Another Vaccination Scare?

Red flag number 1 - "jabs"

You can usually stop reading at that point, but if you want stronger evidence:

Red flag number 2 - "cocktail"

We now have a confirmed Anti-Vaccination Liar sighting. No need for further exploration.
 
Okay, now we have to define pandemic. Oy.
http://www.m-w.com/dictionary/pandemic

occurring over a wide geographic area and affecting an exceptionally high proportion of the population
It does NOT matter where the strain comes from. Only that people are extremely susceptible to that particular strain, and therefore more people than usual get sick.

We get a flu season, not a pandemic. Technically.

You can double the vaccines given, but there is still not enough herd immunity. You need x% of the population covered to have any HUGE effect, not just a doubling of a small number of people getting coverage.

For instance, if one out of thousand is covered, then 2 out of a thousand (double the amount) is really not enought to make a difference.
 
Red flag number 1 - "jabs"

You can usually stop reading at that point, but if you want stronger evidence:

Red flag number 2 - "cocktail"

We now have a confirmed Anti-Vaccination Liar sighting. No need for further exploration.

Yeah, but look at the response we got from people that don't realize that, and we know that most people will never just recognize antivaccinators that way. There is a local lady in my city that writes this exact stuff into the local papers as much as she can.

One paper published my response, the other didn't. The paper that published my response is no longer printing her misinformation. The paper that ignored me is still publishing that jargon AND links to MERCOLA, NVIC, etc.

Everyone is exploring those kind of articles constantly, and hearing that jargon like it's normal language now. Very few people will accept that those are red flags. We have to tell them why they are red flags. Help.
 
Okay, now we have to define pandemic. Oy.
http://www.m-w.com/dictionary/pandemic


It does NOT matter where the strain comes from. Only that people are extremely susceptible to that particular strain, and therefore more people than usual get sick.

We get a flu season, not a pandemic. Technically.

You can double the vaccines given, but there is still not enough herd immunity. You need x% of the population covered to have any HUGE effect, not just a doubling of a small number of people getting coverage.

For instance, if one out of thousand is covered, then 2 out of a thousand (double the amount) is really not enought to make a difference.

But it went from 16% of the population to 44% of the population. These are not numbers so small no effect would be expected.
The vaccine should have reduced influenza by a significant amount.

About the pandemic thing...can you provide a link on seasonal flu mutating into a pandemic?
I've done quite a bit of reading on this topic, and you're the only person I've ever heard claim that vaccinating for seasonal flu will prevent a pandemic by keeping the seasonal strains from mutating into a pandemic strain.
 
Eos said:
It does NOT matter where the strain comes from. Only that people are extremely susceptible to that particular strain, and therefore more people than usual get sick.
But whether people are extremely susceptible depends on where the strain comes from. A strain to which large numbers of people have been exposed means that large numbers of people are immune. Seasonal strains differ antigenically from those which circulated during previous years, which is why they are able to get traction; but immunity to the previous strain confers at least some degree of protection against the variant, which is why seasonal strains don't erupt in pandemics.

kelly said:
I've done quite a bit of reading on this topic, and you're the only person I've ever heard claim that vaccinating for seasonal flu will prevent a pandemic by keeping the seasonal strains from mutating into a pandemic strain.
I'm sure what Eos is referring to is the possibility of a reassortment event occurring between a human-adapted strain and an avian-adapted strain.
 
dymanic said:
I'm sure what Eos is referring to is the possibility of a reassortment event occurring between a human-adapted strain and an avian-adapted strain.

That's not what she said...

Here...

eos said:
Not only that, but supressing the spread of the virus can help keep it from mutating into a strain that will get us an overdue pandemic.

me said:
I think most of the pandemic fear center around avian influenza crossing over into humans, not out presently circulating strains mutating.

eos said:
You really don't think a pandemic strain could come from a strain of any flu circulating? Really? Now you're showing your ignorance about viruses.
 
I think I may fire a salvo. However, I had a tangle with my local NPR station broadcasting anti-vax stuff from a chiropractor. The station manager said they gave equal time to a public health official. so they were clear. They consider themselves conduits of information, not evaluators of said info.

You just summed up what is wrong with 90% of journalism in the United States.
 
Does anyone know anything about this?

This paper appears to be Maurice Hillman's "manifesto" on influenza, written shortly before his death. He was an unusually bright guy, and he has an interesting idea here:

http://www.daimi.au.dk/~roald/evolu...04/EV04_litt/uge_4/Hilleman_InfVaccine_02.pdf

Assuming that the seroepidemiologic definitions
relating to the 1889 and 1900 pandemics are correct, it can be
concluded that pandemic influenza of man during the more
than 110 years from 1889 to 2002 was restricted to three
HA subtypes, H1, H2, and H3. Interpreting that information
as revealed in Table 4, there is a speculative possibility that
an interval of about 68 years must pass before a particular H
serotype can reappear as the cause for a new pandemic.
By
coincidence, this is about the length of the contemporary
human lifespan. A 68-year recurrence restriction, if real,
would suggest that there may need to be a corresponding
approximate 68-year period before sufficient subsidence of
host immunity, humoral, cellular or whatever, before a past
virus can regain access and become established as a “new”
human influenza A virus in the human population.


There was a complicating factor in creating the concept
of a 68-year cycle for development of host population receptivity.
This complication arose from the “premature” reappearance
of the H1N1 virus in 1977 rather than in 1986, 9
years before it would be expected according to the 68-year
concept. It will be recalled that the reappearance of H1N1
in 1977 was not a natural event, but, rather, the result of an
almost certain escape of 1950 H1N1 virus from frozen storage
[28] in an icebox (see Section 3.2). Such virus was likely
to have been able to establish itself in a sufficiently large
population of young persons who had been born since 1957.
Looking at the big picture, historically, it is both atypical
and remarkable for influenza A that two H subtypes, H3N2
and H1N1 have been able to circulate together since 1977
and to infect large numbers of persons to the present time.
If the 68-year, or thereabouts, concept for recycling from
appearance to reappearance of a particular subtype is to be
considered real, then it is evident that H2N2 should be the
cause for the next pandemic and the banner year should
be 34 years hence in 2025. By the same reasoning, H3N2
should follow in 2036. H1N1, after an absence, should reappear
in 2052 assuming its normal time for reappearance was
1986, having been skewed by an artificial reappearance in
1977.
The bottom line in these speculations may be that the
host population itself may be as important as the antigenic
differences among the H1, H2, and H3 viruses themselves in
defining the possibility for reappearances in new pandemics.
Clearly, there may be multifactorial “extra ingredients” factors
such as a role for cell-mediated immunity which, at
present, must have an importance which has not been disclosed
to date.

Any of you have any opinions about that?
Does that seem correct, or plausible, or was he getting fuzzy-headed in his old age?
 
I'm going to have to read that before I say anything about it. Never heard of it before. The stuff about exhuming bodies from the permafrost got me hooked. Fascinating.
 
Does anyone know anything about this?

This paper appears to be Maurice Hillman's "manifesto" on influenza, written shortly before his death. He was an unusually bright guy, and he has an interesting idea here:

http://www.daimi.au.dk/~roald/evolu...04/EV04_litt/uge_4/Hilleman_InfVaccine_02.pdf



Any of you have any opinions about that?
Does that seem correct, or plausible, or was he getting fuzzy-headed in his old age?

That paper is about three years before he died. He had postulated this position even before. He does have the distinction of being the first to develop an influenza vaccine before an epidemic in 1957. I also remember seeing something about that flu cycle list in his biography:
http://www.amazon.com/Vaccinated-Defeat-Worlds-Deadliest-Diseases/dp/0061227951/

I just finished listening to his daughter, Jeryl Lynn Hilleman, talk about his life with conversations with her mother, and several people he worked with:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/radio4/science/pip/kuea4/
 
HC said:
He does have the distinction of being the first to develop an influenza vaccine before an epidemic in 1957.

It's interesting that he seems a bit skeptical about H5N1 being the next pandemic virus, too. His whole theory on influenza in general seems directly opposed to what Robert Webster (the WHO flu guy) thinks.

robinson said:
I'm going to have to read that before I say anything about it. Never heard of it before. The stuff about exhuming bodies from the permafrost got me hooked. Fascinating.

And who knew that the 1977 epidemic/pandemic was the result of a lab accident???
 
I'm going to have to read that before I say anything about it. Never heard of it before. The stuff about exhuming bodies from the permafrost got me hooked. Fascinating.

These two books go into great detail about that:
http://www.amazon.com/Flu-Story-Great-Influenza-Pandemic/dp/0743203984/
and
http://www.amazon.com/Great-Influenza-deadliest-pandemic-history/dp/0143036491/

(they should both be read because they go over different aspects... but the first one should be read first)
 
Getting back to an earlier point, remember how they stopped it? The great Flu Pandemic?

The method still works.
 
It was an old cure, one almost forgotten by many. But 100% effective in stopping a Pandemic.

Hint: Cuba used it to stop HIV from becoming a problem there.
 
It was an old cure, one almost forgotten by many. But 100% effective in stopping a Pandemic.

Hint: Cuba used it to stop HIV from becoming a problem there.

Isolation and quarantine?

The thing about influenza is that it's highly contagious before symptom onset.
So I don't see how quarantine can work well in ther long run. You might be able to slow it down a bit that way, but there's a limit to it's effectiveness after that.

From what I understand about the 1918 pandemic, virtually everyone was eventually infected and developed (some) immunity.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom