instead of laboratory data.
 
Effects of annual influenza vaccination on winter mortality in elderly people with chronic pulmonary disease.
Conclusions: Our data suggest benefit from the influenza vaccination and support an annual vaccination strategy for elderly COPD patients.

Influenza vaccination in community-dwelling elderly: impact on mortality and influenza-associated morbidity.
Our results indicate that, in a season of mild influenza activity and good antigenic match between vaccine strains and circulating strains, influenza vaccination reduced mortality in the vaccinated population. Our data support an annual vaccination strategy for all community-dwelling elderly.

Annual influenza vaccination in community-dwelling elderly individuals and the risk of lower respiratory tract infections or pneumonia.
CONCLUSION: In this study, annual influenza revaccination was associated with a reduction in LRTI in community-dwelling elderly individuals.
Clinical effectiveness of influenza vaccination in persons younger than 65 years with high-risk medical conditions: the PRISMA study.
CONCLUSION: Persons with high-risk medical conditions of any age can substantially benefit from annual influenza vaccination during an epidemic.
Cost-effectiveness of influenza vaccination of healthy children.
The vaccination was cost saving in all age groups even with assumed vaccine efficacy of 60%. The results show that influenza vaccination would be cost saving in all children <or=13 years of age in Finland, which advocates reconsideration of the current influenza vaccine recommendations in all countries.
Clinical effectiveness of first and repeat influenza vaccination in adult and elderly diabetic patients.
CONCLUSIONS: Adults with type 2 diabetes, like other individuals from recognized risk groups, benefit considerably from influenza vaccination, and no difference in vaccine effectiveness was observed between first-time and repeat vaccination.
Influenza vaccine effectiveness in healthy 6- to 21-month-old children during the 2003-2004 season.
CONCLUSIONS: Although 2 doses of vaccine were 69% effective against ILI office visits and 87% effective against pneumonia/influenza office visits, 1 dose did not prevent office visits during the 2003-2004 influenza season.
Effectiveness and cost-benefit of influenza vaccination of healthy working adults: A randomized controlled trial.
CONCLUSION: Influenza vaccination of healthy working adults younger than 65 years can reduce the rates of ILI, lost workdays, and physician visits during years when the vaccine and circulating viruses are similar, but vaccination may not provide overall economic benefits in most years. JAMA. 2000;284:1655-1663.
Vaccines for preventing influenza in healthy adults.
AUTHORS' CONCLUSIONS: Influenza vaccines are effective in reducing cases of influenza, especially when the content predicts accurately circulating types and circulation is high. However, they are less effective in reducing cases of influenza-like illness and have a modest impact on working days lost. There is insufficient evidence to assess their impact on complications. Whole-virion monovalent vaccines may perform best in a pandemic.
Well d'uh. Not all ILI is influenza!
 
Newsflash for skeptigirl: cohort studies and population based studies don't prove dick. Don't argue about it. People who get vaccinations are usually more healthy than those who don't, before they get the vaccination.

If you want research with power, you need a carefully constructed RCT
 
Newsflash for skeptigirl: cohort studies and population based studies don't prove dick. Don't argue about it. People who get vaccinations are usually more healthy than those who don't, before they get the vaccination.

If you want research with power, you need a carefully constructed RCT

I take it you didn't bother reading the studies then? I only checked the last two. The second last one is an RCT and the last one is a Cochrane Review which is a systematic review of RCTs.

Edit - Of the rest, there were 2 case control studies (controlling for previous health and comorbid conditions), and the cohort studies included things like previous health in the analysis.
 
Last edited:
Great, I just finished the second one with incredibly long passages of details and you tell me I need to read the other one as well. ;)

Barry's book might be of more interest to someone in the medical profession because he describes a lot of the history of medicine at the time. What it lacked though was much history of the pandemic outside the US. He touched on it but not in the detail he went into re the US events.


One of the reasons I think they should be read together is that there was surprisingly little overlap. I also think Kolata's book should be read first because it is much less technical, more readable and dwells more with the stories of those affected by the flu pandemic.

I had both Kolata's book and another book by another author checked out of the library at the same time. I cannot remember who wrote the other book (it was published about the same time as Kolata's), but it was a chore to get through. I ended up skimming it.

It has been a few years, but I believe Kolata did go into some more detail about outside the USA, and how the influenza pandemic influenced WWI.

Reading her book made reading Barry's book much easier. I did not find it too tedious, and I found the history of medicine fascinating.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom